This article was published in FDA Consumer magazine several years ago. It is no longer being maintained and may contain information that is out of date. You may find more current information on this topic in more recent issues of FDA Consumer or elsewhere on the FDA Website, by checking the site index or home page, or by searching the site. |
Cardiovascular Spare Parts by Ricki Lewis, Ph.D. The human cardiovascular system is highly efficient, yet enormously complex. A thousand times each day, the muscular heart pumps five quarts of blood through the arteries, to the smaller arterioles and finally the microscopic capillaries, and then through ever larger venules and veins, back to the heart. The journey of blood through the capillaries alone covers more than 60,000 miles! In such an intricate and interconnected system, it's easy to see how a single glitch can profoundly affect health. Medical researchers have devised some ingenious ways to replace malfunctioning cardiovascular parts. Substitute heart valves have been in use for three decades, and replacement blood, blood vessels, and even a heart are being developed. Many of these inventions are carefully crafted combinations of synthetic materials and biological substances, designed to hopefully equal nature, yet at the same time mimic the body closely enough so that the immune system does not reject the new part. Plus, these products must present a smooth surface for blood to flow over. Even the tiniest uneven surface can rupture a passing platelet, triggering the chemical cascade of clotting that can obstruct blood flow to a vital organ. Red Blood Cell Substitutes Blood is a complex mixture of red cells, white cells, and platelets, suspended in a watery, protein-rich plasma. Because these components must be present in specific proportions, duplicating nature's recipe is a daunting task. But the rise in blood-borne infections, such as hepatitis and AIDS, has made the idea of a blood substitute quite appealing. The next best thing, many researchers think, is a substance that can do the work of red blood cells in transporting and delivering oxygen to the body's tissues and removing wastes. The hemoglobin protein in red blood cells normally carries out this function. A safe and effective red cell substitute must meet strict criteria. "It must be absolutely disease-free, have a long storage life, and it must do the job for an extended period of time," says Joseph Stocks, M.D., a blood banking expert at the Maine Medical Center in Portland. Several types of chemicals can carry oxygen. In 1965, Leland Clark, Ph.D., at the University of Cincinnati, showed that some chemicals soak up so much oxygen that they could supply the vital gas to an animal immersed in it. He dropped a mouse into a beaker filled with silicone oil. The animal's lungs quickly filled and it sank--but kept breathing! Silicone oil proved too toxic, so Clark next worked with the perfluorochemicals (PFCs), organic compounds containing the element fluorine. Clinical trials with PFCs began in 1978, and the first red cell replacement using these chemicals was approved by the Food and Drug Administration in January 1990. The product, Fluosol, is a mixture of two PFCs, a mild detergent, and lipid molecules from egg yolk. Its use is very restricted. "Fluosol was approved as an oxygen-carrying drug in limited amounts, to be used during balloon angioplasty in the coronary arteries," explains Joseph Fratantoni, M.D., of FDA's Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research. With balloon angioplasty, an inflated balloon is used to press plaque against artery walls, opening up the blocked vessel. Blood flow to the neighboring area is temporarily impeded during the procedure, which may cause chest pain and change in heart muscle function. But Fluosol, infused through a narrow tube in the balloon, keeps the area oxygenated. Previous attempts to deliver blood through the balloon failed because a very small tube must be used, and the red cells are too large to squeeze through. But a Fluosol particle is only 1/900th the volume of a red blood cell, and the preparation is half as thick as blood. With the protective effect of Fluosol, it may be possible to extend the angioplasty technique to more patients. Fluosol may have other applications. Clinical trials are under way to examine its use following administration of "clot-busting" drugs such as streptokinase and tissue-plasminogen activator. After a clot is dissolved, the rush of blood through the opened region can damage tissue. Fluosol may stem this tide by allowing a steadier trickle of fluid past as the clot breaks apart. It may also help to save heart muscle normally deprived of oxygen during a heart attack and to oxygenate donated organs awaiting transplant. An obvious red cell substitute is the hemoglobin molecule itself, which would probably not trigger an immune reaction if freed from the red blood cells that normally contain it. (Such an immune reaction can occur if a mismatched blood transfusion, containing cells from incompatible blood types, is given.) There would be no compatability problem with freed hemoglobin, but it could carry disease, unless purified. Researchers at Somatogen Inc. in Broomfield, Colo., have circumvented these problems by mass-producing human hemoglobin in genetically engineered bacteria and yeast, providing a pure and abundant source of the molecule, much as human insulin is supplied to diabetics. But use of single hemoglobin molecules outside of their red cell carriers presents several problems. The molecules are broken in two in the body, and can then squeeze through the one-cell-thick walls of the capillaries and easily enter the kidney tubules to be excreted before delivering oxygen where it's needed. In addition, without co-factors contained in the red cell, hemoglobin cannot efficiently bind oxygen delivered by the lungs, and also loses antioxidant biochemicals that normally protect surrounding cells from damage by too much oxygen. Fortunately, clever chemists have already overcome these technological hurdles. They link individual hemoglobin molecules together, or chemically augment them. This provides the bulk the molecules need to stay in circulation. The molecule can even be further modified so that it not only binds and transports oxygen, but relinquishes it easily to oxygen-depleted tissues. Several companies are applying these chemical manipulations to human hemoglobin derived from donated blood, starting with a "crosslinking" technique developed by Quest Blood Substitute, Inc., in Detroit. Werner Wahl, Ph.D., vice president for science and technology at Quest, explains: "When you crosslink hemoglobin molecules, you add a chemical reagent to tie two or more of them together. There are lots of kinds of chemicals you can use, but some are better than others. Exactly how you crosslink determines the characteristics of the hemoglobin." Each company then introduces its own chemical modifications. One substitute, for example, follows crosslinking with a special pasteurization process to eliminate viral contaminants. A compromise between a free, "naked" hemoglobin molecule and nature's red cell packaging is to enclose hemoglobin in a fatty bubble called a liposome, forming a structure called a "neohemocyte." Biologically, this makes sense. "Evolution spent an awful lot of time and energy wrapping hemoglobin in a membrane. So, maybe it isn't surprising that when you unwrap the package, there is trouble," says Fratantoni. At the University of California at San Francisco, pharmaceutical chemist C. Anthony Hunt, Ph.D., is wrapping hemoglobin in the same type of capsules used to enclose ink in "carbonless carbon" paper and scents in "scratch 'n sniff" papers. But so far in animal studies, the immune system rapidly seeks and destroys these neohemocytes. Brave New Blood Vessels Delivery of blood through open vessels is crucial to cardiovascular function. Block a vessel with plaque or a clot, and blood flow backs up, robbing nearby tissues of vital oxygen. Blood can only flow through a smooth conduit. So far, none of the several methods to unclog or replace blocked arteries keeps them smooth indefinitely. Plaque that is scraped away or pressed against the artery wall recurs. A transplanted blood vessel may provoke the recipient's immune system to reject it, and taking a vessel from the patient's own body involves surgery at two sites rather than just one. Synthetic blood vessels cause problems too. "There is a great need for a living artery equivalent that has the properties of an actual artery," says Eugene Bell, Ph.D., chief scientific officer of Organogenesis, Inc., in Cambridge, Massachusetts. "No small-caliber, synthetic vascular graft presently exists that will remain unplugged by blood clots." That company's "living blood vessel equivalent," now being tested in animals, is a flexible yet strong tubule mimicking the triple-decker structure of real blood vessels. It is built of an inner layer of tile-like cells (called endothelium), a middle layer of smooth muscle, and an outer layer of connective tissue. The cells, which come from human cadaver arteries, are grown in the laboratory and then molded into the tubules. A very important step is the removal of molecules on the cells that are most likely to trigger an immune attack. A woven-in Dacron mesh lends strength to the tubules. The blood vessel equivalent can be made in any length or width, and can tolerate the pressure exerted by blood hurtling through the circulatory system. The vessel replacements can be stitched to their natural counterparts so seamlessly that blood clots are not likely to form. Bell foresees eventual use of the living blood vessel equivalent in cardiac bypass surgery, and in replacing damaged arteries in the brain and legs. Another possible blood vessel replacement is Dacron vessels coated with the patient's own endothelial cells. Because the body recognizes these cells as "self," it does not reject the replacement vessel. By adding certain growth factors, the cells are coaxed to knit a one-cell-thick endothelial lining on the interior of the Dacron tubules smooth enough to prevent clotting. In cell culture experiments conducted by Stuart Williams, Ph.D., and co-workers at Jefferson Medical College in Philadelphia, the lining began to form immediately. Valves Heart valves are flaps of tissue embedded in thin sheets of connective tissue. Located at strategic points in the heart, the valves keep blood flowing in one direction. About seven different types of artificial valves are approved for use by FDA. Some are similar to the first device, which resembled a ball in a cage. It was implanted in a 52-year-old man in 1961 by Albert Starr, M.D., and M.L. Edwards, M.D. "It's hard to beat the original Starr-Edwards model," says John Watson, chief of the devices and technology branch of the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. "Claude Pepper was one of the original people in Congress who helped form the institute, and he subsequently received a Starr-Edwards valve. He lived for 20 years and died from something unrelated. The fundamental design has been refined in terms of surgical technique and clinical management, but really there have been no significant breakthroughs." But opinion varies. Says William Letsing, M.D., of FDA's Office of Device Evaluation, "The Starr-Edwards is a 1960s type valve. Many newer models, such as the St. Jude, have much better hemodynamics and a higher state of technology." When natural heart valves do not close properly, are abnormally thick, or are damaged by rheumatic endocarditis (a complication of rheumatic fever that can also sometimes follow strep throat), replacement valves are lifesaving. After open-heart surgery became possible in the 1950s, surgeons first tried to treat valve disease by scraping away the calcium deposits causing the problem. But it was clear that replacing, rather than repairing, the valve would be more effective. Today mechanical prosthetic heart valves are built of a ceramic and a metal (such as titanium). Pig valves and cow pericardium (outer heart muscle) are also fashioned into valves that are mounted on synthetic bases called stents. About 75,000 people receive replacement heart valves in the United States each year. Mechanical models are generally used for those under 65 because of superior long-term durability, and for children, who tend to deposit calcium on biological valves. Older patients are usually given animal models that do not last as long because they are less likely to calcify or be blocked by clots and may not require replacement. Many patients with mechanical replacement valves must take anti-clotting drugs because they otherwise would have a considerably increased risk of a dangerous clot forming. But even a medical device as successful as heart valves can be improved. Charles Peskin, Ph.D., a mathematician at New York University, uses computer modeling to design better valves. Depicting the heart and its circulation in three dimensions, he alters the curvatures of the discs and angles of the pivot points so that the smoothest possible blood flow is achieved. "We think of clotting purely as a chemical process, but it also depends on fluid mechanics," Peskin says." If the blood stagnates in a pool, a clot will form. We're trying to design a valve so there will be no regions of stagnation." One of Peskin's heart valve designs is being patented, but his device is still a long way from an FDA application. The Artificial Heart In the 1980s, four men lived for varying amounts of time with artificial hearts. But problems were rampant. The plastic, metal and Velcro of the heart attracted bacteria to areas inaccessible to many antibiotics. The device also caused blood clots, triggering strokes. As a result, life for the "permanent" artificial heart recipient was difficult. Recipient William Schroeder, for example, suffered from strokes, seizures, fever, and depression on many of his record-setting 620 days with the Jarvik-7 device, which was then used predominantly as a short term "bridge to transplant." But even this temporary use was halted in January 1990. The attachment of the Jarvik device to the bulky exterior equipment is thought to be a route of infection. So many scientists hope a fully implantable, electrically driven artificial heart can be developed. Other artificial hearts are under development at the University of Arizona in Phoenix, the University of Utah in Salt Lake City, Pennsylvania State University in Hershey with 3M Corp., the Cleveland Clinic Foundation with Nimbus, Inc., Temple University in Philadelphia with Abiomed, Inc., the Minneapolis Heart Institute, and the Texas Heart Institute in Houston. Ventricular Assist Devices A currently more fruitful area of research is the electrically powered implantable ventricular assist device, a pump used to support the patient's left ventricle, the chamber that must work most vigorously to send blood on its way throughout the body. The 1970s and 1980s saw a variety of experimental left ventricular assists, all tethered to outside support equipment. Used as a bridge to transplant, the device is promising. In a study reported by R. Gaykowski, L. Barker, and W. Yates at the 34th annual meeting of the American Society for Artificial Internal Organs, 92 heart patients received Jarvik-7 devices while awaiting a heart transplant. Of these 92, 63 received donor hearts, and 35 of these survived, a survival rate after transplant of 56. In a similar evaluation of patients using the ventricular assist to sustain them until a donor heart became available, survival after transplant was 82. The difference in performance between the two devices may be anatomical location or technology complexity. "The technology for both devices is similar. But control of the total artificial heart is more difficult, because there are both left and right ventricles that must be integrated," says the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute's Watson. One type of totally implantable ventricular assist device is a blood pump about the size of a softball, inserted beneath the heart in the muscles of the abdomen. Blood from the left ventricle is diverted to the pump, which then sends it to the aorta, the largest artery in the body. The pump senses when to boost the blood by way of an electrically driven control unit that monitors the cardiac cycle. The control unit, about the size of a deck of cards, is also implanted in muscle. The implanted miniature electrical engine and rechargeable battery are charged from the outside by a coil and battery pack worn by the patient. The external coil is coupled to a second coil implanted under the skin of the abdomen. "We expect to begin implanting the device in people for clinical study in the fall of 1991. We are now in the process of fabricating the systems, selecting clinical centers, and developing protocols that will require an IDE [investigational device exemption] from the FDA," says Watson. Many cultures have regarded the heart as the center of a person's being. In the coming century, scientists hope to beat heart disease by a prudent combination of prevention and an arsenal of cardiovascular spare parts. n Ricki Lewis has a Ph.D. in genetics and teaches biology at the State University of New York at Albany. Blood's Journey Through the Heart The human heart is built of four chambers. The upper chambers--right and left atria--receive blood from the veins. The lower chambers--right and left ventricles--pump blood into the arteries. Valves keep blood flowing in the proper direction. Blood that has given up its oxygen to the tissues enters the heart at the right atrium. It passes through a valve to enter the right ventricle, from which it crosses a valve to enter the pulmonary artery. The blood then travels through the lungs, picking up oxygen and losing carbon dioxide. The newly oxygenated blood then flows through the pulmonary vein to the left atrium of the heart. The blood passes through another valve to enter the left ventricle, from which it exits the heart through a valve into the aorta, the largest artery. From the branches of the aorta, the blood travels in increasingly narrow arterial vessels, releasing its oxygen to the tissues along the way. The deoxygenated blood travels back to the heart in vessels that gradually increase in diameter, until the blood is in the two branches of the venae cavae, the veins that empty back into the right atrium. --R.L.