{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
SOME KIND OF CHISELER, AS IT WERE. MY MOM USED TO KEEP BORDERS
BACK IN THE COAL MINING COMMUNITY, AND WE TOOK ON A BOARDER AND
THEY CAME TO OUR HOUSE, AND I LISTENED TO HIM FOR A FEW
MINUTES, I'D SAY, -- FROM TIME TO TIME, I'D SAY TO THE WOMAN
WHO RAISED ME, HE'S GOING TO BEAT YOU OUT OF YOUR BOARD BILL.
THAT MAN WON'T PAY YOU. AND I WAS AMAZED IN SO MANY INSTANCES
{16:30:41} (MR. BYRD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TO FIND, TO MY CHAGRIN, THAT THAT MAN WOULD NOT PAY HIS BOARD
BILL. HE WAS A CHISELER. THAT'S WHAT WE'RE PORTRAYED TO BE,
CHISELERS, DEADBEATS. WE WON'T PAY OUR DUES. WE WON'T PAY OUR
ARREARAGES. THE U.S. HAS BEEN BAILING OUT THE REST OF THE U.N.
FOR YEARS NOW. TAKE THE U.S. OUT OF THE U.N., WHAT DO YOU HAVE
LEFT?
WHAT IS THERE LEFT?
{16:31:17} (MR. BYRD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE U.N. IN FACT OWE THE UNITED STATES.
THEY OWE US A MASSIVE BACK BILL FOR MILITARY OPERATIONS AND
FUNDING. AS I WAS SAYING ON THE FLOOR YESTERDAY, THE FIRST
QUESTION THAT WAS EVER ASKED IN THE HISTORY OF THE WORLD, THE
HISTORY OF THE UNIVERSE, IN THE HISTORY OF ALL CREATION, THE
QUESTION FIRST THAT WAS EVER ASKED -- THE FIRST QUESTION THAT
{16:31:54} (MR. BYRD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WAS EVER ASKED WAS WHEN GOD WALKED THROUGH THE GARDEN OF EDEN
IN THE COOL OF THE DAY SEARCHING FOR ADAM AND EVE. THEY HAD
FORFEITED -- THEY HAD FORFEITED THEIR RIGHT TO HAVE EVERLASTING
LIFE IN THAT GARDEN OF BLISS, A VIRTUAL PARADISE, BY EATING
{16:32:29} (MR. BYRD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FROM THE TREE OF KNOWLEDGE, SO GOD CAME LOOKING FOR THEM IN THE
COOL OF THE DAY AND HE ASKED THAT
FIRST QUESTION: "ADAM, WHERE ART THOU?" THEY HAD HIDDEN. "ADAM,
WHERE ART THOU?" AND SO WE MIGHT WELL ASK THE OTHER MEMBERS OF
{16:33:03} (MR. BYRD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE U.N., WHERE WERE YOU WHEN WE WERE IN THE HOT SANDS OF THE
GULF, WHEN WE HAD SENT OUR MEN AND WOMEN AWAY FROM THEIR HOMES,
AWAY FROM THEIR FIRESIDES, AWAY FROM THEIR CHILDREN, AWAY FROM
THEIR LOVED ONES TO TAKE POSSIBLE ACTION TO PROTECT YOU AND
YOURS?
WHERE WERE YOU?
WHERE WERE YOU?
{16:33:44} (MR. BYRD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. PRESIDENT, THE TIME HAS COME FOR THE ADMINISTRATION TO COOL
DOWN, COOL DOWN ITS HOT RHETORIC ON THE MATTER OF THE SO-CALLED
ARREARAGES BY THE UNITED STATES. AND THE TIME HAS COME TO SEE
THE FOREST, NOT JUST THE TREES TREES, ON THE MATTER OF WHO IS
FULFILLING THE RESPONSIBLE ROLE ROLE, THE RESPONSIBLE ROLE, OF
INTERNATIONAL LEADERSHIP AGAINST AGGRESSION. I COMMEND THE
{16:34:23} (MR. BYRD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SENATOR FOR HIS AMENDMENT. I THANK HIM FOR ALLOWING ME TO BE A
COSPONSOR OF IT. I HOPE THAT IT WILL GET A BIG VOTE IN THIS
CHAMBER, SO THAT A CLEAR MESSAGE IS SENT TO THE WHINERS -- TO
THE WHINERS -- BOTH IN NEW YORK AND DOWN PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE ON
THIS WHOLE ISSUE. MR. PRESIDENT, I YIELD THE FLOOR.
{16:34:59 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE CHAIR RECOGNIZES THE DISTINGUISHED
SENATOR FROM THE GREAT STATE OF MINNESOTA.
{16:35:04 NSP} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. GRAMS: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. PRESIDENT. MR. PRESIDENT, I
JUST WANT TO ALSO RISE TODAY TO SUPPORT THIS AMENDMENT. YOU
KNOW, THE UNITED STATES HAS BEEN CALLED "THE DEAD DEADBEAT."
IT'S BEEN CALLED "THE BULLY" AT THE UNITED NATIONS. THE U.S.
HAS BEEN ACCUSED OF BEING-I HAVE HANDED AND NOT DOING ITS FAIR
SHARE FOR THE INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY. THE U.S. HAS BEEN
BERATED AND BELILD AT EVERY TURN BY MANY OF THE COUNTRIES THAT
HAVE BEEN BENEFITING MOST FROM THE U.S.' GENEROSITY BOTH IF
TERMS OF SECURITY GUARANTEES AND ALSO IN TERMS OF ECONOMIC
{16:35:35} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ASSISTANCE. MR. PRESIDENT, AMERICA-BASH SOMETHING A POPULAR
PASTTIME AT THE U.N. AND THIS ADMINISTRATION IS DOING NOTHING
TO STOP T IN FACT, THIS ADMINISTRATION HAS BEEN CONTRIBUTING TO
THE FEEDING FRENZY BY TRYING TO UNDERCUT THE TERMS OF THE U.N.
REFORM PLAN INSTEAD OF STANDING BY THE DEAL THAT IT HELPED
NEGOTIATE. IF THIS ADMINISTRATION IS ENCOURAGING ANTI-AMERICAN
SENTIMENT AT THE UNITED NATIONS IN ORDER TO GAIN LEVERAGE WITH
CONGRESS TO WATER DOWN THE REFORMS, WELL, IT IS UNCONSCIONABLE
{16:36:08} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AND IT'S NOT GOING TO WORK. MR. PRESIDENT, THIS ADMINISTRA
ADMINISTRATION HAS BEEN SO WEAK IN DEFENDING THE HONOR AND
REPUTATION OF THE U.S. AT THE UNITED NATIONS AND SO NEGLECT IN
HIGHLIGHTING THE GREAT CONTRIBUTIONS -- AND SO NEGLIGENT IN
HIGHLIGHTING THE GREAT CONTRIBUTIONS THAT AMERICA IS MAKING TO
PROMOTE INTERNATIONAL SECURITY THAT WE FEEL COMPELLED TO DIRECT
THE ADMINISTRATION TO DO SO WITH THIS AMENDMENT. NOW, WHILE THE
U.S. IS BEING CALLED "A DEADBEAT" REGARDING ITS INTERNATIONAL
OBLIGATIONS, WELL, THE FACTS SAY SOMETHING QUITE DIFFERENT. THE
U.S. MAY OWE ARREARS TO THE U.N., BUT THAT IS ONLY BECAUSE THE
{16:36:38} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
U.S. RECEIVED NO CREDIT AT THE UNITED NATIONS FOR THE $2.97
BILLION THAT U.S. TAXPAYERS SPENT IN FISCAL YEAR 1997
IMPLEMENTING U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTIONS. AGAIN, NEARLY
$3 BILLION OF U.S. TAXPAYER MONEY TO HELP IMPLEMENT U.N.
SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTIONS LAST YEAR ALEON. WE RECEIVED NO
CREDIT FOR THE MORE THAN $6.4 BILLION THAT THE U.S. TAXPAYERS
HAVE SPENT TO DATE IN AND AROUND BOSNIA, AND WE WILL RECEIVE NO
CREDIT FOR THE EMERGENCY FUNDING OF AN ADDITIONAL $487 MILLION
{16:37:15} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FOR THE BOSNIAN MISSION AND THE $1.4 BILLION FOR U.S.
DEPLOYMENTS IN THE PERSIAN GULF THAT THE PRESIDENT IS ASKING
FOR IN THIS BILL. AS WE ALL KNOW, OUR TROOPS ARE IN THE GULF TO
SUPPORT A SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 687 ON IRAQ. THAT DOESN'T
MEAN WE WILL GET CREDIT FOR OUR CONTRIBUTION AT THE UNITED
NATIONS. AND WHILE WE DO NOT NEED TO -- WHILE WE DO NEED TO
SETTLE OUR DISPUTES ARREARS AT THE U.N., MR. PRESIDENT, WE
SHOULD NOT BE MYOPIC. THE U.S. TAXPAYER IS DOING FAR MORE THAN
{16:37:49} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
PULLING ITS WEIGHT IN THE INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY. THIS
AMENDMENT IS NECESSARY TO ENSU THAT ALL U.N. MEMBER STATES ARE
AWARE OF THE GREAT SACRIFICES THAT THE AMERICAN TAXPAYERS ARE
MAKING TO SUPPORT U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTIONS SINCE U.N.
BOOKKEEPING OBSCURES THE FACTS. FIRST, THIS AMENDMENT STATES
THAT U.S. TAXPAYERS SHOULD BE COMMENDED FOR THEIR GENERAL ROSS
SUPPORT IN MAINTAINING INTERNATIONAL PEACE AND SECURITY. THE
U.N. SHOULD PUBLICLY ACKNOWLEDGE THE SUPPORT AND IMMEDIATELY
REDUCE THE U.S. PEACEKEEPING ASSESSMENT TO 25% -- THAT IN
ACCORDANCE WITH U.S. LAW. SECOND, IT CALLS ON THE PRESIDENT TO
{16:38:21} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DIRECT THE U.S. AMBASSADOR TO THE U.N. TO INTRODUCE A SECURITY
COUNCIL RESOLUTION REQUIRING THE SECURITY COUNCIL TO REPORT TO
ALL MEMBER STATES ON THE AMOUNT THAT THE UNITED STATES HAS
SPENT SUPPORTING U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTIONS JUST SINCE
JANUARY 1 OF 1990, AS DETERMINED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE.
THIRD, IT REQUESTS THE SECRETARY OF STATE TO "NOTIFY" ALL
MEMBERS OF THE SECURITY COUNCIL ON THE AMOUNTS BOTH CREDITS AND
UNCREDITED THAT D.O.D. HAS SPENT SUPPORTING U.N. SECURITY
COUNCIL RESOLUTIONS -- AGAIN, JUST SINCE JANUARY 1 OF 1990.
{16:38:55} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AND, FOURTH, MR. PRESIDENT, IT REQUIRES THE PRESIDENT TO REPORT
BACK TO THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEES -- THE APPROPRIATE
COMMITTEES IN THE HOUSE AND SENATE WITHIN 45 DAYS ON THE
EFFORTS TO CARRY OUT THESE STEPS IN THIS AMENDMENT. NOW, I
DON'T KNOW HOW FAR THIS AMENDMENT WILL GO FORWARD GETTING THE
U.S. TAXPAYERS THE RECOGNITION THAT THEY DESERVE FOR U.S.
SUPPORT AT THE U.N., BUT I DO HOPE THAT IT WILL PUT THE U.S.
ARREARS IN PERSPECTIVE. BOTH THE ADMINISTRATION AND THE
CONGRESS AGREE THAT THE U.S. OWES ONLY $54 MILLION TO THE U.N.
{16:39:30} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
REGULAR BUDGET AND $658 MILLION FOR PEACEKEEPING EXPENSES. NOW,
THAT IS $712 MILLION. AND YOU COMPARE THAT TO THE NEARLY $3
BILLION THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE SPENT IN FISCAL YEAR 1997
ALONE. WE SPENT MORE THAN FOUR TIMES THAT AMOUNT LAST YEAR
ALONE IMPLEMENTING U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTIONS. MR.
PRESIDENT, THROUGHOUT THE HISTORY OF THE U.N., THE UNITED
STATES HAS ALWAYS BEEN ITS MOST GENEROUS DONOR. AMERICAN
TAXPAYERS CURRENTLY ARE BILLED AT 25% FOR THE ENTIRE U.N.
{16:40:04} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OPERATING BUDGET AND 30.4% OF THE PEACEKEEPING BUDGET, ALTHOUGH
THE U.S. NOW PAYS 25%, AS I MENTIONED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
LAW PASSED BY, AGAIN, A DEMOCRAT-CONTROLLED CONGRESS AND SIGNED
INTO LAW BY PRESIDENT CLINTON. CURRENTLY, THOSE BILLS TOTAL
MORE THAN $600 MILLION ANNUALLY. IN CONTRAST, SAUDI ARABIA,
KUWAIT, AND CHINA, WHICH HAS A VETO IN THE SECURITY COUNCIL,
ONLY PAY ABOUT 1% OF THE ENTIRE U.N. REGULAR BUDGET. THE FLOOR
{16:40:36} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OF ASSESSMENT LEVELS WAS JUST LOWERED FROM .01% OF THE U.N.
OPERATING BUDGET FROM ABOUT $106,000 A YEAR TO .001% OR UNDER
$11,000 SO THAT EACH DEPRIKS THOSE NATIONS WILL NOT BE ENOUGH
TO EVEN COVER ONE-TENTH OF THE SALARY OF ONE OF THEIR
HIGHLY-PRICED BUREAUCRATS. IT WILL ONLY PAY ABOUT ONE-TENTH OF
THE SALARY OF ONE OF THEIR BUREAUCRATS AT THE U.N. THAT'S ALL
THEY PAY. AND DESPITE THIS FACT, EACH MEMBER AT THE U.N. HAS
{16:41:09} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ONE VOTE ON BUDGET ISSUES. IN ADDITION TO THE ASSESSED PAYMENTS
I JUST MENTIONED, THE U.S. VOLUNTARILY AND GENEROUSLY
CONTRIBUTES HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO PROGRAMS LIKE
UNILATERAL SERVINGS UNHRC AND THE VOLUNTARY FUNDS FOR VICTIMS
OF TORTURE. SO, MR. PRESIDENT, THE UNITED STATES PAYS MORE THAN
ITS FAIR SHARE FOR WORLD PEACE, STABILITY, AND HUMANITARIAN
EFFORTS. AND THAT BEING SAID, WE DO NEED TO SETTLE OUR DISPUTES
ARREARS TO THE UNITED NATIONS AND WE DID ENGAGE IN GOOD-FAITH
NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE ADMINISTRATION, AND WE MADE A DEAL ON THE
U.N. REFORM PACKAGE. THE SENATE, WITH THE FULL SUPPORT OF THE
{16:41:42} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ADMINISTRATION, PASSED THIS BIPARTISAN LEGISLATION TWICE BY A
90-5 ROLL CALL VOTE AND AGAIN BY UNANIMOUS CONSENT. THE ONLY
THING THAT PREVENTED THIS AGREEMENT FROM BECOMING LAW WAS A
DISPUTE OVER AN UNRELATED ISSUE. THIS ADMINISTRATION THEN
DECIDED TO FOREGO NEARLY $1 BILLION FOR THE UNITED NATIONS AND
$3.5 BILLION FOR THE I.M.F. SO IT COULD PRESERVE THE ABILITY
FOR U.S. GRANT RECIPIENTS TO LOBBY FOREIGN GOVERNMENTS TO
LIBELIZE THEIR ABORTION LAWS. WELL, MR. PRESIDENT, SECRETARY
{16:42:17} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ALBRIGHT ALSO RECENTLY SAID THAT FAILURE TO PAY THE U.N.
ARREARS WOULD RESULT IN A "SHUTDOWN OF OUR NATIONAL SECURITY
POLICY." WELL, I MUST SAY THAT I WAS SOMEWHAT ATAKEN BACK BY
THAT STATEMENT, AS I WAS NOT AWARE THAT THIS ADMINISTRATION HAD
OFFICIALLY SUBCONTRACTED OUR NATIONAL SECURITY POLICY TO THE
U.N. INDEED, I WILL FIGHT TO MAKE SURE THAT IT WILL NEVER
HAPPEN, BUT IF THE U.S. TRULY IS SUFFERING A LOSS OF PRESTIGE
AND EFFECTIVESS IN THE GLOBAL ARENA BECAUSE OF OUR U.N.
ARREARS, AS THE ADMINISTRATION CONTENDS, THEN IT IS
{16:42:50} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
IRRESPONSIBLE FOR THIS ADMINISTRATION TO JEOPARDIZE OUR
SECURITY INTERESTS AND INTERESTS FOR DOMESTIC POLITICAL
CONSIDERATIONS. SO, MR. PRESIDENT, I HOPE THAT IN THE NEAR
FUTURE, CONGRESS WILL PASS THE U.N. REFORM PACKAGES AND THE
PRESIDENT WILL SIGNING IT INTO LAW SO THAT WE CAN PUT THIS
SMALL MATTER OF THE DISPUTED ARREARS BEHIND US. REGARDLESS OF
FATE OF THAT LEGISLATION, I ALSO BELIEVE THAT IT IS IMPORTANT
THAT WE PASS THIS AMENDMENT SO THAT THE REST OF THE WORLD WILL
BE AWARE OF WHAT WE ALL KNOW -- AND THAT IS THE HUGE SACRIFICE
THAT THE UNITED STATES TAXPAYERS MAKE TO SUPPORT U.N. SECURITY
{16:43:22} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
COUNCIL ACTIVITIES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. PRESIDENT. I YIELD
THE FLOOR.
{16:43:26 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE CHAIR RECOGNIZES THE DISTINGUISHED
SENIOR SENATOR FROM NORTH CAROLINA.
{16:43:34 NSP} (MR. HELMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HELMS: I THANK THE CHAIR. MR. PRESIDENT, I THANK THE
SENATOR FOR HIS REMARKS, AS I DO SENATOR GREGG AND PARTICULARLY
SENATOR BYRD, WHO IS ALWAYS ELOQUENT. NOW, MR. PRESIDENT, I
WANT TO BE SURE THAT ALL OF THE COSPONSORS ARE IDENTIFIED, AND
I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT THAT THE DISTINGUISHED MAJORITY LEADER
BE LISTED AS A COSPONSOR, SENATOR GREGG, SENATOR GRAMM, SENATOR
HOLLINGS, SENATOR BYRD, SENATOR FAIRCLOTH, AND SENATOR
ASHCROFT.
{16:44:03 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION, SO ORDERED.
{16:44:06 NSP} (MR. HELMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HELMS: AND, MR. PRESIDENT, I ASK FOR THE YEAS AND NAYS.
{16:44:10 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE CLERK WILL CALL THE ROLL -- IS THERE A SUFFICIENT SECOND?
{16:44:20 NSP} (A SENATOR) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THERE IS A SUFFICIENT SECOND. A SENATOR: MR. PRESIDENT?
{16:44:24 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE YEAS AND NAYS HAVE BEEN ORDERED. THE
{16:44:25 NSP} (A SENATOR) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CLERK WILL CALL THE ROLL -- A SENATOR: MR. PRESIDENT?
{16:44:27 NSP} (MR. BIDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. BIDEN: MR. PRESIDENT?
PARLIMENTARY INQUIRY.
{16:44:32 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR DELAWARE.
{16:44:35 NSP} (MR. BIDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. BIDEN: IS THERE -- WAS UNANIMOUS CONSENT -- IS THERE TIME
TO VOTE?
IF NOT, I'D LIKE TO SPEAK THREE MINUTES ON THIS AMENDMENT.
{16:44:44 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THERE'S NO AGREEMENT ON THIS AMENDMENT.
{16:44:48 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THERE IS A AGREEMENT. BUDE BIDE HE'D
LIKE TO SPEAK.
{16:44:50 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE CHAIR RECOGNIZES THE DISTINGUISHED
SENATOR FROM DELAWARE.
{16:44:56 NSP} (MR. BIDEN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. BIDEN: LET ME THANK THE CHAIR FOR ACCOMMODATING ONE OF MY
CONCERNS THAT I HAD, THAT HE CHANGE. I AGREE FULLY AS THE
SENATOR KNOWS FROM OUR MANY
{END: 1998/03/25 TIME: 16-45 , Wed. 105TH SENATE, SECOND SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}