ATOP-HF     ATOP R&D    ATO    FAA    DOT     Ask FAA    
Aviation Maintenance

Aviation Maintenance > Maintenance Tools and Aids  > Human Error Assessment and Reduction Technique

 

HUMAN ERROR ASSESSMENT AND REDUCTION TECHNIQUE (HEART)

 

Function

To quantify operator errors by analyzing task characteristics.

 

Procedure

 

1. Classify the task type (GTT, Generic Task Type)
A - Totally familiar, performed at speed with no idea of likely consequences
B - Shift or restore system to new or original state on a single attempt without supervision or procedures

C - Complex task requiring high level of comprehension and skill

D - Fairly routine task performed rapidly or given scant attention

E - Routine highly-practised, rapid task involving relatively low level of skill

F - Restore or shift a system to original or new state following procedures with some checking

G - Completely familiar, well designed, highly practised routine task occurring several times per hour

H - Respond correctly to system command even when there is an augmented or automated supervisory system

M - None of the above

 

2. Assign Nominal Human Error Probability for each task (r)
A - 0.55
B - 0.26
C - 0.16
D - 0.09
E - 0.02
F - 0.003
G - 0.0004
H - 0.00002

 

3. Identify Error Producing Conditions and associated factors (EPC_f)
1 – Unfamiliarity
2 – Shortage of Time
3 – Low signal to noise ratio
4 – Ease of information suppression
5 – Ease of information  assimilation
6 – Model mismatch (operator / designer)
7 – Reversing unintended actions
8 – Channel capacity overload
9 – Technique unlearning
10 – Transfer of knowledge
11 – Performance standard ambiguity
12 – Mismatch between perceived / real risk
Total effect (f)
1 – x 17
2 – x 11
3 – x 10
4 – x 9
5 – x 8
6 – x 8
7 – x 8
8 – x 6
9 – x 6
10 – x 5.5
11 – x 5
12 – x 4

 

4 Determine the assessed proportion of Affect (APOA) based on the analysts judgment: Analyst estimates how much the conditions influence the unreliability of the task (p).

5. Calculate HEP (Human Error Probability):
HEP = r *
Õ
pi*(EPC_fi – 1) + 1
where i is the number of associated EPC factors and
and
Õ is the product over all EPC factors and must be smaller than 1 (Nominal Likelihood of Human Error).

 

6. Consider Error Reduction Measures
Error Reduction Measures can be assigned based on the associated, see Humphrey 88, Williams 88)

This procedure description was primarily informed by following Report:

Eurocontrol (2004). Review of Techniques to support the EATMP Safety Assessment Methodology, V(1), EEC Note No. 01/04

 

Advantages

Fast

Low resource requirements

 

Disadvantages

Guidance required to assign APOAs

Only single tasks can be assessed

Open to subjective variability between analysts

 

References

Eurocontrol (2004). Review of Techniques to support the EATMP Safety Assessment Methodology, V(1), EEC Note No. 01/04

 

P. Humphreys, Human reliability assessors guide, Safety and Reliability

Directorate UKAEA (SRD) Report No TRS 88/95Q, October 1988.

J.C. Williams, A data-based method for assessing and reducing human error to improve operational performance, 4th IEEE conference on Human factors in Nuclear Power plants, Monterey, California, pp. 436-450, 6-9 June 1988.

 

Tools

Risk Assessment

 


Human Error Assessment and Reduction Technique (HEART)
                 Product Type:  Tool             Product Class:  FAA Template
                               Year:                                Author:  Moertl, Peter
          Lifecycle Phase(s):  In-Service Management

            Lifecycle Task(s):  Establish

     Lifecycle Keyword(s):