{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
{12:00:04} (END-TEST) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
{12:00:10 NSP} (PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE: THE SENATE WILL COME TO ORDER. THE
CHAPLAIN WILL NOW DELIVER THE OPENING PRAYER.
{12:00:28 NSP} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE CHAPLAIN: ALMIGHTY GOD, CREATOR OF THE WORLD, RULER OVER
ALL LIFE, OUR ADONAI, SOVEREIGN LORD OF OUR LIFE, WE JOIN WITH
OUR JEWISH FRIENDS IN CELEBRATING ROSH HASHANAH, "THE HEAD OF
THE YEAR," THE BEGINNING OF THE DAYS OF AWE AND REPENTANCE, A
TIME OF RECONCILIATION WITH YOU AND WITH ONE ANOTHER. WE THANK
YOU THAT WE ARE UNITED IN OUR NEED TO REPENT, TO RETURN TO OUR
{12:00:59} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
REAL SELVES FOR AN HONEST INVENTORY, AND THEN TO COME BACK TO
YOU WITH A HUMBLE AND CONTRITE HEART.
FORGIVE OUR SINS OF OMISSION: THE WORDS AND DEEDS YOU CALLED US
TO DO THAT WE NEGLECTED, OUR BLAND CONDONING OF PREJUDICE AND
HATRED, AND OUR TOLERATION OF INJUSTICE IN OUR SOCIETY. FORGIVE
OUR SINS OF
COMMISSION: THE TIMES WE TURNED AWAY FROM YOUR CLEAR AND
{12:01:34} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SPECIFIC GUIDANCE AND THE TIMES WE KNOWINGLY REBELLED AGAINST
YOUR MANAGEMENT OF OUR LIVES AND YOUR RIGHTEOUSNESS IN OUR
NATION. SOUND THE SHOFAR IN OUR SOULS; BLOW THE TRUMPETS; AND
WAKE OUR SOMNOLENT SPIRITS. AROUSE US AND CALL US TO SPIRITUAL
REGENERATION. AWAKEN US TO OUR ACCOUNTABILITY TO YOU FOR OUR
LIVES AND THE LEADERSHIP OF THIS NATION. WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
{12:02:06} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ATONING GRACE AND FOR THE OPPORTUNITY FOR A NEW BEGINNING. HELP
THE JEWS AND CHRISTIANS CALLED TO SERVE IN THIS SENATE, THE
SENATORS' STAFFS, AND THE WHOLE SUPPORT TEAM OF THE SENATE TO
CELEBRATE OUR UNITY UNDER YOUR SOVEREIGNTY AND TO EXEMPLIFY TO
OUR NATION THE ONENESS OF A SHARED COMMITMENT TO YOU. IN YOUR
{12:02:44} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HOLY NAME. AMEN.
{12:02:52 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: MR. PRESIDENT?
{12:02:57 NSP} (PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE: THE ABLE MAJORITY LEADER, SENATOR
LOTT OF MISSISSIPPI, IS WREAKED.
{12:03:00 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: THANK YOU, MR. PRESIDENT. CONGRATULATIONS TO YOU, MR.
PRESIDENT. I UNDERSTAND THAT ONE OF YOUR SONS WAS MARRIED THIS
PAST WEEKEND AND WE WISH HIM MUCH HAPPINESS IN THE FUTURE. THIS
AFTERNOON THE SENATE WILL BE IN A PERIOD OF MORNING
BUSINESS UNTIL 2:00 P.M. I KNOW THERE ARE SENATORS THAT WISH TO
SPEAK DURING THAT TIME. SENATOR CRAIG IS HERE. FOLLOWING
MORNING BUSINESS, THE SENATE WILL RESUME CONSIDERATION OF S.
1301, WHICH IS THE SKURNLE BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION ACT. AS
ANNOUNCED, PREVIOUSLY, THERE WILL BE NO ROLL CALL VOTES DURING
TODAY'S SESSION OUT OF RESPECT FOR THE JEWISH HOLIDAY. MEMBERS
{12:03:30} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ARE REMINDED THAT A CLOTURE PETITION WAS FILED ON FRIDAY TO THE
COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE TO THE CHILD CUSTODY PROTECTION ACT.
THEREFORE, MEMBERS WILL HAVE
UNTIL 1:00 P.M. TODAY TO FILE FIRST-DEGREE AMENDMENTS. THE NEXT
ROLL CALL VOTE WILL
OCCUR AT APPROXIMATELY 2:20 P.M. TOMORROW ON OR IN RELATION TO
THE KENNEDY MINIMUM WAGE AMENDMENT. FURTHER VOTES ARE EXPECTED
TOCK STACKED FOLLOWING THE MINIMUM WAGE VOTE AND THEN CONTINUE
INTO THE EVENING AS THE SENATE ATTEMPTS TO COMPLETE ACTION ON
THE BANKRUPTCY BILL. ALL MEMBERS WILL BE NOTIFIED AS TO THE
{12:04:04} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TIME AND NUMBER OF VOTES DURING TUESDAY'S SESSION. AS THAT
INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE. BUT AGAIN WE WILL HAVE A VOTE OR
VOTES -- POSSIBLY AS MANY AS TWO OR THREE -- BEGINNING
AT 2:20 P.M. AND OTHER VOTES IN THE AFTERNOON PLUS WE WILL HAVE
HOPEFULLY FINAL PASSAGE ON BANKRUPTCY REFORM AND THE CLOTURE
VOTE ON CHILD CUSTODY. AND THEN TUESDAY MORNING WE WILL
ANNOUNCE THE SCHEDULE FOR THE BALANCE OF THE WEEK AS BEST WE
CAN DETERMINE T BUT THAT TAKES A LOT OF COOPERATION FROM
{12:04:38} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MEMBERS ON BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE. I YIELD THE FLOOR, MR.
PRESIDENT.
{12:04:44 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: UNDER THE PREVIOUS ORDER, THERE WILL NOW
ABFEARED FOR THE TRANSACTION OF MORNING BUSINESS FOR A PERIOD
OF TIME NOT TO EXTEND BEYOND THE HOUR
OF 2:00 P.M.
THE TIME UNTIL 1:00 P.M. SHALL BE UNDER THE CONTROL OF THE
SENATOR FROM IDAHO, SENATOR CRAIG, OR HIS DESIGNEE.
AND THE TIME UNTIL 2:00 P.M. SHALL BE UNDER THE CONTROL OF THE
SENATOR FROM NORTH DAKOTA, MR. DORGAN, FOR HIS DESIGNEE. MR.
CRAIG: MR. PRESIDENT?
{12:05:08 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM IDAHO.
{12:05:13 NSP} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. CRAIG: MR. PRESIDENT, I HAVE REQUESTED SPECIAL ORDERS THIS
MORNING IN MORNING BUSINESS TO TALK ABOUT OUR PRESIDENT, TO
TALK ABOUT OUR PRESIDENT'S POLICIES, TO TALK ABOUT THIS
ADMINISTRATION AND THE POLICIES THAT IMPACT ALL AMERICANS. AS
WE KNOW, THE SENATE HAS CONVENED AT A VERY INTERESTING, UNIQUE,
IF NOT SAD DAY IN THE HISTORY OF THIS NATION'S PRESIDENCY. I
WILL NOT DWELL ON THAT. IT WOULD BE VERY INAPPROPRIATE FOR ME
{12:05:44} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TO DO SO. WHAT I DO WANT TO TALK ABOUT IS AN AGENDA THAT WE
HAVE ATTEMPTED TO HANDLE APPROPRIATELY HERE ON THE FLOOR FOR
THE LAST SEVERAL WEEKS. THAT IS TO DO THE BUSINESS OF THIS
CONGRESS AND TO DO THE BUSINESS OF GOVERNMENT. TO MOVE THE
APPROPRIATIONS BILLS IN AN ORDINARILY FASHION, AS OUR PUBLIC --
IN AN ORDERLY FASHION AS OUR PUBLIC AND AS THE CITIZENS OF THIS
NATION WOULD EXPECT OF US. FOR THE LAST TWO WEEKS WE HAVE
ATTEMPTED TO DEAL WITH AN APPROPRIATIONS BILL APPROPRIATING
MONEY TO THE INTERIOR DEPARTMENT AND TO ITS INSUL LARRY
{12:06:18} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AGENCIES TO IN LARGE PART ADMINISTER POLICY AND MANAGE THE
PUBLIC RESOURCES, THE PUBLIC LAND RESOURCES OF THIS COUNTRY.
BUT ANYONE WATCHING AND CERTAINLY THE MAJORITY LEADER THAT JUST
LEFT THE FLOOR KNOWS HOW FRUSTRATING IT HAS BEEN IN AN ATTEMPT
TO RESPONSIBLY MOVE THIS LEGISLATION ONLY TO HAVE OUR
COLLEAGUES ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE AISLE LARGELY OPPOSE IT,
OPPOSE IT BECAUSE WITHIN THE BILL ARE CORRECTIVE MEASURES THAT
REFLECT AND ATTEMPT TO ADJUST THE MISGUIDED POLICIES OF THIS
{12:06:53} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ADMINISTRATION AS IT DEALS WITH OUR PUBLIC LAND RESOURCES. WE
HAVE MADE PROPOSED CHANGES. WHY?
BECAUSE THE PUBLIC'S OF THE PUBLIC -- BECAUSE THE PUBLICS OF
THE PUBLIC LANDS WEST ARE SAYING THAT NO LONGER DOES THIS
ADMINISTRATION REFLECT OUR INTEREST OS OUR CONCERNS OR OUR
ECONOMIES. WHY AM I SPEAKING UNIQUELY TO THE WEST?
WELL, THE APPROPRIATIONS BILL LARGELY DEALS WITH WESTERN PUBLIC
LAND STATES' INTERESTS. BUT IN MY STATE OF IDAHO WHERE 63% OF
THE LAND BASE IS OWNED BY AND MANAGED BY THE FEDERAL
{12:07:27} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
GOVERNMENT, PUBLIC LAND POLICY IS CRITICAL. AND MINE IS ONLY A
63% OWNERSHIP. IN OTHER STATES LIKE NEVADA, IT IS MUCH HIGHER.
SO GOES THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, SO MANAGES THE LAND, SO GOES
THE ECONOMY. AND THE LIFESTYLES AND THE CHARACTER OF THOSE
STATES. SO WHAT I'D LIKE TO SPEND THE NEXT FEW MINUTES
DISCUSSING ARE THOSE POLICIES AND OUR CONCERN ABOUT THE
ATTITUDE OF THIS ADMINISTRATION AS IT HAS IMPACTED OUR
{12:08:01} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
POLICIES. THE PROVISIONS THAT I AM TALKING ABOUT IN THE
APPROPRIATIONS BILL, IF WE CAN EVER GET FWOOK IT, ARE NECESSARY
IN MY VIEW AND APPROPRIATE BECAUSE MANY OF US FEEL THIS
ADMINISTRATION HAS GONE AROUND CONGRESS AND THE STATES AND THE
LOCAL OFFICIALS IN AN EFFORT TO PLACE BROAD RESTRICTIONS ON THE
USE OF PUBLIC LANDS FOR PRODUCTIVE ECONOMIC USE, SUCH AS MINING
AND FOREST PRODUCTS AND GRAZING AND EVEN RECREATION.
RECREATION, A RELATIVELY BENIGN USE OF THE PUBLIC LAND, IS NEW
{12:08:32} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BEING SHAPED, DIRECTED AND OFTENTIMES CHARACTERIZED BY NEW
POLICIES OF THIS ADMINISTRATION. WE BELIEVE STRONGLY THAT THE
PROVISIONS WE HAVE PLACED IN THE INTERIOR APPROPRIATIONS BILL
ARE NECESSARY. AS I MENTIONED EARLIER,TO BLOCK THE
ADMINISTRATION'S ARROGANT ABUSE OF POWER AND ITS FAILURE TO
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT OUR STATES OUGHT TO HAVE A SAY IN THE USE OF
OUR NATURAL RESOURCE BASES. DURING THE PAST 175 YEARS, THE
{12:09:06} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
UNITED STATES HAS UNDERGONE AN ASTONISHING PERIOD OF PHYSICAL
AND ECONOMIC GROWTH. WE ACQUIRED THE LOUISIANA TERRITORY,
BOUGHT ALASKA FROM THE RUSSIANS AND FOUGHT A WAR WITH MEXICO
OVER THE SOUTHWEST AND CALIFORNIA. DURING THAT TIME, AMERICANS
MOVED WESTWARD, PURSUING DREAMS OF ECONOMIC INDEPENDENCE AND
THE OPPORTUNITY TO RAISE THEIR FAMILY OR THEIR FAMILIES IN A
NEW LAND. OUR GOVERNMENT ENCOURAGED THE WESTWARD MOVEMENT OF
THESE HEARTY PEOPLE BY CREATING OPPORTUNITY THROUGH THE
{12:09:39} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HOMESTEAD ACT OR THE TIMBER AND STONE ACT OR THE MINING LAW OF
1872. THESE STATUTES AND OTHERS WERE DESIGNED TO ENCOURAGE
PEOPLE TO SEEK A NEW LIFE, TO BUILD THE WEALTH OF A NATION BY
DEVELOPING ITS VAST STORE OF NATURAL RESOURCES. AND THE EFFORT
WAS SUCCESSFUL BEYOND ANY NATION OR ANY PEOPLE'S WILDEST DREAMS
AND IMAGINATIONS. THOUSANDS OF AMERICAN FAMILIES AND
{12:10:13} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SHOPKEEPERS AND -- AMERICAN FARMERS AND SHOPKEEPERS AND CLERKS
TUNING THE CHALLENGE AND MOVED WEST. THEY BUSTED THE SOD OF THE
CENTRAL PLAINS AND ESTABLISHED AN AGRICULTURAL WONDER. THE
BREADBASKET OF THE WORLD, NEVER KNOWN BEFORE BY MAN. THESE
ESTABLISHED -- THEY ESTABLISHED ENORMOUS CATTLE AND LIVESTOCK
OPERATIONS FROM TEXAS TO KANSAS AND MONTANA AND THROUGHOUT THE
ROCKY MOUNTAIN STATES, INCLUDING MY STATE OF IDAHO. THOUSANDS
OF PROSPECT ERLS FANNED OUT ACROSS THE STATE IN SEARCH OF GOLD
{12:10:46} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AND SILVER AND OTHER MINERALS. WHAT THESE EARLY MINERS FOUND AT
SUFMT TTER'S MILL IN COLORADO OR AT TELL U RIDE IN COLORADO OR
AT THE BASIN IN IDAHO AND HUNDREDS OF OTHER BOOM TOWNS ACROSS
THE WEST, GALVANIZED THE NATION. THOUSANDS MORE ORDINARY
AMERICANS GOT CAUGHT UP IN THE GOLD RUSH, TOO. MOST WERE NOT
SUCCESSFUL IN FINDING THEIR BONANZA. INSTEAD, THEY FORMED THE
BACKBONE OF THE NEW WEST, BECAUSE THEY BROUGHT OTHER SKILLS AND
TALENTS WITH THEM. THESE ARE THE PEOPLE WHO BUILT THE GREAT
{12:11:23} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CITIES OF DENVER AND SALT LAKE CITY AND BOISE AND HELENS AND
HOUSTON AND SAN FRANCISCO. THEY BECAME THE MERCHANTSS, THE
BANKERS THE DOCTORS, AND THE EDUCATORS THAT HELPED ENSURE THE
SUCCESS OF THE INTERMOUNTAIN AND THE COASTAL WEFMT THESE
AMERICANS BUILT THE GREAT TRANSCONTINENT RAILROAD TO BRING
ADDITIONAL SETTLERS INTO THE GROWING CITIES AND TOWNS AND TO
MOVE THE EXPLODING BASKET OF WESTERN PRODUCE GOODS TO THE
MARKETS OF THE EAST. THROUGHOUT THE BALANCE OF THE 19TH CENTURY
{12:11:59} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AS WELL AS THE 20TH CENTURY, BOTH FEDERAL AND PRIVATE LANDS IN
THE WEST CONTRIBUTED MIGHTILY TO THE ECONOMIC SUCCESS OF OUR
GREAT NATION. IN ADDITION TO GOLD AND SILVER DEPOSITS, LEAD,
NICKEL, GOLD, IRON AND OTHER MINERALS WERE DISCOVERED AND
DEVELOPED. IN THE 1920'S AND 1930'S, OIL AND NATURAL GAS
DEPOSITS WERE FOUND IN COLORADO, WYOMING, MONTANA, UTAH, AND
NEW MEXICO AND, OF COURSE, THE FOREST PRODUCTS AND THE LIVE
{12:12:34} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
STOCK INDUSTRIES CONTINUED TO GROW AND TO PROSPER, PROVIDING
BUILDING MATERIALS AND FOOD FOR OUR GROWING NATION. THESE
ACHIEVEMENTS WERE NOT REALIZED BY THE UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
BUT BY THE WOMEN AND THE MEN WHO ACCEPTED THE CHALLENGE, WHO
HAD THE VISION AND TO HAD THE COURAGE. THEY TOOK ENORMOUS RISK
AND WITH THEIR LIVES AND WITH THEIR FORTUNES THEY BUILT NEW
BUSINESSES, OPEN MINES, STARTED RANCHES AND FARMS AND BEGAN NEW
{12:13:05} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
LIVES AND CREATE ADD NEW CULL TURX A TRA DIGS, A WESTERN
CULTURE TRADITION, BASED ON WISE AND SUSTAINABLE USE OF THE
LAND AND ITS RESOURCE. MR. PRESIDENT, I CAN TALK ABOUT THIS
FIRSTHAND. MY OWN FAMILY IS A PART OF THAT TRADITION OF
INDEPENDENCE AND DETERMINATION. 100 YEARS AGO NEXT YEAR MY
GRANDFATHER SAT FOOT IN IDEA HOED AND TOOK ADVANTAGE OF THE
HOMESTEAD ACT AND BEGAN TO BUILD A RANCHING OPERATION THAT
FLOURISHED TO BUILD A FAMILY AND TO BE PASSED TON A FUTURE
{12:13:42} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
GENERATION. THE WESTERN TRADITION RECOGNIZED THE VALUE OF LAND
AND ITS RESOURCES AND THE NEED TO HUSBAND THOSE RESOURCES
CAREFULLY AND SUSTAINABLY. NO ONE CAN HONESTLY BELIEVE THAT WE
WHO LIVE ON AND DEPEND ON THESE PRECIOUS LANDS WOULD SEEK TO
STRIP THEM OF ALL OF THEIR VALUES AND DENY THEIR USE AND THEIR
BEAUTY TO THE REST OF AMERICANS. YOU SEE, MY GRANDDAD TAUGHT MY
FATHER THAT TRADITION AND MY FATHER TAUGHT ME THAT THE LAND WAS
{12:14:18} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
A SACRED RESOURCE THAT SHOULD BE MANAGED WISELY. INDEED, WITH
FOREST PRODUCTS, MINING AND OIL AND GAS PROBLEMS PROBLEMS,
RECREATION OOL OPPORTUNITIES BEGAN TO FLOURISH FLOURISH, BEGAN
TO INCREASE. MORZ AND MORE AMERICANS ARE COMING TO ENJOY THE
NATURAL BEAUTY AND THE RESOURCES OF THE INTERMOUNTAIN WEST.
THEY COME TO ENJOY OUR HUNTING AND OUR FISHING, OUR
SIGHTSEEING, OUR CAMPING, OUR MOUNTAIN CLIMBING AND TO JUST BE
{12:14:50} (MR. CRAIG) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
PLAIN QUIET. IN OTHER WORDS, TO SEARCH FOR AND FIND SOLITUDE.
THESE OPPORTUNITIES WERE ONCE AVAILABLE ONLY TO THOSE OF US WHO
LIVED IN THESE GREAT STATES OF THE WEST -- THE
{END: 1998/09/21 TIME: 12-15 , Mon. 105TH SENATE, SECOND SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}