Copyright 2000 A Lamaze International Publication The Polomeno Family Intervention Framework for Perinatal Education: Preparing Couples for the Transition to Parenthood This article has been cited by other articles in PMC. | ||||
Abstract Couples face many challenges as they transform themselves from dyad to triad. For some couples, these challenges are life-enriching experiences, while for others, chaos ensues, potentially leading to separation and divorce. The transition to first-time parenthood, even for well-functioning couples, is fraught with potential disorganization. At the same time, it provides opportunities for simultaneous self-growth and conjugal enrichment. What role can perinatal educators play in preparing couples to deal with the changes associated with this transition? To answer this vital question, the author presents her conceptualization of perinatal education as a primary family intervention framework during the perinatal period. Keywords: perinatal education, transition, parenthood, couples, intervention framework | ||||
The challenge in perinatal programs is not only to prepare couples for childbirth but also to sensitize them to the transition to parenthood and all that it entails. Preparation for the transition to the couple partnership* within the parent role requires the educator to devote time to the couple's relationship and help them to reconnect as needed. This includes teaching the couple how to be more in tune with each other, increase their sense of intimacy, improve conjugal support and communication, and enhancetheir sexual relationship. The author believes that perinatal education is entering a new era as perinatal educators become well educated, expand their knowledge base, conduct research, and experiment and evaluate different approaches. She proposes that the expanded practice of perinatal education include a primary family intervention framework for couples experiencing the transition to parenthood. This article will present an approach that has evolved from the author's development and experimentation with various programs for perinatal education. What information would assist perinatal educators to prepare couples for the transition to parenthood? This can be done in separate classes, or it is possible to include this information in traditional childbirth education classes without compromising preparation for the birth experience (Polomeno, 1997e). How can this be done, if at all? When is it best done? Should perinatal education be expanded so couples can be better prepared for the transition to parenthood? | ||||
Today, perinatal education is becoming a recognized specialty with a firmly established scientific basis. It has grown from a one-to-one approach in the early years to a comprehensive program, and it has developed from the practice of childbirth education (Nichols & Zwelling, 1997). Perinatal education has been defined as “health education for the family unit during pregnancy, childbirth, and the early parenting period … [It] is composed of a variety of different types of classes that address the needs of all family members as the family moves from one developmental life cycle stage to another during the childbearing years” (Nichols & Zwelling, 1997, p. 590). It has become family oriented by focusing on this transition period of the family (Peterson & Peterson, 1993). Malnory (1996) stipulates that, as a developmental stage, pregnancy is not only critical for the well-being of the person, the infant, and the family but also for the well-being of the couple. The perinatal educator has a supportive role of providing information about the normal processes and changes that are common during this time of transition (Lothian, 1993). Starn (1993) indicates that perinatal education may be “looked upon as an opportunity to strengthen family systems through anticipatory guidance and skill building that family members may use throughout the life cycle” (p. 35). Zwelling (1996) indicates that “childbirth education, for the most part, has been accepted by the health care community and most childbirth classes have moved into the health care system” (p. 428). She specifies that a favorable outcome of this movement is twofold: more parents can be reached and childbirth educators can have a positive influence on the health care system. Ernst (1994) explains, “Science supports the expansion of education ofparents and family-centered childbirth, mainstreaming midwifery, and developing alternatives to the acute care hospital for childbirth. These three major efforts … promote the fundamental need for consumers to take more responsibility for their health and for the way they use the medical care system. This basic shift of responsibility is essential to effective, long-term reform” (pp. 134-135). Thus, if parents are to be part of effective, long-term health care reform with increased responsibility, it follows that educating parents only for childbirth is no longer sufficient but should be expanded to include the whole transition to parenthood. Sheila Kitzinger, author and long-time birth advocate, challenges perinatal educators to re-examine the content and the structure of prenatal classes. She and others recommend that educators help prepare families for fulfilling births and making smooth transitions to parenthood (Elliott, 1995). In a recent critique of the author's perinatal education program for the health promotion of expectant fathers (Polomeno, 1998a, 1998b), Budin (1998) quotes a perinatal educator who was part of the analysis: “ … [W]e as childbirth educators have always put so much emphasis on an event that occurs in a few hours (labor and birth) and we have not focused on issues that affect these couples for a lifetime” (p. 38). Issues that influence the preparation of couples for the transition to parenthood lie partly with trends that occur in both society and the health-care system. In this new century, these trends will influence adults, their relationships, family making, and childrearing. Perinatal education must broaden its base to prepare couples not only for childbirth and early parenting but also for the entire transition to parenthood. Broadening the base of perinatal education involves modifying current programs to include knowledge about the transition to parenthood, relational skills such as communication and emotional support, family health promotion, and enrichment of marital intimacy and sexuality.
| ||||
Several changes occurring in society will influence men and women, their relationships with each other, and how they will birth and parent their children. Perinatal educators have the opportunity to respond to these trends in order to meet the future needs of childbearing and childrearing couples. In his book Psychotrends, Frazier (1994) highlights some of these predicted major changes:
Other authors (as cited below) predict additional societal trends will affect partnering and sexuality in the next century:
| ||||
At the same time, a paradigm change is occurring in health care delivery in both the lay and professional literature. Overall, there is a rapidly emerging emphasis on establishing a prevention and wellness focus. This shift will create sweeping changes in all arenas of the health-care marketplace. Arnold and Kirby (1996) mention some of these sweeping changes: the consolidation of affiliations within communities, regions, and across continents; the improvement of the health status of communities with more integrated community efforts; the designing of accessible health care systems compatible with quality and cost containment indicators; and the expansion and dissemination of technology. The perinatal specialty is one that has profoundly and rapidly been impacted by these changes. Jones and Maestri (1997) explain how alternative health care delivery systems such as Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs), Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs), and Independent Practice Organizations (IPOs) are being developed in the United States: “These new delivery systems further challenged the traditional functioning of the health care system by adding services that emphasize preventive maintenance, in addition to the treatment of illness … [H]ospitals have responded by reducing operating costs, decreasing the average length of stay (ALOS), and implementing market strategies that target the health care needs of women. Thus, the interaction of consumer demand and economic constraints mandated that hospitals replace outmoded obstetric systems with maternity services that are high in quality, cost efficient, and consumer sensitive” (p. 38). Canada, which has a social medicine model of health care delivery, has also reorganized its health care system due to escalating health care costs. Some predict that the relationship between the health care team and their clientele will change more towards partnership, collaboration, and consumer empowerment and participation (Cox, 1997; Jewell, 1994; Sheer, 1996; Skelton, 1994). As a result, health care workers will need to support families by putting more emphasis on health promotion and disease prevention, increasing the significance of parenting to society, working with families to reduce fragmented care, achieving optimal outcomes, promoting a more consumer-friendly system with increased focus on primary health care/promotion education outside the walls of academic health centers, and inviting family participation in primary prevention and early treatment of illness (Cox, 1997). The members of the health care team themselves will need to work in an interdisciplinary mode rather than a multidisciplinary one so that each member of the health care team will understand and be conversant in the cognitive maps or thought processes of the other team members. The new knowledge base, then, will be greater than the sum of the knowledge of the participants (Sheer, 1996). Quimby (1994) states, “Finally, the dialogues must take place in all health care arenas and with professionals, patients, families, policy makers, and business leaders; in short, everyone with an interest in the outcomes must participate” (p. 122). How will perinatal educators participate in these dialogues and respond to the above trends? How can perinatal education be modified? The author proposes that perinatal education be considered a primary family intervention. She has developed an intervention framework, which is presented in this next section. | ||||
In this section, the Polomeno Family Intervention Framework for Perinatal Education will be introduced. Each component of the framework is presented below. (See Figure 1.) Overview Steil (1997) explains, “Relationship intimacy must be continuously affirmed through shared experiences in which partners feel understood and valued. Under these conditions, intimacy benefits both partners, enriching their relationship and promoting psychological and emotional growth. In the absence of understanding and validation, or through mere neglect, there can be stagnation and gradual deterioration, a diminution of shared experiences and a decline in appreciation and affection” (p. 76). Based on family life theory (Cowan, 1991), if a couple does not successfully adapt to each stage of conjugal life, unresolved emotional issues will be brought into the next stage of conjugal life, potentially increasing the already existing strain often associated with each stage of parenthood. The accumulation of conjugal strain could eventually result in emotional withdrawal and set into motion an irreversible process leading to dissatisfaction and unhappiness with the relationship. This can potentially result in separation and divorce.Assumptions Underlying Promoting Partnership during Parenthood The following five principles underlie the intervention framework:
The Concepts at the Heart of the Framework Family Intimacy. Conjugal intimacy is foundational for intimacy within the total family. “Family intimacy is critical … since the family will [ideally] become the safe haven for each of its members. The sense of security the family produces will have beneficial consequences, both short-term and long-term, for their unborn's development and the development of other children to follow” (Polomeno, 1998e, p. 20). Schaef's definition of intimacy can be adapted for family intimacy: “True [family] intimacy is a process that grows with time. It is a process of knowing and being known, and it requires openness and willingness from each person involved. [Family] intimacy has no techniques … [and] cannot be orchestrated. It starts with the self, knowing the self and being present to the self … [Family] intimacy is not static. It is always moving to a new level. It is an energy flow with no barriers … [and] cannot be controlled. Like a feeling, it cannot be held onto or reproduced at will. We notice [family] intimacy. We do not produce it” (1989, pp. 136-137). The Scope of Conjugal Intimacy. Street (1994) defines intimacy as interactions that relate to open self-disclosure and close personal exchanges. This includes the sharing of feelings, hopes, fears, and vulnerabilities. Conjugal intimacy includes—but is more than—sexual intimacy (Schaefer & Olson, 1981). Intimacy can exist between any two persons, but conjugal intimacy is seen as a crucial component of a healthy relationship (Kenny & Acitelli, 1994). Indeed, intimate couples report feeling the presence of their partner even though he or she is not physically present (Monsour, 1994). Knowing that the other is always in one's thoughts is essential to the maintenance of intimacy. Adults have described it as “feeling the other in one's blood!”—a statement that reflects the strong mind-body-spirit connection. Intimacy must be recreated daily and renewed in each stage of conjugal life. The feeling that each partner is in tune with the other is also important (Keeley & Hart, 1994). If a couple feels out of synchrony, they can develop strategies to re-establish this bond and/or admit they are temporarily out of synchrony. Conjugal intimacy is a wonderful healer and a support in the hassles of everyday life. However, the changes associated with the transition to parenthood can disturb the feeling of synchrony or harmony. If so, with effort the couple can re-establish intimacy in their relationship (Clulow & Mattinson, 1989; Polomeno, 1997e), leading to a renewal of love and sexuality.
Couples should be aware that physical love is not sufficient to maintain a long-term committed relationship such as marriage (Clulow & Mattinson, 1989; Dinkmeyer & Carlson, 1989; Polomeno, 1999d, 1999e). The successful transition to parenthood necessitates emotional and psychological intimacy, the most difficult of all intimacies to experience (Carlson, Sperry, & Dinkmeyer, 1992), and include the following traits:
At least two authors, Framo (1981) and White (1998), state that the greatest gift parents can give their offspring is a viable, happy, healthy, and loving relationship. Assuming this is so, perinatal education can make a major contribution to society by helping couples tune in to the changes in the emotional and psychological intimacy of their relationship, while simultaneously promoting the emotional and physical health of the next generation. Thus, promoting a couple's relationship through the perinatal transition is a foundational aspect of family health promotion.
The Shared Meaning Approach to Building Intimacy The reader is encouraged to become acquainted with Duck's (1994)A General Model of the Serial Construction of Meaning, which forms the basis for this section of the framework. Four stages are exhibited in the model: (a) commonality, (b) mutuality, (c) equivalence of meaning, and (d) sharing. To attain a sharing of meaning in a relationship, a couple must appraise and determine the meaning contained within their interaction. The appraisal process is activated through the use of interactive perceptions, as presented in Table 1 and repeated in Figure 1. Each person's perception (self-perception) and the other's perception (metaperception) are interwoven in a communications dance so that the couple may find meaning or the significance in a given situation, often leading to the common ground(Allen & Thompson, 1984).When a couple feels they are sharing a situation, they will begin to feel that they are similar (Genero, et al., 1992). Similarity (Monsour, 1994) is important as one partner gains understanding about himself/herself, his/her partner, and the situation (Kelly, 1969). The couple will experience feelings of closeness and reciprocity, leading to feelings of being a team, two people in a partnership (Cutrona, 1996). This appraisal-meaning-common-ground building process is mediated by communication, social support, sexuality, intimacy, and equality (Suitor, 1991). Primary Family Prevention: Anticipatory Guidance The following goals form the basis of the teaching approach to promote intimacy in a couple experiencing transition to parenthood:
Mediators and the Process of Family Intervention The mediators include communication, social support, maintenance behaviors, intimacy and sexuality, and equality. These are addressed in Table 1. | ||||
The following theoretical content is offered as a teaching guide for the perinatal educator. Five questions are raised in this section of the article: (a) What are transitions? (b) What happens to family health during transitions? (c) What is the transition to parenthood? (d) What is the connection between the conjugal relationship and the transition to parenthood? and (e) What types of interventions are appropriate for couples coping with this transition? A perinatal educator can choose parts of this theoretical content to explain the transition to parenthood to couples attending perinatal education classes. The integration of the content will depend on the type of program being taught, the nature of the group attending classes, the time factor, the training and comfort level of the educator, and the pertinence of the theoretical background. Transitions Defined. Transitions are pauses in the family life cycle or periods of disorganization and reorganization as the family and its members advance from one stage of life to another. (See Table 2.) Cowan (1991) defines transitions as “longterm processes that result in a qualitative reorganization of both inner life and external behavior” (p. 5). Each transition has the potential to be accompanied by changes in health-promoting lifestyles (Bomar, 1996) as well as potential health disturbances at the physical, psychological, emotional, and social levels due to biological changes in hormonal function and the immune system (Dura & Kiecolt, 1991). Transitions may be developmental or situational and expected or unexpected (Murphy, 1990). Some transitions may trigger a greater response than others (Cowan, 1991). See Table 2.Family Health During Transitions. The family unit typically undergoes four stages in its health during family transitions: (a) evaluation of the current lifestyle, (b) planning for behavior change, (c) implementation of behaviors to enhance family health, and (d) evaluation of family outcomes (Pender, 1987). It is important that members of the family unit accomplish the developmental tasks associated with each stage of the family life cycle in order to successfully move on. If crises are encountered during the family life transitions and are not resolved, then fixations, regressions, and other forms of psychological dysfunction may result (Cowan, 1991).The Transition to Parenthood. The transition to parenthood is classically defined as the time period beginning with a pregnancy and terminating a few months after the baby's arrival (Goldberg, 1988). (See Table 2.) However, an extension has been proposed by Gottlieb and Pancer (1988) as beginning with the couple's decision to become pregnant and terminating when the child is between 2 and 3 years old (Wright & Leahey, 1994). This time span of 2 to 4 years is congruent with the time people usually need as when experiencing any of the major life transitions (Hetherington & Camara, 1984; Wallerstein & Kelly, 1980).The author of this article has conceptualized the transition to parenthood as containing nine phases.
The transition to parenthood can be considered complete when the child is 2 years old. This belief is based on clinical observations from the domain of family therapy that alludes to the 2-year period demarcating a major life transition (Hetherington & Camara, 1984; Wallerstein & Kelly, 1980). Cowan and colleagues (1991) state, “We believe that it makes sense to describe the end of the transition to parenthood as occurring, on the average, when the first child is about 2 years old” (p. 88). (See Table 3.) The Connection of Conjugal Relationship and Transition to Parenthood. A connection—both positive and negative—exists between the conjugal relationship of a couple and the transition to parenthood. (See Table 4.) Couples usually express feelings of closeness and mutuality due to the sharing of a common project and of maturity with the increased responsibilities of childrearing (Lederman, 1984). Increased personal and conjugal fulfillment and satisfaction seem to occur (Bomar, 1989; Shereshefsky & Yarrow, 1973) with couples who have successfully adapted to the transition to parenthood. Conversely, some couples experience less conjugal satisfaction (Cowan, Cowan, Heming, & Miller, 1991) from increased personal and conjugal stress (Bomar, 1989; Cowan, et al., 1991), which may lead to an emotional distance in the relationship (Keith & Whitaker, 1988). The arrival of the first child most affects the couple's relationship (Bradt, 1989; Broom, 1984; Clulow, 1982) and is perceived differently by men and women (Clulow, 1991).Interventions for Couples in the Transition to Parenthood. Any interventions focusing on the couple's relationship in the transition to parenthood should be aimed at reinforcing the relationship (Cowan, et al., 1991), which will have long-term consequences for their children's early development and psychological well-being. Each partner's evaluation of the transition and the combination of their evaluations could affect their satisfaction with the relationship (Cowan & Cowan, 1988). After an appraisal process, the couple's strengths and resources can be utilized in order to reduce any negativity that could be attributed to relationship failure rather than the stress associated with the transition itself. A group setting such as that provided by perinatal education classes can be the ideal safe haven or time-out for couples to explore issues, concerns, thoughts, and feelings (Clulow, 1982; Cowan et al., 1991). The role of the perinatal educator is to facilitate this awareness, create a safe environment for exploring issues, support the couples in their exploration through effective communication, reinforce existing strengths and resources, and assist the couples as they develop their feelings of partnership leading to the couple's common ground. | ||||
Several perinatal education concepts or programs are summarized below and represent various aspects of the intimacy intervention useful with transitioning couples. These may be integrated into a traditional childbirth education course or added as separate courses to a comprehensive perinatal program. Health Promotion from the Couple's Perspective. A couple is encouraged to understand and establish health promotion for themselves and lay the foundation for the next generation (Polomeno, 1999d, 1999e). Health and all its dimensions, including their love for each other, are stressed as important for the couple's relationship and for short-term and long-term conjugal satisfaction and intimacy.Health Promotion for the Expectant Father. The promotion of family health should be expanded to include the expectant father (Polomeno, 1998a, 1998b), especially since he is traditionally left out while the pregnant partner and fetus are being cared for by the health-care team.Fetal Touch. A couple can rediscover each other through a third person, namely, the fetus (Polomeno, 1998e, 1997a). Conjugal partners can enter into the world of the unborn, learn about their child's development, touch and massage the fruit of their love, and become intimate with their child before his or her birth. As the expectant parents caress the pregnant abdomen, their touch can become loving, sensual, sexual, and even erotic (Polomeno, 1997a). The baby shares in the expectant parents' intimate exchanges and closeness.Intimacy During Pregnancy. Many couples become more separate during the physical and psychological changes associated with pregnancy. Each partner may withdraw temporarily from the relationship to ponder these changes and integrate them into their psyche. If so, this temporary rift can lead to the withdrawal of physical intimacy, which may set a negative precedent for the future of the relationship. To prevent negative outcomes, intimacy should then be evaluated by the couple during pregnancy, and the couple can be encouraged to focus on the sexual changes occurring at that time and learn to understand each other's experience (Polomeno, 1997e).Sexuality of the Birth Event. Intimacy continues as the couple gives birth to their offspring (Polomeno, 1998d, 1998e). “The sexual overtones associated with the birth event [when] discussed by perinatal educators [can assist couples to] continue the psychological work involved in transforming the intimacy dimension of their relationship … The transformation of the couple's intimacy which begins with pregnancy and continues during labor and birth can become important in laying the foundation for the couple's future family intimacy” (Polomeno, 1998c, p. 18). When each stage of the transition to parenthood is fully lived and integrated into the couple's core of shared meaning, they are supported in becoming successful parents and having a happy and intimate relationship. Broome and Koehler (1986) support the notion that “… unmet expectations [about the birth event] could lead to a generalized feeling of dissatisfaction with both the event and the spouse that could affect perceptions of parenting and marital satisfaction later” (p. 40).Sex and Breastfeeding. In the postpartum, as mothers choose to breastfeed their babies, this experience also has sexual overtones and can affect and be affected by a couple's relationship and their intimacy (Polomeno, 1999a). Consequences of breastfeeding include a mother's needs for affection being met in part by her baby, the normal sensual feelings associated with the experience, and the precarious nature of the woman's libido. For her, the breasts are no longer considered as a primary erogenous zone, and this may require the male partner to modify his sexual repertoire during this period. Milk-filled breasts sexually excite some men. Couples with sexual openness have used their imagination to enrich their experience when milk ejects from the woman's breasts following her orgasm during the sexual encounter.Postpartum Sexuality. The couple's sexual relationship often requires some adjustment in the postpartum (Polomeno, 1996). The woman's libido may not automatically return after the birth of her baby, but it can be reawakened and nurtured by her partner. A four-stage process for the reawakening of a woman's libido has been prepared. This information has been greatly appreciated by both men and women. The use of perineal massage can be encouraged, especially as a means of desensitizing the vagina and preparing it for the resumption of sexual intercourse in the postpartum.Social Support. A couple often needs external social support to successfully adjust to the transition to parenthood. At times and for various reasons, a woman may find herself alone in this adjustment (Polomeno, 1997b). Couples can be taught to strengthen their support system. This information is applicable for heterosexual couples, but much of its content can also be pertinent for gay and lesbian couples. Building strong support systems can be helpful for all life situations. One goal will be to promote, both directly and indirectly, the child's physical, emotional, and social development.Grandparents. Intergenerational support is also important for the couple's successful transition to parenthood. Grandparents can be helpful in enhancing both conjugal intimacy and family intimacy (Polomeno, 1999b, 1999c). The grandparents can be buffers for any stress that may occur in each stage of the transition to parenthood. Harmonizing the relationships between the conjugal partners and between themselves and their offspring is very helpful. The grandparents themselves are experiencing their own transition, which could have an impact on their children and grandchildren. Thus, providing support for the grandparents' transition may assist them to offer more optimal support for the new parents.High-Risk Pregnancy. A couple's intimacy may be disturbed by high-risk pregnancy, especially if antenatal hospitalization is required (Polomeno, 1997c, 1997d). Even couples experiencing normal pregnancy gain preparedness by obtaining a basic understanding of high-risk pregnancy, the organization of at-risk perinatal health services, and coping strategies to deal with the emotional upheavals associated with the situation. | ||||
To what extent are perinatal educators and/or comprehensive perinatal programs preparing couples for the transition to parenthood? Many are beginning to do so, but some educators may need more knowledge and training in order to better prepare couples for this important life transition. Martin and Starling (1989) believe that clinician educators must especially increase their familiarity with conjugal issues and recent changes in health services. Many couples can benefit from supportive anticipatory guidance and counseling that acknowledges the predictable changes in their relationships (Goldberg & Michaels, 1988). The normalization associated with anticipatory guidance can reduce anxiety and frustration that often surround conjugal conflict and set the stage for adaptation and resolution. One aspect of the perinatal educator's role becomes that of validating the couple's feelings. Additionally, sharing feelings in discussion within a group setting of expectant parents can reopen channels of communication for a participating couple. Cutrona (1996) says, “In the same way that people are not born with the knowledge of how to be good parents, we are not born knowing how to be supportive marital partners” (p. 101). What couples may not have learned from their childhood role models related to partnering and parenting can be addressed in programs of perinatal education. Healthy families is the desired outcome for perinatal education practice, the greater society, and ultimately, the health-care system.
| ||||
Footnotes *In this article, the author will refer to the couple's partnership, which includes both marital and nonmarital pairs. Other terms to be used synonymously are the conjugal relationship or the conjugal dyad. | ||||
References
| ||||