{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
{14:45:04} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
{14:49:26 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM ARIZONA.
{14:49:29 NSP} (A SENATOR) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
A SENATOR: I ASK THAT THE QUORUM CALL BE DISPENSED WITH.
{14:49:30 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{14:49:32 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MCCAIN: MR. PRESIDENT, I HAVE A BILL AT THE DESK AND ASK
FOR ITS CONSIDERATION.
{14:49:38 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE DELERK WILL REPORT.
{14:49:47 NSP} (THE CLERK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE CLERK: -- THE CLERK WILL REPORT.
{14:49:50 NSP} (THE CLERK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE CLERK: --
{14:49:54 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MCCAIN: I ASK FOR ITS CONSIDERATION.
{14:49:57 NSP} (THE CLERK) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE CLERK: A BILL TO AMEND THE DEFENSE BASE CLOSURE REALIVEMENT
ACT OF 1990, TO AUTHORIZE ADDITIONAL ROUNDS OF BASE CLOSURES
UNDER THAT ACT IN 2003 AND 2005, TO MODIFY CERTAIN AUTHORITIES
RELATING TO CLOSURES AND REALIGNMENTS UNDER THAT ACT AND FOR
{14:50:11 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OTHER PURPOSES. 6. MR. MCCAIN: MR. PRESIDENT?
{14:50:14 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM ARIZONA CHANGE CANE MR.
PRESIDENT, ON BEHALF OF MYSELF, SENATORS LEVIN, HAGEL,
LIEBERMAN, VOINOVICH, FEINGOLD, JEFFFORDS, DEWINE, I INTRODUCE
THIS LEGISLATION TODAY. OBVIOUSLY IT WILL BE REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON ARMED SERVICES.
{14:50:37 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: DOES THE SENATOR HAVE A REQUEST?
{14:50:40 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MCCAIN: I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT THAT THE BILL BE REFERRED
TO THE COMMITTEE ON ARMED SERVICES.
{14:50:45 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION. THE BILL WILL BE
APPROPRIATE LIR REFERRED -- THE BILL WILL BE APPROPRIATELY
REFERRED.
{14:51:03 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MCCAIN: MR. PRESIDENT, THIS LEGISLATION AUTHORIZE SALES OF
MILITARY INSTALLATION AND REALIGNMENT CLOSURES TO OCCUR IF 2003
AND 2005 COMMONLY KNOWN IN DEFENSE PARLANCE AS BRACK. I WOULD
PREFER TO SAY THAT THIS IS A NEW IDEA. IT ISN'T. IN 1970, THE
BLUE RIBBON DEFENSE PANEL KNOWN AS THE FITZHUGH COMMISSION MADE
REFERENCE TO CONSOLIDATION OF MILITARY ACTIVITIES, THAT FEWER
INSTALLATIONS WOULD CONTRIBUTE TO EFFICIENT OPERATIONS AND
{14:51:35} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
REDUCE SUBSTANTIAL -- WOULD PRODUCE SUBSTANTIAL SAVINGS. IN
1983, THE PRESIDENT'S PRIVATE SURVEY ON COST CONTROL, THE GRACE
COMMISSION, MADE STRONG RECOMMENDATIONS FOR MILITARY BASE
CLOSURES IN 1997, THE DEFENSE REVIEW RECOMMENDED THAT EVEN
AFTER FOUR BASE CLOSURE ROUNDS IN 1988, 1991, 1993, 1995, THE
ARMED SERVICES MUST "SHED EXCESS INFRASTRUCTURE." LIKEWISE IN
1997 DEFENSE REFORM INITIATIVE AND NATIONAL DEFENSE PANEL
STRONGLY URGED CONGRESS AND DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE TO MOVE
{14:52:08} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
QUICKLY TO RESTORE THE BASE REALIGNMENT AND CLOSURE PROCESS.
MR. PRESIDENT, WE HAVE TOO MANY MILITARY BASES. THE COLD WAR IS
OVER. WE WILL NEVER HAVE A REQUIREMENT FOR AS MANY BASES WE
HAVE TODAY. AND CLEARLY WE COULD SAVE ACCORDING TO MOST
CONSERVATIVE ESTIMATES SOMEWHERE BETWEEN $3 BILLION AND 4
BILLION A YEAR OF TAXPAYER DOLLARS THAT ARE NOW EXPENDED
UNNECESSARILY ON KEEPING MILITARY BASES OPEN. THE CONGRESSIONAL
{14:52:45} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BUDGET OFFICE, FORMER SECRETARY CHENEY AND WILLIAM COHEN,
NEARLY ALL THE SERVICE CHIEFS AND OTHER DEFENSE EXPERTS HAVE
BEEN CONSISTENT IN THEIR PLEA THAT THE PL BE PERMITTED TO
DIVIDE VEST THEMSELVES OF EXCESS INFRASTRUCTURE BEYOND WHAT WAS
ELIMINATED DURING THE PRIOR ROUNDS OF BASE CLOSINGS. LOU THE
END OF 1998, THE PL HAD CLOSED 97 MAJOR BASES IN THE UNITED
STATES, AFTER FREE -- FOUR PREVIOUS ROUNDS OF BRACK. SINCE
THEN, IT HAS CLOSED NONE. MOREOVER, THE SAVINGS FROM CLOSING
{14:53:16} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ADDITIONAL UNNEEDED BASES SHOULD BE USED FOR MOD DAIGS
PURPOSES. MR. PRESIDENT, WE'VE HEARD OVER THE LAST SEVERAL
YEARS THE DIRE SITUATION OF OUR MILITARY FORCES. WE'VE HEARD
TESTIMONY OF READINESS, MODERNIZATION PROGRAMS, THAT ARE
DECADES BEHIND SCHEDULE AND QUALITY OF LIFE DEFICIENCIES THAT
ARE SO GREAT, WE CANNOT RETAIN OR RECRUIT THE PERSONNEL WE
NEED. AS A RESULT OF THIS REALIZATION, THERE HAS BEEN A
GROUNDSWELL OF SUPPORT IN CONGRESS FOR THE ARMED FORCES.
INCLUDING A NUMBER OF PAY RETIREMENT AND MEDICAL BENEFIT
{14:53:48} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
INITIATIVES AND THE PROMISE OF A SIGNIFICANT INCREASE IN
DEFENSE SPENDING. ALL THESE PROPOSALS ARE EXCELLENT STARTING
POINTS TO HELP REBUILD OUR MILITARY, BUT WE MUSTN'T FORGET THAT
MUCH OF IT WILL NOT BE HELPFUL IF THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE IS
OBLIGATED TO MAINTAIN 23% EXCESS CAPACITY AND INFRASTRUCTURE.
WHEN WE ACTUALLY LOOK FOR DOLLARS TO PAY FOR THESE INITIATIVES,
IT IS UNCONSCIONABLE THAT SOMEONE WOULD NOT LOOK TO THE
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO BE SAVED BY BASE REALIGNMENT AND
{14:54:20} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CLOSURE. ONLY 30% OF THE DEFENSE BUDGET FUNDS COMBAT FORCES.
WHILE THE REMAINING 70% IS DEVOTED TO SUPPORT FUNCTIONS SUCH AS
BASES. CONTINUING TO SQUANDER PRECIOUS DOLLARS IN THIS MANNER
WILL MAKE IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR US TO ADEQUATELY MODERNIZE OUR
FORCES FOR THE FUTURE. THE JOINT CHIEFS OF STAFF HAVE STATED
REPEATEDLY THAT THEY DESIRE MORE OPPORTUNITIES TO STREAMLINE
THE MILITARY INFRASTRUCTURE. WE CAN'T SIT BY IDLY AND THROW
MONEY AND IDEAS AT THE PROBLEM WHEN PART OF THE SOLUTION IS
{14:54:53} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
STARING US IN THE FACE. THIS LEGISLATION OFFERS A SIGNIFICANT
CHANGE TO PRESENT LAW. UNDER THIS BILL, PRIVATIZATION IN PLACE
WOULD BE PERMITTED ONLY WHEN EXPLICITLY RECOMMENDED BY THE
COMMISSION. ADDITIONALLY, THE SECRETARY OF DEFENSE MUST
CONSIDER LOCAL GOVERNMENT INPUT IN PREPARING HIS LIST OF
DESIRED BASE CLOSURES. TOTAL BRACK SAVINGS REALIZED FROM THE
FOUR PREVIOUS CLOSURE ROUNDS EXCEED TOTAL COST TO DATE.
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE FIGURES SUGGEST PREVIOUS BASE CLOSEINGS
{14:55:28} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WILL SAVE AFTER ONE TIME CLOSING COSTS $15 BILLION THROUGH
FISCAL YEAR 2001, $25 BILLION THROUGH 2003, AND $6.1 BILLION A
YEAR THERE AFTER. ADDITIONAL NEEDED CLOSURES CAN SAVE $20
BILLION BY 2015 AND $3 BILLION A YEAR THERE AFTER. SOONER OR
LATER THESE SURPLUS BASES WILL BE CLOSED ANYWAY. THE SOONER THE
ISSUE IS ADDRESS, THE GREATER WILL BE THE SAVINGS AND WILL
ULTIMATELY GO TOWARD DEFENSE MODERNIZATION AND GREATER PAY
RAISES FOR SERVICE MEMBERS. PREVIOUS BASE CLOSURE ROUNDS HAD
{14:56:03} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MANY SUCCESS STORIES. FOR EXAMPLE, AFTER ENGLAND AIR FORCE BASE
CLOSED IN 1992. ALEXANDER, LOUISIANA, BENEFITED FROM THE
CREATION OF OVER 1,400 JOBS. NEARLY DOUBLE THE NUMBER OF JOBS
LOST. ACROSS THE UNITED STATES, ABOUT 60,000 NEW JOBS HAVE BEEN
CREATED AT CLOSING MILITARY BASES. AT BASES CLOSED MORE THAN
TWO YEARS, NEARLY 75% OF THE CIVILIAN JOBS HAVE BEEN REPLACED.
IN CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA, THE NUMBER OF DEFENSE JOB LOSSES
AS A PERCENTAGE OF THE WORKFORCE WAS GREATER THAN AT ANY OTHER
{14:56:40} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BASE CLOSURE LOCATION LOCATION. 23 MAJOR ENTITIES ARE REUSING
THE FORMER NAVY FACILITIES AND PROVIDING FOREMAN 3,300 JOBS.
AND ANOTHER 13 MORE IN CIVILIAN INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS ARE
PENDING ADDING SOON EVEN MORE NEWLY CREATED JOBS TO THAT
NUMBER. ADDITIONALLY, ROUGHLY 75% OF THE 6 MILLION SQUARE FEET
OF LEASEIBLE SPACE ON THE BASE IS OCCUPIED. THIS IS COMPARABLE
TO THE SUCCESSES IN MY HOME STATE OF ARIZONA WITH A CLOSURE OF
WILLIAMS AIR FORCE BASE IN THE VALLEY. THIS IS NOT TO SAY THAT
{14:57:13} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BASE CLOSURES ARE EASY FOR ANY COMMUNITY, BUT IT DOES SUGGEST
THAT COMMUNITIES CAN AND WILL CONTINUE TO THRIVE. MR.
PRESIDENT, WE CAN CONTINUE TO MAINTAIN A MILITARY
INFRASTRUCTURE THAT WE DON'T NEED OR WE CAN PROVIDE THE
NECESSARY FUNDS TO ENSURE OUR MILITARY CAN FIGHT AND WIN FUTURE
WARS. EVERY DOLLAR WE SPEND ON BASES WE DO NOT NEED IS A DOLLAR
WE CANNOT SPEND ON TRAINING OUR TROOPS, KEEPING PERSONNEL
QUALITY OF LIFE, AT AN APPROPRIATE LEVEL, MAINTAINING FORCE
STRUCTURE, REPLACING OLD WEAPONS SYSTEMS AND ADVANCING OUR
{14:57:49} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MILITARY TECHNOLOGY. WE NEED TO FINISH THE JOB WE STARTED BY
AUTHORIZING THESE TWO FINAL ROUNDS OF BASE REALIGNMENT AND
CLOSURE. I URGE MY COLLEAGUES TO JOIN US IN SUPPORT OF THIS
CRITICAL BILL AND TO WORK DILIGENTLY THROUGHOUT THE YEAR TO PUT
ASIDE LOCAL POLITICS FOR WHAT IS CLEARLY IN THE BEST INTEREST
OF OUR MILITARY FORCES. MR. PRESIDENT, I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT
THAT THE BILL TO AUTHORIZE TWO ADDITIONAL BASE REALIGNMENT
CLOSURE ROUNDS BE PRINTED IN THE CONGRESSIONAL RECORD FOLLOWING
MY REMARKS.
{14:58:17 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{14:58:20 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MCCAIN: FOURTH MORE, I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT IF THERE ARE
ANY MORE STATEMENTS RELATING TO BASE CLOSURE, THEY BE PRINTED
IN THE RECORD AND I ASK AT THIS TIME UNANIMOUS CONSENT THAT THE
STATEMENT OF SENATOR LEVIN BE INCLUDED IN THE RECORD
IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING MY REMARKS.
{14:58:31 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION, SO ORDERED.
{14:58:35 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MCCAIN: MR. PRESIDENT, I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT THAT SENATOR
MCCAIN'S LEGISLATIVE FELLOW NAVY WLT COMMANDER DALE BULB
GRANTED FULL PRIVILEGES DURING CONSIDERATION TO AMEND THE
DEFENSE CLOSURE AND REALIGNMENT ACT.
{14:58:45 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{14:58:51 NSP} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MCCAIN: MR. PRESIDENT, I BELIEVE THAT THIS MEASURE IS LONG
OVERDUE. I BELIEVE THAT THE ADDITIONAL THREE TO $4 BILLION A
YEAR THAT WE COULD SAVE BY CLOSING UNNECESSARY BASES COULD BE
USED FOR THE BETTERMENT OF THE QUALITY OF LIFE OF OUR MEN AND
WOMEN IN THE MILITARY. I BELIEVE THAT IT IS REALLY HARD TO
UNDERSTAND WHY WHEN THE MAJORITY OVERWHELMINGLY OF OUTSIDE
{14:59:21} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OPINION, WHETHER IT BE LIBERAL OR CONSERVATIVE ORGANIZATIONS
THAT ARE WATCHDOGS OF OUR DEFENSE POLICIES AND PROGRAMS, ALL
AGREE THAT WE HAVE TOO MANY BASES. WE NEEDED THESE BASES DURING
THE COLD WAR, AND WE NEEDED THEM VERY BADLY AND THEY OBVIOUSLY
CONTRIBUTED ENORMOUSLY TO OUR ABILITY TO WIN THE COLD WAR. NO
ONE ENVISIONS, NO ONE ENVISIONS FUTURE THREATS THAT WOULD
REQUIRE THE NUMBER OF BASES THAT ARE PART OF OUR MILITARY
{14:59:53} (MR. MCCAIN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ESTABLISHMENT TODAY. I HOPE THAT THE CHAIRMAN OF THE ARMED
SERVICES COMMITTEE WHO IN THE PAST YEAR SAYS
{END: 2001/02/27 TIME: 15-00 , Tue. 107TH SENATE, FIRST SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}