{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
{11:45:02} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
{11:51:53 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: IS THERE ANYBODY WHO WISHES TO VOTE WHO
HAS NOT HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE?
IF NOT, THE YEAS ARE 77, THE NAYS ARE 19. THE CONFERENCE REPORT
IS AGREED TO.
{11:52:07 NSP} (MR. MOYNIHAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MOYNIHAN: MOVE TO RECONSIDER THE VOTE.
{11:52:09 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: MR. PRESIDENT, MOVE TO LAY THAT ON THE TAKEN.
{11:52:10 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{11:52:12 NSP} (MR. MOYNIHAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. MOYNIHAN: MR. PRESIDENT, THIS WAS A MOMENTOUS MOMENT FOR
THE SENATE, FOR THE NATION AND FOR THE WORLD. WE HAVE PASSED
THE FIRST TRADE BILL IN SIX YEARS WHEN WE HAVE REJECTED OTHERS.
AND THIS HAVING COME BAH B IN THE AFTERMATH OF VERY DIM -- AND
THIS HAVE COME ABOUT IN THE AFTERMATH OF VERY DIM EXPECTATIONS.
AND WITH NO CHANCE WHATSOEVER, WE HAVE COME TO THE POINT WHERE
THIS BILL PASSED BY 77 VOTES. COULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED WITHOUT
THE MAJORITY LEADER, OUR MAJORITY LEADER, WHO PERSONALLY
{11:52:44} (MR. MOYNIHAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CONVENED MEETINGS IN HIS OFFICE DAY AFTER DAY, WITH
MIND-NUMBING DETAILS ABOUT THREAD, YARN, METRIC SQUARE METERS,
HUNDREDS, MILLIONS, BUT IT CAME ABOUT. SENATOR ROTH, OUR
CHAIRMAN, CANNOT -- WHO COULD NOT BE HERE TODAY. HE WILL BE
BACK NEXT WEEK. HE PUT THIS MATTER THROUGH THE FINANCE
COMMITTEE UNANIMOUSLY. AND I WOULD LIKE TO TAKE THE OPPORTUNITY
TO THANK THE STAFF STAFF, WHO NOT ONLY DID THIS BUT DID IT TILL
{11:53:18} (MR. MOYNIHAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DAWN DAY AFTER DAY, OR SHALL I SAY NIGHT AFTER NIGHT. THEY ARE,
ON THE MAJORITY STAFF, FRANK POLK, GRANT A ADONIS, FIRE SHAZID,
TIM KOO EELER. ON THE MAJORITY LEADER'S STAFF, DAVID HOPPE, WHO
IS INDISPENSABLE, AND JIM HECHT. ON OUR MINORITY STAFF, DAVID
POTOFF, OUR SPECIAL NEGOTIATOR, DEBBIE LAMM, LINDA MENGATI,
TIMOTHY HOGAN. AND THEN MAJORITY AND MINORITY TAX STAFFS --
{11:53:54} (MR. MOYNIHAN) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BECAUSE THIS IS A TAX BILL -- MARK CLATER, CLARA PEW, ANITA
HORN, AND MITCHELL KENT. ONCE AGAIN, SIR, AND TO MY DEAR
COLLEAGUE FROM SENATOR GRASSLEY, WHO CARRIED THE MATTER SO
BRILLIANTLY ON THE OTHER SIDE, NOT EVERY DAY WE PASS A TRADE
BILL 4-1. AND THANK YOU, SIR. AND, AGAIN, MR. MAJORITY LEADER,
{11:54:18 NSP} (MR. GRASSLEY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THANK YOU, SIR. THE NATION IS IN YOUR DEBT. MR. GRASSLEY: MR.
PRESIDENT?
{11:54:21 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM IOWA.
{11:54:25 NSP} (MR. GRASSLEY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. GRASSLEY: MR. PRESIDENT, FOLLOWING UP ON WHAT SENATOR
MOYNIHAN JUST SAID AND ASSOCIATING MYSELF WITH THOSE REMARKS,
AS IMPORTANT AS THE BILL WE PASSED IS FOR THE CONTINENT OF
AFTER K5 AND THE CARIBBEAN BASIN INITIATIVE, AND AS IMPORTANT
AS IT IS FOR THE CONSUMERS OF AMERICA AND THE 120,000 NEW JOBS
IT'S GOING TO CREATE FOR AMERICAN WORKING MEN AND WOMEN, THIS
BILL IS FAR MORE SIGNIFICANT FROM MY POINT OF VIEW, BECAUSE, AS
{11:54:55} (MR. GRASSLEY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SENATOR MOYNIHAN SAID, IT'S THE FIRST MAJOR PIECE OF
LEGISLATION, TRADE LEGISLATION, PASSING THE CONGRESS IN YEARS.
AND IN THE MEANTIME, I THINK THE UNITED STATES HAS BEEN SEEN BY
OTHER NATIONS AS GIVING UP SOME OF OUR TRADITIONAL LEADERSHIP
AROUND THE WORLD IN NEGOTIATIONS AND TEARING DOWN TRADE
BARRIERS, WHICH HAS BEEN OUR STATUS AS A WORLD LEADER SINCE
1947. AND I HOPE THAT THIS IS A START OF AMERICA ONCE AGAIN
{11:55:30} (MR. GRASSLEY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
LEADING THE WORLD IN THE REDUCING OF BARRIERS TO TRADE, THE
PROMOTION OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE, AND SEEING TRADE AS MORE
IMPORTANT THAN AID AS AN INSTRUMENT TO HELPING DEPRESSED
ECONOMIES AROUND THE WORLD. I LOOK FORWARD TO THE CONTINUATION
OF THIS ON WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION AGENDAS AND REGIONAL TRADE
AGREEMENTS AS WELL. I YIELD THE FLOOR.
{11:56:00 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE MAJORITY LEADER. MR. DODD: MR.
PRESIDENT?
{11:56:01 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: I WITHHOLD.
{11:56:03 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM CONNECTICUT.
{11:56:05 NSP} (MR. DODD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. DODD: MR. PRESIDENT, I THANK THE MAJORITY LEADER. I JUST
WANTED TO -- AND I'M NOT A MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE, BUT I
WANTED TO COMMEND THE SENATOR FROM NEW YORK ONCE AGAIN FOR HIS
TREMENDOUS LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE, SENATOR GRASSLEY, WHO WAS
FILLING IN FOR SENATOR ROTH, AS YOU POINTED OUT WILL BE BACK
NEXT WEEK, AND TO COMMEND THE LEADERSHIP, THE MAJORITY LEADER,
THE MINORITY LEADER. THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF WHAT THIS BODY CAN
DO ON ISSUES THAT USUALLY PROVOKE THE MOST BITTER DEBATES.
TRADE POLICY AND ISSUES WHEN THEY COME TO THE FLOOR CAN BE
EMENDOUSLY ACRIMONIOUS. AND THE FACT THAT THE LEADERSHIP ON
{11:56:35} (MR. DODD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE HERE WORKED AS DILIGENTLY AND AS HARD
AS THEY DID TRYING TO COME UP WITH SOME UNDERSTANDINGS AS TO
HOW WE COULD RECOGNIZE LEGITIMATE INTERESTS SPEAKS VOLUMES
ABOUT WHAT THIS BODY CAN DO ON SOMETHG AS SIGNIFICANT AND AS
IMPORTANT AS THIS BILL IS. AND SO I DIDN'T WANT THE MOMENT TO
PASS WITHOUT COMMENDING OBVIOUSLY THE FLOOR MANAGERS AND THE
FINANCE COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK BUT ALSO THE LEADERSHIP FOR
THEIR SUPPORT OF THIS. THE ADMINISTRATION AS WELL SHOULD BE
MENTIONED IN THE CONTEXT HERE. WHILE IT'S BEEN X YEARS, WE'RE
GOING TO BE DEALING WITH A COUPLE OF THESE ISSUES NOW IN
{11:57:07} (MR. DODD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
SEQUENCE THAT WILL BE VERY, VERY IMPORTANT. AND OBVIOUSLY,
THEIR BACKING AND SUPPORT ARE WORTHWHILE. AND LASTLY, THE SAME
POINT THAT OUR COLLEAGUE FROM IOWA MADE. MY HOPE IS, MR.
PRESIDENT, THAT THIS WILL ALSO SERVE AS A SPRING BOARD FOR US
TO DEAL WITH OTHER FOREIGN POLICIES MATTERS THAT SERVE THE
INTERESTS OF OUR COUNTRY. WE'VE ENTERED A GLOBAL ECONOMY. WE
ALL KNOW THE LINGO ABOUT THE KIND OF WORLD WE'RE NOW A PART OF.
AND IT'S GOING TO BE CRITICALLY IMPORTANT THAT THE SENATE OF
THE UNITED STATES, IN FULFILLING ITS HISTORIC ROLE AS THE
UNIQUE PART OF THE LEGISLATIVE BRANCH OF GOVERNMENT TO BE
{11:57:40} (MR. DODD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ENGAGED IN THE FOREIGN POLICY INTERESTS OF OUR NATION, AND THIS
TREATY -- THIS AGREEMENT CERTAINLY SERVES THE INTERESTS OF
AFRICA AND THE CARIBBEAN BASIN VERY, VERY WELL. BUT MORE
IMPORTANTLY, IT SERVES THE INTERESTS OF OUR NATION -- OF OUR
NATION -- VERY WELL. AND SO I COMMEND THE STAFF AND OTHERS WHO
WERE INVOLVED AND HOPE WE CAN GET TO THE ANDEAN PACT COUNTRIES
OF COLOMBIA AND VENEZUELA AND ACK DOOR SHORTLY THEREAFTER IN
OTHER CONGRESSES. BUT IT'S A GOOD START, A GREAT START. AND,
GERNG THE LEADERSHIP IN THIS BODY -- AND AGAIN, THE LEADERSHIP
IN THIS BODY DESERVES COMMENDATION FOR THEIR LEADERSHIP AND
{11:58:15} (MR. DODD) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THEIR WILLINGNESS TO PUT A SHOULDER BEHIND THIS EFFORT. SO I
THANK THE MAJORITY LEADER. AND I THANK THE MINORITY LEADER, TOM
DASCHLE, FOR HIS LEADER SHOIP THIS ISSUE.
{11:58:26 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: MR. PRESIDENT THE MAJORITY LEADER.
{11:58:28 NSP} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. LOTT: MR. PRESIDENT, I WANT TO THANK SENATOR MOYNIHAN,
SENATOR DODD, SENATOR GRASSLEY FOR THEIR COMMENTS. AND THEY'RE
ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. THIS IS THE WAY WE CAN DO THINGS WHEN WE MAKE
UP OU MINDS THAT WE'RE GOING TO. KEEP IN MIND THAT JUST A YEAR
AGO, MOST PEOPLE THOUGHT THIS HAD NO CHANCE. THE HOUSE PASSED A
BILL THAT WAS ONLY APPLICABLE TO AFRICA. BUT THEN SENATOR ROTH
AND SENATOR MOYNIHAN SAID, WE SHOULD GO FORWARD ON THIS. THEY
MADE THE POINT THAT WE HAD NOT HAD A MAJOR TRADE BILL IN I
THOUGHT FIVE BUT IN FACT SIX YEARS. I YIELD TO THE
{11:58:59} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DISTINGUISHED SENATOR FROM NEW YORK. HE PAYS SUCH CLOSE
ATTENTION TO THIS. BUT THE CHAIRMAN AND THE RANKING MEMBER SAID
WE SHOULD GO FORWARD WITH THIS AND WE SHOULD ADD THE C.B.I.
REGION, CENTRAL AMERICA, TO THE PACKAGE. AND WE DID THAT. WE
DID WORK TOGETHER ACROSS THE AISLE, BETWEEN THE TWO PARTIES.
THE ADMINISTRATION DID EXPRESS ITS INTEREST IN THIS
LEGISLATION. THE PRESIDENT PERSONALLY CALLED AT LEAST TWICE,
MAYBE THREE TIMES AND TALKED ABOUT HIS HOPE THAT WE COULD GET
THIS DONE. BUT I REMEMBER A CRITICAL MOMENT A MONTH OR SO AGO
{11:59:31} (MR. LOTT) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
LATE AT NIGHT AND WE WERE TRYING TO MAKE THE LAST DECISION THAT
WOULD CLOSE THE PACKAGE UP. AND DAVE HOPPE, MY CHIEF OF STAFF
WAS THERE, JIM HECHT, MY STAFF, WHO HAVE WORKED SO HARD ON THIS
LEGISLATION, KNEW THE SUBSTANCE BETTER THAN I WOULD EVER KNOW
IT. AND IT IS MIND-BOGGLING IN ITS DETAIL AND ALL THE PIECES
THAT WERE IN THIS PACKAGE. BUT WHEN I HAD BASICALLY TO HELP
MAKE THE FINAL DECISION,
{END: 2000/05/11 TIME: 12-00 , Thu. 106TH SENATE, SECOND SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}