{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
WAY, ALTHOUGH HE WAS A CONSERVATIVE DEMOCRAT ON MANY SOCIAL
ISSUES. BUT HE WAS, IN TERMS OF WHAT IS IT THAT THE PEOPLE
NEED, WHAT IS IT THE PEOPLE SHALL HAVE, WHAT IS IT THAT I THINK
I CAN HELP THEM GET IN A STATE WHERE -- IN FACT WHEN HE MADE
THAT DECISION -- NOT TO RUN THAT ISS -- THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE
IN WEST VIRGINIA WAS SOMEWHERE AROUND 17% OR 18%. SO GOVERNMENT
WAS VERY IMPORTANT TO SENATOR RANDOLPH, AND HE LED HIS LIFE AND
{17:45:36} (MR. ROCKEFELLER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HIS LEGISLATIVE LIFE VERY MUCH WITH THAT IN MIND. HE AND
SENATOR BYRD WERE ELECTED AT THE SAME TIME IN 1958, BECAUSE
THERE WAS A SPECIAL VACANCY BECAUSE OF A SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCE.
BUT POSITIVE, CIVIL, COURTEOUS, KIND HE WAS. I ASKED BEFORE I
GOT UP TO -- THE SENATOR GOT UP TO MAKE THESE REMARKS WHERE HE
SAT AND I WAS INFORMED HE SAT IN KNIVES DIFFERENT DESKS. ONE OF
THEM IS THE DESK I THINK SENATOR LEVIN FROM MICHIGAN JUST SPOKE
{17:46:12} (MR. ROCKEFELLER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FROM. BUT OVER HIS TIME HERE, HE INSISTED ON COURTESY IN THE
SENATE, SOMETHING WHICH HAS BEEN PARALLELED BY HIS COLLEAGUE
FOR SO MANY YEARS, SENATOR BYRD, AND I AM TOLD BY MY
FATHER-IN-LAW, SENATOR PERCY WHO IS ALSO HIS VERY CLOSE FRIEND,
THAT HE WOULD OFTEN GET UP AND INSIST ON ORDER IN THE SENATE.
HE WAS VERY MUCH A STICK LETTER FOR PROTOCOL AND ORDER --
STICKLER, AND FOR.
{17:46:48 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: TO COME AND ORDER AND FROM VOTING FROM
ONE'S DESK, SOMETHING SENATOR BYRD FEELS STRONGLY B I REMEMBER
A SENATOR OF KINDNESS AND GOOD HUMOR HE WAS ALWAYS IN AN HE
BULL YENT MOOD, WHO ACTUALLY BOUNCED SOMETIMES -- EBULLIENT
MOOD, WHO ACTUALLY BOUNCED SOMETIMES WHEN HE TALKED HE WAS SO
EXCITE BUILD WHAT HE WAS DOING. BUT HE DEMANDED INTEGRITY IN
THE TREATMENT OF OTHERS, RESPECT IN THE TREATMENT OF OTHERS. HE
WAS VERY OLD FASHIONED IN HIS WAYS AND THUS I THINK WE MISS HIM
{17:47:20} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
EVEN MORE THESE DAYS. HE DID MANY THINGS. HE WAS ALWAYS OPEN TO
NEW IDEAS. HE ACTUALLY, MORE THAN 50 YEARS AGO, FLEW AN
AIRPLANE THAT WAS POWERED ENTIRELY BY METHANOL FOR SOME
DISTANCE. ONE, HE KNEW HOW TO FLY AN AIRPLANE, WHICH WAS
UNUSUAL, SECONDLY HE DID ONE POWERED BY METHANOL WHICH WAS
UNPRECEDENTED. HE INVOLVED HIMSELF FROM A VERY EARLY AGE, AND
HE DID SO WITH EXTRAORDINARY EFFECTIVENESS. I COULD TALK FOR
{17:47:57} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE HOUR WHICH I WILL NOT ABOUT WHAT HE ACCOMPLISHED. EVERYBODY
KNOWS THAT HE REALLY WAS THE FOUNDER OF THE APPALACHIAN
REGIONAL COMMISSION, WHICH HAS DONE SO MUCH TO HELP NOT ONLY
THE STATE HE LOVED, WEST VIRGINIA, BUT 12 OTHER STATES IN
ADDITION TO THAT, AND HE WAS A PRINCIPAL ARCHITECT OF THE
HIGHWAY SYSTEM WHICH HELPS TO PLACE HIM IN TIME BECAUSE THAT
WAS DONE, AS YOU KNOW, THE MIDDLE AND LATE 1950'S. I THINK THE
{17:48:34} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
PROUD HE IS THE OF ALL OF HIS ACHIEVEMENTS OR THE ONE THAT
CAUSED HIM TO TALK THE MOST AND BE THE MOST ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT
WAS THE 26TH AMENDMENT AND HE WAS THE AUTHOR AND THE DRIVER OF
THE 26TH AMENDMENT WHICH GAVE 18 YEARS OLD THE RIGHT TO VOTE IN
THIS COUNTRY. HE PROTECTED THE ENVIRONMENT WITH FEROCITY, HE
WAS TREMENDOUSLY INTERESTED IN COAL AS WELL AS THE ENVIRONMENT,
IN WORKER SAFETY, AND AS I HAVE INDATED IN AVIATION ISSUES AND
{17:49:07} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
JUST IN SIMPLY COUNTLESS OTHER AREAS. HE WAS PRO DID I UNITED
STATES IN HIS VOLUME OF OUT -- PRODIJIOUS IN HIS OUTPUT. HE WAS
CHAIRMAN AFTER POWERFUL COMMITTEE AND CHAIRMAN OF THAT
COMMITTEE FOR A VERY LONG TIME, AND THAT WAS IN THE DAYS WHEN
THE SENATE TENDED TO BE MORE IN CONTROL OF ONE PARTY THAN THE
OTHER FOR A VERY LONG TIME, AND HE WORKED THE SCOOP JACKSONS
AND LYNDON JOHNSONS AND ALL OF THE OTHERS AND THEY WERE ABLE TO
ACCOMPLISH AN ENORMOUS AMOUNT AND HE DID THAT AND HE LOVED IT.
{17:49:42} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HE LOVED DOING THAT. HE FRANKLY LOVED LAYING PAVEMENT OUT
ACROSS THE WIDE HORIZONS OF OUR COUNTRY. THERE WAS AN
INTERESTING ASPECT TO SENATOR RANDOLPH. HE WAS INTENSE ABOUT
ALL OF HIS WORK, BUT HE WAS VERY MUCH OF A UNITED STATES
SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA. HE ACCEPTED FULL
RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE TY TELL UNITED STATES SENATOR, AND
ENACTED -- TITLE OF UNITED STATES SENATOR, AND ENACTED ON ALL
MATTERS RELATING TO THAT WITH INCISIVENESS AND CAREFUL THOUGHT.
{17:50:20} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BUT HE LIKED TO SAY AND OFTEN SAID AND SAID WITH GREAT PRIDE
THAT I AM, "I AM ESSENTIALLY A WEST VIRGINIA SENATOR. I AM NOT
WHAT YOU WOULD CALL A NATIONAL SENATOR OR AN INTERNATIONAL
SENATOR." I THINK IF HE WERE HERE TODAY, I AM NOT SURE THE
WORDS WOULD BE THAT DIFFERENT. AND TO UNDERSTAND THAT ONE HAS
TO UNDERSTAND HIS ROOTS. HE WAS BORN IN THIS TINY COMMUNITY OF
SALEM, WEST VIRGINIA, NOW THE HOME OF PROBABLY AS MANY JAPANESE
{17:50:52} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
STUDENTS IN SOMETHING IN A SAY LEVEL-TOKYO UNIVERSITY AS RESIDE
ANYWHERE ELSE IN THIS COUNTRY. HIS FATHER WAS THE MAYOR OF
SALEM. HE WAS BORN WITH VERY LITTLE MONEY, AND HE WORKED HIS
WAY IN FARM JOBS. HE KNEW AGRICULTURE VERY WELL. HE WORKED FOR
ANYBODY THAT WOULD GIVE HIM A JOB TO PUT A FEW DOLLARS IN HIS
POCKET SO HE COULD FURTHER HIS EDUCATION, AND PROVE HIS
{17:51:28} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
POSSIBILITIES. I LIKE THAT ABOUT HIM, BECAUSE HE WAS UTTERLY A
RURAL SENATOR. BUT WITH AN URBAN REACH WHEN IT CAME TO THE
NATIONAL PART OF HIS RESPONSIBILITIES. HE STARTED IN
JOURNALISM, AND WAS ALWAYS A PROLY U. LIFK WRITER. HE MARRIED
MARY KATHRYN BAB BACK AND ONE ELECT TO THE UNITED STATES AT THE
{17:51:58} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AGE OF 30. ONE DID DO THAT BUT ONE CAN'T GO MUCH LESS EQUALLY.
BUT THEN IT WAS EXTRAORDINARY TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT. AND I
INDICATED HE HAS TWO SONS, JAY AND FRANK. SO MORE THAN 50 YEARS
LATER, MADAM PRESIDENT, I THINK THAT THE GRACIOUS LADY WHO
OCCUPIES THE PRESIDING OFFICER'S CHAIR WILL UNDERSTAND THAT IT
IS QUITE A FEELING FOR ME TO HAVE SUCCEEDED HIM, TO HAVE BEEN
{17:52:31} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ALLOWED TO SUCCEED HIM BY HIS OWN GESTURE OF GENEROSITY, AND
FRANKLY JUST TO BE ABLE TO SUCCEED HIM. HE IS LONG REMEMBERED
IN THIS BODY AS WELL AS IN THE HOUSE FOR THE VERY EXCEPTIONAL
NATURE THAT HE HAD, HIGH OPTIMISM, GREAT CONFIDENCE, ENORMOUS
BELIEF IN COUNTRY, AND HIS ABSOLUTE LOVE FOR HIS STATE. AND HE
ALSO, AND I WILL SAY THIS IN CLOSING, HE HAD A GREAT LOVE FOR
HIS PROFESSION, AND IN THAT I THINK MANY OF US JOIN HIM. HE WAS
{17:53:04} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
NOT ONE OF THOSE WHO FELT THAT BEING IN PUBLIC SERVICE WAS SOME
KIND OF A SECOND CHOICE. I THINK HE FELT IT WAS THE BEST CHOICE
OF ALL. HE WAS SOMEBODY WHO HONORED HIS CRAFT, WHO BROUGHT
GREAT DISTINCTION TO HIS CRAFT, WHO NEVER COMPROMISED ON HIS
PRINCIPLES, AND WHEN HE FACED A WEST VIRGINIA AUDIENCE OR A
SENATE CHAMBER, COULD STAND TALL AND STRONG AND BROAD
SHOULDERED AS HE WAS, AND DO HIS WORK, BECAUSE HE KNEW HE WAS
IN A WORK WHICH WAS ENORMOUSLY IMPORTANT FOR HELPING THE PEOPLE
{17:53:39} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THAT HE SO LOVED FROM THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA. SO THIS IS A
DAY AND A TIME THAT WE HAVE REASON TO REFLECT ON JENNINGS
RANDOLPH AND WHAT MADE HIM AN EXCEPTIONAL PERSON. IT'S SAD, I
THINK, THIS TRADITION IN THE SENATE WHEN WE DO THIS ABOUT
SENATORS WHEN THEY DIE. IT WOULD BE ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO CREATE
A TRADITION TO DO THAT WHILE THEY WERE STILL LIVING, BUT IT
WOULD BE NICE IF THEY COULD HEAR WHAT IT WAS THAT WE SAY ABOUT
THEM, AND I SUSPECT THAT SENATOR JENNINGS RANDOLPH IS ABLE TO
{17:54:12} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HEAR AND TO KNOW ON THIS DAY AND DAYS THAT SUCCEED WHAT HAZE
COLLEAGUES THINK ABOUT HIM. -- HIS COLLEAGUES THINK ABOUT HIM.
I AM PERSONALLY GRATEFUL AS IS OBVIOUS. I AM SURE I WOULD NOT
BE HERE IF IT WERE NOT NOR JENNINGS RANDOLPH, AND I KNOW THAT
MY COLLEAGUES JOIN ME IN OUR PRAYERS AND THOUGHTS FOR HIS
FAMILY, AND THANKING JENNINGS RANDOLPH FOR HIS ENORMOUS
CONTRIBUTION TO A CRAFT WHICH WE CALL "PUBLIC SERVICE," AND WE
{17:54:54} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DO THAT WITH HONOR AND PRIDE. I THANK THE PRESIDING OFFICER.
{17:54:55 NSP} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. WYDEN: MADAM PRESIDENT?
{17:55:00 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM OREGON IS RECOGNIZED.
{17:55:07 NSP} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. WYDEN: MADAM PRESIDENT, I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO SPEAK AS
IF IN MORNING BUSINESS.
{17:55:12 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{17:55:13 NSP} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. WYDEN: THANK YOU, MADAM PRESIDENT. BEFORE THE SENATOR FROM
WEST VIRGINIA LEAVES THE FLOOR, LET ME SAY I THOUGHT HE WAS
EXTRAORDINARILY ELOQUENT, AND I GOT A CHANCE TO KNOW SENATOR
RANDOLPH A BIT AS A MEMBER OF THE HOUSE, AND YOUR STATEMENT
HERE TODAY REALLY SUMS UP THE EXTRAORDINARY QUALITIES OF THIS
GREAT MAN. I AM VERY PLEASED TO HAVE BEEN ABLE TO BE HERE FOR A
FEW MINUTES TO HEAR YOUR VERY FINE SPEECH. MADAM PRESIDENT, WE
{17:55:43} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HAD A THOUGHT NULL DISCUSSION ON THE FLOOR OF THE SENATE
EARLIER TODAY WITH SENATORS MCCAIN AND SENATORS DORGAN
ESPECIALLY WITH RESPECT TO THE HIGH-TECH ISSUES THAT WILL BE
COMING UP OVER THE COURSE OF THIS WEEK. IN A SENSE IT IS IRONIC
THAT WE CALL IT HIGH-TECH WEEK HERE. I AM VERY PLEASED THAT
SENATOR LOTT AND SENATOR DASCHLE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO GET AN
AGREEMENT TO DEAL WITH THESE ISSUES, AND IN A SENSE WE ARE
GOING TO BE DEALING WITH HIGH-TECH ISSUES ALL YEAR ROUND AS WE
{17:56:19} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FACE THE 21ST CENTURY. IT IS NOT GOING TO BE SOMETHING THAT WE
JUST LOOK AT FROM TIME TO TIME BUT IT WILL ESSENTIALLY
DOMINATE, IN MY VIEW, THE DEBATE ABOUT PUBLIC POLICY IN THE
YEARS AHEAD. I AM PARTICULARLY HOPEFUL THAT THIS WEEK WE WILL
HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY ON THE SENATE FLOOR TO DEBATE THE INTERNET
TAX FREEDOM ACT WHICH, AS OUR PRESIDING OFFICER KNOWS, WAS
DEBATED AT SOME LENGTH IN THE SENATE COMMERCE COMMITTEE EARLIER
{17:56:55} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THIS YEAR. MY SENSE IS THAT THESE TAX ISSUES ARE ESPECIALLY
IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT IS SO CRITICAL THAT OUR COUNTRY LAY OUT A
SET OF GROUND RULES, A SET OF PRINCIPLES THAT WILL ADDRESS THE
QUESTION OF TAXATION AND THE DIGITAL ECONOMY. RIGHT NOW YOU CAN
LIVE IN THE DAKOTAS, YOU WANT TO SEND A TASTY FRUIT BASKET FROM
A COMPANY IN OREGON, ORDER IT ONLINE SAY FROM A FIRM IN
{17:57:31} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
VIRGINIA, AND PAY FOR IT WITH A FLORIDA BANK CARD, AND END UP
ABSOLUTELY BAFFLED WITH RESPECT TO HOW MANY JURISDICTIONS MAY
BE IN A POSITION TO IMPOSE TAXES ON THIS PARTICULAR
TRANSACTION. WE HAVE ALREADY HEARD IN TESTIMONY BEFORE THE
COMMITTEE THAT THE UNCERTAINTY SURROUNDING THESE TRANSACTIONS
HAS CAUSED SOME BUSINESSES TO GO UNDER. IN PARTICULAR WE HEARD
FROM A SMALL BUSINESS IN TENNESSEE ABOUT THE PROBLEM. "THE WALL
{17:58:12} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
STREET JOURNAL" RECENTLY REPORTS IN A PEAT-MARWICK SURVEY THAT
MANY FINANCIAL EXECUTIVES ARE UNCERTAIN WITH RESPECT TO HOW
TRANSACTIONS WILL BE HANDLED IN IGH BETTER SPACE, AND THIS HAS
CONTRIBUTED TO -- CYBERSPACE AND THIS HAS CONTRIBUTED TO
UNCERTAINTY TO GO FORWARD AND DO BUSINESS ONLINE, AND RECENTLY
ONE OF THE PROMINENT ANALYSTS A FIRM BY THE NAME OF VERTAX
CITED SEVERAL STATES WHERE IT WAS REALLY IMPOSSIBLE TO KNOW HOW
{17:58:45} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TO PROCEED WITH RESPECT TO ELECTRONIC COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS
BECAUSE IN EFFECT THE RULES WERE SO FLUID THAT WOULD YOU HAVE
TO GET AN INTERPRETATION OF TAX LAW THAT REALLY WAS NOT
WRITTEN. SO I AND OTHERS HAVE INTRODUCED THE INTERNET TAX
FREEDOM ACT, AND IT'S PURPOSE IS SIMPLE. THAT IS TO GIVE
CONSUMERS AND BUSINESSES ENGAGED IN ELECTRONIC COMMERCE A TIME
{17:59:20} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OUT FROM DISCRIMINATORY TAXES SO THAT OUR COUNTRY CAN DEVELOP A
FAIR AND REASONABLE POLICY ON INTERNET TAXATION. AND WE ARE
VERY PROUD OF THE STRONG BIPARTISAN SUPPORT THAT THIS EFFORT
HAS RECEIVED. GOVERNOR GEORGE BUSH, FOR EXAMPLE, FROM THE STATE
OF TEXAS, HAS RECENTLY SPOKEN OUT ON THIS ISSUE. OUR COLLEAGUE,
SENATOR PAT LEAHY OF VERMONT, STREEFB "FORBES", THE LIST OF
SUPPORTERS -- STEVE "FORBES", THE LIST OF SUPPORTERS FOR THIS
{17:59:56} (MR. WYDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
EFFORT LITERALLY SPANS THE SPECTRUM. I BELIEVE THE REASON IT
HAS BEEN POSSIBLE TO GENERATE SUCH
{END: 1998/05/11 TIME: 18-00 , Mon. 105TH SENATE, SECOND SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}