Home > Nuclear > Monument 2 Mine

Monument Valley Upgrader Site (Monument 2 Mine)
                                         

Monument Valley Upgrader Site (Monument 2 Mine)
Apache County, Arizona



Years of Operation Status of Mill
or Plant Site
Uranium Ore
Processed
(Million Short Tons)
Production
(Million Pounds U3O8)
1955-1964, 1964-1967 Decommissioned 1.10 0.77
Mill/Plant Area
(Acres)
Disposal Cell
Area
(Acres)
Disposal Cell
Radioactive
Waste
Volume
(Million Cubic Yards)
Disposal Cell
Total Radioactivity
(Ci, 226Ra)
Disposal Cell
Average Tailings
Radioactivity
(pCi/g, 226Ra)
UMTRA Project
Final Cost
(Million Dollars)
101 A 0.93 A 54 24.13
   ARadioactively contaminated material were relocated and stabilized at the engineered disposal cell at the Mexican Hat mill site in Utah.
   Notes: Uranium Ore Processing and Production are estimated based on historical data. Radioactivity from radium-226 in the stabilized mill tailings is stated as total curies (Ci) and as average picocuries per gram (pCi/g) of tailings. A picocurie is 0.037 radioactive disintegrations per second. Radium-226 (1620 year half-life) is a decay product in the uranium-238 series. It undergoes radioactive decay to produce radon-222, which is a noble gas, an alpha emitter, and the longest-lived isotope of radon (half-life of 3.8 days).



Map of Arizona showing the location of Monument Valley (Monument #2 Upgrader) Mill. Having trouble? Call 202 586-8800 for help.

Location: The former Monument Valley upgrader site is on Navajo Nation land in Cane Valley, Apache County, Arizona, about 20 miles south of Mexican Hat, San Juan County, Utah.

Background:   The Monument Valley uranium district is in the southern part of the Monument Upwarp, a north-trending, broad asymmetrical anticline (fold structure) in northeastern Arizona and southeastern Utah. The Upwarp's thick cover of fluvial and eolian strata has been deeply eroded to expose principally sandstone and shale of Permian, Triassic, and Jurassic age. Nearly all known uranium deposits in the district occur in fluviatile conglomerate and sandstone beds of the Shinarump Member, the basal unit of the Chinle Formation (Late Triassic age). The Shinarump was deposited on the Moenkopi Formation (Early and Middle(?) Triassic age). Throughout the southeastern Utah region, the two rock units are separated by the Middle Triassic unconformity. The individual paleostream channels eroded channels into the underlying Moenkopi beds can be up to several hundred feet wide and more than 100 feet deep. These channels are filled with coarse sediments that locally host uranium deposits, typically in "trashy," cross-bedded, conglomeratic, clayey sandstone with considerable fossilized and carbonized wood.

Uranium ore occurs in the Shinarump scattered at various levels. Ore is also present locally in the upper few feet of the Moenkopi and De Chelly Member (Early Permian) beds where either unit and the Shinarump ore-bearing channel strata are in contact. Ore bodies are generally elongate, lenticular, and follow the trend of the hosting paleochannel strata. The ore occurs mostly in smaller channels but is not known to completely fill any channel. Most ore bodies are about 100 by 50 feet horizontally and average about 5 feet in thickness, though some larger deposits range up to 20 feet in thickness. Uranium mineralization tends to be concentrated in high grade pockets associated with carbonized woody trash, the whole being surrounded by sub-ore grade to sparsely mineralized rock. The uranium-bearing ores in the Shinarump beds are described, based on metal content, as either vanadium-uranium ore, copper-uranium ore, or uranium ore containing minor amounts of vanadium and copper.

In the Monument Valley district, ore production from individual mines ranged from a few tons of ore to near 800,000 tons. For the district, the median production for 54 mines was about 25,300 tons of ore that averaged 0.32 percent U3O8 and 0.91 percent V2O5. The Monument 2 mine was a large vanadium-uranium ore deposit hosted by Shinarump strata that filled a large and deep erosional swale in the unconformity surface atop the Moenkopi Formation. At the mine, Shinarump channel beds are several hundred feet wide and extend for about 1.3 miles along the axis of the swale. A small amount of ore was reportedly mined for vanadium in 1943 from the Monument 2 mineral claim, first staked in 1942. Large-scale mining of the deposit for uranium ore was begun in early 1948 by Vanadium Corporation of America (VCA). In the mid 1950s, underground methods were used to mine pods of higher grade ore through multiple (about 15) short adits or shafts. Overall underground ore production averaged 125 tons of ore per day (TPD). Lower grade and higher grade ores were blended to maintain a minimum-grade, direct-shipping ore containing about 0.30 percent U3O8 and 1.40 percent V2O5. In this phase of mining the Monument 2 deposit, the ore was shipped 185 miles to the company's mill at Durango, Colorado.

In June 1954, stripping operations were begun for openpit mining at the south end of the Monument 2 deposit. Both the underground mines and openpit mine continued to produce until the summer of 1957, when underground mining ended. Openpit operations were continued until the mine was closed in June 1964. The open-pit mine average production rate was about 750 TPD. In its early years, the openpit yielded both higher grade ore along with considerable low grade ore. Later, the openpit yielded only low grade ore. Mined high grade ore was shipped directly to a mill, while low grade ore was stockpiled onsite for later processing to concentrate the uranium and vanadium values. An upgrader plant (1955-1964), a batch-leach plant (1964-1967), and a heap-leaching operation (1966-1967)were used to raise the mine-run, low grade ore to a shipping grade product. All U3O8 recovered from milling of the final products obtained from the upgrader, batch-leach, and heap-leaching plants was purchased by the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (AEC).

The Monument 2 upgrader plant was constructed in mid 1955 by VCA and operated until July 1964. The nearby openpit mine supplied all plant feed. Low grade ore ranged from 0.04 to 0.09 percent U3O8 and 0.4 to 0.8 percent V2O5. The upgrader yielded a shipping-grade product assaying 0.25 to 0.30 percent U3O8 and 1.5 to 3.0 percent V2O5, depending on the feed grade. The upgrader product was shipped to VCA's Durango, Colorado, mill until it was closed in March 1963, and afterward to VCA's Shiprock, New Mexico, mill. Over the upgrader's life, some 1.1 million tons of low grade ore were treated to produce an estimated 0.1 million tons of "slimes" product. The plant handled about 250 TPD, and recovery of uranium and vanadium was 65 to 70 percent. The upgrader used attrition (grinding) and classification (separation of the fines and sand fractions) to concentrate the uranium and vanadium values. Run-of-mine ore was crushed, finely ground, and then treated in wet classifiers to separate the fines fraction (containing most of the uranium and vanadium) from the "barren" sand fraction. After filtering, the fines formed a wet-cake product that was partly dried before being shipped to the mill.

The "barren" sand tailings from the upgrader plant still retained sufficient uranium and vanadium values to warrant retreatment. A batch-leach plant was constructed in early 1964 to reprocess the tailings. It was operated from October 1964 until November 1967 and treated about 1,000 TPD. The tailings were leached with sulfuric acid in large tanks. Solutions were recycled until the desired uranium and vanadium concentrations were achieved. Uranium and vanadium were precipitated using ammonia. The precipitate was filtered, partially dried, and shipped to the Shiprock mill. Estimated overall recovery was 0.2 million pounds U3O8 and 2.0 million pounds V2O5.

In 1966, heap-leaching of low grade mine-dump material was begun at the Monument 2 site. Mine dump material was crushed to one inch size and placed on polyethylene sheeting. Sulfuric acid solution flowed onto the top of the heap, percolated downward, and was captured in perforated piping at the bottom of the piles. The pregnant solution was recirculated until concentrations of about 1.5 grams U3O8 and 7.0grams V2O5 per liter were achieved. Ammonia was added to the leach solution to precipitate the uranium and vanadium. The precipitate was filtered, dried, and shipped to the Shiprock mill. Heap-leaching was continued intermittently until late 1967, when all activities were shut down. It is estimated that about 0.1 million tons of low grade dump material were leached.

In late 1967, the Foote Mineral Company succeeded VCA as the lessee and controller of the site. When the original lease for the mine and plant site expired in 1968, control of the Monument 2 mine, plant, and tailings site reverted to the Navajo Nation.

The upgrader, concentrator, and heap-leaching operations at the Monument 2 site generated about 1.1 million tons of tailings and waste residues. When operations were closed in 1967, the old plant buildings were removed. In the late 1970s, two piles of tailings materials, the contaminated foundations of the upgrader and concentrator plants, other structural debris, and contaminated soil remained at the former ore processing site.

UMTRA Surface Remediation: Contamination at the Monument Valley Site (former Monument 2 ore upgrading site) resulted from past ore-processing operations. When operations ended in late 1967, the site covered about 90 acres. Two on-site tailings piles, one about 10 acres and one about 20 acres in size and some 500 feet apart, remained at the site when remedial action began in May 1989. During the site cleanup project, contaminated surface materials from the process tailings piles, leach areas, evaporation pond, structural debris, and associated contaminated soil and wind blown material from 83 acres at the plant site and four vicinity properties were trucked 17 miles from the Monument 2 site and stabilized in the Mexican Hat Disposal Cell near Mexican Hat, Utah. Following remediation, no residual soil with contamination levels exceeding the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) standard remained at the site. Overall, about 1.3 million tons of tailings, structural debris, and contaminated soil were transported to the disposal cell. A funding lapse caused the Monument Valley Site cleanup project to be suspended in February 1990. The project was resumed in September 1992 and completed in May 1994.

Disposal Area: (See the Mexican Hat Mill Site page for a information about of the Mexican Hat Disposal Cell.)

Responsibility for Remediation: U.S. Department of Energy, 100 percent.

Stewardship: The Monument Valley Site is managed under the DOE's Long-Term Surveillance and Monitoring (LTSM) Program in accordance with the approved site specific plan. U.S. Department of Energy is responsible for the long-term stewardship activities and funding at the Monument Valley Site. Under a cooperative agreement initiated in 1983 with the Navajo Nation, which owns the land, the DOE has permanent custodial access to the site and is responsible for all costs of assessment and remediation. The Navajo Nation is responsible for site enforcement under the agreement, with DOE responsible for costs incurred by the Tribe relating to the site.  

Groundwater Program: Groundwater sampling at the Monument Valley Site conducted over many years has identified a plume of contaminated groundwater that extends northeastward for about one mile from the Monument Valley Site. The plume is estimated to be up to one-half mile wide and to contain about 4.5 million gallons of groundwater contaminated with chemical and radioactive agents. Contaminants exceeding the EPA maximum concentration limits occur in the two uppermost bedrock aquifers of the Shinarump Member and a younger alluvial/dune sand aquifer. Included are nitrate, radium, uranium, and possibly net gross alpha. Active remediation of the contaminated groundwater is planned for constituents that pose a potential health risk and/or exceed EPA standards. Monitoring of the groundwater condition is conducted by the DOE to further characterize the groundwater system and the contaminants. DOE assumes that an active remediation program could result in compliance with the EPA's groundwater standards by 2013 at the earliest. Routine groundwater compliance monitoring will be required for an indefinite period of time after the active remediation work is completed, according to the DOE.



Back to Main Page     Summary Table     Glossary     References