Home

Table 5.11. Effects of toothed scallop dredges on biogenic substrate habitat: summary of published studies. (S = statistically significant; citations in bold print are peer-reviewed publications.

Reference Location Depth Sediment Effects Recovery Approach
Hall-Spencer and Moore 2000a Clyde Sea, Scotland 10-15 m Live bottom (maerl) with some cobble and boulders Disturbance of seafloor to 10 cm; overturned boulders; suspended sediment; erasure of bottom features and burial of living maerl in dredge tracks; most megafauna in top 10 cm either caught in dredge or left damaged in dredge track (large, fragile organisms more vulnerable); rapid aggregation of predatory species in track. Dredge tracks remained visible for 0.5-2.5 yrs; some recovery rates of large epibenthic species variable, some recovering quickly, but others at unexploited site had not recovered 4 yr after dredging; macrobenthic community at previously exploited site recovered within 2 yr. Observations of the effects of single dredge tows at a previously dredged and undredged site; immediate effects and recovery (after 4 yr) evaluated by divers using video cameras.