This article was published in FDA Consumer magazine several years ago. It is no longer being maintained and may contain information that is out of date. You may find more current information on this topic by visiting the section on FDA's Web site for seniors. |
Nutrition and the Elderly by Alexandra Greeley We all know a Norma Kramer--an older person whose life has slowly started to come apart--a widow living alone who in her depression eats sparsely. Her adult son drops by for dinner one night a week, but that may be her only substantial meal until his next visit. Finally, because she can no longer live well enough alone, Norma Kramer moves into a senior citizen's residence. Outgoing now and healthy except for painful arthritis--72-year-old Kramer lives at the Har Sinai West senior high-rise in Baltimore, Md. She looks forward each day to the Eating Together in Baltimore breakfast and lunch program at the residence--for there, not only can she gossip with friends, she also can eat wholesome, hot meals that fortify her. Kramer's story is true, and altogether too common, repeated in varying versions everywhere by people who worry about aging relatives or friends. Without proper supervision, many millions of older Americans exist in a nutritional twilight zone, grappling with the daily challenge of eating--and often not eating well-balanced meals or any meals at all. A recent survey completed for the new Nutrition Screening Initiative (sponsored by Ross Laboratories)--targeted at improving the nutritional health status of the aging--shows that while 85 percent of seniors surveyed believe nutrition is important for their health and well-being, few act on their beliefs. Further, 30 percent admit they skip at least one meal a day. These numbers may well soar, as America continues to gray at an escalating rate. "Twelve percent of the population of the United States is now age 65 or older," says Jeffrey Blumberg, Ph.D., associate director of the USDA Human Nutrition Research Center of Aging at Tufts University. "But in 30 years, the figure will be closer to 20 percent." Higher Risk of Malnutrition Sound nutrition plays a major role in good health for people of any age. But, says Paul Kerschner, senior vice president of the National Council on the Aging in Washington, D.C., seniors tend to be at a disproportionate risk of poor nutrition that can adversely affect their health. He describes the unacceptably high levels of poor nutrition and malnutrition among the elderly, which range from 15 to 50 percent. He says the problem is particularly pronounced among those living in institutional settings. To make matters worse, often the signs and symptoms of malnutrition can baffle and mislead even the professionals. For example, weight loss, lightheadedness, disorientation, lethargy, and loss of appetite are often diagnosed as illness, says Colleen Pierre, American Dietetic Association ambassador and director of the Eating Together in Baltimore program. "What the person really needs is to eat better," she says. Responding to the widespread gap in nutrition knowledge, the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American Dietetic Association, and the National Council on the Aging have joined forces to promote the Washington, D.C.-based Nutrition Screening Initiative. Kerschner says that the hoped-for goal of this five-year initiative is to "start good nutritional habits that will forestall inappropriate acute and institutional care and will help people age well and keep in better health." The campaign was initiated, he continues, because the nutritional status of older people was being ignored, not only by older people themselves, but also by the health-care community. One other goal of the program, he continues, is to point out to institutions that eating is a major part of people's lives. "Even institutions that serve good meals don't present them as part of therapy," Kerschner says. Dietitians and nurses need to realize that meals at any age are an important part of daily life, whether people live at home or in an institution. So just presenting food, then taking it away when a person is finished, doesn't help the person learn good nutritional habits, he says. A Complex Challenge Unfortunately, encouraging older citizens to eat well and to pay serious attention to sound nutrition is a complex challenge with no single, simple solution. For one thing, the aging process itself becomes a real barrier, explains Blumberg. As many people age, he says, their biological clock winds down and they also start to lose lean body mass. Consequently, their interest in food--and their appetites for it --tends to diminish so people cut back on calories. But that's not okay, says Blumberg. "Requirements for many nutrients don't diminish," he says, "and they may even increase with age. Eating less presents real problems leading to deficiency." For example, he says, requirements for vitamin B6 actually increase for older people. "We find that when people are in a depleted but not a deficiency state, there are cognitive changes, changes in the immune systems, and deficits in sensitivity to insulin," he says. But an increase in B6 intake corrects the problems. Health declines have "a cascading effect," says pathologist Philip Garry, professor at University of New Mexico School of Medicine. But after studying 300 older adults from the ages of 65 to 93, Garry has concluded that even the process of aging itself may be retarded through behavioral changes. "You really can slow aging down through eating well, exercising properly, keeping positive, and staying active," he says. "We don't see much change in them [the people in the study] due to aging," he continues, because very few of the people in his New Mexico Aging Process study are sedentary, have memory loss, or are on medications or overweight. "So they are going on in life like they did when they were much younger," he says, telling of a spry 80-year-old man in the study who works as a ski instructor. "The only time we see a dramatic change in someone is when something acute happens, such as a fall. That may precipitate a change in the dietary lifestyle," he says. The reasons seniors shun balanced fare results from more than natural metabolic changes, of course: Some of these other factors are not so obvious. Loneliness, for example, can cripple the person who has always lived with a spouse or other family members, and it seems to hit older men particularly hard, reports Suzanne Murphy, nutritionist at University of California at Berkeley, and co- researcher of a study on the living arrangements and dietary quality of older adults in the United States, funded by the National Institute on Aging. Without cooking or shopping skills, men may eat less or skip meals altogether. Women living alone may simply grow tired of kitchen duty and lose interest in eating. "Older Americans are at risk," she says, "but single older Americans are at greater risk." Depression--often linked to loneliness--may likewise curtail a person's interest in food. Sensory Decline Another roadblock to eating well is the decline in the sense of smell that directly affects a person's ability to taste--and enjoy--food. "We once believed that older people didn't eat well because of their decline in taste and taste buds," says James Weiffenbach, Ph.D., research psychologist, Clinical Investigation and Patient Care Branch, National Institute of Dental Research, National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, Md. "Taste and smell as a sensory system do affect eating. But the ability to taste remains fairly intact with age. It's the decline in the ability to smell that seems to be responsible for 'taste' complaints," he says. Weiffenbach points out that older people have trouble identifying pur}ed foods. Though younger people do much better under usual circumstances, when holding their noses while eating, they are no better at identifying foods than older people. In essence, he says, you can't taste if you don't smell--smell is the real factor in the enjoyment of food. Money worries play a large role, too. After people retire, their incomes often dwindle, forcing them to make some hard cutbacks in their budgets. The one area that usually cuts most easily is the food allowance. In addition, certain medications can kill appetites or taste sensations. Or people may wear ill-fitting dentures that make chewing meats and fibrous vegetables difficult. Perhaps failing eyesight causes meals to look less appealing and makes reading food labels difficult. Perhaps, too, disease or broken bones limit mobility so that shopping or cooking becomes an unwelcome chore. Weakness is another factor. How, asks Gail Martin, assistant administrative director of the National Association of Meal Programs (which represents Meals on Wheels), Washington, D.C., can a frail elderly person carry home a heavy bag of groceries, particularly if that home is six blocks away and that person has no cab fare? Unlike years ago, when all tradesmen came to the door, she continues, shopping today is more difficult. Shoppers generally must leave home, usually by car, to buy their provisions. "If you are 85 years old and have a car," she says, "you must be able to drive it and handle it well enough to maneuver shopping mall parking lots. And you'll probably have to park at a distance from the store. There are obstacles for those even in the best of health. Our society has not thought through how older people are going to live and make it." Practical Suggestions While most experts express dismay at the situation, they all offer practical suggestions that almost every aging American can follow. For one, Blumberg suggests, simply taking supplements can help. "By the time someone is old, the consequences of inappropriate nutrition are hard to void," he explains. "But it's not too late to start to reduce the risk. I know of only one ready alternative, and that's to take supplements. Others talk about fortifying foods. But if the vitamin D requirement for an older person really is two to three times higher than the current allowance, it may not be realistic to tell a 65-year-old woman to drink five glasses of milk a day." Of course, he cautions, supplements in large amounts can be toxic. Another expert, however, does not advise the use of supplements. "I hate to make a recommendation for supplements," says Jean Pennington, associate director for dietary surveillance at the Food and Drug Administration's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition, "unless in special cases when there is an illness or a physiological reason. Then a supplement might be indicated." Generally, she adds, most people get adequate nutrients from the food supply. But if they can't or don't, she says, then supplements taken should not be greatly in excess of the RDA for that nutrient. Or, she continues, people should pay much closer attention to what they are eating and should select the most nutritious foods possible. "People should make the proper selection from the four basics," she says, "and should place more emphasis on grains and vegetables." Enhancing food aromas is another way to stimulate appetite. "The parts of the brain for taste and smell are also connected to hunger/satiety," says Susan Schiffman of the Duke University Medical Center, Department of Psychology. "For example, if you stop eating a meal, you do so because your sense of taste and smell are satisfied; it's not that you feel full yet," she says. Schiffman's research has enabled her to help dieters by finding ways to enhance food aromas that can also increase the taste experience. Dieters may eat less if their food has more flavor. But the same principle works in reverse for older people: Better-tasting food sparks appetites. She has found that enhancing food flavors will increase the consumption of the foods to which flavors have been added-- and the increase in intake is greater for the people who have a greater loss of smell. She explains that seniors can intensify tastes by adding flavors and sweeteners, like herbs (not spices, which may irritate), maple syrup, bacon bits, and butter flavoring. They also can heighten the appeal of their foods by "switching from food to food while eating. That keeps up sensory interest," she says. And when preparing meals, she suggests that seniors combine different textures to make food more appetizing--for example, putting crunchy Grapenuts on smooth frozen yogurt . "Make eating a joyous experience," advises Martin. She describes how simple tricks can turn mealtimes into treats. For starters, she suggests shopping at convenient times when stores are likely to be uncrowded. Then she advises learning to make food budgets stretch by checking unit pricing--that way, people can afford to buy extras. She advises taking a creative approach to meal planning by experimenting with one new food or flavor a week, and to cooking by preparing meals that appeal to the senses. "We eat with our eyes," she says, "so meals should have color and texture and, of course, have taste sensations." But perhaps the key to better eating lies not so much with the mechanics of food preparation as with the social aspects of eating. As most experts agree, mealtimes should be social occasions, spent eating in the company of others, whenever possible. If need be, senior citizens, particularly those living alone, should join a community group-dining program. "An older person's loss of interest in eating is like a failure to thrive," says Pierre. "He or she is not getting enough stimulation or social interaction to feel life is worth living. But generally, once that person is in a social situation, the interest in food returns." Pennington adds that using a feeding service to bring meals in to homebound seniors would ensure better nutrition--and presumably provide some mealtime socialization. Until the problem hits home, most people may not worry about how an older person eats. But research confirms that we really are--at least to a large degree--what we eat. If older people have not laid a good nutrition foundation early in life, says Blumberg, they may be at risk for various chronic diseases, including heart attacks, artherosclerosis, cancer, diabetes, and osteoporosis. And if they continue to subsist on less than wholesome foods, they jeopardize quality of life. "Nutrition," concludes Blumberg, "must be a lifelong process." n Alexandra Greeley is a freelance writer in Reston, Va., who has written on nutrition for Time-Life Books, The New York Times, Newsday, and the South China Post. Recipes for a Long, Healthy Life The Dietary Guidelines for Americans established by the Food and Nutrition Board of the National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences, in Washington, D.C., include the basic food groups that supply people with an adequate diet of minerals, proteins, vitamins, and energy. While no guideline can guarantee perfect health, people who follow these recommendations will give themselves a good foundation for health. In general, people should eat a variety of foods, maintain a desirable weight, and avoid fried and fatty foods in order to cut down intakes of fat, saturated fat, and cholesterol; eat an adequate amount of fiber-rich foods; avoid too much sugar and starch; and drink alcohol only in moderation. The Recommended Dietary Allowances established for the 51 and older age group, says Gail Martin, assistant administrative director of the National Association of Meal Programs, provide a framework around which older Americans should base their diets. If they wish to increase calorie intake, they should select extra portions of food from one of the following categories: Daily regimen: * 2 to 3 half-cup servings of milk, cheese or yogurt for men * 4 half-cup servings of milk, cheese or yogurt for women * 6 or more servings of whole-grain breads or cereals * 2 to 4 half-cup servings of fruit * 3 to 5 half-cup servings of vegetables * 2 to 3 servings, or 5 to 7 ounces, of protein (lean meat, poultry, fish, and alternates such as eggs, nuts, and dried beans and peas) The following recipes, provided by Martin, are balanced, nutritious and wholesome. The dishes also provide a variety of flavors, colors and textures with a minimum of fat and no extra salt. Aunt Louise's Chicken 1 whole chicken breast 1 can stewed tomatoes 1 green pepper, cut into chunks 1 medium onion, cut into chunks 1 clove garlic, minced 1/4 tsp. curry powder 1 bay leaf 1 cup chicken stock Simmer chicken breast in 2 cups of water with bay leaf for 20 minutes. Remove and cool in refrigerator. Skim the fat from top of the stock when it is solidified. Bone the chicken and combine with the chicken stock, stewed tomatoes, green pepper, onions, garlic, and curry powder. Simmer for 20 minutes. Thicken slightly with cornstarch and water. Serve with rice, three-quarters of a cup per person. (Suggestion: Prepare the rice using leftover chicken stock.) Serves 2. Orange Carrots Cook fresh carrot slices until slightly crisp. Instead of butter and/or salt, spoon desired amount of concentrated frozen orange juice over the hot carrots. Bran Cereal Muffins 1 cup whole bran cereal 1 cup milk 1 egg 1/4 cup corn oil 1/4 cup honey 2 tsp. baking powder 1/4 tsp. baking soda 1/2 tsp. salt 1 1/4 cups whole-wheat flour, unsifted Preheat oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. Mix bran cereal and milk in a bowl, and let stand 1 or 2 minutes. Add egg, oil and honey. Beat well. Combine remaining ingredients and stir until well mixed. Add to liquid mixture and stir only until mixed. Spoon into 12 greased muffin tins. Bake about 20 to 25 minutes. Makes 12 medium-sized muffins. Conclude dinner with fresh seasonal fruit. Colleen Pierre of the American Dietetic Association and director of Eating Together in Baltimore observes that many senior citizens prefer to snack rather than sit down to a full, prepared meal. To assure them an adequate intake of all nutrients each day, she recommends the following snack plan--which is a very basic, balanced program that "meets the caloric and nutritional needs of a sedentary woman in the 60-to-75-year age range without cooking a major meal. Add the starred items to meet the caloric needs of the sedentary man the same age," says Pierre. One-day snack plan: * 1 cup of hot chocolate with whole-wheat toast and 1 teaspoon margarine * 1 hard-boiled egg and glass of orange juice * a half cup of low-fat vanilla yogurt with 4 ounces crushed pineapple and 2 tablespoons wheat germ * 2 graham crackers with 2 tablespoons peanut butter and a half cup of low-fat milk * 1 small banana* * unsalted pretzels* * 5 pitted prunes * 1 two-ounce piece of cold chicken, 1 slice rye bread, 1 teaspoon margarine, and a half cup of mixed vegetables (a light meal/snack) * 1 cup split pea soup and 4 unsalted shredded wheat crackers * 1 cup whole-grain cereal with a half cup of low-fat milk, 1 teaspoon sugar, and a serving of fruit* --A.G.