|
|
|
Summary of the 1994 NARC Geographic Information System (GIS) User Survey
Click HERE for graphic. TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 RESPONSE RATE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 STATUS OF GIS USE (QUESTION 1) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 SOFTWARE/HARDWARE (QUESTION 2) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 DIGITAL DATA BASES (QUESTION 3). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 GEOGRAPHIC REFERENCE SYSTEM (QUESTION 4) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 FORMAL STANDARDS AND DATA DICTIONARIES (QUESTIONS 5 AND 6). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 AVAILABILITY OF DATA BASES TO OTHER AGENCIES (QUESTION 7) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .10 APPENDICES: A: SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15 B: RESPONDING AGENCIES - GIS CONTACTS . . . . . . . . . . . . .21 C: RESPONDING AGENCIES - STATUS, HARDWARE/ SOFTWARE, DATABASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS USED . . . . . . . . .33 D: RESPONDING AGENCIES - GIS DATABASES. . . . . . . . . . . . .51 iii LIST OF TABLES Table 1 Status of GIS at Councils of Goverment . . . . . . . . . . 4 Table 2 Types of GIS Packages Used . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Table 3 Data Base Manager Software Used With GIS . . . . . . . . . 6 Table 4 Types of Hardware Used for GIS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Table 5 Types of Data Bases Used or Maintained . . . . . . . . . . 8 Table 6 Locational Accuracy of Data Bases. . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Table 7 Availability of Digital Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .10 v SUMMARY OF THE 1994 NARC GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEM (GIS) USER SURVEY SUMMARY OF THE 1994 NARC GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEM (GIS) USER SURVEY INTRODUCTION In January, a Geographic Information System (GIS) User Survey was sent to 182 councils of governinent (COGs) on the National Association of Regional Councils' (NARC) mailing list. In subsequent months, two follow-up mailings were made to non-responding agencies. The survey was an initial effort by NARC's GIS Technical Network to get a better understanding of the use of GIS by COGs, and the types of data bases being used and maintained. The survey was not intended to provide a complete description of each agency's GIS and their applications, but was intentionally kept short to obtain a higher response rate and to provide a general overview of GIS use by councils of government. A copy of the survey instrument can be found in Appendix A. RESPONSE RATE Following the initial January mailout of the survey to the 182 agencies, a total of 43 or 23.6 percent responded. A second mailing was sent to non-responding agencies in February, increasing the response rate to 53.2 percent (97 agencies). As part of NARC's effort to establish a GIS Technical Network, a third mailing to non- responding agencies was made in early March. This final mailing yielded an additional 18 responses, for a total of 114 agencies responding to the survey, or a response rate of 62.6 percent. A list of the responding agencies, with a GIS contact person's name and address, is contained in Appendix B. STATUS OF GIS USE (QUESTION 1) Almost 60 percent of the COGs responding have had a GIS in operation for more than one year, while over one-fifth of the COGs have had a GIS in operation for more than three years. Sixteen agencies (14 percent) responded that they were gathering information about GIS. Table I provides a breakdown of responses to Question 1: "Which of the following best describes your agency regarding the use of a GIS?" 3 Table I STATUS OF GIS AT COUNCILS OF GOVERNMENT # of % of Agencies Total Our functions don't require GIS 0 0% Haven't considered the need for a GIS 0 0% Gathering information about GIS 16 14% Currently implementing a GIS 23 20% Have had a GIS in operation less than 1 year 7 6% Have had a GIS in operation 1 to 3 years 43 38% Have had a GIS in operation for more than 3 years 25 22% TOTAL 114 100% 4 SOFTWARE/HARDWARE (QUESTION 2) Ninety-six agencies indicated that they used at least one GIS software package. Forty-four agencies listed two or more packages. A total of 17 different packages were listed as in use. The top three software packages listed were: Arc/Info - PC Arc/Info (55 users), Atlas GIS (25 users), and MapInfo (18 users). Table 2 provides a breakdown of the number of users for each package. Table 2 TYPES OF GIS PACKAGES USED # of Agencies % of Agencies Using Software Responding ArcCad 7 7% Arc/Info 36 37% PC Arc/Info 19 20% ArcView 12 12% Atlas GIS 25 26% AutoCad 3 3% CAD - Intergraph 1 1% CMap 3 3% Erdas 2 2% Geo/SQL - Generation 5 1 1% GIS Plus 6 6% MapGraphix 2 2% MapInfo 18 19% Strings 1 1% Transcad 2 2% Unisys 1 1% Ultimap 1 1% TOTAL 140* 144%* *A total of 96 agencies responded, with some agencies using more than one package. 5 Fifty-eight agencies indicated that they were using at least one Relational Data Base Management System (RDBMS) package in conjunction with their GIS. Eleven agencies listed two RDBMSs. A total of 17 different RDBMS packages were listed, with various versions of DBase listed by the most agencies (29 users). Table 3 provides a breakdown of the number of users for each package. Table 3 DATA BASE MANAGER SOFTWARE USED WITH GIS # of Agencies % of Agencies Using Software Responding Access 1 2% Alpha4 2 3% DBase 29 50% Empress 1 2% Excel 1 2% FilePro 1 2% FoxBase 3 5% FoxPlus 2 3% FoxPro 4 7% Info 8 14% Ingres 3 5% Oracle 4 7% Paradox 6 10% RBase 1 2% SAS 1 2% Sybase 1 2% Ultimap RCDMS 1 2% TOTAL 69* 120%* *A total of 58 agencies responded, with some agencies using more than one package. 6 Ten different general categories of hardware platforms were listed by 95 agencies responding. Twenty-three agencies listed two different platforms. PCs were listed the most often (75 users), followed by SUN workstations (27 users). Table 4 provides a breakdown of listed hardware platforms. Table 4 TYPES OF HARDWARE USED FOR GIS # of Agencies # of Agencies Using Hardware Responding Apollo 1 1% Apple 1 1% Data General 1 1% HP 700 Series 5 5% IBM Risc 6000 2 2% MacIntosh 1 1% PC 75 79% SUN 27 28% UNIX 1 1% Vax 4 4% TOTAL 118* 123%* *A total of 95 agencies responded, with some agencies using more than one hardware platform. Appendix C provides a list of each of the responding agencies, their GIS software, RDBMS listed, and hardware. DIGITAL DATA BASES (QUESTION 3) Of the 81 agencies responding, an average of just over nine data bases were listed in response to Question 3, "Please complete the following table for the digital data bases used and/or maintained by your agency." Fifty percent of the agencies listed five or fewer data bases. The average number of data bases listed as primary and secondary were the same, just over four per agency. Just over 30 percent of the agencies responding indicated that they did not maintain digital data bases created from primary data (data gathered by their agency). An equal number of agencies (14 percent) indicated they maintained one or two digital data bases from primary source data. Thirty percent of the responding agencies indicated they used one digital data base obtained from some other agency. Another 18 percent indicated using two data bases from secondary sources. 7 The data bases listed were catagorized into 25 different groups, including a miscellaneous category. Table 5 contains a list of the 25 categories of data bases, with the number of agencies indicating they use or maintain digital data bases. The table further indicates whether the data bases are primary, secondary, both primary and secondary, or the source was not specified. Table 5 TYPES OF DATA BASES USED OR MAINTAINED Total # of Not Agencies Primary Secondary Both Specified Activity Centers (hospitals, schools, major employers, etc.) 7 4 2 0 1 Administrative, Political Planning Boundaries 43 13 14 12 4 Agriculture 3 2 0 1 0 Aquifers 6 1 4 0 1 Current Land Use 29 20 7 1 1 Floodplains 15 6 6 0 3 Geodetic Control Points 5 1 3 0 1 Hazardous Waste Sites 5 2 1 0 2 Highways, Roads 40 15 19 2 4 Historic Sites 4 1 3 0 0 Hudrology 27 3 20 2 2 Parcels 7 4 1 0 2 Planned Land Use, Zoning 24 17 4 0 3 Public Lands Ownership 3 2 0 1 0 Public Land Survey 5 1 3 0 1 Satellite Imagery 5 0 5 0 0 Slopes 3 1 1 0 1 Soils 17 1 12 0 4 TIGER, Census 59 6 50 3 0 Topography, DEM 5 1 4 0 0 Utilities 9 2 4 2 1 Vegetation 4 1 0 2 1 Watersheds, Drainage Basins 15 6 6 1 2 Wetlands 8 1 5 0 2 Miscellaneous 52 16 14 15 7 Appendix D provides a list of each responding agency and the categories of data bases they use and/or maintain. 8 Many of the agencies that listed multiple types of data bases used or maintained also indicated varying measures of Vocational accuracy. Table 6 presents the number of agencies by general categories of the accuracy of their data bases. When more than one measure of accuracy was given for multiple data bases, the predominant level of accuracy is reported. Most councils of government use and maintain 'regional scale" digital data bases with locational accuracies of 100 feet or more (47 percent). Very few agencies indicated having data bases with locational accuracies of less than ten feet. Predominant accuracy levels for each agency are provided in Appendix D. Table 6 LOCATIONAL ACCURACY OF DATA BASES # of Agencies % of Total Less than or equal to 40 feet 6 10% 41 to 99 feet 15 23% 100 plus feet 30 47% Indicated Varies 2 3% Indicated Unknown 11 17% TOTAL 64 100% GEOGRAPHIC REFERENCE SYSTEM (QUESTION 4) While most agencies used one reference system for their data bases, 17 of the 92 agencies responding to Question 4, "What geographic reference system are you using?", indicated more than one system was in use at their agency. State Plane Coordinate systems were listed by 57 of the 92 agencies responding. Thirty-six agencies use latitude/Longitude, and sixteen agencies listed UTM. Appendix D contains the geographic reference system used by each agency. FORMAL STANDARDS AND DATA DICTIONARIES (QUESTIONS 5 and 6) Forty percent of the agencies indicated formal standards are used in developing and maintaining their data bases. Most agencies having standards indicated they are willing to share their standards with other agencies. Over half (55 percent) of the responding agencies indicated data dictionaries existed for their data bases. 9 AVAILABILITY OF DATA BASES TO OTHER AGENCIES (QUESTION 7) A variety of responses were provided to Question 7, "How available and/or accessible are the data bases to outside agencies?" Table 7 provides a breakdown of the responses to this question. The most often provided response was that their data were "public domain" (25 percent), followed by II percent of the agencies indicating their data was free to other public agencies. Table 7 AVAILABILITY OF DIGITAL DATA % of # of Responses Total No charge 2 2% Public domain 22 25% Free to members, charge others 10 11% Free to other public agencies 3 4% Fee for private clients 1 1% No restrictions, cost for certain data bases 2 2% Few restrictions 5 6% Copy costs 3 4% Nominal charge 4 5% Cost recovery 8 9% Standard fee charged 1 1% Cost to public agency, no policy for private 1 1% Depends on data base 1 1% Depends on size and time required for request 1 1% Sold through non-profit corporation 1 1% Open to data exchange 1 1% Not yet determined 8 9% Not available in digital form 5 6% Refer to other agency 3 4% Varies 5 6% TOTAL 87 100% Appendix C shows the availability of data bases to outside agencies for each agency responding to Question 7. 10 APPENDICES APPENDIX A NARC GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEM USER SURVEY January 1994 Agency: __________________________________________________________ Address: __________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________ GIS Contact Person: ________________________________________________ Title: ________________________________________________ Department: ________________________________________________ Phone: ( )_______________ FAX:( )___________ 1. WHICH OF THE FOLLOWING BEST DESCRIBES YOUR AGENCY REGARDING THE USE OF A GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEM (GIS)? a. Our functions don't require a GIS (SKIP TO QUESTION 8) b. Haven't considered the need for a GIS (SKIP TO QUESTION 8) c. Gathering information about GIS (SKIP TO QUESTION 8) d. Currently implementing a GIS e. Have had a GIS in operation for less than a year f. Have had a GIS in operation for 1 to 3 years g. Have had a GIS in operation for more than 3 years 2. IF YOU HAVE A GIS: a. WHAT SOFTWARE ARE YOU USING? (ARC/INFO, INTEGRAPH, GIS PLUS, ETC.) ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ b. IF YOU ARE USING A RELATIONAL DATA BASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM IN CONJUNCTION WITH YOUR GIS, WHICH ONE(S)? (INGRES, ORACLE, SYBASE, ETC.) ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ c. WHAT HARDWARE PLATFORMS) ARE YOU USING TO RUN YOUR GIS SOFTWARE? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ - OVER - Page 1 of 3 15 Click HERE for graphic. APPENDIX A 4. WHAT GEOGRAPHIC REFERENCE SYSTEM ARE YOU USING? (LATITUDE/LONGITUDE, UTM, STATE PLANE CORDINATES, ETC.) _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ 5. ARE FORMAL STANDARDS USED IN DEVELOPING AND MAINTAINING THESE DATA BASES? _____Yes ____No 6. DO DATA DICTIONARIES EXIST FOR THESE DATA BASES? ___Yes ___No 7. HOW AVAILABLE AND/OR ACCESSIBLE ARE THE DATA BASES TO OUTSIDE AGENCIES? (PUBLIC DOMAIN, RESTRICTIONS ON TRANSFER OF DATA, PRICE OF THE DATA TO OUTSIDE AGENCIES, ETC.) _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ 8. PLEASE PROVIDE ANY COMMENTS CONCERNING THE OBJECTIVES OF THE FEDERAL GEOGRAPHIC DATA COMMITTEE'S (FGDC) FRAMEWORK WORKING GROUP. _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ 9. WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE ON THE MAILING LIST FOR THE NARC NATIONAL TECHNICAL NETWORK ON GIS AND RECEIVE MONTHLY PROGRESS REPORTS ON THE FGDC FRAMEWORK WORKING GROUP? ____Yes ____No THANK YOU FOR COMPLETING THIS SURVEY, YOUR COMMENTS ARE APPRECIATED. Page 3 of 3 APPENDIEK B APPENDIEK B RESPONDING AGENCIES - GIS CONTACTS Mr. David Kruse Ms. Elaine Wray Alamo Am Council of Governments Ark-Tex COG 118 Broadway Ste 400 P 0 Box 5307 San Antonio, TX 78205 Texarkana, TX 75505 210-225-5201 903-832-8636 Mr. John Sharp Mr. Kent Anness Assoc Of Central Bluegrass Area Dev Dist Oklahoma Governments 699 Perimeter Dr Suite 200 Lexington, KY 40517 6600 N Harvey PL 606-269-8021 Oklahoma City, OK 73116 405-848-8961 Ms. Teri Bell BCDCOG Mr. Chuck Skaggs Suite 400 AMBAG 5290 Rivers Avenue P 0 Box 838 No Charleston, SC 29406 Marina, CA 93933-0838 803-529-0400 408-883-3750 Mr. Mark Kushner Ms. Roni Gehring-Pratt Benton Franklin Ada Planning Association Regional Council Suite 100 P. O. Box 217 413 W Idaho Street Richland, WA 99352 Boise, ID 83702 208-345-5274 Mr. Rakesh Sharma Bel O Mar Regional Council Ms. Constance Blackmon P O Box 2086 Atlanta Regional Commission Wheeling, WV 26003 200 Northcreek, Suite 300 304-242-1800 3715 Northside Parkway Atlanta, GA 30327-2817 Mr. Alfonso Casana 404-364-2520 Barren River Area Dev District P O Box 90005 Mr. Paul Fisher Bowling Green, KY 42102-9005 ASCOG 502-781-2381 P 0 Box 1647 Duncan, OK 73534 Mr. Jay Aguilar 405-252-0595 Bear River Assoc Of Govts 170 N Main Street Logan, UT 84321 801-752-7242 21 Mr. Steven Anes Mr. Bradley Birge Bi-State Regional Commission Capitol District Reg Plan Comm P 0 Box 3368 214 Canal Square Rock Island, EL 61204-3368 Schenectady, NY 12305 309-793-6300 518-393-1715 Ms. Laura Jefferson Ms. Dianne Wilson Buffalo Trace Area Dev District Coastal Georgia RDC P 0 Box 460 127 F Street Maysville, KY 41056 Brunswick, GA 31522 606-564-6894 912-264-7363 Mr. Tom Wilkinson Jr Mr. Pat Mason Brazos Valley Dev Council CMPDD P.O. Drawer 4128 P.O. Box 4935 Bryan, TX 77805-4128 Jackson, MS 39296-4935 409-775-4244 601-981-1511 Mr. Joel Duke Ms. Alice Appleby Central Alabama Regional Central Midlands Plan & Dev Comm Reg Plan Council Third Floor 236 Stoneridge Dr 125 Washington Ave Columbia, SC 29210 Montgomery, AL 36104 803-771-0887 205-262-4300 Mr. Thomas Wight Mr. Bob Henderson Central New York Regional Centralina Council Of Govts Planning & Development Board P 0 Box 35008 Suite 122 Charlotte, NC 28235 90 Presidential Plaza 704-372-2416 Syracuse, NY 13202 315-422-8276 Mr. Malcolm Baker Central Connecticut RPA Ms. Barbara MacFarland P 0 Box 1880 Capitol Region Council of Govts Bristol, CT 06011-1880 221 Main St 4th Floor 203-589-7820 Hartford, CT 06106-1864 203-522-2217 Mr. Jay Appleton Chittenden County Regional Ms. Dianne Fischer Planning Commission Catawba Regional Plan Council P 0 Box 108 P 0 Box 450 66 Pearl Street Rock Hill, SC 29731 Essex Junction, VT 05453 803-327-9041 802-658-3004 22 Mr. Mike Vead Mr. Jeffrey Jones Catawba Regional Plan Council East Central Florida P 0 Box 450 Regional Plannning Council Rock Hill, SC 29731 1011 Wymore Rd., Ste. 105 803-327-9041 Winter Park, FL 32789-1737 407-623-1075 Mr. Bharat Dwa Central Texas COG Mr. Warrren Sallade P 0 Box 729 East West Gateway Belton, TX 76513 911 Washington Street 817-939-1801 St Louis, MO 63101 314-421-4220 Ms. Tammy Brown Cumberland Valley Area Dev Dist Ms. Freida Black P 0 Box 1740 Fivco Area Dev Dist London, KY 40741 3000 Louisa Street 606-864-7391 P 0 Box 636 Catlettsburg, KY 41129 Mr. Bill Wagner 606-739-5191 Cascades West COG 408 SW Monroe Avenue Ms. Monica Frederick Corvallis, OR 97333 Genesse/Finger I-akes 503-757-6851 Regional Planning Council 143 State Street Mr. Aland Coons Rochester, NY 14614 Douglas County GIS 716-546-5902 Room 210 Courthouse 1036 SE Douglas Ms. Annie Trauernicht Roseburg, OR 97470 Greater Nashville Reg. Council 503-440-4229 7th Fl, Stahlman Bldg 211 Union Street Mr. Randall Rutsch Nashville, TN 37201 Denver Regional COG 615-862-8828 Suite 250-B 2480 W 26th Avenue Mr. Keith Harpole Denver, CO 80211-5580 Green River Area Dev District 303-480-6767 3860 US 60 West Owensboro, KY 42301 Mr. Robert Monroe 502-926-4433 East Alabama Regional Planning And Development Commission Ms. Jean Lang-Carroll P 0 Box 2186 Grand Valley Metro Council Anniston, AL 36202 Suite 500 205-237-6741 2 Fountain Place NE Grand Rapid, MI 49503 616-776-3876 23 Mr. Max Sanifield Mr. Craig McCoy Houston Galveston Area Council Kisatchie-Delta Reg Plan District 3555 Timmons P 0 Box 12248 Houston, TX 77027 Alexandria, LA 71315-2248 713-627-3200 318-487-5454 Mr. David Hudson Ms. Annette Handshoe Heart Of Texas COG Kentucky River Area Dev Dist 300 Franklin Avenue 381 Perry Co Park Road Waco, TX 76701-2244 Hazard, KY 41701 817-756-7822 606-436-3158 Ms. Lesley Keeling Mr. Dan Phillips Heart Of Texas COG Kentuckiana Regional Planning 300 Franklin Avenue And Development Agency Waco, TX 76701-2244 11520 Commonwealth Drive 817-756-7822 Louisville, KY 40299 502-266-6084 Mr. Andrew Smialek II Hampton Roads Planning District Mr. James Roueche The Regional Building KYOVA Interstate Plan Comm 723 Woodlake Dr P 0 Box 939 Chesapeake, VA 23320 Huntington, WV 25701 804-420-8300 304-523-7434 Mr. Dave Hannon Mr. Cress Bates Housatonic Valley Council Lane Council of Govts Route 25 125 E Eighth St Old Town Hall Eugene, OR 97401 Brookfield, CT 06804 503-687-4391 203-775-6256 Mr. Bob Swank Mr. Robert Penderass Lane Council of Govts INCOG 125 E Eighth St Suite 600 Eugene, OR 97401 201 W 5th Street 503-687-4435 Tulsa, OK 74103-4236 918-584-7526 Mr. Glen Skinner LENOWISCO Mr. Robert Ball Planning District Commission Kern Council of Governments P 0 Box 366 1401 19th Street Ste 200 Duffield, VA 24244 Bakersfield, CA 93301-4400 703-431-2206 805-861-2191 24 Mr. Charles St Clair Mr. Wayne Harris Land of Sky Regional Council Mid-Ohio Regioanl Plan Comm 25 Heritage Drive 285 E Main Street Asheville, NC 28806-1998 Columbus, OH 43215-5222 704-254-8131 614-228-2663 Mr. Russell Mays Ms. Bonnie Prigge Lincoln Trail Area Dev Dist Meramec Regional Planning Comm P 0 Box 604 101 West 10th Street Elizabethtown, KY 42702 Rolla, MO 65401 502-769-2393 314-364-2993 Ms. Rita Walton Mr. Doug Marvel Maricopa Assoc of Govts Miami Valley Reg Plan Comm 1820 West Washington St 400 Miami Valley Tower Phoenix, AZ 85007-3208 40 West 4th Street Daytona, OH 45402-1827 Mr. Douglas Carnahan 513-223-6323 Metro. Area Planning Council 60 Temple Place Mr. Bob Griffiths Boston, MA 02111-1306 Metro Washington COG 617-451-2770 Ste 300 777 North Capitol St, NE Mr. Frank Lenk Washington, DC 20002-4226 Mid-America Regional Council 202-962-3280 300 Rivergate Center 600 Broadway Mr. Kevin Parrish Kansas City, MO 64105-1536 No Central Florida Reg Plan Council 816-474-4240 2009 NW 67th Place Gainesville, FL 32606 Mr. Robert Beckler 904-955-2200 Merced Co. Assn. of Govts. 1770 M Street Mr. Bob O,Neal Merced, CA 95340-4712 North Central Texas COG 209-723-3153 P O Box 5888 Arlington, TX 76005-5888 817-640-3300 Mr. Richard Bolen Metro Mr. Joseph Hadley Jr 600 NE Grand Ave Northeast Ohio Four County Portland, OR 97232 Reg Plan & Dev Org 969 Copley Rd Mr. Bobby Partridge Akron, OH 44320 Metroplan 216-836-5731 Suite B 501 West Markham Little Rock, AR 72201 501-372-3300 25 Mr. Ken Heatherington Mr. Cheng-I Tsai NE Florida Reg Plan Council Ohio Kentucky Indiana Suite 350 Regional Council Of Govts 9143 Phillips Hwy Suite 400 Jacksonville, FL 32256 801-B West 8th Street 904-363-6350 Cincinnati, OH 45203 513-621-7060 Ms. Rebecca Galarnbos Northwestern Indiana Regional Ms. Gail Kushner Planning Commission Pima Association Of Govts 6100 Southport Road 177 N Church Ave Ste 405 Portage, IN 46368 Tucson, AZ 85701 219-763-6060 602-792-1093 Ms. Heidi Van Keuren Ms. Mary Frye Northern Kentucky Area Dev Dist Pikes Peak Area COG 16 Spiral Drive 15 South 7th Street P 0 Box 668 Colorado Springs, CO 80905 Florence, KY 41022-0668 719-471-7080 606-283-1885 Mr. Sarwar Mansoor Mr. Elery Keene Panhandle Regional Planning Comm North Kenngbec Reg Plan Comm P 0 Box 9257 7 Benton Avenue Amarillo, TX 79105-9257 Winslow, ME 04901 806-372-3381 207-873-0711 Mr. Jay Clark Mr. Matt Marrs Puget Sound Regional Council Nortex Reg Plan Comm 216 First Ave S P 0 Box 5144 Seattle, WA 98104-2534 Wichita Falls, TX 76307 817-322-5281 Mr. Paul Krou Piedmont Triad COG Mr. William Vaughan Suite 201 Northern Virginia Plan Dist 2216 W Meadowview Rd Suite 100 Greensboro, NC 27407-3401 7535 Little River Tpke 910-294-4950 Annandale, VA 22003 703-642-0700 Mr. David Cole Region I Plan & Dev Council Mr. Matthew Dolge P 0 Box 1442 NW Piedmont Council Of Govts Princeton, WV 24740 280 South Liberty St 304-425-9508 Winston-Salem, NC 27101 910-722-9346 26 Mr. Scott Arnbs Mr. Ken Gebert Region 2 Planning Comm SACOG Floor 16 3000 "S" Street, Ste 300 120 W Michigan Sacramento, CA 95816-7055 Jackson, MI 49201 916-457-2264 517-788-4426 Mr. Steve Kunkel Mr. W D Smith SANDAG Region 4 Plan & Dev Council Mail Station 980 500 B Main Street 401 B St Ste 800 Summersville, WV 26651 San Diego, CA 92101-4287 304-872-4970 619-595-5318 Mr. Chris Callahan Mr. Brian Bresdin Regional Intergovernmental Council SBCAG 511 Centml Avenue 222 E Anapamu Street Charleston, W 25302 Santa Barbara, CA 93108 304-345-8191 805-568-2945 Ms. Elaine Wilkinson Mr. Mike Powers Regional Planning Commission SBCAG 333 St. Charles Ave #1100 222 E Anapamu Street New Orleans, LA 70130-3122 Santa Barbara, CA 93108 504-568-6611 Mr. Don Belanger Mr. David Ahnert Southeast Michigan Rockingham Planning Commission Council Of Governments 121 Water Street Suite 1900 Exefer, NH 03833 660 Plaza Drive 603-778-0885 Detroit, NH 48226 313-961-4266 Ms. Jo Alice Evans Richmond Regional Mr. Dan Roberts Planning Dist Comm Southeast Texas Reg Plan Commission Suite 101 P 0 Drawer 1387 2104 W Leburnum Ave Nederland, TX 77627 Richmond, VA 23229 409-724-1911 804-358-3684 Mr. Manuel Cela Mr. Arnold Waters South Florida Reg Plan Council Rogue Valley COG Suite 140 155 S Second St 3440 Hollywood Blvd Central Point, OR 97502 Hollywood, FL 33021 503-664-6674 305-961-2999 27 Mr. Peter Williams Mr. Eric Johnson San Joaquin COG Spokane Regional Trans Council 4th Floor Room 627 102 S San Joaquin Street 808 W Spokane Falls Blvd Stockton, CA 95201-1010 Spokane 9 WA 99201-3333 209-468-3913 509-625-6370 Mr. Stan Balsman Ms. Jennifer Fais Southeast Missouri Reg Southern Tier Central Regional Planning Commission Planning & Development Board P 0 Box 366 145 Village Square Perryville, MO 63775 Painted Post, NY 14870 314-547-8357 607-962-5092 Mr. Thomas Tucker Mr. Ronald Southard Southeast Missouri Reg Southern Tier West Regional Planning Commission Planning & Development Bd 1 West St Joseph Street 465 Broad Street Perryville, MO 63775 Salamanca, NY 14779 314-547-8357 716-945-5301 Mr. Suresh Narayanan Mr. Hunter Wynne Southern Oklahoma Dev Association South-West Florida 15 1st Avenue SE Regional Planning Council P 0 Box 848 P 0 Box 3455 Ardmore, OK 73402 North Ft Myers, FL 33918-3455 405-226-2250 813-995-4282 Ms. Carol Corker Ms. Bettina Varner Southside Planning District Comm TARCOG P 0 Box 150 Suite A South Hill, VA 23970 115 Washington St SE 804-447-7101 Huntsville, AL 35801-4883 205-533-3330 Mr. Wade Fox Southwestern Penn Reg Plan Comm Mr. Marshall Flynn The Waterfront Tampa Bay Reg Plan Council 200 First Ave 9455 Koger Blvd Pittsburgh, PA 15222-1573 St Petersburg, FL 33702 412-391-5590 x 312 813-577-5151 Mr. Paul Mission Mr. William Balsley SRPEDD Tulare County 88 Broadway Planning And Development Dept Taunton, MA 02780 County Civic Center 508-824-1367 Room III Courthouse Visalia, CA 93291-4593 209-733-6168 28 Mr. Craig Anderson Ms. Faith Hege Tri-County Reg. PIn. Comm. Western Piedmont COG 913 W Holmes Ste 201 317 First Ave NW Lansing, MI 48910 Hickory, NC 28601 517-393-0342 704-322-9191 Mr. Robert Wood Texoma Council Of Govts 10000 Grayson Dr Denison, TX 75020 903-786-2955 Mr. David Read Thurston Reg Plan Council Suite B 2404 Heritage Ct SW Olympia, WA 98502 206-754-4996 Mr. Andy Miller Upper Savannah COG P 0 Box 1366 Greenwood, SC 29648 803-941-8050 Ms. Heather Gruber West Alabama Plan & Dev Council Suite 1 4200 Highway 59 North Northport, AL 35476 205-333-2990 Mr. Mark Teuscher Wasatch Front Regional Council Suite 200 420 West 1500 South Bountiful, UT 84010 801-299-5712 Mr. Bryan Gillett West Michigan Shoreline Regional Development Commission P 0 Box 387 Muskegon, MI 49443-0387 616-722-7878 29 APPENDIX C APPENDIX D Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. APPENDIX D Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. Click HERE for graphic. .
