{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
BARN YOU KNOW WHAT WE DID IF WE CHASED THE HORSE, GOT THE HORSE
AND BROUGHT IT BACK TO THE BARN. THAT'S NOT ROCKET SCIENCE. I
DID HAVE TO TAKE A LOT OF SCHOOL COARSE TOSS TEACH ME THAT. YOU
GO BRING THE HORSEBACK. NOW WHAT THEY HAVE DECIDED IS NO, WE
WILL JUST DECIDE THE HORSES ARE OUT OF THE BARN HERE IN THE WAY
THINGS ARE SUPPOSED TO WORK IN A MANNER THAT PRESERVES SAFETY
AND SUNNESS OF OUR BANKS AND IN A MANNER THAT PRESERVES
SEPARATION OF CERTAIN KINDS OF ACTIVITIES, SOME THAT ARE
INHERENTLY RISKY AS OPPOSED TO THOSE THAT REQUIRE SAFETY AND
{14:15:36} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SOUNDNESS, THINGS HAVE HAPPENED SO THAT WE ARE PERSUADED LET'S
JUST GET RID OF ALL THE RULES AND REWRITE THEM IN A WAY THAT
JUST CIRCLES THE ACTIVITY THAT'S NOT BEEN ENGAGED IN OUR
COUNTRY TO STAY THOSE WHO HAVE DONE IT OKAY THAT'S WHERE YOU
ARE, IT IS A NEW DAY, WE WILL CALL IT MODERN DAYS AND WE WILL
SAY IT IS JUST FINE. WELL, IT IS NOT FINE WITH ME. YOU NOW, IT
IS INTERESTING THAT WE LIVE IN 1999 NOW IN THE MONTH OF MAY.
HAVING EXPERIENCED THIS REMARKABLE ECONOMY. I'M ONE WHO WITH
{14:16:08} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ALL OF MY COLLEAGUES WOULD SAY, WHAT A REMARKABLE OPPORTUNITY
TO LIVE IN AN ECONOMY THAT HAS VIRTUALLY NO INFLATION, HAS
VIRTUALLY FULL EMPLOYMENT. IT SEEMS TO HAVE ECONOMIC GROWTH
THAT CONTINUES UNABATED. AND WHOSE STOCK MARKET CONTINUE TO SET
NEW RECORDS. 23 DAYS ANOTHER 1,000 POINTS. YOU GET THE FEELING
GEE, THE STOCK MARKET IS LIKE ONE OF THOSE SLOT MAS SHEENS THAT
PAYS OFF EVERY TIME YOU PULL THE HANDLE. EVERY TIME YOU PUT A
{14:16:41} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
QUARTER IN YOU GET A QUARTERBACK BEYOND WHAT YOU PUT IN. THERE
ARE PEOPLE WHO HAVE BEGUN TO INVEST IN THIS ECONOMY OF OURS
THROUGH MUTUAL FUNDS AND INTO THE MARKETS AND SO ON AND SO
FORTH WHO APPARENTLY BELIEVE THERE IS ONLY ONE DIRECTION FOR
OUR ECONOMY AND ONLY ONE DIRECTION FOR OUR MARKETS AND THAT'S
UP. AND SINGLE DIGIT RETURNS ARE NOT ENOUGH U. SUFFICIENT.
RETURNS ARE NOW EXPECTED OF 15%, 20%, 25, 30% A YEAR. WELL, OF
{14:17:12} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
COURSE THAT WILL NOT CONTINUE. WE WANT A COUNTRY WITH THE TWIN
ECONOMIC GOALS OF STABLE PRICES AND FULL EMPLOYMENT AND
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY AND GROWTH. BUT WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH
PERIODS IN THIS COUNTRY WHERE WHEN YOU SIT DOWN AND ADD THINGS
UP, SOMEHOW THE ANSWER DOESN'T SEEM CORRECT. THIS ISN'T ALL
GOING TO CONTINUE. ONE DAY IN ONE WAY THERE WILL BE
ADJUSTMENTS. COMPANIES SELLING THREE AND 400 TIMES EARNINGS WE
THINK THAT'S GOING TO CONTINUE?
I DON'T THINK SO. NOW, WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN RECENT YEARS IN
{14:17:45} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THIS COUNTRY DESPITE ALL OF THE GOOD NEWS IS A SERIES OF
ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES BY FIRMS THAT 20 YEARS AND 40 YEARS AGO
WOULD NEVER HAVE THOUGHT IN ENGAGING IN THOSE ACTIVITIES, AND
THOSE ACTIVITIES WHICH REALLY REPRESENT A KIND OF A NEW FORM OF
GAMBLING BY FIRMS THAT SHOULD NOT BE INVOLVED IN GAMBLING,
REPRESENTS NOW AN ACCEPTABLE KIND OF BEHAVIOR. LET ME GIVE YOU
{14:18:21} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SOME DEMOCRATS OF SOME OF IT. I STARTED THIS MORNING BUT I AM
GOING TO READ A BIT MORE BECAUSE I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT FOR HE
SHALL TO UNDERSTAND AND HEAR THIS. I MENTIONED TOO BIG TO FAIL.
BIG BANKS THAT HAVE BECOME SO BIG OUR GOVERNMENT SAYS THEY
CAN'T BE ALLOWED TO FAIL. AND OF COURSE WE CONTINUE THEN EVERY
DAY TO SEE MORE MERGERS TO ALLOW MORE BANKS TO JOIN THE TOO BIG
TO FAIL LIST. BUT IT IS NOT JUST THE BANKS. I WANT TO READ THE
STORY OF LONG TERM CAPITAL MANAGEMENT BECAUSE ILLUSTRATIVE OF
{14:18:52} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
NOT ONLY WHAT'S HAPPENING AT THIS MOMENT IN THIS CHAPTER OF OUR
HISTORY, BUT ALSO WHAT HAPPENED IN 1994 WITH A MASSIVE LOSSES
ACROSS OUR COUNTRY IN DERIVATIVE ACCEPT S, THE RISK THAT BOND
GO AWAY. THEY ARE TIGHTENING THERE GRIP ON THE WORLD ECONOMY
AND NO ONE KNOWS HOW TO CONTROL THEM. UNREGULATED HEDGE FUNDS,
BANKS, HOLDING COMPANIES THAT NOW FUSE AND MERGE BANKS
UNDERWRITING SECURITIES, INSURANCE, IS ALL OF THAT A CAUSE FOR
CONCERN?
{14:19:26} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
LET ME READ A COUPLE THINGS AND SEE WHETHER PERHAPS THIS CAN BE
INTERPRETED IN A MANNER DIFFERENTLY THAN THOSE WHO HAVE DRAFTED
THE CURRENT LEGISLATION. IT IS NOT A SECRET THAT I HAVE SAID
THAT I THINK THIS CURRENT BILL, THE UNDERLYLE BILL, FINANCIAL
MODERNIZATION FOR 1999 IS A TERRIBLE BILL. I DON'T MEAN
DISRESPECT TO EITHER THE MANAGER OR THE CHAIRMAN OF THE
COMMITTEE OR THE RANKING MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE, I DON'T
MEANEY DISRESPECT TO THEM, IT IS JUST THAT THIS IS MOOG THIS
COUNTRY IN THE WRONG DIRECTION. THIS IS TERRIBLE LEGISLATION TO
{14:20:00} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BE CONSIDERING AT THIS POINT. LONG TEMPLE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT A
PRIVATE COMPANY?
BIG INVESTORS, ALL RICH. GOT TO BE RICH TO INVEST IN THIS
LONG-TERM CAPITOL MANAGE. YOU GOT TO BE SMART. A SMART OPERATOR
WITH LOTS OF MONEY. YOU FORM A PRIVATE COMPANY CALLED LONG TERM
CAPITAL MANAGEMENT AND YOU BEGIN BETTING. I WILL DESCRIBE THE
BETS IN A MOMENT. BUT LET ME DESCRIBE AUGUST 21, LAST YEAR. IT
WAS A FRIDAY. HALF THE PARTNERS AT LONG TM CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
HAD BEEN GONE FROM THEIR OFFICE THAT FRIDAY. INSIDE THE
{14:20:40} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ASSOCIATES THAT DAY LOGGED ON TO THEIR COMPUTERS AND SAW
SOMETHING THAT BEGAN TO STRIKE SOME FEAR IN THEIR HEARTS. U.S.
TREASURY RICE WERE SKYROCKETING. THROWING THEIR RELATIONSHIP TO
OTHER SECURITIES OUT OF WHACK. THE DOW JONES INDUSTRIAL AVERAGE
WAS SWOONING. BY NOON IT WAS DOWN. THE EUROPEAN BOND MARKET WAS
IN SHAMBLES. THIS LONG TERM CAPITAL MANAGE, THIS HEDGE FIRM,
THEIR BETS WERE BLOWING UP AND NOBODY COULD DO ANYTHING ABOUT
{14:21:15} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
IT. BY 1 1 O'CLOCK IN THE MORNING THE FUND LOST $150 MILLION IN
A WAGER THEY MADE ON THE PRICES OF TWO TELECOMMUNICATIONS
STOCKS ENGAGED IN A TAKE OVER. THEN IN A SINGLE BET THAT THEY
HAD TIED TO THE U.S. BOND MARKET THEY LOST $100 MILLION.
ANOTHER $100 MILLION EVAPORATED THE NEXT HOUR IN A SIMILAR
TRADE IN BRITAIN. BY DAY'S END, THIS PRIVATE HEDGE COMPANY,
L.T.C.M., HAD HEMORRHAGED ONE HALF OF A BILLION DOLLARS. IS
{14:21:48} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
EQUITY SUVENG TO $1.3 BILLION DOWN A THIRD FOR THE YEAR. THIS
IS FROM "THE WALL STREET JOURNAL" RECOUNT OF IT. PARTNERS
SCRAMBLE OUT OF THEIR OFFICES AND ON TO THE TRADING FLOOR AS
ASSOCIATES STAIRED AT THEIR SCREENS IN DISBELIEF MAKING FRANTIC
PHONE CALLS AROUND THE GLOBE THEY REACHED JOHN MERRY WHETHER
THE FOUNDER OF THIS FIRM AT A DINNER IN BEIJING. HE BOARDED THE
NEXT PLANE TO THE U.S. ARROWS ENFELLED CALLED IN FROM SUN
VALLEY, IDAHO WHERE HE WAS SETTLING IN FOR A VACATION. LEFT HIS
WIFE AND CHILDREN BEHIND AND MADE AN ALL NIGHT TRIP TO
{14:22:19} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
GREENWICH. THEN THE BRASS A SEMI-BELLS THE NEXT MORNING.
IT IS 7:00, ON SUNDAY, AND ONE AFTER ANOTHER THE PARTNERS FROM
LONG TERM CAN TALL MANAGEMENT BEGIN CALLING IN, TOKYO AND
LONDON, THEY REPORTED THEIR MARKETS HAD DRIED UP. THERE WERE TO
BUY YEARS, NO SELLERS WAS ALL BUT IMPOSSIBLE TO MANEUVER OUT OF
THESE LARGE TRADING BETS THAT THEY HAD. THEY HAD SEEN NOTHING
LIKE IT. THE CARNAGE THAT WEEKEND SET OFF EVENTS UNPRECEDENTED
IN THE WORLD OF HIGH FINANCE CULMINATING WITH A $3.625 BILLION
{14:22:56} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BAIL OUT FUNDED BY A CONSORTIUM OF 14 WALL STREET BANKS AND
ENGINEERED BY THE FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD. LONG TERM CATCH TALL
MANAGEMENT LOST MORE THAN 90% OF ITS ASSETS BY THE TIME IT WAS
BAILED OUT AND THE MARKETS WERE ROYALED FOR WEEKS. LONGER TERM
IT FORCED MANY OF THE WORLD'S LARGEST AND MOST SOPHISTICATED
INSTITUTIONS AL INVESTORS TO REDEFINE THE WAYS THEY MANAGE RISK
AND TRIGGERED KAULTSZ FOR CURVE U. TOUGHER REGULATION OF HEDGE
FUNDS THOSE FREE WHEELING INVESTMENT POOLS THAT KAY TER TO THE
{14:23:32} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WEALTHY. SO, HERE IS A COMPANY THAT LOST $3.6 ABOUT THE. WHAT
HAPPENED?
IT GUESS BAILED OUT. IN A CONSORTIUM OF BANKS INVESTING AT THE
BEHEST OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD AT MEETINGS AROUND BY THE
FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD. WELL, LET'S HERE E. HEAR A BIT MORE
ABOUT THIS CASE BECAUSE IT RELATE TO AN AMENDMENT I AM GOING TO
OFFER. IN AN INDUSTRY OPERATED BY SHARP P MONEY MANAGERS, LONG
TERM CAPITAL HAD THE MOST WELL-KNOWN. ROBERT HER TON AND MYRON
{14:24:02} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SHOALS. IN THE END IT WASN'T ALL ROCKET SCIENCE. IT WAS ABOUT
SMART MARKETING APPEALING TO A WEALTHY KLEIN ENTELL WHO WANTED
TO BE ABLE TO SAY THEIR MONEY WAS BEING MANAGED BY A PASS ELF
PHD'S. IT WAS ABOUT MASSIVE BORROWING, UP TO $50 FOR EVERY $1
INVESTED. LONG TERM CAPITAL MANAGEMENT WAS LIKE A SUPERMARKET,
A HIGH VOLUME LOW MARGIN BUSINESS TRYING TO EVENING OUT SMALL
PROFITS FROM THOUSANDS OF INDIVIDUAL TRANSACTIONS. MYRON ONCE
TOLD ME THEY ARE SUCKING UP NICKLES FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD
{14:24:35} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SAYS HER TON MILLER A UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO BUSINESS PROFESSOR
AND A NOBEL PRIZE WINER IN ECONOMICS. "BUT BECAUSE THEY ARE SO
LEVERAGED, THAT AMOUNTS TO A LOT OF MONEY, ALL WHICH HAVE
EXPLAINS HOW SO MANY GENIUSES SOMETIMES OVERCOMING DIVISION NGS
THEIR RANKS, GOT IT SO WRONG. AND ALL THE WHILE VANITY GREED
AND A CONSULT OF PERSONALITY BLINDED SOME TO THE WORLD'S MOST
REFUTABLE FINANCIAL INSTITUTION FRS WALL STREET -- EXCUSE ME,
REPUTABLE FINANCIAL WALL STREETS STALL WARTS TO SWISS BANKS TO
{14:25:08} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PITFALLS INHERIT IN SUCH A STRATEGY." THE ARTICLE ABOUT
LONG TERM CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, THIS PRIVATE HEDGE FIRM IS A
LENGTHY ONE AND I SHALL NOT READ IT ALL, ALTHOUGH I AM SORELY
TEMPTED JUST BECAUSE I THINK THE SENATE RECORD OUGHT TO HAVE A
COMPLETE DESCRIPTION. SO MR. PRESIDENT, LET ME ASK CONSENT TO
AT LEAST INCLUDE THE ENTIRE ARTICLE AS A PART OF THE SENATE
RECORD.
{14:25:45 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{14:25:48 NSP} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. DORGAN: THE REASON I OFFER THIS IS TO SAY WE ARE NOW
TALKING TODAY ON THE FLOOR OF THE SENATE ABOUT A STRATEGY THAT
SAYS WE WANT TO IGNORE THE LESSONS OF HISTORY. WE WANT TO
IGNORE THE TACT THAT IN THE 1920'S, IN THE GO-GO 1920'S WHEN
EVERYBODY MADE MONEY AT EVERYTHING, AND WHEN BANKS DECIDED TO
FUSE THEIR ACTIVITIES AND BE INVOLVED NOT JUST IN BANKING BUT
ALSO IN UNDERWRITING SECURITIES AND A RANGE OF OTHER VERY RISKY
ENTERPRISES, WE ARE GOING TO IGNORE THOSE LESSONS THAT WE
{14:26:20} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
LEARNED DURING THAT PERIOD. YOU KNOW THE BANK HOLIDAYS THAT
EXHIFTED AT THE -- EX O OWE EXISTED AT THE START OF THE GREAT
DEPRESSION?
THE WHEN STUDIES WERE DONE TO DETERMINE WHAT HAPPENED IN THE
1920'S, ONE OF THE THINGS THEY DISCOVERED IS WHAT HAPPENED IS
WHAT YOU WOULD EXPECT TO HAPPEN. IF YOU HAVE SOMETHING CALLED
BANKS WHOSE PERCEPTION OF SAFETY AND SOUNDNESS IS AT THE ROOT
OF THEIR STABILITY AND VIABILITY, WHEN YOU HAVE BANKS FUSING
THEIR ACTIVITIES WITH INHERENTLY RISKY ACTIVITIES, UNDERWRITING
{14:26:57} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SECURITIES, FOR EXAMPLE, AND OTHERS, ULTIMATELY THOSE KINDS OF
RISKS, THOSE KINDS OF BETS THAT EXIST OVERCOME THE PERCEPTION
AND THE REALITY OF SAFETY AND SOUNDNESS AND PEOPLE BEGIN
GETTING WORRIED AND NERVOUS AND PULLING THEIR MONEY OUT OF
BARNS AND YOU HAVE BANK FAILURES. SO THE CONGRESS IN THE 1930'S
CALLED A BILL CALLED GLASS-STIEGALL, AND GLASS-STIEGALL SAID
YOU KNOW WHAT WE SHOULD DO?
WE SHOULD LEARN THE LESSONS. MY GOSH, LET US NOT PUT ACTIVITIES
TOGETHER WITH BANKS THAT ARE SO INHERENTLY RISKY. LET US
{14:27:33} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SEPARATE THEM FOREVER. AND SO WE DID. AND WE PROHIBITED CERTAIN
KIND OF INVESTMENT AND ACQUISITION BY BANKS AND REQUIRED THAT
CERTAIN ENTERPRISES DO BUSINESS AND COMPETE IN THEIR OWN
SPHERE. BANKS WERE PROHIBITED FROM BEING INVOLVED IN MOST OF
THE SECURITIES ISSUES, UNDERWRITING SECURITIES AND INSURANCE
AND MORE. NOW, OVER THE YEARS THAT SERVED THIS COUNTRY PRETTY
WELL, BUT BANKS HAVE MADE THE CASE IN RECENT YEARS AND THEY ARE
RIGHT ABOUT THIS, THAT EVERYBODY ELSE WANTED TO INVADE THEIR
{14:28:07} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TERRITORY. EVERYBODY NOW WANTS FOB A BANK. IF YOU ARE SELLING
CARS YOU WANT TO FINANCE CARS. YOU WANT TO BE A BANK. EVERYBODY
WANTS TO CREATE SOME SORT OF HO AMONG RECOGNIZED ONE STOP
STATION WHERE PEOPLE CAN BUY THEIR INSURANCE, BUY THEIR HOME,
FINANCE IT. AND SO BANKS SAY PEOPLE ARE INTRUDING ON OUR
TOUGHER, AND THE ONLY WAY WE CAN COMPETIS TO COMPETE ON THEIR
TUVER AS WELL AND WE WANT GLASS-STIEGALL REPEALED AND HERE IT
{14:28:43} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
IS. THE BILL SITS ON THE FLOOR OF THE SENATE TODAY, REPEALS
GLASS-STIEGALL. IT JUST FORGETS, APPARENTLY 60 YEARS OR 70
YEARS OF HISTORY. IT WILL ALL BE ALL RIGHT. DON'T YOU SEE
AROUND YOU?
THE ECONOMY IS GROWING, UNEMPLOYMENT IS DOWN, INFLATION IS IT
DOWN. THE STOCK MARKET IS UP. DOWN YOU UNDERSTAND, SENATOR DOR
BEGAN?
I GUESS NOT. MAYBE AS I SAID PELESSLY HOLD FASHIONED ABOUT
THIS. I THINK IT IS A FUNDAMENTAL MISTAKE TO DECIDE TO REPEAL
GLASS-STIEGALL AND DECIDE WE OUGHT TO ALLOW BANKS AND ALL OF
{14:29:13} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE OTHER FINANCIAL INDUSTRIES MERGE INTO ONE GIANT
SMORGASBOARD OF FINANCIAL SERVICES. THOSE WHO ARE AROUND TO
VOTE TO BAIL OUT A FAILED SAVINGS AND LOAN INDUSTRY TO $500
BILLION OF THE TAXPAYERS MONEY, ARE THEY GOING TO WANT TO BE
AROUND 10 YEARS OR 15 YEARS FROM NOW WHEN WE SEE BAIL OUTS OF
HEDGE FUNDS PUTTING BANKS AT RISK?
OR HOW ABOUT THE BANKS NOT JUST BAILING OUT OF A HEDGE FUND,
BUT BANGS HAVE THE OWNERSHIP OF THE HEM FUNDS. THAT'S WHAT WE
HAVE NOW. THIS BAIL OUT OF LONG TERM CAPITAL MANAGEMENT SAYS
{14:29:50} (MR. DORGAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THAT WE HAVE SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENTS BY SOME. LARGEST BANKS IN
THESE HEDGE FUNDS. OR HOW ABOUT DERIVATIVES?
I AM NOT AN EXPERT IN THIS
{END: 1999/05/06 TIME: 14-30 , Thu. 106TH SENATE, FIRST SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}