Acknowledgments

The research presented here was conducted as part of a college-level course at Santa Clara University.  Anthropology 146 “Anthropological Perspectives on the Spanish and Native American Experience” taught by Russell K. Skowronek during the spring of 2004.  We would like to take this opportunity to thank Meredith Kaplan, Superintendent, and David Smith, Park Ranger-Interpretive Specialist, of the Juan Bautista de Anza National Historic Trail for their encouragement and support of the project.  Special thanks are due to Dr. Jack S. Williams of the Center for Spanish Colonial Archaeology for graciously sharing a draft of his monumental California Mission Studies Association manuscript titled, Los Presidios: Guardians of Alta California’s Mission Frontier.

 

Women’s Experiences along the Juan Bautista de Anza Trail

At the beginning of the 21st century women in the United States enjoyed a way of life that was unprecedented in the history of women-kind – or was it?  More than two and a quarter centuries ago, Juan Bautista de Anza led 200 settlers to the San Francisco Bay Area.  Among these people were thirty families comprised of several women and girls.  These pioneers brought the social norms of their culture – norms that were very different from that of the English-speaking world and those of the native peoples of Alta California.

Clothing and Accessories

      Clothing worn by Spanish people in the New World was more diverse and colorful than traditional dress in Spain.  Women traditionally wore long pleated skirts, enaguas or refejos (full petticoats), an apron, a blouse, a jubon or laced bodice, and shawls (Foster 1960: 97).  Although skirts were usually worn long, it was not unusual for the skirt to only reach the knee.  In such cases, the woman wore colorful woolen socks, which served a decorative rather than practical purpose and often didn’t have feet.  Women frequently wore head coverings, which served to protect women from the cold and sun.  These head coverings included shawls, hats, bonnets, straw hats with colorful ribbons, or a variety of head cloths.  The rebocino was unique to Mexico and served a variety of functions including shawl, head cover, and blanket.  On special occasions, the women enjoyed dressing in Spanish and European finery.  While Native Americans were reluctant to adopt many Spanish traditions, they adopted Spanish clothing due to formal acculturation.  The Santa Clara Account reveals orders placed in for several hundred petticoats (Skowronek and Fanta).  These orders indicate that the Spanish were concerned in clothing the Natives in what they considered appropriate attire.  In addition to acculturation, Foster hypothesizes that there probably was not much resistance to the new clothing because of the practicality and usefulness of the clothing.  For example, Native American women probably appreciated warm, wool skirts when it was cold.

      The Ohlone women from what is now Monterey and the San Francisco Bay Area actually already had much warmer clothing for the winter, much better suited than the badly made mission cloth.  Their own rabbit-skin and otter-skin cloaks provided plenty of warmth for the winter months (Margolin 1978: 162). In warmer weather the Ohlone women dressed in skirts made from tule reeds and deer skins.  They did not wear shoes or sandals.  They also wore beautiful necklaces made from abalone shells, clam shell beads, and olivella acorns (Margolin 1978: 14).   The Chumash women from the Santa Barbara area also wore similar necklaces made from the nearby ocean resources.  There are differences between the two groups’ dress. The Chumash necklaces were also fashioned from bone and steatite (Heizer 1978: 509).

      Chumash women wore two knee-length skirts made of buckskin, one in front and one behind.  The edges were adorned with snail shells and cut abalone shells.  Their hair was cut in bangs combed forward, with the rest loose in the back.  Their ears were pierced and wore earrings made of shell and stone. In the Chumash society both men and women painted their bodies for spiritual rituals. The women arrived wearing antelope skins, their bodies painted, and carrying a colorful bundle of feathers (Heizer 1978: 512).  Ohlone women’s bodies were also painted and ornamented during dance rituals, though less elaborately than the men who wore skirts of raven or crow feathers (Margolin 1978: 152).

Occupations

While women in Spanish society clearly did not have equal status to men, they were granted rights which other European women did not enjoy.  For example, women were able to own property and testify in courts.  Many Spanish women in the New World were involved in a variety of occupations.  Some women worked at teachers.  Wives of soldiers accompanied the army and worked as “nurses, laundresses, storekeepers, assistant cooks, and other similar menial capacities” (Williams 2000 [3:1] 6).  Women occupied such artisan trades as weaving, pottery, cigar making, and shoe making.  Additionally, enough references to female artisans in these areas suggest it was common place for women to have such jobs, although it is questionable whether these women obtained special status such as masters or owning shops.  Women in textile production even formed their own guilds similar to those of men (Johnson 1986: 243).  Furthermore, wives and daughters of skilled artisans assisted their husbands and fathers and were essential to operating at a level to earn an income.  Women also owned a significant portion of the stalls in the markets where people came to buy and sell wares.  Thus, they were able to achieve a certain level of social and political status in both Spain and Mexico.

Women of the Chumash and Ohlone Indian groups were given important occupations essential to the community. Women gathered and prepared shellfish and wild plant foods, and men hunted sea and land mammals and fished (Hollimon 1992). In the Ohlone tribe women gathered acorns, which they prepared for mush daily (Margolin 1978: 43).  They prepared this mush in groups, creating a rhythm with their grinding as they sang along (Margolin 1978: 14).  Women did not only gather roots and acorns, but most were daily basket makers and considered artists.  These baskets were not only esthetically pleasing, but each was skillfully crafted for their specific purposes (Margolin 1978: 121). Ohlone women could also become a curing shaman, who could set bones, induce abortions, and control bleeding with a compress made of animal hair.  Unique to the Ohlone shaman is the ability to release pressure caused by brain tumors by puncturing the cranium, called trepanning (Margolin, 132).  Elite women in the Chumash society were sometimes given even more power than a shaman.  In some cases daughters or sisters of a deceased Chumash chief would inherit the position of chief (Heizer 1978: 510). 

Courtship and marriage

Spanish tradition and religion were very strict.  Premarital sex was forbidden and marital fidelity was expected.  “If an adult man entered the house of another man while his wife was unattended and in the residence, his actions were considered proof of adultery” (Williams 2000 [3:1] 2).  There were laws against such actions, and strict punishment was dealt to offenders.  “Women were thought to be sexually powerful creatures who could lead men astray” (Hurtado 1999: 5).  Family honor was largely the responsibility of the women, who preserved it through virginity.  A double standard existed where men could earn a certain amount of respect for seducing a woman while the woman as well as her family were shamed and dishonored.  “Prestige was awarded to a male who had as many sexual partners as possible” (Williams 2000 [3:1] 4). 

Women lacked significant power to refuse the wishes of their fathers and husbands.  However, they were not powerless as records of women accusing men of seduction and rape indicate.  There are also recorded cases of women involved in illicit affairs and priest records of illegitimate babies (occasionally, the priests themselves were suspected of fathering such children) (Hurtado 1999: 27). 

Priests and parents tried to restrict women and prevented illicit sexual encounters through separation, even going so far as to lock women up in some instances.  In cities and towns throughout the New World separation of the sexes was the norm.  Because of this, a popular meeting place in these communities was in plazas around the fountains, where girls filled water jugs.  As a result of such supervision, there were lower incidents of premarital pregnancies.  If such did result, friars and priests warned against rushing into potentially loveless and unhappy unions (Nunis 1996: 13).

Engagements were often arranged between go betweens (Foster 1960: 125).  According not only to social norms but also to Spanish law, a couple was only considered engaged after parental approval (Nunis 1996: 12).  Some, like Nunis, say arranged marriages were not common, as parents wanted their children to enjoy a union of love.  Others like Hurtado say that while the theory that women should not be forced into marriage against their will persisted, this was not always the case in practice.  Laws and traditions supported patriarchy and women could not refuse the wishes of their fathers.  “Elite families often arranged marriages of their children so that a good match would be assured rather than leaving this important matter to the whims of mere youthful passion” (Hurtado 1999: 25).  The number of men in colonial California greatly outnumbered the women.  This put additional pressure on women to marry, and at young ages.  Sergeant Vallejo was visiting the Lugo family when Sonora Lugo was in labor.  Vallejo had a limited medical training and helped deliver the baby girl, Maria Antonia.  He asked the grateful parents for betrothal to the new born, which they agreed to.  Fourteen years later, Maria Antonia and Vallejo, age forty, were married (Hurtado 1999: 26). 

There were other reasons for age differences among married couples.  It was important for men to support the family financially, while for women the importance was virginity and fertility.  This usually resulted in men marrying much younger women.  “Apparently, such ability [for men to achieve financial security] was demonstrated at a relatively young age in California, with many men taking the vows at 17 or 18 years of age” (Williams 2000 [3:1] 2). 

A long courtship and engagement were preferred in the society, which was hoped, “Would instill in the couple recognition of the nature, function, and permanency of marriage” (Nunis 1996: 12).  Finally, after obtaining permission for marriage from the governor as required by the Church, couples must be granted the blessing of the church before marriage.  This was obtained through the answering of routine questions, as well as agreeing to the canons of the church regarding marriage (Nunis 1996: 15). 

The average age of a groom according to the 1836 Los Angeles census was 38.8 years and the average age for a bride was 29.8 years, with the average age difference between the couple at 8.9 years (Nunis 1996: 9).  However, the ideal age for marriage for women was eighteen.  These numbers were lower than a century before, reflecting both social changes and the increase in a younger population.  Marriage rituals were similar throughout SpainNew World because they both followed traditions set by the Catholic Church.  These rituals included reading the banns (anyone knowing a reason the couple shouldn’t get married was urged to come forward and voice the evidence), confession, and communion. and the

            The church emphasized wifely obedience.  It viewed sex between spouses as purely for the purpose of procreation.  Further, it only condoned sexual intercourse in the missionary position since, “Other positions were unnatural because they made the woman superior to her husband, thus thwarting God’s universal plan” (Hurtado 1999: 5).

            Although they were considerably more liberal than the Spanish about premarital sex and homosexuality the Ohlone severely restricted sexual intercourse.  Even married couples were not allowed to make love freely while the woman was menstruating, while the male was preparing for a deer hunt, white woman was nursing, or while either one was getting ready for a spiritual event.  Sex was seen interfering with the life of the spirit, which is the basis for Spanish sexual restrictions as well.  The Ohlone’s sex restrictions served as a form of birth control.  The nursing mother, unable to have sex, would not conceive until her child was able to walk on their own.  This is practical in a highly mobile society (Margolin 1978: 85).

            In the Chumash society there were transvestite males called Berdaches, who had mixed-gender status (Hollimon 1992).  They were allowed to take on the role of ‘women’ from a young age, and were considered women.  They were completely accepted by the community as ‘wives’ of their husbands, even if their other wives were women.  Female homosexuality was limited to sex, and it was unthinkable for a woman to adopt male clothing and roles (Margolin 1978: 84).  When the Spanish arrived, they attempted to put an end to institutionalized homosexuality.  One suspected ‘berdache’ was captured and stripped naked at Mission Santa Clara.  For three days he was forced to sweep the guardhouse and do other tasks in order to publicly humiliate him.  When he was released he was told he should “live as a man” (Williams 2000: 6(2), 14).

Marriage was highly respected in both the Ohlone and Chumash societies.  Except for chiefs and captains, most Chumash men only had one wife. A Chumash wife was bought with beads, skins, or a blanket from her family (Heizer 1978: 511).  In Ohlone marriages the second wife was not considered a concubine or mistress, but an equal wife. Sometime her children were treated unequally however.  In Ohlone marriages virginity was not required, but it was regarded with respect.  Traditionally the woman would protest and scratch the face of her husband on her wedding night out of modesty (Margolin 1978: 86).  Adultery was considered wrong, and women could fight or even kill her husband’s mistress if she was not in her family. In Chumash society adultery was not settled by individuals fighting.  It was punished by whipping (Heizer, 511). Ohlone divorce was allowed, but the couple had to have worked hard to maintain their relationship (Margolin 1978: 83).   

If an Ohlone woman’s husband died she went into a deep state of mourning which lasted anywhere from six months to a year.  The widow beat her breasts while wailing and screaming when she knew her husband had died.  She later singed her hair close to her scalp and covered her face with ashes and pitch (Margolin 1978: 145).  She was most feared because she was closest to the deceased, meaning he could haunt her.  A widow was kept in isolation for the mourning period, but afterwards returned to normal (Margolin 1978: 148).

Pregnancy, birth, and infancy

The reality of Spanish culture differed markedly from the idealized pronouncements of the church.  Spanish society was based around the family.  Young wives hoped for a quick pregnancy.  A wife who did not become pregnant within the first year was pitied and could lose social status (Foster 1960: 113).  Many superstitions and actions arose regarding the hastening of pregnancy (Foster 1960: 114).  The more normal of these traditions included prayer and pilgrimage.  Many believed that difficulty to become pregnant resulted from “open kidneys.”  They placed the skin of newly butchered sheep onto the women’s back to heal the kidneys.  People also believed that lack of love between couples inhibited pregnancy, while sexual enjoyment and coinciding orgasms help, and the course of the moon was very influential.  In different areas, different actions were thought to increase the chance of pregnancy.  These included sex under a bridge, sex in a bed facing west, and the man pressing his left foot on the wall during sex (Foster 1960: 114). 

Once a woman became pregnant, her lifestyle changed, although not much.  For examples, certain food and drink limitations were set.  However, they strongly supported satisfying antojos, or cravings, which they believed were really the cravings of the unborn baby and if not met, would lead to birthmarks.  Superstitions revolved around pregnancy as well.  For example, a woman was not to wind string around her neck as this was thought to cause the strangulation of the baby at birth by the umbilical cord (Foster 1960: 112). 

During childbirth, the woman usually sat on a chair or her husband’s knees, or crouched next to a wall.  To hasten the birth, women would blow in bottles, gag on their hair, or drink their husbands’ urine to promote vomiting and thus speed contractions (Foster 1960: 112).  At birth, new mothers would often say, “Di a luz un nino” or I gave light to a child (Nunis 1996: 24).  Ritual burials of placenta were common, and the umbilical cord was often saved as an amulet.  After childbirth, if the family could afford it the mother would observe cuarentena, a forty day rest period.  She would often stay in the dirty sheets for up to a week, as there were superstitions regarding cleaning too quickly.  Though one would expect Indian women to maintain their native, traditional “female culture,” anthropologists have discovered that these traditions not only transcended New World Spanish classes, but also in acculturated Indians (Foster 1960: 122).

The baby was often baptized early before the mother had risen.  This was due to the fact that if they died, the Spanish believed babies who were not baptized would remain in limbo.  Baptisms were a festive occasion.  The selection of Godparents was important, as they were to be both spiritual leaders of the godchild as well as a surrogate parent in the event anything happened to the parents.  Contrary to traditions in Spain, Spanish Mexican godparents were usually friends of the parents, and the bond between parents and godparents was stronger than that between the godparents and child.

Chumash and Ohlone birth and childhood were also important processes, marked by spiritual rituals.  What most shocked the Spanish was the fact that Chumash women went to great lengths to loose their first child.  If the child was not aborted, it would die immediately after birth.  Superstition told them if they did not loose the first child they would never conceive again (Heizer 1978: 511).  The high infant mortality rate controlled the population. Women knew how to induce abortions, and the curing shaman would help them (Margolin 1978: 132).  Chumash women gave birth by digging a hole wherever they were when the labor began.  This hole was then lined with straw in order to build a fire.  Husbands could not touch their wives until the child could stand alone, and he must avoid meat or the child might die (Heizer 1978: 511). Ohlone women would avoid fish, meat, and salt while pregnant and would shape their infant’s head by pressing their hands into the child’s forehead and firmly pushing towards the sides (Margolin 1978: 72).  The Chumash flattened the child’s nose in a similar mark of community (Heizer 1978: 511). Ohlone infants were bathed at least once a day by their mother, and carried in a basketry cradle decorated with beads and shells which would be filled with fresh cattail fluff after each bath (Ohlone 1978: 14).

Childhood and education

The average number of children per family in Los Angeles during the 1830s was 4.4 children, though there is record of fertile families, such as Teresa Hartnell gave birth to eighteen children in Santa Barbara (Nunis 1996: 23).  For women who married at the ideal age of eighteen, they often had their first child at the age of twenty.  Birthdates were celebrated as a feast day, and were important both religiously and socially (Nunis 1996: 26).  The education of children in religion and social roles began as soon as the child was active.  Children were taught social, cultural, and family values and responsibility so they could function as a member of society when they matured.  Children in the New World were taught skills that were useful in frontier living, such as horseback riding, the use of a lasso, as well as dancing, music, poetry, and song (Nunis 1996: 29). 

Most young girls did not obtain formal education.  Only select members of the upper class were able to afford tutoring for their daughters, while others sent their daughters to convents for education.  Other wealthy families provided their daughters with books for self-education.  However, most women were illiterate among the lower class.  Regardless of formal education, upper-class girls, “Learned and acquired skills in home management, drawn work, music, and dance” (Nunis 1996: 33).  When girls reached the age of twelve, they were much more closely supervised to maintain family honor.  They also assumed more responsibility to help their mothers with household tasks.  Boys of the same age were afforded much more freedom (William 2000 4 [3:1] 15).  Girls of all social status were taught domestic skills and good social behavior, so that when they reached adulthood they would marry and give birth to a new generation and continue the cycle.

Childhood for young Ohlone boys and girls was very similar.  Children followed older boys or girls in their duties.  Children were taught at a young age how to defecate in a hole and cover it so evil could not result.  Families did not whip or punish children, they instead taught by example.  At eight years old they separate. Girls helped grind acorns, make tule mats and baby cradles, and gather roots and herbs.  They also began to study plants, learning when and where plants grow, what songs to sing when approaching plants, how to collect different kinds of seeds, and when to dig roots (Margolin 1978: 74). Young girls also began their long and difficult apprenticeship in basket making (Margolin 1978: 75). 

            During puberty Chumash girls were not allowed to eat meat or grease and could not look into a burning fire (Heizer 1978: 511).  In the Luiseno area are abstract paintings are thought to have been made by girls as part of their puberty rites.  Ohlone girls, at the first sign of bleeding, retreated into the corner of their dwelling, or a separate hut.  They fasted, not eating meant, fish, salt, or drinking cold water.  They are warned against touching themselves, and if they must scratch they must do it with a stick.  Menstruation was of great importance.  Women came to visit her during the day, giving advice, secrets, and listened to her dreams.  Male and female relatives would perform ritual dances for her in order to make her passage into womanhood easier.  At the end of her period her family would prepare a feast in her honor, she would be bathed and dressed in fine beads. At puberty she would also receive tattoos, older women would scratch her face, breasts and shoulders with a sharp stone.  They would then rub charcoal dust into the wounds.  The scars would then form a distinct design in black, green, or blue.  The lines and dots carved into her face are a signal of her lineage (Margolin 1978: 75). The young native girl would then become a woman, and continue her lineage through her distinct role in the community.

 

 

 

Bibliography

Campa, Arthur L. 

      1979.  Hispanic Cultures in the South West. University of Oklahoma Press.  Oklahoma.

Foster, George M.

1960  Culture and Conquest: America’s Spanish Heritage. Quadrangle Books Inc.        Chicago, Illinois

 Heizer, R.(editor)

1976    A Collection of Ethnographical Articles on the California Indians. Ballena Press Publications in Archaeology, Ramona.

.Hurtado, Albert L.

1999    Intimate Frontiers: Sex, Gender, and Culture in old California. New            Mexico Press. Albuquerque, New Mexico.

Margolin, M.

1978    Ohlone Way: Indian Life in the San Francisco-Monterey Bay Area.  Heyday Books, Berkeley.

Nunis, Doyce. B. Junior, Editor.

      1996  Women in the Life of Southern California. Historical Society of Southern             California. Los Angeles, California.

Schell Hoberman, Louisa and Susan Migden Socolow, Editors.

1986  Cities and Society in Colonial Latin America.  University of New Mexico Press.  Albuquerque, New Mexico.

Skowronek, Russel K. and Jelena Radovic Fanta, Editors.

      2004 [draft] Mission Santa Clara de Asis Account Book. Translated by Jelena

Radovic Fanta with Russell K. Skrowronek. Unpublished manuscript on file Santa         Clara University, Santa Clara, CA.

Williams, Jack S.