U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission
SEC Seal
Home | Previous Page
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission

Report of the Advisory Committee on the Capital Formation and Regulatory Process

Addendum to Appendix B

Comparison of Company Registration to Universal Shelf Registration

ItemFull Company RegistrationModified Company RegistrationCurrent Universal Shelf
REGISTRATION
SEC ReviewNo prior review, unless extraordinary transactionSame as Full Company RegistrationPotential review upon filing of registration statement or post-effective amendment to registration statement (PE); no prior review upon takedown unless file PE
Filing FeeNominal upfront fee; pay as you goSame as Full Company RegistrationUpfront fee based on entire dollar amount registered
Updating Incorporate by reference all Exchange Act reportsSame as Full Company RegistrationSame as Full Company Registration
Limitations on Type/Amount of Securities to be RegisteredNone; need only list in Form C-1 classes of securities to be registered; no dollar amount need be specified in original registration statementSame as Full Company RegistrationDollar amount reasonably expect to issue within 2 years; equity issued in at the market offering may not exceed 10% public float
Procedure for adding additional type of security/additional dollar amount to registration statementForm C-1 would cover all securities the issuer has authority to issue in an indefinite amountSame as Full Company RegistrationCurrently prohibited; new registration statement required; possibility of review upon filing new registration statement
Distribution MethodNo restrictionsSame as Full Company RegistrationFor equity, must be either a fixed price offering, or if an at the market offering, must be in an amount less than 10% of public float and sold through an underwriter
ItemFull Company RegistrationModified Company RegistrationCurrent Universal Shelf
ELIGIBILITY
Reporting HistoryTwo yearsSame as Full Company RegistrationOne year
Public Float Requirement$75 millionSame as Full Company Registration$75 million, unless offering of non-convertible investment grade securities and certain other instances (in which case no minimum public float required)
Exchange Listing/NMSRequiredSame as Full Company RegistrationNot required
Mandatory Disclosure Enhancements (Top Mgt Certifs, Mgt Report to Audit Cmtee; Expanded and Accelerated 8-K; Risk Factors in 10-K)RequiredSame as Full Company RegistrationNot required
Foreign Issuers Eligible?Not eligible for pilot unless undertake to file same Exchange Act reports and satisfy same disclosure requirements as domestic issuers (although Commission should consider whether current foreign filings would be sufficient)Same as Full Company RegistrationEligibility standards same as for domestic issuers, with added requirement that a 20-F/10-K has been filed with the SEC
ItemFull Company RegistrationModified Company RegistrationCurrent Universal Shelf
EXEMPTIONS FROM REGISTRATION
Exempt Transactions - GeneralNot allowed unless involves non-convertible debt sold to institutions; all equity securities (which includes equity equivalents (e.g., warrants, convertible debt)) are registered and freely tradeable by nonaffiliates;Same as Current Universal Shelf, except that if issuer wishes to register but is not able to make public disclosure of material information, may do limited placement of securities to accredited investors as long as disclose information to such investors Allowed but securities are restricted by regulation; not freely tradeable absent registration or a valid exemption from registration
if issuer is not able to make public disclosure of material information, may do limited placement of securities to accredited investors as long as disclose information to such investor and contractually restrict resale until information made publicand contractually restrict resale until information made public
Securities Act Metaphysics Involving Equity SecuritiesVirtually eliminated since all equity securities are deemed registered and all other securities may be deemed registered; no need for most resale restrictionsAlthough issuer still able to do private placements of equity securities, incentives to do exempt offerings minimizedNot eliminated since issuers still conduct private placements of equity securities
OFFSHORE SALES/RESALESOffshore sales of securities may take place outside the Form C-1; flowback of securities placed offshore are registered on Form C-1 (fee is calculated by reasonably estimating amount of securities likely to flow back within statutory period)Same as Full Company Registration, except flowback not required to be registered on Form C-1; resales into the U.S. may not take place absent registration or valid exemption (same as Current Universal Shelf)Offshore sales of securities may take place under Regulation S safe harbor; resales into the U.S. may not take place absent registration or valid exemption
ItemFull Company RegistrationModified Company RegistrationCurrent Universal Shelf
TRANSACTIONAL DISCLOSURE
Requirement for Prior Notice/Public Filing of Registration Statement and Amendments TheretoC-1 generically registers all types of securities without specifying quantity or dollar amount; upon takedown, specify dollar amount and type of securities to be offered and pay fee; Same as Full Company RegistrationShelf registration statement filed specifying types of securities and total dollar amount registered; PE required only if Section 10(a)(3) update, fundamental change, or change in plan of distribution,
filing of transactional information generally would not trigger a PE unless extraordinary transaction; if non-de minimis equity offering, MUST file Form 8-K with transactional/material developments information no later than date of first sale;but first two can be satisfied through incorporation by reference; no other notice or public filing required prior to takedown; transactional/material developments info filed after takedown (and after delivery to investors) in prospectus supplement;
if de minimis equity offering or non-convertible debt offering, MAY file Form 8-K with transactional/material developments information if elect to use incorporation by reference method of prospectus delivery; NOTE: Committee recommends that the Commission require filing of Form 8-K with transactional/material developments info for non-de minimis equity or equity equivalent offering off universal shelf under same conditions as Full Company Registration
otherwise, such information filed in prospectus supplement at same time delivered to investors;
if file material developments information on Form 8-K rather than deliver, must file Form 8-K in a sufficient time in advance of offering so that market can react to information before a sale can occur
ItemFull Company RegistrationModified Company RegistrationCurrent Universal Shelf
TRANSACTIONAL DISCLOSURE (cont'd)
Prospectus Delivery - GeneralPhysical prospectus delivery is required for nonaccredited investors in nonroutine or extraordinary transactions only, or for security specific disclosure if new security;Same as Full Company RegistrationProspectus supplement containing transactional/material developments disclosure must be physically delivered to investors at least two business days after the earlier of pricing or first use;
otherwise, prospectus may be physically delivered, or information constituting the prospectus may be incorporated by reference into the confirm or other document delivered to investorsdelivery of transactional/material developments info through incorporation by reference not permitted
NOTE: Committee recommends that the Commission require filing of 8-K with transactional/material developments info for non-de minimis equity or equity equivalent offering under same conditions as Full Company Registration even if info actually delivered
ItemFull Company RegistrationModified Company RegistrationCurrent Universal Shelf
AFFILIATES AND STATUTORY UNDERWRITERS
Resales by AffiliatesAll affiliate resales deemed registered under Form C-1unless sold under Rule 144; Same as Current Universal Shelf, except that affiliate resales could be registered on Form C-1Issuer may register resale for affiliate on shelf registration statement or any other registration statement (fee paid upfront); or affiliate may resell under Rule 144, in a private placement, or in an offshore placement;
affiliates that would be subject to resale limitations would be only those affiliates who are holders of 20% voting power; holders of 10% voting power w/ board seat; their reps; CEO; and inside directors; affiliates subject to these limitations include all persons defined as affiliates
presumption rebuttable for 20%/10% with board seat
Resales of Affiliates of Acquired CompaniesNo resale limitations unless fit within category aboveSame as Current Universal ShelfAffiliates of acquired companies receiving registered acquiror securities subject to resale limitations
Statutory UnderwriterLimited to broker-dealers acting on behalf of issuer or affiliate in distributionNot limitedNot limited
ItemFull Company RegistrationModified Company RegistrationCurrent Universal Shelf
LIABILITY
Section 11 "strict" liabilityApplies to all information in Form C-1 when filed, all information in any PE to the Form C-1, and all Exchange Act reports incorporated by reference;Same as Full Company RegistrationApplies to all info in registration statement when declared effective, all info in any PE to registration statement, and all Exchange Act reports incorporated by reference;
would apply to all transactional/material developments info mandatorily filed on Form 8-K (non-de minimis equity offering) OR voluntarily filed on Form 8-K for purposes of using incorporation by reference method of prospectus delivery does not apply to transactional/material developments info contained in prospectus supplement upon takedown
(de minimis equity offerings and non-convertible debt offerings)NOTE: Committee recommends that the Commission require filing of 8-K with transactional/material developments info for non-de minimis equity offering under same conditions as Full Company Registration thereby attaching Section 11 liability to this info
Section 12(a)(2) liabilityApplies to all information in document used as prospectus whether document deemed prospectus through incorporation by reference method of prospectus delivery (e.g., confirm or selling materials), or traditional prospectus with prospectus supplementSame as Full Company RegistrationApplies to all information in traditional prospectus with prospectus supplement; does not attach to other selling materials (antifraud liability only)

http://www.sec.gov/news/studies/capform/coregsl2.htm


Modified:08/06/96