Back

 

Draft: Version 1.3, updated 9-1-98

Young Stand Thinning and Diversity Study (YSTDS) Post-thinning Woody Detritus Inventory Summary Report

Thomas L. Buford and James R. Boyle


Department of Forest Resources
Oregon State University, College of Forestry
Corvallis, Oregon 97331-5703

 

Introduction - Woody detritus serves key ecological functions in forest ecosystems. It stores and supplies nutrients and water to organisms, contributes to soil development, supplies energy for microbes and provides habitat for vertebrates and invertebrates.

The objective of this inventory is to provide post-thinning, base line information characterizing the aboveground woody detritus stores for each YSTDS treatment area. Our goals are to provide estimates of weight of each type of woody detritus per unit area, and, by using literature values of elemental concentrations of woody materials, provide crude estimates of nutrient contents of each detritus component.

Inventory of woody detritus is required for comparison between treatments, comparison with old-growth stands and for comparison with future entries into the YSTDS stands. These values can also be useful for statistical blocking in future analysis of other ecological features.

Methods - Five woody detritus fractions were measured to estimate total detritus values for the sampling areas. The forest floor component consisted of material above mineral soil and at least 1/4 inch in diameter. Fine woody debris was material greater than 1/4 inch and less than 1 inch in diameter. Coarse woody debris was downed material greater than 1 inch in diameter, stumps and snags.

Stumps and snags were individually measured in 0.1 ha fixed plots that varied from 13 to 33 plots per treatment, depending on the size of the treatment area.

Coarse woody debris other than stumps and snags was measured using a modified Brown line transect method for fire fuel inventories. The modifications included addition of species and log decay classes to the data.

Fine woody debris was measured in 1m2 fixed plots and the forest floor was sampled using 0.1013 m2-sampling rings. All sample areas were randomly placed in the treatment area.

Preliminary results - Table 1 shows summary values for all size fractions of woody detritus. There was no significant difference in total detritus levels between treatments. There were, however, significant differences in fine (0.25" to 1" diameter) woody detritus, coarse (1" to 3" diameter) woody detritus, snags and stumps. See table 1 for means separations.


Table 1. Young Stand Thinning and Diversity Study summary of post-treatment woody detritus fractions and selected nutrient contents in kg/ha. Nutrient concentrations for coarse woody detritus are from Sexton and Harmon, 1996. Nutrient concentrations for forest floor are from Prescott and Preston, 1994.

Treatment

kg/ha

>3" Detritus

1"-3" Detritus

Stumps

Snags

0.24" - 1" Detritus

Forest Floor

Total

Control

Mass

189,631

3,091a

19,418a

8,934a

27,189a

26,900

275,163

-

N content

175

-

21

9

-

401

606

-

P content

8

-

1

0

-

24

33

-

K content

30

-

3

2

-

24

58

-

Ca content

266

-

23

12

-

325

626

Heavy Thin

Mass

176,274

8,681b

24,846ab

1,976b

57,045b

56,313

325,135

-

N content

160

-

26

2

-

839

1,027

-

P content

7

-

1

0

-

51

59

-

K content

27

-

4

0

-

51

82

-

Ca content

247

-

31

2

-

681

962

Light Thin

Mass

194,496

6,592b

22,575ab

4,966ab

42,474b

41,929

313,032

-

N content

176

-

23

5

-

625

829

-

P content

8

-

1

0

-

38

47

-

K content

30

-

3

1

-

38

72

-

Ca content

272

-

27

6

-

507

813

Light Thin w/ gaps

Mass

186,293

7,915b

28,417b

2,249b

45,584b

44,999

315,457

-

N content

169

-

29

2

-

670

871

-

P content

8

-

1

0

-

40

49

-

K content

29

-

4

0

-

40

74

-

Ca content

261

-

34

3

-

544

843

Note: Values for the detritus size fractions followed by the same letter are not significantly different (p < 0.05) based on an analysis of variance and LSD multiple comparison test.