{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
{09:30:01} (START-TEST) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
{09:30:38 NSP} (END-TEST) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
END-TEST: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
{09:30:41 NSP} (PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE: THE SENATE WILLSCOM TO ORDER. THE
CHAPLAIN WILL NOW DELIVER THE OPENING PRAYER.
{09:30:51 NSP} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE CHAPLAIN: "THE HOUR IS COMING, AND NOW IS, WHEN TRUE
WORSHIPERS WILL WORSHIP THE FATHER IN SPIRIT AND TRUTH; FOR THE
FATHER IS SEEKING SUCH TO WORSHIP HIM." GRACIOUS LORD OF OUR
LIVES, WE RESPOND TO THIS INVITATION TO WORSHIP YOU. IN THE
QUIET OF THIS MOMENT, WE WORSHIP YOU IN THE SPLENDOR OF YOUR
{09:31:21} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MAJESTY. YOU ARE INFINITE, ETERNAL, AND UNCHANGEABLE; IN YOUR
BEING, YOU ARE WISDOM, HOLINESS, GOODNESS, AND TRUTH. WE
WORSHIP YOU IN RESPONSE TO YOUR GRACE, YOUR UNQUALIFIED LOVE
FOR EACH OF US. THANK YOU FOR YOUR FAITHFULNESS. YOU NEVER GIVE
UP ON US. EVEN THOUGH WE FALTER AND FAIL, YOU NEITHER LEAVE NOR
{09:31:57} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FORSAKE US. YOUR PROVIDENTIAL CARE FOR OUR NATION HAS BEEN
CONSISTENT ALL THROUGH OUR HISTORY. AS A PEOPLE, WE RETURN TO
YOU. NOW, LORD, HOW SHALL WE WORSHIP YOU IN THE MIDST OF THE
WORK OF THIS DAY?
WE WANT TO LIVE MAGNIFICENTLY BY MAGNIFYING YOU IN THE MUNDANE
AS WELL AS THE MOMENTOUS. WE WANT OUR WORK ITSELF TO BE OUR
{09:32:33} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
RESPONSE OF WORSHIP. OUR DESIRE IS TO GLORIFY YOU IN ALL WE
THINK, DECIDE, AND DO. EVERYTHING WITHIN US STANDS ON TIPTOE TO
WORSHIP YOU, FOR YOU ARE OUR GOD IN WHOM WE PLACE OUR TRUST.
{09:33:07} (THE CHAPLAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AMEN.
{09:33:10 NSP} (PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE: THE ABLE MAJORITY LEADER, SENATOR
LOTT OF MISSISSIPPI, IS RECOGNIZED.
{09:33:15 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: THANK YOU, MR. PRESIDENT. TODAY THE SENATE WILL
RESUME CONSIDERATION OF THE STATE DEPARTMENT AUTHORIZATION
BILL, UNDER THE PREVIOUS ORDER. A CLOTURE VOTE ON THE MOTION TO
PROCEED TO S. 975, THE STEEL IMPORT LIMITATION BILL, WILL
TAKE PLACE AT 12:15 WITH 40 MINUTES OF DEBATE ON THE MOTION
PRIOR TO THE VOTE. FOLLOWING THAT VOTE, THE SENATE WILL STAND
IN RECESS
UNTIL 2:15 P.M. SO THAT THE WEEKLY PARTY CAUCUSES CAN MEET. IT
IS THE INTENTION. LEADER TO COMPLETE ACTION ON THE STATE
DEPARTMENT REAUTHORIZATION BILL DURING TODAY'S SESSION OF THE
{09:33:45} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SENATE AND TO RESUME CONSIDERATION OF THE AGRICULTURE
APPROPRIATIONS BILL. I THOUGHT WE HAD REACHED AN AGREEMENT AS
TO EXACTLY HOW TO COMPLETE THE STATE DEPARTMENT AUTHORIZATION
BILL LATE YESTERDAY AFTERNOON, BUT BECAUSE OF THE ABSENCE OF
SOME SENATORS THAT NEEDED TO BE CONSULTED WITH, WE WERE NOT
ABLE TO LOCK IN THE PROCEDURE AND THE TIME FOR COMPLETING THAT
ACTION. I WOULD HOPE WE COULD COMPLETE IT, THOUGH, THIS MORNING
AND HAVE THE VOTE OR VOTES ON OR IN RELATIONS TO THE STATE
DEPARTMENT AUTHORIZATION BILL AFTER THE PARTY CAUCUSES AT
{09:34:17} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
2:15. WHEN WE GO BACK TO THE AGRICULTURE APPROPRIATIONS BILL,
WE WOULD EXPECT A NUMBER OF VOTES THIS AFTERNOON.
UNFORTUNATELY, THE DEMOCRATIC LEADERSHIP HAS CHOSEN TO CONFUSE
THE ISSUE AND DELAY THE ACTION ON THE AGRICULTURE
APPROPRIATIONS BILL BY OFFERING THE PATIENTS S. BILL OF -- THE
PATIENTS' BILL OF RIGHTS TO THIS IMPORTANT BILL. WE COULD WORK
OUT AN AGREEMENT OTHERWISE IF THEY WOULD BE REASONABLE AS TO
HOW WE MIGHT CONSIDER THAT ISSUE. BUT NOW IT IS PENDING TO THE
AGRICULTURE APPROPRIATIONS BILL AND I WOULD EXPECT THERE WOULD
{09:34:50} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BE A COUPLE OF VOTES ON OR IN RELATION TO THAT ISSUE AS WELL. I
UNDERSTAND THERE IS A BILL AT THE DESK DUE FOR ITS SECOND
READING.
{09:34:59 NSP} (PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE: THE CLERK WILL READ THE BILL.
{09:35:01 NSP} (THE CLERK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE CLERK: A BILL ENTITLED THE PATIENTS' BILL OF RIGHTS.
{09:35:03 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: I OBJECT TO FURTHER PROCEEDINGS ON THIS BILL AT THIS
TIME.
{09:35:06 NSP} (PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE: THE BILL GOES TO THE CALENDAR.
{09:35:21 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: THANK YOU, MR. PRESIDENT. I YIELD THE FLOOR.
{09:35:25 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: UNDER THE PREVIOUS ORDER, SENATE WILL
NOW RESUME CONSIDERATION OF SENATE BILL 886, WHICH THE CLERK
WILL REPORT.
{09:35:34 NSP} (THE CLERK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE CLERK: A BILL TO AUTHORIZE APPROPRIATIONS FOR THE
DEPARTMENT OF STATE FOR FISCAL YEARS 2000 AND 2001 AND SO FORTH
{09:35:40 NSP} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. MR. MACK: MR. PRESIDENT?
{09:35:45 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM FLORIDA.
{09:35:49 NSP} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MACK: I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO BE ABLE TO ADDRESS THE
SENATE FOR UP TO 15 MINUTES IN MORNING BUSINESS.
{09:35:54 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{09:35:56 NSP} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MACK: THANK YOU, MR. PRESIDENT. PROPONENTS OF THE QUOTA
LEGISLATION TO BE CONSIDERED LATER TODAY HAVE SPOKEN WITH VIGOR
AND PASSION REGARDING THE INJURY HAS BEEN SUFFERED BY DOMESTIC
STEEL COMPANIES AND THE THREAT IMPORTS POSE TO THE WORKERS AT
THOSE COMPANIES. HOWEVER, I FEEL COMPELLED TO RISE TODAY TO
RESPOND TO MANY OF THE ASSERTIONS RAISED REGARDING THE STEEL
INDUSTRY SPECIFICALLY AND MORE GENERALLY I THINK IT IS
IMPORTANT TO SPEAK TO SEVERAL OTHER FACTORS RELATED TO THE
BILL. FIRST, THERE ARE ECONOMIC BENEFITS ALL AMERICANS ENJOY AS
{09:36:26} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
A RESULT OF LOWERING TRADE BARRIERS. SECOND, THE HARMFUL
MESSAGE A QUOTA BILL WOULD SEND TO OUR TRADING PATTERNS AND,
THIRD, THE INAPPROPRIATENESS OF CONGRESS SINGLING OUT A
SPECIFIC INDUSTRY FOR SPECIAL TREATMENT. THE FIRST POINT I
WOULD LIKE TO MAKE IS THAT THE IMPORT SURGE IS OVER. ACCORDING
TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE, IMPORTS HAVE RETURNED TO THEIR
TRADITIONAL LEVELS. IN FACT, OVERALL STEEL IMPORTS IN THE FIRST
{09:36:58} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FOUR MONTHS OF 1999 ARE BELOW THE PREIMPORT SURGE LEVELS.
MOREOVER, EVEN WITH THE IMPORT SURGE OF 1998, U.S. STEEL
PRODUCERS REPORTED PROFITS OF OVER $1 BILLION. FURTHERMORE, IN
REVIEWING DATA PROVIDED BY THE STEEL MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION,
I WAS SURPRISED TO FIND THAT U.S. STEEL PRODUCTION HAS
INCREASED OVER THE LAST TEN YEARS. THE 1998 STEEL OUTPUT OF
107.6 MILLION TONS WAS 10% GREATER THAN 1990. ADDITIONALLY, I
{09:37:32} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WAS INTERESTED TO DISCOVER THAT SINCE 1987, IMPORTS AS A
PERCENTAGE OF DOMESTIC CONSUMPTION, HAVE REMAINED CONSTANT AT
AROUND 20%. AGAIN, ACCORDING TO THIS DATA, NO GROUND HAS BEEN
LOST DESPITE PROTESATIONS TO THE CONTRARY. SOME HAVE ARGUED
THAT THE FINANCIAL ILL HEALTH OF SEVERAL SPECIFIC COMPANIES
SUCH AS BETHLEHEM STEEL COMPANY, WORTON STEEL COMPANY, LACKLEAD
STEEL CORPORATION, ACME METALS INCORPORATED AND GENEVA STEEL
{09:38:04} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
COMPANY ARE THE DIRECT RESULT OF LAST YEAR'S IMPORT SURGE.
HOWEVER, THE FACT IS THAT MANY OF THE INTERGRAILTED STEEL MILLS
HAVE A HISTORY OF DECLINING FINANCIAL HEALTH EVIDENT WELL IN
ADVANCE OF THE ASIAN CRISIS IN THE 1998 IMPORT SURGE. THIS IS
REFLECTED IN THEIR STOCK PERFORMANCE WHICH, WITHOUT EXCEPTION,
SHOWS A PRONOUNCED DECLINE IN THE VALUE OF THEIR STOCK OVER THE
LAST FIVE YEARS AND HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE SURGE IN
IMPORTS. NOTING THE DECLINING EMPLOYMENT FIGURES IN THE STEEL
{09:38:37} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
INDUSTRY, PROPONENTS OF THE QUOTA BILL SUGGEST THE U.S. IS
LOSING MARKET SHARE BUT THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS, IMPORTS HAVE
NOT THRODE A DECREASE IN MARKET SHARE. U.S. STEEL PRODUCTION IN
TRADITIONAL INTEGRATED MILLS HAS REMAINED FAIRLY FLAT. IMPORT
COMPETITION HAS MERELY FORCED U.S. STEEL TO BECOME MORE
EFFICIENT. THE GROWTH IN DOMESTIC PRODUCTION THAT HAS ALLOWED
U.S. STEEL TO RETAIN ITS DOMESTIC SHARE HAS BEEN ALMOST
EXCLUSIVELY A RESULT OF OUR NATION'S MINI MILLS THAT ACCOUNT
{09:39:10} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FOR ALMOST 60% OF PRODUCTION. THEY USE AN INNOVATIVE PRODUCTION
TECHNIQUE TO RECYCLE SCRAP STEEL. THESE ENVIRONMENTALLY
FRIENDLY PRODUCERS ARE TRANSFORMING THE STEEL INDUSTRY AND I
THINK HERE IT IS WORTH NOTING THAT THE ASSOCIATION OF MINE KNEE
MILLS IS NEUTRAL -- MINI MILLS IS NEUTRAL. SOME ARGUE OUR
FOREIGN COMPETITORS ARE PLAYING BY DIFFERENT RULES -- BY A
DIFFERENT SET OF RULES. THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT OUR CURRENT
ANTI-DUMPING LAWS ARE INTENDED TO ADDRESS. THE STEEL INDUSTRY
{09:39:43} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HAS SHOWN ITSELF TO BE INTIMATELY FAMILIAR WITH AND MORE THAN
WILLING TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THESE LAWS. EVEN THOUGH STEEL
ACCOUNTS FOR ONLY 5% OF OUR IMPORTS, THE INDUSTRY HAS GENERATED
46% OF THE UNFAIR TRADE COMPLAINTS BROUGHT BEFORE THE U.S.
INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION DURING THE LAST TWO DECADES. OUR
CURRENT LAWS PROVIDE APPROPRIATE PROTECTION FOR ALL INDUSTRIES.
THEY SHOULD NOT BE CIRCUMVENTED IN ORDER TO PROVIDE
EXTRAORDINARY PROTECTION FOR A SINGLE INDUSTRY. MR. PRESIDENT,
TRADE PROMOTES PROSPERITY. AND ALL TOO OFTEN WE HEAR COMPLAINTS
{09:40:15} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OF LOST JOBS AND INVAISHABLY THE BLAME IS LAID TO TRADE. THIS
ALLEGATION HAS GONE UNANSWERED FOR FAR TOO LONG. TRADE HAS
GIVEN US FAR MORE JOBS THAN WOULD OTHERWISE BE VAIFMBIT THE
FACT IS THAT THE SIZE OF OUR TRADE SECTOR HAS GROWN STEADILY
DURING THE LAST 50 YEARS. AS A SHARE OF THE ECONOMY, TRADE
DOUBLED BETWEEN 1950 AND 1980 AND HAS DOUBLED AGAIN BETWEEN
1980 AND 1998. NOT SURPRIORSINGLY, EMPLOYMENT HAS EXPANDED FROM
{09:40:53} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
99 MILLION IN 1990 TO -- IN 1980 TO 133 MILLION TODAY. FAR FROM
HARMING OUR ECONOMY, TRADE HAS BEEN A MAJOR CONTRIBUTING FACTOR
TO OUR GROWTH AND OUR PROSPERITY. REAL G.D.P. IS NOW 64%
GREATER THAN IT WAS IN 1980 AND WE HAVE EXPERIENCED ONLY NINE
MONTHS OF RECESSION DURING THE LAST 16 YEARS. MOREOVER, OUR
GROWTH RATE IS NOW THE HIGHEST AND OUR UNEMPLOYMENT RATE THE
LOWEST AMONG THE G-7 NATIONS. TRADE MAKES IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO
FOCUS OUR PRODUCTION ON THE THINGS WE DO BEST AND THEREBY
PRODUCE A LARGER OUTPUT AND ENJOY A HIGHER STANDARD OF LIVING.
{09:41:26} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FOR GOODS AND SERVICES THAT WE PRODUCE CHEAPLY, WE CAN EXPAND
OUR OUTPUT AND SELL ABROAD AT ATTRACTIVE PRICES. AND FOR THINGS
THAT WE DO POORLY, WE CAN ACQUIRE THEM ECONOMICALLY FROM
FOREIGN PRODUCERS. THUS, TRADE PROMOTES PROSPERITY. AND, MR.
PRESIDENT, THE STEEL QUOTA BILL ALSO SENDS THE WRONG MESSAGE.
WE HAVE FOUGHT FOR OPEN MARKETS BOTH THROUGH GATT AND NOW THE
W.T.O., AND WE HAVE BEEN ENGAGED IN THIS FIGHT AND THIS BATTLE
FOR ALMOST 50 YEARS. AND FOR SOMETIME WEEL WE HAVE TOLD THE
{09:42:00} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WORLD THAT ECONOMIC FREEDOM -- WE HAVE TOLD THE WORLD THAT
ECONOMIC FREEDOM AND ECONOMIC PROSPERITY ARE A KEY. LET ME MAKE
FOUR POINTS WITH RESPECT TO THE MESSAGE. A QUOTA BILL WOULD
SEND THE WRONG MESSAGE TO THE EUROPEAN UNION. IT WOULD SEND A
WRONG MESSAGE TO THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIES. IT WOULD SEND A WRONG
MESSAGE TO INVESTORS AND IT WOULD SEND A WRONG MESSAGE TO OUR
TRADING PATTERNS. LET ME TOUCH LIGHTLY ON EACH OF THOSE. WITH
{09:42:33} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
RESPECT TO THE EUROPEAN UNION, WE ARE CURRENTLY IN THE MIDST OF
A TRADE DISPUTE WITH THE E.U. REGARDING THEIR RESTRICTIONS ON
BOTH BANANAS AND BEEF. THE STEEL QUOTA BILL UNDERCUTS OUR
POSITION ON THESE ISSUES. HOW CAN WE COMPLAIN ABOUT
RESTRICTIONS OF OTHERS WHILE WE OURSELVES ARE ERECTING TRADE
BARRIERS?
AND WITH RESPECT TO THE LEADERS OF THE FORMER COMMUNIST
COUNTRIES, THIS BILL SAYS, WHEN WE THINK IT IS CONVENIENT, IT
IS ALL RIGHT TO SUBSTITUTE POLITICAL MANIPULATION FOR MARKETS.
I CAN ASSURE YOU, THE LEADERS OF THE FORMER COMMUNIST COUNTRIES
{09:43:06} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ARE WATCHING. IF A PROSPEROUS AMERICA WITH A LOW UNEMPLOYMENT
RATE IS WILLING TO BAILOUT TROUBLED -- BAIL OUT TROUBLED FIRMS,
HOW CAN WE EXPECT THEM TO REFRAIN?
AND WITH RESPECT TO INVESTERS, INVESTMENT FLOWED INTO THE
UNITED STATES AND THE U.S. ECONOMY REMAINS STRONG. IN NO SMALL
DEGREE THIS CONFIDENCE OF INVESTORS WAS DUE TO THE OPENNESS OF
OUR ECONOMY AND OUR RELIANCE ON MARKETS RATHER THAN POLITICS.
AND AGAIN WITH RESPECT TO OUR TRADING PATTERNS, OUR TRADING
{09:43:37} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
PATTERNS MOST OF WHICH HAVE BOTH LOWER AND SLOWER RATES OF
GROWTH AND HIGHER UNEMPLOYMENT ARE UNLIKELY TO STAND IDLY BY
WHILE WE IMPOSE TRADE BARRIERS. RETALIATION AND ESCALATION OF
TRADE BARRIERS ARE A LIKELY SIDE EFFECT. AND FINALLY, IT BEARS
MENTIONING THAT IT IS A SERIOUS MISTAKE FOR CONGRESS TO PLAY
FAVORITES. THIS IS PRECISELY WHAT IS INVOLVED HERE. THIS BILL
PRODUCES A TAXON STEEL USERS IN ORDER TO SUBSIDIZE STEEL
PRODUCERS. A SUBSTANTIAL SHARE OF THE U.S. STEEL INDUSTRY
{09:44:11} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
REFINES RAW STEEL INTO FINISHED AND SPECIALTY GOODS. THE U.S.
STEEL INDUSTRY IS THEREFORE THEREFORE A MAJOR PURCHASER OF --
THE U.S. STEEL INDUSTRY IS THEREFORE A MAJOR PROCHER OF --
PURCHASER OF GOODS. MOREOVER, THIS BILL WOULD TREAT THE STEEL
INDUSTRY DIFFERENT FROM OTHER INDUSTRIES. STEEL IS NOT THE ONLY
INDUSTRY THAT HAS BEEN ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY CURRENCY DEVALUE
-- DEVALUATIONS. THE SALES OF MANY FIRMS WERE AFFECTED AS A
{09:44:46} (MR. MACK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
RESULT OF THESE FACTORS. WHY SHOULD THIS INDUSTRY BE SINGLED
OUT FOR SPECIAL TREATMENT?
AND IN CONCLUSION, MR. PRESIDENT, I WANT TO STRESS THAT THE
LEGISLATION WE WILL BE CONSIDERING LATER TODAY PROPOSES THAT
THE CONGRESS INTERVENE IN THE MARKET, RISK A TRADE WAR AND
{END: 1999/06/22 TIME: 09-45 , Tue. 106TH SENATE, FIRST SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}