{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
IS WIDELY ACKNOWLEDGED TO BE A SHORT-COMING. COLOMBIA IS A
LARGE COUNTRY. ONE OF THEIR DEPARTMENTS IS AS LARGE AS THE
NATION OF EL SALVADOR. IN FIGHTING INSURGENCY, THE STATE HAS TO
DEFEND MANY CRITICAL AREAS, BUT ALSO HAS TO HAVE THE CAPABILITY
TO MASS AND EE ECONOMIZE FORCES TO ATTACK GUERRILLA FORMATIONS
WHEN THEY PRESENT THEMSELVES. MR. PRESIDENT, COLOMBIA'S ARMY
{20:30:36} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HAS BARELY 40 HELICOPTERS FOR A TERRITORY THE SIZE OF TEXAS AND
MEXICO COMBINED. EL SALVADOR, 1/50TH THE SIZE OF COLOMBIA, HAD
80, TWICE AS MANY DURING ITS CIVIL WAR. MR. PRESIDENT, ALTHOUGH
THE ARMY HAS 12,000 SOLDIERS, MOST OF THEM ARE ONE-YEAR CON
SCRIPPS. APPROXIMATELY 35% ARE HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATES NOT
ASSIGNED TO COMBAT DUTIES BY LAW. AT ANY TIME, ABOUT 30% ARE
UNDERGOING BASIC TRAINING. A LARGE PORTION OF THE MAINING
{20:31:14} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FORCES IS ASSIGNED TO STATIC DEFENSE OF KEY ECONOMIC OR
ISOLATED MUNICIPAL OUT POSTS. THAT LEAVES, MR. PRESIDENT, ONLY
ABOUT 20,000 SOLDIERS REMAINING FOR OFFENSIVE COMBAT
OPERATIONS. THESE ARE THE VETERANS OR VOLUNTEERS THAT
CONSTITUTE APART FROM THE OFFICER CORPS ACTION THE ONLY TRUE
REPOSITORY OF TRUE COMBAT EXPERIENCE IN THE COLUMBIAN ARMY.
NOW, MR. PRESIDENT, CONSIDER THAT THE ACTIVE GUERRILLA COME BA
{20:31:50} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TANTS ALONE NUMBER BETWEEN 11,000 TO 20,000. DO THE MATH. IT
DOESN'T LOOK GOOD. IT'S CONCEIVABLY A RATIO OF 1-1. A FIGHTING
RATIO OF 1-1. HOW CAN A MILITARY WITH LIMITED RESOURCES, MR.
PRESIDENT, FIGHT TWO GUERRILLA MOVEMENTS WHICH HAVE VIRTUALLY
UNLIMITED RESOURCES FROM DRUG TRAFFICKING, KIDNAPPING,
EXTORTION AND ARMS TRAFFICKING?
HOW CAN THEY DO IS IN THE ANSWER IS, IT IS VERY, VERY
DIFFICULT, AND COLOMBIA FACES A HUGE CHALLENGE. MR. PRESIDENT,
{20:32:25} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE COLUMBIAN ARMY HAS ALREADY SUFFERED A STRING OF MILITARY
DEFEATS. IN 1998, THE COLUMBIAN ARMED FORCES SUFFERED THREE
MAJOR BLOWS IN MARCH, AUGUST, AND THEN AGAIN IN NOVEMBER. IN
FACT, THE FARK EXECUTED ONE OF ITS MAJOR BLOWS AGAINST THE
MILITARY JUST AS PRESIDENT P PASTRANO WAS MEETING WITH FARK
LEADERS ON PEACE TALKS. THE FARK CURRENTLY OLDS OVER 300
MILITARY AND POLICE PRISONERS OF WAR. AND ACCORDING TO JANE'S
{20:32:58} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
INTELLIGENCE REVIEW, COLUMBIAN GUERRILLAS KILLED 445 SOLDIERS
DURING 1998. MR. PRESIDENT, IF YOU INCLUDE COLUMBIAN NATIONAL
POLICE, THE FIGURE WOULD RISE AS HIGH AS 600. THE CNP TOO HAS
EXPERIENCED SIGNIFICANT LOSSES. OVER 4,000 POLICEMEN HAVE BEEN
KILLED IN COLOMBIA IN THE PAST DECADE. 4,000. MR. PRESIDENT, AS
IF THE FARK WEREN'T ENOUGH AFTER PROBLEM, LET ME NOW FURTHER
{20:33:32} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
COMPLICATE THIS SITUATION BY DISCUSSING THEIR SECOND PROBLEM.
AND THAT IS THE WAR WITH THE E.L.N. FIRST THE FARK, NOW THE
E.L.N. THE E.L.N. HAS BEEN ENVIOUS OF THE ATTENTION THE FARK
HAS BEEN GETTING PARTICULARLY AT THE NEGOTIATING TABLE, AND AS
A RESULT, THE E.L.N. RESORTED TO A SERIES OF RECENT HOSTAGE
TAKINGS. SHORTLY AFTER PRESIDENT PASTRONA AND THE FARK
ANNOUNCED IN APRIL THAT FORMAL NEGOTIATIONS WOULD TAKE PLACE IN
THE SUMMER, THE E.L.N. HIJACKED A COLOMBIAN COMMERCIAL AIRLINER
{20:34:07} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
IN APRIL KIDNAPPING 41 PASSENGERS AND CREW. THEN SHORTLY AFTER
THE DEFENSE MINISTER'S RESIGNATION, ABOUT 30 E.L.N. GUERRILLAS
INVADED A CHURCH SERVICE IN AN UPPER-CLASS NEIGHBORHOOD IN CALI
AND ABDUCTED OVER 40 WORSHIPERS. IN RESPONSE THE GOVERNMENT
DEPLOYED MORE THAN 3,000 SOLDIERS AND POLICEMEN TO TRY TO
LOCATE THEM. NOW WHILE SOME HOSTAGES HAVE BEEN RELEASED FROM
THE HIJACKING, AND FROM THE CHURCH INCIDENT, APPROXIMATELY 50 L
{20:34:46} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
STILL BEING HELD INCLUDING TWO AMERICANS. NOW, MR. PRESIDENT, I
HAVE OUTLINED THE TWO MAIN GUERRILLA GROUPS WHICH ARE A
SIGNIFICANT THREAT TO COLOMBIA. HOWEVER, I HAVE NOT YET SPOKEN
OF ANOTHER, A THIRD ONGOING WAR WHICH POSES AN ADDITIONAL AND
SUBSTANTIAL THREAT. I AM TALKING NOW ABOUT THE COLOMBIAN PARA
MILITARIES. IN FACT THE COLOMBIAN PARA MILITARIES ARE SEEKING A
{20:35:18} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ROLE AT THE NEGOTIATION TABLE. THEY ARE AN UMBRELLA
ORGANIZATION WE BELIEVE OF 5,000 ARMED COMBATANTS. THERE
MISSION HAS BEEN TO COUNTER THE GRIP OF LEFTIST GUERRILLAS.
CARLOS COSTANIO THE POWERFUL LEADER OF THE GROUP HAS BEEN
QUOTED DEFENDING THE STRATEGY OF KILLING VILLAGERS WHO ARE
GUERRILLA SUPPORTERS AND SYMPATHIZERS. THE PARAMILITARIES ARE
FUNDED BY WEALTHY LANDOWNERS, AND IN SOME CASES, COCAINE
{20:35:53} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TRAFFICKERS. THEY EX O OWE THEY EXZERO OWE THEY EXERCISE
INCREASING INFLUENCE AND DID DURING 1998 EXTENDING THEIR
PRESENCE INTO AREAS PREVIOUSLY UNDER GUERRILLA CONTROL. THE
PRESENCE OF PARAMILITARY GROUPS HAS DRIVEN A WEDGE IN PEACE
TALKS BECAUSE THE FARK REFUSES TO NEGOTIATE UNLESS IT
GOVERNMENT CLAMS DOWN ON THE RIGHT WINNING GUNMEN. THE PROBLEM
IS THE GOVERNMENT ALSO HAS A PROBLEM IN TRYING TO CONTROL THE
PARAMILITARY. NOW IN AN ATTEMPT TO BECOME A PLAYER AT THE
{20:36:26} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
NEGOTIATING TABLE, COSTANIO ORGANIZATION KIDNAPPED A COLOMBIAN
SENATOR JUST LAST MONTH. IN FACT, COSTANIO SAID SHORTLY AFTER
THE ABDUCTION HIS AIM WAS TO GAIN POLITICAL RECOGNITION ON A
PLACE AT THE NEGOTIATING TABLE FOR HIS MOVEMENT. THE SENATOR
WAS FREED AFTER BEING HELD FOR ABOUT TWO WEEKS. THE SENATOR
LATER COMMENTED THAT THE PASTRANO GOVERNMENT SHOULD EVENTUALLY
INCLUDE COLOMBIA'S PARAMILITARY FORKS IN NEGOTIATIONS TO END
{20:36:59} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE 35-YEAR LONG CIVIL WAR. SINCE THE LEFTIST REBELS VEHEMENTLY
OPPOSE THEIR PARTICIPATION IN THE PEACE TALKS, PROS PEGST FOR
THE PEACE NEGOTIATIONS ARE COMPLICATED EVEN FURTHER. NOW, MR.
PRESIDENT, BEFORE I TALK ABOUT THE INCREASING DRUG THREAT FROM
COLOMBIA, LET ME SPEND A FEW MINUTES ON THE GENERAL VIOLENCE IN
COLOMBIA. ACCORDING TO THE U.N. HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN
RIGHTS, COLOMBIA LEAD LED THE WORLD IN KIDNAPINGS IN 1998 AND
MAY BE THE MOST LIKELY PLACE IN THE WORLD TO BE ABDUCTED. THE
{20:37:33} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
COUNTRY AVERAGES 5 PEOPLE A -- FIVE PEOPLE A DAY -- FIVE PEOPLE
A DAY, SNATCHED BY GUERRILLAS OR OTHER CRIMINALS. GUERRILLAS
FROM THE FARK, E.L.N., SMALLER POPULAR LIBERATION ARMY
ACCOUNTED FOR APPROXIMATELY 1,600 KIDNAPINGS OF THE 2,600
REPORTED IN 1998. A REPORT ISSUED BY THE COLOMBIA GOVERNMENT'S
ANTI-KIDNAPPING OFFICE IN MAY CALCULATED THAT AT LEAST 4,925
PEOPLE HAVE BEEN ABDUCTED SINCE JANUARY 1996, WITH THE LARGEST
{20:38:09} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TOTAL COMING IN 1998. NOW MR. PRESIDENT, THE PROBLEM WITH THIS
STATISTICS IS THAT MANY FAMILIES AND BUSINESSES PREFER TO DEAL
DIRECTLY WITH KIDNAPERS, AND SIMPLY NEVER REPORT THE ABDUCTIONS
TO THE POLICE. HENCE THIS FIGURE IS ONLY THE OFFICIAL FIGURE.
IT IS UNDERSTANDABLY DIFFICULT TO COUNT HOW MANY KIDNAPINGS
ACTUALLY OCCUR IN COLOMBIA EVERY DAY, EVERY MONTH, EVERY YEAR.
IMAGINE, IF WE CAN, LIVING IN A COUNTRY WHERE YOU CAN'T SEND
OUR CHILD ON SCHOOL FIELD TRIPS, WHERE YOU CAN'T DECIDE TO GO
{20:38:43} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OUT OF BOGOTA FOR THE WEEKEND TO ADVICE ILT RELATIVES IN A
NEARBY CITY. IN FACT THE SITUATION IS SO GRAVE THAT YOU THINK
TWICE ABOUT GOING TO THE GROCERY STORE OR EVEN TO A MOVIE. A
RECENT "NEW YORK TIMES" ARTICLE DESCRIBED THE LIVES OF
COLUMBIANS AND PRE CRAUGSS -- PLEA CAUTIONS THEY TAKE ON A
DAILY BASIS. THE ARTICLE STATED MCCOLLUM YAN'S REFUSE TO FLY ON
ANY AIRPLANE THAT IS NOT A JET. THEY CITE THE EXAMPLE OF THE
E.L.N. HIJACKING OF 5 PROP PLANE. THE COLUMBIAN QUOTED IN THE
{20:39:15} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ARTICLE COMMENTED THAT IT IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE FOR GUERRILLAS
TO TAKE OVER A BIG JET AND MAKE IT LAND AT SOME AIRSTRIP OUT IN
THE JUNGLE. THAT WAS HIS EXPLANATION. IN THE WEEK BEFORE
EASTER, A TRADITIONAL VACATION TIME THROUGHOUT ALL OF LATIN
AMERICA, TRAVEL WITHIN COLOMBIA WAS DOWN 40% OVER LAST YEAR
ACCORDING TO A COLUMBIAN CIVIC FLWUPE. MR. PRESIDENT, WITH
INCREASING REGULARITY, THE 5 MILLIONAIRESS DENTS OF BOGOTA ARE
CANCELING TRIPS TO TOWNS THAT ARE BARELY A TWO-HOUR DRIVE AWAY,
{20:39:48} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WHILE TRAFFIC ON HIGHWAYS, THE CARIBBEAN COAST, ALSO DROPPED
SIGNIFICANTLY. KID NACHING IS SUCH A SIGNIFICANT THREAT THAT A
GOVERNMENT STUDY MADE PUBLIC ESTIMATES THAT THE COUNTRY'S THREE
MINUTE GUERRILLA GROUPS HAVE OBTAINED MORE THAN $1.2 BILLION IN
KIDNAPPING RANSOMS IN RECENT YEARS. MR. PRESIDENT, THE
SITUATION IN COLOMBIA HAS GOTTEN SO BAD, SO BAD THAT OUR STATE
DEPARTMENT RECENTLY ISSUED A WARNING ADVISING AMERICANS NOT TO
TRAVEL TO COLOMBIA. YOU SEE, COLUMBIANS ARE NOT THE ONLY
{20:40:21} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TARGETS. U.S. CITIZENS ARE TARGETS AS WELL. IN LATE 1997 THE
STATE DEPARTMENT ADDED THE FARK TO ITS LIST OF TERRORIST
ORGANIZATIONS. IN JANUARY, 1999, GUERRILLAS ANNOUNCED ALL U.S.
MILITARY AND LAW ENFORCEMENT PERSONNEL IN COLOMBIA WOULD BE
CONSIDERED LEGITIMATE TARGETS TO BE KILLED OR CAPTURED. IN LATE
FEBRUARY, THE FARK VICIOUSLY MURDERED THREE U.S. HUMAN RIGHTS
WORKERS. THIS EXECUTION MET WITH NO REACTION FROM OUR
{20:40:57} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ADMINISTRATION. A RESOLUTION WAS RECENTLY INTRODUCED IN THE
HOUSE CALLING ON THE COLUMBIAN GOVERNMENT TO PURSUE THE
KILLERS. MEMBERS OF THE FARK, AND TO EXTRADITE THEM TO THE
UNITED STATES. MR. PRESIDENT, COLUMBIAN TERRORISTS CONTINUE TO
TARGET AMERICANS, KIDNAPPING OVER A DOZEN U.S. CITIZENS IN 1999
SO FAR. AND THIS IS THE DOUBLE -- THIS IS DOUBLE THE TOTAL
AMOUNT FOR THE PREVIOUS YEAR. THE 1998 STATE DEPARTMENT
{20:41:28} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TERRORISM REPORT ALSO SUGGESTS THAT TERRORISTS ALSO CONTINUE TO
BOMB U.S. COMMERCIAL INTERESTS, SUCH AS OIL PIPELINES, AND
SMALL BUSINESSES. MR. PRESIDENT, THERE HAS ALSO BEEN MUCH
CONCERN THAT THE CIVIL WAR IN COLUMBIA COULD SPILL OVER INTO
NEIGHBORING COUNTRIES, INCLUDING VENENZUELA, WHERE THE
PRESIDENT, PRESIDENT CHAVEZ IS ALLEGED TO HAVE CONTACTS IN THE
PAST WITH THE E.L.N. 5 SPILL-OVER INTO VENENZUELA WOULD BE A
DISASTER FOR THE UNITED STATES AND THIS HEMISPHERE. GIVEN THE
{20:42:00} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FACT THAT VENDS WAY LA IS OUR NUMBER ONE IT SHALL LET ME REPEAT
THIS -- OUR NUMBER ONE SUPPLIER OF FOREIGN OIL. THE SWAYS IS SO
GRAVE THAT VENENZUELA SENT 30,000 TROOPS TO THE BORDER WITH
CLOFM YEAH. THERE HAS ALSO BEEN A RECENT EXODUS OF CLOME YANS
INTO VENENZUELA IN A TWO DAY PERIOD RECENTLY 2,000 BEGAN THEIR
EXODUS TO VENENZUELA AFTER DEATH SQUADS MASSACRED ABOUT 80
{20:42:36} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
PEOPLE NEAR A BORDER TOWN. MANY OF THE COLUMBIANS WERE SAID TO
BE COCOA FARMERS. AT FIRST PRESIDENT CHAVEZ SAID THEY WERE
PREPARED TO OFFER TEMPORARY REFUGE NEUROMUSCULAR THEY COULD
RETURN SAFELY TO THEIR HOMES. HOWEVER, ONLY ONE DAY AFTER THE
RECENT CROSS-OVER BEGAN, VENDS WAY LA ALREADY STARTED -- VENDS
WAY LA STARTING SENDING COLUMBIANS BACK COLOMBIA. IN A FEW
DAYS, ALL HAD BEEN SENT BACK. COLOMBIA-V VENDS WAY LONG
{20:43:07} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
RELATION SHIPS HAVE BEEN TENSE. TARGET, WHILE PRESIDENT CHAVEZ
SAID HE WOULD PLAY A ROLE IN NERSS, IN MID-MAY HE ANNOUNCED HE
WOULD MEET WITH FARK AND THE FARK COMMANDER. TWO MONTHS EARLIER
THE PRESIDENT AGREED -- THE PRESIDENT HAD ANGER PRESIDENT
PASTRANO BY SUGGESTING THE FARK'S ARRANGED STRUGGLE WAS
LEGITIMATE AN DECLARING THAT VENZUELA REMAIN NEUTRAL IN THE
CONFLICT. THERE HAS BEEN CONCERN MR. PRESIDENT ABOUT A
{20:43:45} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SPILLOVER OF CONFLICT INTO ECUADOR. IN FACT THEY INDICATE REBEL
FORCES HAVE CROSSED OVER TO THEIR NATION PRIMARILY FOR REST AND
RELAXATION. WITH THE END OF ITS BORDER DISPUTE WITH PERU,
ECUADOR IS?
THE PROCESS OF LOCATING 10,000 TROOPS TO THE COLUMBIAN BORDER.
IN ADDITION INTELLIGENCE REPORTED IT HAS TAKEN DOWN SOME
GUERRILLA SUPPLY ROUTES. COLOMBIA ALSO BORDERS PANAMA, WHICH
SHOULD BE OF SIGNIFICANT CONCERN TO OUR NATION. IT IS KNOWN --
{20:44:18} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
IT IS A KNOWN FACT THAT COLUMBIAN REBELS HAVE BEEN INFILTRATING
THE A PROVINCE IN PANAMA FOR QUITE SOME TIME IN SEARCH OF
SPLICE. IN LATE MAY, HUNDREDS OF PANAMANIANS THREAD THEIR HOMES
FEARING A VIOLENT CRASH BETWEEN COLUMBIAN GUERRILLAS AND
PARAMILITARY BOUNTY HUNTERS. WITNESSES CLAIM THERE WERE ABOUT
500 FARK REBELS INSIDE OF PANAMA. MR. PRESIDENT, THIS REBEL
CROSSING IS OCCURRING JUST 250 MILES SOUTHEAST OF THE PANAMA
{20:44:52} (MR. DEWINE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CANAL. AND LET ME REMIND ALL OF MY COLLEAGUES THAT THE U.S.
MILITARY FORCES ARE NOW, AS WE SPEAK, DEPARTING FROM
{END: 1999/06/30 TIME: 20-45 , Wed. 106TH SENATE, FIRST SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}