National Park Service Title Black Band and Arrowhead
  Shaped by Site: Three Communities' Dialogues on the Legacies of Lynching  
MenuBar Menu:  GreatPlaces, Great Debate Overview pdf Menu:  Opening Keynote Menu:  Shaped by Site Menu:  Getting Visitors to do More than Listen Menu:  Whose History is It? Menu:  Passing the Passion Menu:  Evoking Legacies Menu Class Action Menu:  Civic Engagement on a Shoestring Menu:  Fundraisers Roundtable Menu:  Dialogue Skills Training Mobile Workshops Menu:  Working Groups Menu:  Remarks-Marie Rust Menu:  Closing Keynote Menu:  Closing Reception Menu:  Photo Album Menu:  Share Your Thoughts Menu:  Share Your Thoughts Photo of Liz Sevcenko
Liz Ševcenko is Vice President for Interpretation for the Lower East Side Tenement Museum and Coordinator for the International Coalition of Historic Site Museums of Conscience. Completing her Ph.D. in American history at New York University, she has most recently published "The Making of Loisaida" in Mambo Montage: The Latinization of New York City (Columbia University Press, July 2001). Her project "Mapping Memories," in which visitors were invited to contribute their memories to a changing map of New York City and discuss conflicting claims to urban space, was produced at the Museum of the City of New York, the Tenement Museum, the Eldridge Street Project, the Smithsonian Folklife Festival, as well as at community centers and street fairs. She has partnered with public artist Shimon Attie on projects in New York and Boston exploring the hidden histories of urban landscapes.

At the Tenement Museum, Ms. Ševcenko has directed several initiatives to bring history to bear on discussions on pressing social issues and projects to address them. As Coordinator of the International Coalition of Historic Site Museums of Conscience, Ms. Sevcenko works with the directors of historic sites around the world, building their capacity to use their histories to address contemporary issues. The Coalition is currently working with the National Park Service, the National Trust for Historic Preservation, and the National Trust of Britain on how to develop sites of conscience initiatives within their networks. The Coalition has also partnered with the International Center for Transitional Justice to consult with NGOs and municipal governments around the world on how to establish places of memory as sites of reconciliation and rebuilding in societies recovering from trauma. Ševcenko has consulted with various historic sites and networks of cultural institutions, including the Minnesota Historical Society, the Paso Al Norte Immigration History Center in El Paso, TX and the Sanford Ziff Museum in Miami, FL. She had the pleasure of coordinating the "Great Places, Great Debates" conference with the National Park Service and the Regional Plan Association.

lsevcenko@tenement.org

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lynching History Draws Record Crowds
Liz Ševcenko, Vice-President for Interpretation at the Lower East Side Tenement Museum and Coordinator for the International Coalition of Historic Site Museums of Conscience, moderated Shaped by Site: Three Communities' Dialogues on the Legacies of Lynching, one of two concurrent sessions that kicked off the conference panel presentations.

Liz described an American museum culture reluctant to tackle subject matter as emotionally charged and disturbing as our nation's history of public lynchings. Museums were offered an opportunity to use the postcards and photos of public lynchings that James Allen has collected for over a quarter of a century. The collection, Without Sanctuary: Lynching Photography in America, would form the nucleus of any exhibits. However, the images of the lynchings that so besmirched America throughout the early 20th century took museums well out of their comfort zone.

This session's panel was made up of representatives from three sites that met the challenge of exhibiting this collection. They were the New York Historical Society in New York City, the Andy Warhol Museum in Pittsburgh, and the Martin Luther King Jr. National Historic Site in Atlanta. While the sites themselves are very different, the three found themselves with something in common; they were each overwhelmed by visitors who wanted to view the exhibit. Liz told the conference audience that while this is a difficult history to grapple with, people are demanding that we do so. The New York Historical Society had 50,000 visitors in the first five months; the Andy Warhol Museum had its best attendance since 1994; and the Martin Luther King Jr. National Historic Site had 177,000 visitors view the exhibit. Each site recognized the importance of handling the exhibit with sensitivity so the same "spectacle" mentality that produced the photographs would not be replicated in their display.

Museums Tailored Exhibit to Own Community
Selling the Atlanta museum community on a lynching exhibit was particularly tough. The city prided itself on being a "City Too Busy to Hate." Reminding folks of a past so recent, brutal, and hate-filled was not something relished by many community leaders. The New York Historical Society told the story against the contemporary backdrop of tortured Haitians in New York City and Pittsburgh's Andy Warhol Museum mounted the exhibit in a community reflecting on its own recent local racial incidents. While each site started with James Allen's collection of photos and postcards, each also actively worked to engage its community in telling the lynching stories through its own lens.

Story is Chilling
Liz showed participants a bit of a film produced by the curator of the Atlanta exhibit of "Without Sanctuary." This film states that while 4,743 people were reported to have been killed by lynch mobs, historians estimate that an equal number were lynched and not reported. Lynchings were "advertised" in newspapers - people came from out of town to watch. Children were let out of school. Photographs were taken of lynchings and some of these became postcards. These photographs often showed the bodies of the lynched men and women with spectators smiling for the camera or even enjoying a picnic lunch. It was not until the 1930s that lynching was no longer socially acceptable. Although they continued for some time, lynchings were finally forced underground by mid-century.

One Result Younger people in particular indicated through their feedback that the exhibit made them recognize that African-Americans really had faced incredible adversity. They had never really understood that these citizens were treated so very differently than whites not so long ago.

Kathleen Hulser of the New York Historical Society describes herself as 'inherently born to like civic engagement". At the New York Historical Society, she says they "didn't have time to think about what what we couldn't do". More

Jessica Gogan of the Andy Warhol Museum says their museum might at first seem an unlikely venue. Why house this in a museum devoted to the "King of Pop"? It was though, Andy Warhol's practice to engage with contemporary themes and issues. More

Saudia Muwwakkil from Martin Luther King, Jr. National Historic Site describes the park as a logical place to tell this story. More than 80% of recorded lynchings occurred in the South; the backdrop of lynchings is a part of what shaped Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and the Civil Rights movement . More

The title bar image is a photo of Jessica Gogan of the Andy Warhol Museum and Kathleen Hulser of the New York Historical Society taken at the Great Places, Great Debates Conference as they watched the powerful audiovisual presentation used at the Martin Luther King Jr. National Historic Site and other venues (National Park Service Image). Images of this sort prompted Abel Meeropol (Aka Lewis Allan) to compose Billie Holiday's eerie signature song "Strange Fruit"

Strange Fruit
Southern trees bear strange fruit
Blood on the leaves
Blood at the root
Black bodies swinging in the southern breeze
Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees
Pastoral scene of the gallant south
The bulging eyes and the twisted mouth
The scent of magnolia sweet and fresh
Then the sudden smell of burning flesh
Here is a fruit for the crows to pluck
for the rain to gather
for the wind to suck
for the sun to rot
for the tree to drop
Here is a strange and bitter crop

Abel Meeropol 1938

Additional Resources

Liz Sevcenko's session introduction is included below. In addition, her paper "Activating the Past for Civic Action: The International Coalition of Historic Site Museums of Conscience" was included in the Conference Notebook and is available here as well. It is a brief overview of the provocative work members of the Coalition are doing individually and collectively.

Liz Sevcenko's Shaped by Site Introduction

Activating the Past for Civic Action



You may also want to visit the International Coalition of Historic Sites of Conscience website:

http://www.sitesofconscience.org/

and Emory University's site on the Atlanta Without Sanctuary exhibit

http://www.emory.edu/WithoutSanctuaryExhibit/

The materials on the Lower East Side Tenement Museum website are also well worth a look.

http://www.tenement.org/

Last Updated: 01/05/2005
 
Menu Button to National Park Service Home PageMenu Button to DOI Home PageMenu Button to FOIA Menu Buttom to Privacy and Disclaimer Menu Button to Feedback