Date: Thu, 31 Jan 2002 09:52:08 EST Subject: Fwd: [FRCtech2002] Digest Number 29 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ There are 22 messages in this issue. Topics in this digest: 1. Re: Pneumatic solenoids [sic] From: "frcengineers" 2. Re: Timing issues From: "frcengineers" 3. On parts usage and fabrication From: "frcengineers" 4. Drive Train and Motor Newsletter From: "frcengineers" 5. Re: Mostly electronics questions From: "frcengineers" 6. FedEx shipping to regionals From: FIRST Robotics 7. RE: On parts usage and fabrication From: "Dillard, Gary J" 8. Regarding the Autodesk Visualization Award formats From: FIRST Robotics 9. Re: Music in Chairman's Award From: "frcengineers" 10. Re: please respond quickly From: "frcengineers" 11. Drill Motor and Atwood Motor Fusing From: "frcengineers" 12. What Are Bearings? From: "frcengineers" 13. What's A Belt? From: "frcengineers" 14. Re: Tire marks on soccer ball??? From: "frcengineers" 15. Bosch EcoSlide Bearings? From: "bmusser1" 16. Re: Bosch EcoSlide Bearings? From: "frcengineers" 17. Contact With The Goal From: "markpettit" 18. Re: Contact With The Goal From: "frcengineers" 19. clarification From: "azizh1" 20. Re: clarification of goal interaction From: "frcengineers" 21. [Fwd: rules confusion] From: mitch johnson 22. Re: [Fwd: rules confusion] From: "frcengineers" ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 1 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 14:52:08 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: Pneumatic solenoids [sic] Q: The kit came with several selenoids. Our qestion is: 1. Can we use more than the number provided in the kit; 2. Can we use all singles, all doubles or any mix we desire? A: You're limited to what you have. Please direct all pneumatics questions to fhord@hpeco.com, listed in Appendix F of the manual. M4 ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 2 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 16:39:42 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: Timing issues > The 2002 guidelines for the animation competition state: > "Animation cannot be more than 30 seconds. Timing begins as soon as > your still frame with the required identifying information clears the > screen. To ensure accurate timing of your Entry, we suggest you make > a clean break to animation." > > But, the picture on the bottom of the page shows a gap between the > identifying information and the animation content. This gap is the > same size as the suggested 5 second gap after the animation. Do we > include a gap between the title and animation or not? A) Per page 12 in the Awards section of the manual: "Questions: If you have questions regarding the Autodesk Award for Visualization or Entry Requirements, please write to Autodesk at: first.entries@autodesk.com." ----- ER ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 3 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 17:44:37 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: On parts usage and fabrication We continue to receive numerous posts from teams asking if they can use this material or that material, and if they can manufacture this thing or that item from it. While we would like to respond to every one of these posts, they take FIRST's unfortunately limited time away from responding to the more detailed and important technical implementation questions that teams have. To repeat post 350: You can use the quantities in your 2002 Kit of Parts plus the quantities of material in the Additional Hardware List plus whatever you can buy from Small Parts... but you still have the 130 lb. robot weight limit. You can buy "additional" parts and material above the quantities in the Kit and Additional Hardware List to have as "spares" in case something fails on your robot. Follow the Pneumatics rules as well. They've been reiterated in team updates and posted here several times. If it wasn't provided in the kit and not available through the resources above, it cannot be used in this year's competition. Carbon fiber is not a substitute for fiberglass. (Maybe next year.) A 2x2 square of lumber is not a substitute for 1x4s. We're about to go to the questions about bearings assemblies. The point of the competition is to manufacture whatever you need out of those allowed raw materials, as long as you don't violate the weight limit rules or any other rules that control manufacturing or the game or anything else. If you want to build wheels out of plywood that followed the additional hardware list rules, go for it. If you want to build a small Eiffel tower out of parts you can get from the Small Parts catalog, without violating the height restriction, go for it. Read the construction, safety and usage rules. Please avoid peppering the board with questions of this type, because it slows down our ability to answer the questions that need our ruling or opinion on a gray area or a technical implementation. We read and respond to, delete or reject every post. Let us help all of you better by keeping the posts focused on things that really aren't clear. If we could organize the information better to make it easier to find, make a constructive suggestion and we will do our best to make it happen. What's great is that there are a lot of apparent rookies using the board. That's a good thing. We can answer questions about rules, some technical parts questions, important interpretations, etc. We can't really help tell you how to build your robot or best practices on using different components - yet. Check with your engineer mentors. Hook up with teams in your area that are willing to be mentors (using our map.) Ask for help in the Technical forum on Delphi. And again - we apologize for whatever confusion we caused with the # of cylinders and the goal interaction details. It's not an excuse but this is a new process for us too, and our intent is only to get more resources out here in the public domain that everyone can use. Thanks for your assistance. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 4 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 19:19:20 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Drive Train and Motor Newsletter All, thought you might be interested in the following technical discussion about drive trains and motors. Looks like a lot of excellent material in here. While ChiefDelphi isn't an "official" FIRST resource, it is a great website with very dedicated FIRSTers contributing daily. Very useful material here - enjoy, and thanks Ken! *********** Hello Everyone, Have you ever wondered how the Drive Train works on your robot? Or, what's so special about the new black motor you got from the kit of parts? Have you ever spend half an hour flipping through the manual looking for motors' blueprint/specs? Or, spending hours online searching for places to buy gears/sprockets? If you are like me, or any engineers on any of the teams out there, you would be thinking a lot about motors and gears (or sprockets, depend on your preference)· There are so many things you have to think about for the robot· And so little time to waste on finding information you need· So, what I am about to show you is made especially for people like us, who like to stay up all night thinking about the robot, or gear ratio for what motor, or what motors for what components, or how to put together a 4 motor drive train. What I am talking about is a newsletter named "Fresh from the forum", summarizing discussions happened on the chiefdelphi.com forum about the FIRST Robotics competition. I just finished a second one that will provide you a lot of useful information for building the robot. Specifically, this edition of newsletter will include ALL you can find about motors, gears/sprockets, and drive train from chiefdelphi.com forum. The newsletter, "Motor and drive train edition" of Fresh From the Forum, is located @ http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=2108 inside the "Bulletins and Newsletters" forum. Table of content: I. FIRST 2002 Motors in General II. In depth discussion of specific motors III. Gears IV. Drive train V. Wheels and treads / Traction Even if you aren't interested in the mechanical aspect of the robot, chances are, someone from you team is. So, please don't ignore this e-mail. Forward it to your team member, and other people/teams who might be interested in this. Please feel free to come in and take a look. Decide for yourself if all the information is worth the time reading. Even if you've decided everything for your robot, it is still worth the time saving these information for future reference. So, without taking any more of your time, please go ahead and click on the link above and take a look. You might see something you like ;-) "Gotten busy with your team now that season has started? Don't fret, all the need-to-know info from the chiefdelphi.com forums right here at your fingertips..." -Fresh From the Forum Thanks for your time. And good luck with the competition. :-) -Ken Leung 1999-2001: Team 192 GRT 2001~????: Team 000, 100, 192, 258, 419· ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 5 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 21:52:25 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: Mostly electronics questions > Would a ribbon cable be considered an entanglement risk? 1" wide? > 5" wide? 1 foot wide? A) It depends on how you use it. Ribbon cables make sense but it depends where you expose them. > If a ribbon cable were used would it be allowed to control a smaller > robot that could run to the end zone when the primary robot was in > the goal scoring zone? A) It is allowed unless it is a possible entanglement issue but this would likely be a potential high risk. > Is an optical sensor purchased from an approved supplier considered > to be a custom circuit and must be completely contained in the > custom circuit box or can it be placed in the project box? A) Optical sensors purchased from Digi-Key or Future Electronics must be contained inside the custom circuit box. They may not be in the project box or elsewhere on the robot. > Must all of the custom circuit fit in a single custom circuit box? A) Yes, the BUD box specified on the Additional Hardware list. > If I want to count the teeth on a sprocket with an IR sensor is > there any approved sensor I can place outside of the custom box to > do this, if so can it be connected to either the first controller > or a custom circuit? If not is the gear allowed to enter the custom > box so an IR device could count the teeth? A) If it is outside the box, then it must be one of the supplied sensors. You may also purchase switches per the Additional Hardware List, such as non-contact reed switches that work with permanent magnets, and use those anywhere on the robot. Alternately, the gear may be extended into the custom circuit enclosure in order to be measured with sensors located inside the box. > The rules state that masking or duct tape is not allowed to be used > in the construction of the robot. Would we be allowed to fabricate > a device that would dispense masking tape on the carpet as an > extension of the robot for the purpose of being in 2 separate zones > and be tethered to both? Would it still count if we zipped a piece > of tape straight to the goal scoring zone, broke the tape, did > everything else we wanted, then drove the robot into the goal zone > and had our wheels touching the tape? Would we be in 2 zones? A) Absolutely no, no, no. > May we use a mirror to deflect the infrared sensor to aid in detect > infrared? If not how about aluminum foil? If not, how about polished > aluminum? A) You can use whatever was in your Kit of Parts, what is on the Add'l Hardware List or whatever you can buy from Small Parts. See Rule K1. Teams may not devise devices with the intent to interfere with sensors on other robots. > If we are using a stamp processor in our custom circuit, is there > any port on the innovation first controller we may use to pass > serin and serout data between the two? At first glance it looks > like we need to use the digital ports to simulate data transfer > between the two. A) No. The custom circuit may only be connected to the robot controller via the digital and analog input ports and/or the PWM and Relay outputs. ----- FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 6 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 15:12:22 -0800 (PST) From: FIRST Robotics Subject: FedEx shipping to regionals We've started receiving questions about the FedEx shipping arrangements. **Rather than replying specifically to the individual posts, here's a more detailed explanation.** Fedex will cover the cost of shipping your robot crate, up to 400 lbs, to one regional event, to the Championship if you're going, and home. (Home meaning in all cases wherever you want the robot crate picked up and sent back to.) The airbills provided in your kit of parts are for this purpose. Using an excellent example conveniently provided by a highly respected member of ChiefDelphi, who will remain nameless (Joe), let us illustrate. ;-) *** Multiple regionals and the Championship *** A team is going to 2 regionals and the Championship Event. This requires 4 robot shipments: 1) to first regional from home 2) to second regional from first regional 3) to Championship Event from second regional 4) to home from the Championship Event. Q: Which of these shipments will FedEx make for us for free? A: Fedex would cover shipments 1, 2 and 4, or shipments 2, 3 and 4. This is up to the team to decide which option minimizes the costs for their regional. *** Multiple regionals, no Championship *** 1) to first regional from home 2) to second regional from first regional 3) to nth regional from nth -1 regional 4) to home from nth regional A: FedEx would cover any one of 1, 2 and 3, with 4. Bottom line, one robot crate to one regional of your choice, and home. *** One regional and the Championship *** This requires 3 robot shipments: 1.) To the regional from home 2.) To the Championship from the regional 3.) To home from the Championship A: FedEx would cover all three shipments. *** One regional, no Championship *** Fedex will cover the shipment to the regional event, and home. Will FIRST arrange for other carriers to be available [at] the end of an event for the shipment that FedEx will not pay for (e.g. Yellow Freight)? A: Good question. We'll be posting that information shortly. Build on! -M4 __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Great stuff seeking new owners in Yahoo! Auctions! http://auctions.yahoo.com ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 7 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 15:08:49 -0500 From: "Dillard, Gary J" Subject: RE: On parts usage and fabrication At the risk of getting flooded with questions from rookies..................... Team 180 SPAM (and I'm sure almost all of the other veteran teams) would love to help out with mentoring rookie teams, maybe helping to filter out some of the questions about general rules and materials before they get posted and save you some time. Problem is, I suspect many of the rookie teams either don't feel right "bothering" other teams or don't know the avenues to ask questions other than this forum. We posted our team as willing to mentor and haven't received any requests (that I'm aware of - hopefully our website links are working), and I have no success contacting the rookie teams in our state - either they don't have a website up or the website listed with FIRST is a generic school site. Rookie teams - You aren't bothering us! We'd all love to help, just ask - there are no dumb questions, and if your robot is better it makes us compete better. Use the mentoring maps, check out the forums at Delphi. If you come across a team website with a message board or guest book, sign in and let them know you need help. Gary J. Dillard Lockheed Martin - Perry Technologies 561-494-2437 [This message contained attachments] ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 8 Date: Tue, 29 Jan 2002 17:00:52 -0800 (PST) From: FIRST Robotics Subject: Regarding the Autodesk Visualization Award formats Regarding the Autodesk Award for Visualization, Autodesk has done some testing and found that rendering 30 seconds of animation "uncompressed" yields files larger than can be stored on a CDROM. Because of this, we ask that submittors use the Cinepak codec at 640 x 480 and 100% quality. This setting will yield good results and provide a standard of comparison for the teams. We will add this to the next team update. -M4 __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Great stuff seeking new owners in Yahoo! Auctions! http://auctions.yahoo.com ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 9 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 01:13:07 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: Music in Chairman's Award Q: Using music in the Chairman's award, does it all have to be written and performed for the award or have a written consent from the label? Meaning, do we need to get written consent to use any copywritted musc in the award for eligability? Thanks a bunch, Adam Thompson A: Adam, great question, thanks for asking. In the spirit of gracious professionalism, any/all music used in a video submission should be "acknowledged" in the end credits--- ie: "Burning Down The House" by Talking Heads (or maybe more appropriately, "You Gotta Fight For Your Right to Party" by Beastie Boys) You don't need to get consent from the music label as long as you provide this acknowledgement/credit. -M4 ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 10 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 01:46:52 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: please respond quickly Hello, I posted a question about a week and a half ago, and it has still not received an answer. It is very important, so please answer quickly. The question was: The Canadian skyway distributor is out of stock of the skyway wheels that we need and they won't have any more for about 2 weeks. We can't afford to lose this time. They sold us some wheels that they say are exactly the same as the skyway wheels, except that they don't have the skyway logo on them. Are these wheels acceptable to use? Also, could you please let us know if we are allowed to make permanant skid marks on the balls? Thanks in advance. A quick response would be very much appreciated. A: We wiped out most posts that looked too old or duplicated from previous weeks, hoping to keep the backlog down. If we angered some of you by doing this, we're sorry, but we had to take a hammer to try to avoid wading through piles of questions we thought we'd answered. Yes, these wheels will be acceptable, just keep docs on the specs to back it up if asked. And, yes, skid marks on the balls are expected... we hope they're only being caused by a throwing mechanism with tires.... ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 11 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:14:29 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Drill Motor and Atwood Motor Fusing We apologize for having deleted the original message that this response was to answer. Figure 2.1 in the manual incorrectly shows the Drill and Atwood motor fused with a 20A breaker. It should be 30A. We will also put this into a Team Update. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 12 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:16:53 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: What Are Bearings? We apologize for having deleted the original message that this response was to answer. When the Additional Hardware list says bearings, any size, any amount, that is exactly it. A ball slide, linear bearings, and the like are considered bearings. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 13 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:24:03 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: What's A Belt? We apologize for having deleted the original message that this response was to answer. What is a belt? A precise definition will serve no purpose except to stimulate more questions so... if a store's product is, for example, called "XYZ belting" or the like, i.e., it has "belt" in the product name, not necessarily what the store personnel call it, then it is okay to use as per the Additional Hardware list. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 14 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:27:57 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: Tire marks on soccer ball??? > Are black tire marks on the soccer ball considered damaging the > ball? Our team is planning to use a wheel supplied from the kit to toss the soccer balls. Tire marks are left on the ball. Is that > acceptable? A) Toss away! We do expect that the balls will get marked up. We do, however, try to avoid poking the balls (or eyes, for that matter) with sharp objects. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 15 Date: Wed, 23 Jan 2002 15:32:19 -0000 From: "bmusser1" Subject: Bosch EcoSlide Bearings? Are we allowed to use Bosch EcoSlide Bearings to provide a bearing for linear motion. The bearing would ride in the Bosch Rail channel. Members of our team were assuming yes since, according to the Additional Hardware "Bearings" it says any amount any size. Would thier assumption be true. Thanks. Team 226 ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 16 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:35:36 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: Bosch EcoSlide Bearings? > Are we allowed to use Bosch EcoSlide Bearings to provide a bearing > for linear motion. The bearing would ride in the Bosch Rail > channel. Members of our team were assuming yes since, according to > the Additional Hardware "Bearings" it says any amount any size. > Would thier assumption be true. A) Yes. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 17 Date: Thu, 24 Jan 2002 13:24:50 -0000 From: "markpettit" Subject: Contact With The Goal Our robot is designed to "nest" the goal by pulling it into an octagonal shaped indentation. May we add a 45 degree angle to the "nest" so that when we pull the goal into the nest (by the waterpipe), the goal will ride up the said angle. The angled piece will be, at most, one inch wide and all contact would be made with the very corner edge of the top piece of plywood's angle iron. Thanks, ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 18 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:43:53 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: Contact With The Goal > Our robot is designed to "nest" the goal by pulling it into an > octagonal shaped indentation. May we add a 45 degree angle to the "nest" so that when we pull the goal into the nest (by the waterpipe), the goal will ride up the said angle. The angled piece will be, at most, one inch wide and all contact would be made with the very corner edge of the top piece of plywood's angle iron. A)According to response #571 in Yahoo, this is allowed. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 19 Date: Thu, 24 Jan 2002 16:25:02 -0000 From: "azizh1" Subject: clarification I need to clarify something, say we grab a goal by the 12" bars and pull it into our robot and we have a wedge that pushes on the bottom lip of the top piece of stainless steel & plywood, which gives us some additional downwards force on our robot, Now we are not lifting the goal and we are not holding on to the goal only by the top peace of angle. Is this ok? ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 20 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:47:57 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: clarification of goal interaction > I need to clarify something, say we grab a goal by the 12" bars and > pull it into our robot and we have a wedge that pushes on the bottom lip of the top piece of stainless steel & plywood, which gives us some additional downward force on our robot. Is this ok? A)According to response #571 in Yahoo, this is allowed. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 21 Date: Thu, 24 Jan 2002 11:59:31 -0800 From: mitch johnson Subject: [Fwd: rules confusion] mitch johnson wrote: > I am confused by two messages 483 and 461. 461 states that gears, > pulleys, casters, and bearings must be an exact match to spi catalog but > > 483 states that additional hardware can be purchased anywhere. Since > appendix c states bearings, sprockets, gears, and pulleys Does that not > imply that we can purchase and use any bearings, sprockets, gears, and > pulleys from any source even if it is not an exact match in the spi > catalog? Other wise why are teams allowed to manufacture their own > drive systems? > thank you ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Message: 22 Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2002 03:57:58 -0000 From: "frcengineers" Subject: Re: [Fwd: rules confusion] > > I am confused by two messages 483 and 461. 461 states that gears, pulleys, casters, and bearings must be an exact match to spi catalog but 483 states that additional hardware can be purchased anywhere. Since appendix c states bearings, sprockets, gears, and pulleys Does that not > > imply that we can purchase and use any bearings, sprockets, gears, and > > pulleys from any source even if it is not an exact match in the spi > > catalog A) Anything listed in the Additional Hardware list can be bought any where you wish. If you need an item and it was not one of the items in your 2002 Kit of Parts and not on the Additional Hardware list, then you scan the SPI catalog. If it is there, you can use it. If SPI is out or heavily baclordered, you can go any where you wish BUT it must be exactly like the SPI you would have gotten. The sources are additive and the order in which you check your sources are K of P, Add'l Hdwe list, and SPI. FIRSTsnow ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/