Alternatives to Methyl Bromide for Eradicating
Pests in Exported Softwood Chips, Lumber, and Logs
L. David Dwinell, Research Plant Pathologist, Southern
Research Station, USDA Forest Service,
Athens, GA 30602.
Global transport of wood fiber without causing environmental harm or
ecological disaster requires that the wood be free of pests. USDA Forest
Service research on decontaminating coniferous chips, green lumber, and
logs has concentrated on the pinewood nematode (PWN) Bursaphelenchus
xylophilus and its pine sawyer (Monochamus) vectors. Methyl
bromide has been the treatment for this and other quarantine pests of logs
and other wood products. Mitigation procedures that have been
investigated over the past decade include fumigation, irradiation,
chemical dips, and elevated temperature.
A native of North America, the PWN has become a destructive introduced
pest in the forests of Japan and other Asian countries.
Bursaphelenchus xylophilus, carried by pine sawyers, are
transmitted to recently felled logs or dead or dying conifers,
particularly pines, during oviposition. These pests may be found
in chips, green lumber, and logs. The PWN has been intercepted
in chips, green lumber and packing-case wood exported from North
America. As a result of these and other interceptions, the European
Union and other countries regulate all coniferous imports to protect
their forests from the PWN and other exotic pests.
USDA scientists from the Southern Research Station of the Forest
Service and the former Stored Products Insects Research and Development
Laboratory of the Agricultural Research Service determined that metam
sodium and aluminum phosphide were effective in eradicating the PWN in
southern pine chips. To demonstrate the practicality of in-transit
fumigation, they applied phosphine to a shipload of woodchips exported
from Georgia to Sweden. The experiment was successful and awaits broader
application.
The irradiation of pine chips was considered to be an alternative to
fumigation. Southern Research Station and Georgia Institute of Technology
scientists treated PWN-infested wood samples in a cesium-137 irradiator
and found 0.9 MRAD to be the lethal dosage. Subsequently, Canadian
scientists reported that 0.7 MRAD dosage (cobalt 60 gammacell 220
irradiator) will eliminate the PWN in aqueous solution. These data
support the contention that a higher dosage is necessary to eliminate the
PWN in vivo than in vitro. The scientists concluded that 0.9
MRAD was too high to make this an attractive means of disinfestation for
commercial wood.
The Southern Research Station studied the efficacy of dip-diffusion
sodium borate treatments for eradicating the PWN in chips and for
eradicating the PWN and pine sawyers in debarked pine logs. Neither the
liquid nor the powder formulations were effective in controlling PWN or
pine sawyers. However, in a companion treatment, PWN and sawyers were not
recovered from pine logs fumigated with methyl bromide at the rate of
240g/m3.
Using elevated temperatures to eradicate mesophilic organisms in wood
shows the most promise. Mortality of the PWN and its vectors in wood is
primarily a function of moisture content, heat source, time, and
temperature. For example, conventional heat, live steam, and hot water
can raise wood temperatures to levels that are lethal to the PWN (greater
than 45 ° C). Research by scientists from Georgia Institute of
Technology and the Southern Research Station determined that the mortality
of the PWN in pine chips exposed to radio frequency waves was a function
of temperature. In a subsequent study, they evaluated the effectiveness
of radio waves and steam, alone or in combination, on PWN-infested chips.
High temperatures are possible in less time by combining steam and radio
waves, suggesting that the relationship between these two heat sources may
be synergistic. Cooperative research between Southern Research Station
and Canadian scientists found that a radio-frequency/vacuum kiln was
effective in eliminating the PWN and its vectors in sawn wood.
Elevated temperature can pasteurize or sterilize softwood chips, sawn
wood, or logs. Heating southern pine chips, green lumber, and logs to a
corewood temperature of 60 ° C for 30 minutes is sufficient to
eliminate such mesophilic pests as PWN, pine sawyers, and pathogenic
fungi. A team of scientists from the Southern Research Station, European
Union, and Canada concluded that heating coniferous wood to a corewood
temperature of 56 ° C for 30 minutes will eradicate the PWN and its
vectors. Shorter exposure times can be achieved with thermal treatments,
such as live steam and radio waves, that rapidly heat the wood to high
temperatures.
Drying coniferous wood at conventional kiln schedules is essentially a
wood sterilization process. The time-temperature schedules required to
dry sawn wood to commercial standards are much higher than those required
to eradicate pests in the wood. This has been confirmed by Southern
Research Station, Finnish, Canadian, and South Korean scientists.
Europe now accepts coniferous chips, sawn wood, and logs that are
certified to have been kiln-dried or treated at 56 ° C for 30
minutes. South Korea now allows the importation of kiln-dried pine sawn
wood. The research and development on elevated temperature as a
mitigation procedure for decontaminating transported wood has required the
cooperative efforts of several countries. Many individuals within the
USDA Forest Service, Foreign Agricultural Service, Agricultural Research
Service, and Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service worked together to
bring science and politics together. The value of these wood exports to
the United States has been estimated at $355 million per year.
Similar control principles are appropriate for export or import of
chips, green lumber, or logs. Pest control begins in the forest, but
forest practices should be followed by heat or other mitigation procedures
in the ideal wood management system.
[October 1996 Table of Contents]
[Newsletter Issues
Listing]
[Methyl Bromide Home
Page]
[ARS Home Page]
[USDA Home Page]
Last Updated: November 1, 1996
|
|
|