NASA ENGINEERING NETWORK
Follow this link to skip to the main content
+ Contact LLIS
Go
ABOUT NASALATEST NEWSMULTIMEDIAMISSIONSMyNASAWORK FOR NASA

+ NASA Home
FIND ENGINEERING RESOURCES BY
LLIS HOME
NASA CENTERS
MISSION DIRECTORATE
TOPICS
BY YEAR


Public Lessons Learned Entry: 0429

Lesson Info:

  • Lesson Number: 0429
  • Lesson Date: 1996-07-15
  • Submitting Organization: JPL
  • Submitted by: J.A. Roberts

Subject:

Low Strength Solder Joints (~1975)

Abstract:

In the process of reflow soldering flat pack leads to printed circuit boards during the Voyager program, it was discovered that a high phosphorous content in the plating process for the Kovar leads can weaken solder joints. Evaluate the effects of phosphorus when soldering or welding nickel plated surfaces.

Description of Driving Event:

(Relevant Historical Lesson(s) Learned)

While in the process of reflow soldering flat pack leads to printed circuit boards during the Voyager program, small black spots were observed on some leads of various CD 4000 series flat packs. Analysis revealed the solder surface of the leads to be poorly wetted, caused by a high phosphorus content in the plated surface, and the solder joints to be substantially weakened. (Some joints when barely touched, fell apart). As a result, suspect flat packs were replaced, wherever found.

The Kovar leads of the flat packs are electroless nickel plated to provide a solderable surface. The plating process, which also coplates elemental phosphorus, begins to plate a poor solder surface when the phosphorus content exceeds approximately 7% by weight. Since the nickel depletes at a faster rate than the phosphorus, it is necessary to monitor the plating solution and maintain an acceptably low level of phosphorus. Also, when a poor solder is found to exist as a result of excess phosphorus, platers will usually overplate with tin to regain a solderable surface. This overplate when exposed to the mechanical and thermal stresses of lead forming and reflow soldering will crack and pull away from the phosphorus rich nickel plate below.

Reference(s):
Part Failure Analysis Report Log 2624

Lesson(s) Learned:

A high phosphorous content in the plating process can weaken solder joints.

Recommendation(s):

Evaluate the effects of phosphorus when soldering or welding nickel plated surfaces.

Evidence of Recurrence Control Effectiveness:

N/A

Documents Related to Lesson:

N/A

Mission Directorate(s):

N/A

Additional Key Phrase(s):

  • Hardware
  • Industrial Operations
  • Parts Materials & Processes

Additional Info:

    Approval Info:

    • Approval Date: 1996-03-28
    • Approval Name: Carol Dumain
    • Approval Organization: JPL
    • Approval Phone Number: 818-354-8242


    FirstGov - Your First Click to the US Government
    + 2004 Vision for Space Exploration
    + FY 2005 Budget Request
    + 2003 Strategic Plan
    + Freedom of Information Act
    + The President's Management Agenda
    + FY 2003 Agency Performance and Accountability Report
    + NASA Privacy Statement, Disclaimer,
    and Accessibility Certification

    + Freedom to Manage
    NASA
    Curator:Manson Yew
    NASA Official: Gregory Robinson
    + Contact LLIS