{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
AND PERHAPS THIS ISN'T THE IDEAL SPOT FOR THIS DEBATE. I
ADDITION I WOULD ONLY SAY THAT THAT WAS THE AGREEMENT WHICH WAS
REACHED BY 100 SENATORS. THAT WE WOULD HAVE AMENDMENTS THAT
WERE NOT SPECIFICALLY GERMANE TO BANKRUPTCY AS PART OF THE
FINAL BILL THAT WE WILL DEAL WITH ON THE FLOOR THIS YEAR. SO
THE IDEA, I WOULD JUFLT HOPE WHO WILL ARGUE THAT WE SHOULDN'T
BE DEALING WITH THIS ISSUE WILL BE EQUALLY VOCAL IN COMPLAINING
ABOUT OTHER LESS GERMANE ISSUES IN THE BANKRUPTCY DEBATE,
{13:00:38} (MR. ABRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BECAUSE CLEARLY WE'RE GOING TO HEAR SOME FROM BOTH SIDES THAT
COULD BE ARGUED AS TO BEING INAPPROPRIATE IN THIS CONTEXT. THE
FACT IS, MR. PRESIDENT, I THINK THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WANT TO US
TAKE A TOUGH STAND ON DRUGS, WANT US TO TAKE A TOUGH STAND IN
FAVOR OF TOUGHER DRUG SENTENCES. OUR AMENDMENT ACCOMPLISHES
THAT, AND I SINCERELY HOPE OUR COLLEAGUES WILL JOIN US IN
SUPPORTING IT IN ITS PASSAGE A LITTLE LATER THIS MORNING. MR.
PRESIDENT, I YIELD THE FLOOR.
{13:01:05 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM NEW JERSEY.
{13:01:11 NSP} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LAUTENBERG: MR. PRESIDENT, THE -- ISK UNANIMOUS CONSENT --
HOIS THE TIME APPORTIONED?
{13:01:19 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM NEW JERSEY HAS 45
MINUTES, AND THE OTHER SIDE HAS 16 1/2.
{13:01:29 NSP} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LAUTENBERG: I THANK THE CHAIR. WE'LL TRY TO SAVE SOME TIME
FOR MY FRIEND FROM IOWA, ABOUT TWO MINUTES. MR. PRESIDENT, I
WANT TO RAISE MY VOICE IN OPPOSITION TO THIS AMENDMENT BECAUSE
I THINK IT'S WRONGHEADED DISTRACTION FROM THE REAL ISSUE THAT
PARENTS ALL OVER THIS COUNTRY CARE ABOUT, AND THAT IS THE
EPIDEMIC OF GUN VIOLENCE IN OUR SOCIETY AT LARGE, AND
ESPECIALLY IN OUR SCHOOLS. THIS AMENDMENT WOULD ALLOW FEDERAL
{13:02:00} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
EDUCATION FUNDING TO BE SHIFTED FROM SPECIAL EDUCATION,
COMPUTER TECHNOLOGY, BILINGUAL EDUCATION AND OTHER KEY PROGRAMS
TO PROVIDE VOUCHERS TO STUDENTS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF SCHOOL
VIOLENCE. NOW, ALL OF US -- IN A WAY, I'VE GOT TO TELL YOU, I
THINK THIS AMENDMENT HAS A CRUEL TWIST TO IT BECAUSE WE ALL
WANT TO BE OF HELP WHEREVER WE CAN BE TO THOSE WHO ARE
VICTIMIZED BY VIOLENCE. BUT LOOK AT THE WAY THE PROGRAM'S
DESIGNED. VOUCHERS TO SCHOOLS?
{13:02:38} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
IT DOESN'T, IN MY VIEW, REALLY MAKE A LOT OF SENSE WHEN IN FACT
IF WE COULD GET GUNS -- KEEP GUNS AWAY FROM OUR SCHOOLS, WE
WOULD NOT HAVE TO BE THINKING ABOUT VOUCHERS, BUT RATHER ABOUT
HOW WE EDUCATE OUR CHILDREN. IF WE COULD BRING OUR -- THE
TEACHERS INTO THIS SCHOOLROOM, AS THE PRESIDENT WOULD LIKE TO
HAVE US DO, 100,000 TEACHERS, PERHAPS THE WORKLOAD FOR MANY
WOULD BE ABLE TO BE CONFINED TO A SERIOUS REVIEW OF THE
EDUCATIONAL REQUIREMENTS. SO, THIS AMENDMENT, MR. PRESIDENT, IS
{13:03:16} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DISTURBING ON MANY LEVELS, SO MANY THAT I'M NOT SURE WHERE WE
BEGIN. IS THIS THE ANSWER TO SCHOOL VIOLENCE?
IGNORE THE CAUSES. DO NOTHING TO REMEDY THE ISSUE ISSUE, BUT
SHIFT CERTAIN KIDS OUT OF PUBLIC SCHOOLS. DOES THE REPUBLICAN
MAJORITY REALLY BELVE THAT SCHOOLS SHOULD CUT SPECIAL EDUCATION
AND COMPUTER FUNDING IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS TO FUND VOUCHER PROGRAMS?
NOW, MR. PRESIDENT, WE'RE APPROACHING THE 21ST CENTURY, AND
{13:03:53} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
EVERYONE KNOWS THAT WHEAFERT 20TH CENTURY BROUGHT BY WAY --
WHATEVER THE 20TH CENTURY BROUGHT BY WAY OF TECHNOLOGY,
COMPUTERS, ET CETERA, IS LIKELY TO BE DWARFED IN THE EARLIEST
YEARS OF THE 21ST CENTURY, AND IT ALL STARTS WITH A COMPUTER
BASE. WHY WE WOULD WANT TO TAKE NDS AWAY FROM THOSE PROGRAMS IS
REALLY HARD TO UNDERSTAND. IT'S NOT WHAT AMERICA'S PARENTS
WANT. THEY WANT ANSWERS. WE HAD ONE OF THE ANSWERS ON THE FLOOR
OF THIS SENATE. IT PASSED THIS BODY. THEY WANT TO SEE A
{13:04:27} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
JUVENILE JUSTICE BILL PASSED. BUT THE MAJORITY HAS BURIED THIS
LEGISLATION IN CONFERENCE AND DECLARED IT DEAD FOR THE YEAR.
IT'S HARDLY A WAY TO RESPOND TO THE ANGUISHED CALLS THAT WE
HEAR ALL OVER THIS COUNTRY. IT INCLUDES, YES, STRICTER
PUNISHMENT FOR THOSE WHO WOULD VIOLATE THE RULES OF BEHAVIOR IN
OUR SOCIETY, BUT IT WILL ALSO CLOSE THE GUN SHOW LOOPHOLE THAT
TOOK THE ANONYMOUS YER OUT OF THE EQUATION. IT REDUCED THE
POSSIBILITY THAT ANYONE WHO IS ON THE TEN MOST WANTED LISTS OF
{13:05:01} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE F.B.I. COULD WALK INTO A GUN SHOW AND BUY A GUN. AS
ATROCIOUS, AS OUTRAGEOUS AS THAT SOUNDS, THAT'S THE TRUTH. I
DON'T KNOW WHEN THE CONGRESS IS GOING TO CATCH UP WITH THE
AMERICAN PEOPLE. THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ARE SO FAR AHEAD OF THE
CONGRESS THAT IT'S EMBARRASSING. POLL AFTER POLL PLEADS WITH
THE SENATE, PLEADS WITH THE HOUSE. TAKE AWAY THE AVAILABILITY
OF GUNS SO FREELY, OR AT LEAST IF YOU'RE NOT GOING TO TAKE IT
AWAY, MAKE SURE THAT THOSE WHO BUY GUNS ARE QUALIFIED, THAT
{13:05:37} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THEY KNOW WHAT TO DO, THAT THEY'RE MATURE, THAT THEY'RE NOT
LIKELY TO USE THEM FOR A VIOLENT ENDING. THE PUBLIC IS
DEMANDING AN END TO THE GUN VIOLENCE. IT'S REACHED EPIDEMIC
PROPORTIONS. THE EVENT OF LAST WEEK PROVED NO ONE IS SAFE FROM
MAN YAKS WHO AMASS ARSENALS OF DEADLY WEAPONS AND USE THEM TO
GUN DOWN WHOLE GROUPS OF PEOPLE, PEOPLE FROM HAWAII TO SEATTLE,
FROM COLORADO TO TEXAS TO KENTUCKY. JUST THINK ABOUT IT.
SCHOOLCHILDREN, HIGH SCHOOLCHILDREN IN COLUMBINE, EVERYONE
{13:06:15} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
REMEMBERS THAT -- WILL NEVER FORGET -- THE PICTURE OF THAT
CHILD HANGING OUT THE WINDOW, PLEADING FOR HELP BEFORE SHE
FALLS TO THE -- HE OR SHE FALLS TO THE GROUND. AND THEN THE
NEXT ONE IS OFFICE WORKERS RUNNING AWAY FROM A GUNMAN IN
ATLANTA, GEORGIA. AND THE NEXT PICTURE OF YOUNGSTERS GATHERING
TOGETHER TO PRAY, BEING ASSAULTED BY A GUNMAN AND RUNNING FOR
THEIR LIVES FROM THAT. WE'VE GOT TO DO SOMETHING HERE TO STOP
THIS INSANITY. WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT A SYSTEM THAT
{13:06:47} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MAKES IT EASIER FOR SOMEONE TO BUY A GUN THAN TO GET A DRIVER'S
LICENSE. MR. PRESIDENT, WE ARE ABOUT AT THE END OF THIS
LEGISLATIVE SESSION, AND ONE THING IS CLEAR. WE HAVE GIVEN IN
TO THE EXTREMISTS OF THE GUN LOBBY, THE N.R.A., WHO POSE EVEN
THE MOST COMMON-SENSE -- WHO OPPOSE EVEN THE MOST COMMON-SENSE
PROPOSALS TO STOP GUN VIOLENCE. IF I WAS THEIR ADVISOR, I WOULD
SAY LISTEN GUYS, LISTEN WOMEN, LET'S GIVE IN ON THIS ONE. IT
DOESN'T HURT US A DARNED BIT AND IT MAKES US LOOK LIKE WE'RE IN
{13:07:23} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TOUCH WITH THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. BUT, NO, THE EXTREMISTS WENT
OUT, AND THEY HAVE THEIR HAND IN THIS PLACE AND THEY HAVE THEIR
HAND IN THE HOUSE, AND THEY TURN OUR PROGRAMS AWAY FROM PUBLIC
OPINION AND PUBLIC DEMAND. MOST AMERICANS ASSUME THAT THE
HORRIFIC SHOOTING IN COLUMBINE WOULD BE ENOUGH, THE ULTIMATE
OUTRAGE. MOST AMERICANS THOUGHT THAT THE VISION OF TWO HIGH
SCHOOL STUDENTS SYSTEMATICALLY KILLING 12 CLASSMATES AND A
TEACHER AND WOUNDING 23 OTHERS WOULD FINALLY SPUR CONGRESS TO
{13:07:55} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ACTION, WOULD FINALLY SAY THAT'S ENOUGH, THAT'S ENOUGH. AFTER
THOSE -- THAT TERRIBLE INCIDENT, 89% IN ONE POLL, 91% IN
ANOTHER POLL ASKED FOR THE ELIMINATION OF THE GUN SHOW
LOOPHOLES. BUT IT WAS IGNORED HERE. THE PUBLIC OUGHT TO LOOK AT
WHY IT WAS IGNORED. THE REASON I THINK IT WAS IGNORED IS THAT
CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTIONS OVERWHELM THE GOOD JUDGMENT AND THE
DEMANDS OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTIONS. GET
{13:08:30} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ELECTED, THAT'S WHAT COUNTS. THERE'S MORE TO IT THAN THAT. THAT
IS SEVEN MONTHS AGO WHEN THAT HAPPENED. STILL CONGRESS HASN'T
ACTED EVEN WHILE THE BODY COUNT RISES. JUST LAST WEEK NINE MORE
PEOPLE WERE SHOT AND KILLED IN RAMPAGES BY TWO GUNMEN. ONE OF
THESE GUNMEN OWNED 17 HANDGUNS. IN MAY OF THIS YEAR THE SENATE,
WITH VICE PRESIDENT GORE'S HELP, PASSED MY GUN SHOW LOOPHOLE
AMENDMENT AS PART OF THE JUVENILE JUSTICE BILL. THE GUN SHOW
LOOPHOLE AMENDMENT -- I'LL TAKE A MINUTE MORE DESCRIBE -- SAID
{13:09:03} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THAT GUN SHOWS, WHERE SO MANY GUNS ARE BOUGHT, TRADED AND SOLD,
HAD A PLACE FOR NONLICENSED GUN DEALERS, NONFEDERALLY LICENSED
GUN DEALERS. IN THOSE CASES ANYONE, IT DIDN'T MATTER WHOURP,
COULD WALK UP TO ONE OF NOSE GUN DEALERS AND SAY, "GIVE ME 20
GUNS, AND HERE'S THE MONEY." AND THERE WOULD BE NOT ONE
QUESTION ASKED. WHAT'S YOUR NAME?
WHERE DO YOU LIVE?
WHAT DO YOU DO FOR A LIVING?
HAVE YOU BEEN IN JAIL?
HAVE YOU BEEN A DRUG ADDICT?
HAVE YOU BEEN AN ALCOHOLIC?
HAVE YOU BEEN KNOWN TO HAVE BURSTS OF TEMPER AND OUTRAGE?
{13:09:38} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HAVE YOU BEAT YOUR WIFE, YOUR CHILDREN?
NOT ONE QUESTION. IT'S OUTRAGEOUS. NOT ONE QUESTION. WE TRY TO
CLO THAT -- CLOSE THAT LOOPHOLE. AND IT WAS A COMMON-SENSE
MEASURE THAT WOULD HAVE STOPPED LAWBREAKERS, UNDER AGE
CHILDREN, MENTALLY UNSTABLE FROM WALKING INTO A GUN SHOW AND
WALKING OUT WITH A SMALL ARSENAL. WE FAFED 51-50. BUT AS SOON
AS THE SENATE PASSED MY AMENDMENT, THE N.R.A. SOUNDED ITS
{13:10:09} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ALARM, AND ITS ALLIES WENT TO WORK TO DEFEAT THE PROPOSAL IN
THE HOUSE. THE GUN LOB BY SPENT MILLIONS ON RADIO AND TV ADS,
BUT OF COURSE THOSE ADS DIDN'T MENTION THE GUN MASSACRES THAT
FOLLOWED COLUMBINE. THEY DIDN'T MENTION THAT IN THE FIRST WEEK
IN JULY A VIOLENT RACIST WENT ON A SHOOTING RAMPAGE IN ILLINOIS
AND INDIANA KILLING FOUR PEOPLE AND INJURING NINE. AND A FEW
WEEKS LATER A DERANGED DAY TRADER IN ATLANTA SHOT NINE PEOPLE
TO DEATH IN AUGUST AND WOUNDED 13, OR THAT IN AUGUST A MAN WITH
{13:10:41} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
A .44 CALIBER GLOCK GUN KILLED THREE CO-WORKERS IN ALABAMA.
THERE IS NO SAFE -- THERE IS NO PEOPLE, GROUP OF PEOPLE SAFE,
NO ETHNIC GROUP, RELIGIOUS GROUP, OTHERWISE. FIVE DAYS AFTER
THAT A WHITE SUPREMACIST KILLED A FILIPINO POSTAL WORKER, SHOT
FOUR YOUNG PEOPLE AT A JEWISH DAY-CARE CENTER. WHO WILL FORGET
THAT SCENE?
THESE LITTLE KIDS, KIDS LIKE MY GRANDCHILDREN, BEING LED OUT BY
POLICEMEN OUT OF THE SCHOOLYARD, SCHOOLHOUSE WHERE THEY WENT TO
LEARN AND VE FUN, RUNNING AWAY FROM A KILLER. OR THAT JUST LAST
{13:11:18} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MONTH A WELL-ARMED MANIAC WALKED IN A BAPTIST CHURCH IN FORT
WORTH, TEXAS, AND KILLED SEVEN YOUNG PEOPLE AT A PRAYER
GATHERING. DAY BY DAY THIS DEATH TOLL IS ON OUR FAMILIES AND
OUR FRIENDS, WHERE WE WORK, WHERE WE LIVE. PEOPLE KILLED BY
GUNS EVERY YEAR IN THIS COUNTRY, MORE PEOPLE THAN WE LOST
DURING THE KOREAN WAR. ADDITIONALLY, WE WIND UP TREATING 134,0
GUN SHONE WOUNDED, AND THE COST TO THE COUNTRY IS OVER $2
{13:11:57} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BILLION A YEAR, AND TAXPAYERS PAY ALMOST HALF OF THAT. AND
WHILE THE N.R.A. MAY BE ON THE REPUBLICANS SIDE, LAW
ENFORCEMENT IS ON OURS. I WO WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT IN DRAFTING
MY GUN SHOW AMENDMENT, AND I RECEIVED NUMEROUS LETTERS FROM LAW
ENFORCEMENT ORGANIZATIONS SUPPORTING THAT AMENDMENT AND OTHER
GUN-SAFETY MEASURES THE SENATE PASSED. I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT
THAT THE COPIES OF THE LETTERS BE INSERTED IN THE RECORD.
{13:12:27 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{13:12:30 NSP} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LAUTENBERG: SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES MAY RECALL THAT FORMER
PRESIDENT GEORGE BH RESIGNED FROM THE N.R.A. BECAUSE THE
ORGANIZATION REFERRED TO LAW ENFORCEMENT PEOPLE AS JACK-BOOTED
THUGS. WHAT A TWIST THAT IS. TO TRY AND PIN ON OUR LAW
ENFORCEMENT PEOPLE, WHO COURAGEOUSLY ARE OUT THERE RISKING
THEIR OWN LIVES, TRYING TO PROTECT OTHERS, REFER TO THEM AS
JACK-BOOTED THUGS. THAT HARDLY DOES IT. I SALUTED GENERAL --
{13:13:00} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
PRESIDENT BUSH FOR THAT ONE. 10 WE OUGHT TO BE SKEPTICAL WHEN
THE N.R.A. SAYS IT SUPPORTS LAW ENFORCEMENT. WE OUGHT TO BE
SKEPTICAL ALSO WHEN THEY USE THE SECOND AMENDMENT TO PROMOTE
EXTREMIST VIEWS. WE HAVE TO LOOK EVERY NOW AND THEN AND SEE
WHAT THE SECOND AMENDMENT REALLY SAYS. AND I QUOTE HERE, "A
WELL-REGULATED MILITIA BEING NECESSARY TO THE SECURITY OF A
FREE STATE, THE RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE TO KEEP AND BEAR ARMS SHL
NOT BE INFRINGED." IT DOESN'T SAY THAT YOU OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO
BUY IT WITHOUT A LICENSE. IT DOESN'T SAY THAT IF YOU'RE CRAZY,
YOU OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO BUY A GUN. IT DOESN'T SAY IF YOU'RE 12
{13:13:33} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
YEARS OLD, YOU OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO BUY A GUN. IT DOESN'T SAY
YOU OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO BUY AS MANY GUNS AS YOU WANT. NO MATTER
HOW BROADLY ONE WANTS TO INTERPRET THAT, THERE IS NOTHING THERE
THAT SAYS THAT YOU SHOULDN'T HAVE TO HAVE A LICENSE TO BUY A
GUN. NONE OF THAT. BUT THE AMENDMENT, THE INTERPRETATION OF THE
AMENDMENT HAS BEEN BROADENED, BUT THE COURTS DON'T HOLD THAT.
THE COURTS DON'T SUPPORT IT. BUT THAT'S THKIND OF GOBBLEDYGOOK
THAT ACCOMPANIES THAT. IT'S LIKE WHEN THEY SAY GUNS DON'T KILL,
PEOPLE KILL. WELL, WHO PULLS THE TRIGGER?
ANIMALS?
{13:14:07} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
I GUESS MAYBE IN SOME WAY THEY ARE. YOU'LL NOTICE THAT YOU
NEVER HEAR THE N.R.A. TALKING ABOUT THE FIRST 13 WORDS IN THAT
AMENDMENT, "A WELL-REGULATED MILITIA BEING NECESSARY TO THE
SECURITY OF A FREE STATE." THEY ONLY CITE THE LAST 14 WORDS,
WHEN IT ARGUES THAT THE AMENDMENT CREATES AN UNLIMITED RIGHT
FOR INDIVIDUALS TO BEAR ARMS. NONSENSE. AND THE N.R.A. KNOWS
THE HISTORY OF THE SECOND AMENDMENT, DOESN'T SUPPORT THE
ORGANIZATION'S RADICAL VIEWS. WHEN THE CONSTITUTION WAS BEING
{13:14:44} (MR. LAUTENBERG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DEBATED, EACH STATE HAD ITS OWN MILITIA, AND MOST ADULT MALES
WERE REQUIRED TO ENLIST AND TO SUPPLY THEIR ENE-- OWN
EQUIPMENT, INCLUDING THEIR OWN GUNS. THE SECOND AMENDMENT WAS
WRITTEN IN RESPONSE TO CONCERNS THAT EXCESSIVE FEDERAL POWER
MIGHT LEAD TO THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT PASSING LAWS TO DISARM
THOSE STATE
{END: 1999/11/10 TIME: 13-15 , Wed. 106TH SENATE, FIRST SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}