{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
IMPACT ON OUR CAPACITY TO NEGOTIATE, TO PRESSURE, TO IMPACT, TO
PUSH FOR, TO SPEAK ABOUT, TO PUSH THE MORALITY OF, TO STAND FOR
A STANDARD OF BEHAVIOR THAT IS DIFFERENT FROM THE KIND OF
KILLING AND MARAUDING THAT HAS GHUFRND SO MUCH OF THIS CENTURY.
NOW SOME WILL SAY WELL, THE BALKANS ARE DIFFERENT. SOME WILL
SAY, WELL, QUESTION CAN'T ALWAYS EFFECT THE OUTCOME OF THESE
THINGS. THE FACT IS, MR. PRESIDENT, WE CAN EFFECT THIS OUTCOME.
{18:15:35} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WE CAN EFFECT THIS RESULT. WE DO HAVE THE POWER AND THE ABILITY
TO DO THIS. I'VE HEARD SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES COMING TO THE
FLOOR AND SAYINGTHIS IS ISN'T GOING TO EFFECT OUR CAPACITY TO
FIGHT SOME OTHER WAR SOMEWHERE. WHAT WAR?
WHERE?
WHAT ARE THEY TALKING ABOUT?
I MEAN ARE WE PLANNING SUDDENLY SOME OTHER WAR THAT WE ARE NOT
AWARE OF?
THIS IS STARING US IN THE FACE. IT IS HERE. IT IS NOW. WE ARE
AT WAR. AND THE QUESTION WE ARE GOING TO ASK OURSELVES IS
WHETHER OR NOT WE ARE PREPARED TO WIN OR WHETHER WE ARE GOING
{18:16:08} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TO PUT OBSTACLE AFTER OBSTACLE IN FRONT OF OURSELVES TO DEPRIVE
OURSELVES OF THE ABILITY TO ACHIEVE THE GOALS THAT ARE
ACHIEVABLE. I HEAR SOME REFER TO OBVIOUSLY VIETNAM ALLOT AND
OTHER KINDS OF CONFLICTS BUT I SUGGEST THIS IS NOT A VIETNAM
UNLESS WE MAKE IT A VIETNAM. UNLESS IT IS OUR OWN LACK OF
RESOLVE AND PURSUIT. SOME SAY WELL IT IS A MISTAKE IN THE FIRST
PLACE YOU DON'T WANT TO GO DOWNED THE ROAD PURSUING A MISTAKE.
I SUPPORT THAT NOTION. I RECALL CAM COMING BACK FROM VIETNAM BE
{18:16:44} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TO BE HARD TO ASK SOMEONE TO DIE FOR A MISTAKE. ESPECIALLY THE
LAST PERSON TO DIE FOR T I UNDERSTAND THAT. BUT THE QUESTION
IS, IS THIS A MISTAKE?
WHEN 58 OF US VOTED ON THE FLOOR OF THE UNITED STATES SENATE TO
SEND PEOPLE INTO HARM'S WAY IN ORDER TO ACHIEVE GOALS, WE WERE
MAKING A JUDGMENT ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT WE THOUGHT IT WAS A
MISTAKE TO INTERVENE. AND ONCE WE DECIDE TO INTERVENE, MR.
PRESIDENT, LET US AT LEAST HAVE THE COURAGE TO PERSEVERE. WHY
DID WE INTERVENE?
{18:17:18} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WELL, I BELIEVE THAT THE IMPERATIVES OF INTERVENTION OUTWEIGH
THE ALTERNATIVES SO FAR THAT IT IS HARD TO REALLY MEASURE THE
COUNTER ARGUMENTS. ANY ONE OF US IN THE UNITED STATES SENATE
CAN HEAR THIS WELL IN THE SENATE RINGING OUT OF THE VOICES OF
THOSE WHO WOULD HAVE COME TO THE FLOOR IN THE IMAGES OF CNN
NIGHT AFTER NIGHT HAD BEEN MILOSEVIC RUNNING UNSTOPPED OVER THE
PEOPLE OF KOSOVO. UNSTOPPED AND NO EFFORT WHATSOEVER TO TRY TO
PREVENT HIM. I COULD HEAR PEOPLE COMING TO THE FLOOR AND SAYING
{18:17:49} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WHERE IS A PRESIDENT WITH THE COURAGE OF RONALD REAGAN OR
GEORGE BUSH WHO IS WILLING TO DRAW THE LINE AT THEY DID?
YOU CAN HEAR THOSE SPEECHES NOW. THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN SPOKEN.
PRESIDENT GORING BUSH IN FACT HAD THE SAME POLICY THAT
PRESIDENT CLINTON HAS. GEORGE BUSH SAID THAT THEY WOULD DREW
THE LINE IN KOSOVO BEFORE HE LEFT AND TOLD MR. MILOSEVIC IN NO
UNCERTAIN TERMS, DON'T MONKEY AROUND WITH THIS ONE. AND BECAUSE
HE HAD THE CREDIBILITY OF WHAT HE HAD DONE IN KUWAIT, YOU CAN
BET THAT MADE A DIFFERENCE. THAT'S WHY WE ARE HERE ON THE FLOOR
{18:18:24} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WITH THIS AMENDMENT,TO GIVE IT THE KIND OF CREDIBILITY THAT IT
DESERVES. TO BACK UP OUR SOLDIERS WHO ARE RUNNING THOSE RISKS
ON A DAILY BASIS WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT THERE IS A
RATIONALE FOR OUR HAVING ASKED THEM TO DO WHAT THEY ARE DOING.
NOW, MR. PRESIDENT, I DON'T -- I DON'T BY ANY SENSE OF THE
IMAGINATION BELIEVE WE HAVE EXHAUSTED THE AIR CAMPAIGN IN THIS.
IT A STOP SHE IS ME IN SOME WAYS THAT SO MANY -- A STOP SHE IS
{18:18:59} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ME IN SO MANY WAYS THAT PEOPLE THINK THAT AN AIR CAMPAIGN THAT
KNOCK ON WOOD THAT HAS NOT YET COST US THE LIFE OF ONE PILOT
THOUGH THE LOSS OF A PLANE, I AM ASTONISHED AS A FORMER PERSON
WITH THE QUALITY AND CARE THIS HAS BEEN PROSECUTED. WE LOSE
MORE PEOPLE EVERY WEEK IN THE MILITARY OF THIS COUNTRY IN
NORMAL TRAINING AND OPERATIONS. THE FACT THAT THIS HAS BEEN
CARRIED ON NOW FOR 40 YEARS, MELDING, DUTCH, BRITISH, GERMANS,
{18:19:32} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AMERICANS, FRENCH, GREEKS, SO MANY DIFFERENT -- 19 DIFFERENT
COUNTRIES TOGETHER, MELDING ALL OF THESE AIRPLANES IN MULTIPLE
SORTIES AND BRINGING THAT TOGETHER IS REALLY A REMARKABLE
ACCOMPLISHMENT. AND AT THE SAME TIME DAY, BY DAY, BY DAY,
ALBEIT SOME MEMBERS OF THE YUGOSLAVIA ARMY MAY FEEL BETTER AND
THINK GEE, WE HAVE BEEN GIVEN A PURPOSE IN LIFE, THE FACT IS
THAT ON A DAILY BASIS, THEIR CAPACITY TO WAGE THE WAR IS BEING
{18:20:07} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
STRIPPED AWAY. I MEAN WHO IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WOULD CHOOSE MR.
MILOSEVIC'S HAND TO PLAY IN THIS VERSUS THE HAND OF NATO?
SO THE QUESTION BEFORE THE UNITED STATES SENATE AND THIS
COUNTRY IS WILL WE HAVE THE CAPACITY TO STAY AND PLAY OUT THE
HAND THAT WE HAVE?
THIS IS NOT VIETNAM, MR. PRESIDENT. THIS IS NOT A COUNTRY THAT
STRETCHES FROM THE EQUIVALENT OF THE NORTH OF NEW ENGLAND OR
NEW ENGLAND ALL THE WAY DOWN TO THE TIP OF FLORIDA WITH A LAOS
{18:20:39} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ON CAMBODIA AND ITS BORDER WITH THE SUPERPOWER, FORMER SOVIET
UNION AND CHINA SITTING IN THE BACKGROUND SUPPLYING, PUSHING
DOWN THE HOE WHICH I MINUTE TRAIL, READY TO COME IN IF WE
THREATEN TO USE WHATEVER FORCE MAY BE AVAILABLE TO US. THIS IS
NOT THE UNITED STATES ESSENTIALLY ACTING ALONE. THIS IS A
COUNTRY THE SIZE OF SAN DIEGO COUNTY, THE SIZE OF LOS ANGELES
COUNTY. THE SIZE OF THE STATE OF CONNECTICUT. A PLACE THAT IS
ESSENTIALLY SURROUNDED BY -- SURROUNDED BY FRIENDLY PEOPLE. AND
{18:21:12} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
UNLIKE NORTH VIETNAM AND VIETNAM -- SOUTH VIETNAM AT THE TIME
-- UNLIKE THAT COUNTRY WHERE WE BECAME INVOLVED ON THE SIDE OF
THE ONE OF THE COMBATANTS, WHERE WE CHOSE TO CARRY ON YEARS OF
COLONIAL EFFORT THAT HAD BEEN MISCONSTRUED BY THE POPULATION
AND OUTRIGHT OPPOSED AND RE-VILD FOR YEARS, UNLIKE THE INADVISE
ABILITY OF HAVING BEEN EMBROILED, WE HAVE BEEN CAREFUL HERE TO
SUGGEST THAT WE ARE NOT FOR INDEPENDENCE. WE ARE NOT FOR THE
{18:21:45} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
K.L.A. RAVAGING THEIR COUNTRYSIDE ANYMORE THAN WE ARE FOR MR.
MILOSEVIC AND THE SERBS DOING SO. WE ARE FIGHTING FOR THE
STANDARDS OF INTERNATIONALLY ACCEPTED UNIVERSALLY ACCEPTED
BEHAVIOR. THAT COUNTRY AFTER COUNTRY HAS SIGNED ON TO THROUGH
THE UNITED NATIONS, THROUGH INTERNATIONAL LAW, THROUGH THEIR
OWN CONVENTIONS AND TREATIES AND THROUGH THEIR OWN STANDARDS OF
BEHAVIOR. AND MR. PRESIDENT, I CAN'T THINK OF ANYTHING MORE
RIGHT THAN TAKING A POSITION AGAINST THIS KIND OF THUGRY AND
{18:22:17} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THIS KIND OF AFFRONTERY TO THOSE STANDARDS AS WE LEAVE THE END
OF THIS CENTURY. NOW SOME PEOPLE SAY TO ME, WELL, SENATOR, WE
ARE GOING TO HAVE SOME PEOPLE THERE FOR A LONG TIME. AND MY
ANSWER IS, SO WHAT?
IF THAT'S WHAT IT TAKES IN ORDER TO TRY TO BEGIN TO ACCOMPLISH
A PRINCIPLE TT IS MORE LONG-LASTING, THEN SO BE IT. WHAT IS THE
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN 4,000 TROOPS WHO HAVE BEEN ASKED TO BE PART
OF A PEACEFUL EFFORT TO HOLD -- TO CHANGE THE STANDARDS OF
BEHAVIOR IN KOSOVO AS PART OF SOUTHEASTERN EUROPE, WHAT IS THE
{18:22:50} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THAT AND THE 500,000 TROOPS THAT WE HAD AT A
HIGH POINT IN EUROPE AFTER WORLD WAR II?
DON'T FORGET THE WAY MOST AMERICANS WERE SKEPTICAL OF HARRY
TRUMAN AND THE MARTIAL PLAN. HOW COULD THE UNITED STATES
AMERICA HAVING FOUGHT THE GERMANS TURN AROUND AND PUT MONEY
BACK INTO THEIR COUNTRY?
HOW ON EARTH COULD WE TRY TO BRING THE GERMANS INTO NATO?
WELL WHERE ARE WE TODAY?
{18:23:26} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
A UNITED GERMANY. THE BERLIN WALL GONE. BERLIN ABOUT TO BE THE
REUNITED CAPITAL OF GERMANY AND THE RESULT A GERMANS
PARTICIPATING WITH US IN STANDING UP AGAINST THE VERY KIND OF
THINGS THAT STAINED THE HISTORY OF THIS CENTURY AND OF THEIR
COUNTRY DURING WORLD WAR II. I MEAN IF THERE ISN'T A MORE
BEAUTIFUL CIRCLE IN TERMS OF UNDERSTANDING WHAT IS AT STAKE,
THAT'S IT. AND IT SEEMS TO ME, MR. PRESIDENT, THAT AN
{18:24:00} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
INVESTMENT OF SOME 5,000, 6,000, 7,000 TROOPS, IN SOUTHEASTERN
EUROPE TO GUARANTEE THAT GREECE, MACEDONIA, MONTENEGRO,
ALBANIA, CAN REMAIN STABLE AND NOT BE DRAGGED INTO THIS, THAT'S
WORTHWHILE. SOME WAY CH WOULD SAY SENATOR, WE HAVE HEARD THAT
COME NO ARGUMENT BEFORE. THAT'S THE ONE THEY GAVE US IN
VIETNAM. WELL, MR. PRESIDENT, ONCE AGAIN THE FACTS ON THE
GROUND ARE PROOFERG THE REALITY. CAN STPHIN HERE TELL ME WITH A
STRAIGHT FACE THAT MONTENEGRO WITHOUT OUR CURRENT EFFORTS AND
{18:24:30} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
INVOLVEMENT COULD POSSIBLY WITHSTAND THE STRAINS OF WHAT IS
HAPPENING?
CAN ANYBODY TELLS ME THAT IN THE ENTIRE POPULATION OF KOSOVO
WERE DRIVEN OUT INTO ALBANIA, THAT YOU WOULDN'T SOMEHOW SEE
MACEDONIA, GREECE, ALBANIA, DRAGGED INTO THIS AND ULTIMATELY
THERE ISN'T A PERSON IN THE SENATE WHO DOESN'T UNDERSTAND THAT
WE WOULD HAVE BEEN DRAGGED INTO IT, TOO. THERE WAS AN
INEVITABILITY THAT NATO WOULD BE CALLED ON TO TAKE A STAND. HOW
{18:25:02} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ASTONISHING IT IS THAT PEOPLE FIND SOME MORAL EQUIVALENCY HERE
BETWEEN SOME OF THE DIFFICULTIES OF WAGING A FAIRLY CAREFULLY
PROSECUTED -- NOT FAIRLY -- A CAREFULLY PROSECUTED WAR AND WHAT
WE ARE TRYING TO ACHIEVE. HOW ASTONISHING THAT PEOPLE ARE SO
CONCERNED ABOUT FINDING THAT EQUIVALENCY MEASURED AGAINST WHAT
MR. MILOSEVIC HAS DONE. NOW, I BELIEVE THAT IF WE WILL STAND
OUR GROUND AND BE STEADY AND SHOW THE RESOLVE THAT WE NEED TO
SHOW AS A GREAT COUNTRY AND LEADER OF THE FREE WORLD, THAT WE
{18:25:35} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HAVE THE ABILITY THROUGH THIS AIR CAMPAIGN TO ACHIEVE
ULTIMATELY THE DIPLOMATIC OUTCOME THAT WE WOULD LIKE TO
ACHIEVE. BUT WE HAVE ALSO LEARNED THROUGH ALL OF HISTORY, HENRY
KISSINGER AND RICHARD NIXON WILL TELL YOU IT THIS IN DEALING
WITH THE NORTH VIETNAMESE IN THE OLD CHRISTMAS BOMBING -- I
HATE IT HAD BACK THEN, BUT I HAVE COME TO UNDERSTAND THAT THERE
ARE IN FACT SOMETIMES THINGS THAT DO SPEAK AND MAKE A
DIFFERENCE TO CERTAIN PEOPLE. AND LIKE IT OR NOT AS I HAVE BEEN
DEEPLY INVOLVED IN THAT PART OF THE WORLD IN LAST YEARS, I
{18:26:06} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
REALIZE THAT DID HELP MAKE A DIFFERENCE TO PEOPLE'S DECISION TO
TRY TO COME TO SOME KIND OF RESOLUTION. THE FACT IS THAT WE ARE
NOW BACKING UP DIPLOMACY WITH FORCE. AND I HAVE HEARD SOME
PEOPLE CALL FOR A STAY IN THAT FORCE. THAT SOMEHOW IF WOULD BE
DIPLOMATICALLY NICE IF WE WERE TO TURN AROUND AND HAVE A
BOMBING PAUSE. WELL MY RESPONSE TO THAT, MR. PRESIDENT, IS VERY
SIMPLE. DO NOT LET THE POLITICIANS DECIDE AFTER SENDING THE
MILITARY PERSONNEL IN TO RISK THEIR LIVES, WHEN YOU ARE GOING
{18:26:39} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TO HAVE A BOMBING PAUSE WITHOUT ADEQUATELY PASSING IT BY THE
MILITARY TO KNOW THAT YOU ARE NOT GOING TO PUT YOUR PEOPLE AT
GREATER RISK IF YOU DON'T ACHIEVE YOUR GOALS AT THE BACKSIDE OF
IT. I CAN'T GO INTO ALL THE REASONS FOR THAT, BUT PEOPLE
UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE A GREAT DEAL OF OF REPERCUSSIONS TO A
BOMBING HALT THAT COULD HAVE GREATER JEOPARDY TO OUR PILOTS AND
GREATER JEOPARDY TO WHATEVER USE OF FORCE WE MAY NEED TO USE
DOWN THE ROAD. SO IMPERFECTLY COMMITTED TO HAVING THAT HAPPEN
{18:27:12} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AT THE RIGHT MOMENT, BUT I WANT US TO BE DRIVEN BY THE NEED TO
MEET OUR MILITARY GOALS AND NOT SIMPLY THE POLITICAL
IMPERATIVES AT THE TIME. FINALLY, MR. PRESIDENT, I HEAR
COLLEAGUES SAY WE WANT TO KNOW WHAT THE END GAME IS. WE WANT TO
KNOW WHAT THE STRATEGY IS. WE WANT TO KNOW -- WE EVEN HEARD OF
THE BOL HOFMT ON AMENDMENTS, ARE WE IN THIS TO WIN -- THERE ARE
ONLY THREE OR FOUR CHOICES IN THIS, MR. PRESIDENT. THAT'S ABOUT
IT. ANYBODY OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO FIGURE THEM OUT. YOU CANNOT
{18:27:47} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ACHIEVE YOUR GOALS, STOP THE BOMBING, AND NATO WOULD BE
IRREPARABLY DAMAGED IF NOT SIMPLY FINISHED. MR. MILOSEVIC CAN
DECLARE VICTORY, DO WHAT HE WANTS AND YOU WILL HAVE TO FORCE IN
THERE. THAT'S ONE CHOICE. ANOTHER CHOICE IS THAT YOU CAN
CONTINUE TO PROSECUTE THE AIR WAR AS YOU PRESS THE DIPLOMATIC
EFFORT WITH A GUARANTEE THAT YOU ARE GOING TO PRESS THAT UNTIL
YOU GET THAT EFFORT. AND THE THIRD IS -- AND IT IS THE BEST END
{18:28:20} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
GAME, BEST EXIT STRATEGY OF ALL -- YOU WIN. THAT'S THE EXIST
STRATEGY. YOU ACHIEVE THE SIMPLE, STATED GOAL OF RETURNING THE
KOSOVARS INTO KOSOVO, ALLOWING THEM TO LIVE IN A PROTECTED
STRUCTURE WHERE PEOPLE WON'T BE KILLING THEM. AND AT THE SAME
TIME, HAVE A FORCE THAT HAS THE CAPACITY TO PREVENT THE
U.C.K./K.L.A. FROM KILLING. ITS CALLED PEACE. I THINK THAT'S A
{18:28:52} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
GAME WORTH FIGHTING FOR. WHEN YOU MEASURE THE IMPORTANCE OF
EUROPE, THE INTERGRACE PROCESS NATO PERFORMED -- LET PLEA
MENTION QUICKLY -- TALK TO THE OFFICIALS IN SPAIN OR OTHER
PARTS OF EUROPE ABOUT THE IMPACT OF NATO AS AN ORGANIZING
PRINCIPLE, AS A MEANS OF HAVING BROUGHT COUNTRIES TOGETHER
AROUND DEMOCRACY. AND THEY WILL TELL YOU UNEQUIVOCALLY OF THE
DEGREE TO WHICH THE PROCESS OF MEETING, OF COMING TOGETHER, OF
{18:29:27} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
HAVING MUTUAL RESPONSIBILITIES OF NEEDING TO WORK TOGETHER, THE
WAYS IN WHICH THAT HAD A PROFOUND IMPACT ON THE CAPACITY OF
EUROPE TO DEVELOP SO THAT THEY NOW TALK ABOUT A COMMON -- HAVE
A COMMON MARKET, AND ARE WORKING ON THE LAST EFFORTS TO
INTEGRATION WITH MORE POWER IN BRUSSELS AND MORE CAPACITY AS A
EUROPEAN ENTITY TO SPEAK TO THE WORLD AND TO STAND TORE THESE
PRINCIPLES. ARE WE GOING TO DENY THAT TO SOUTHEASTERN EUROPE?
ARE WE GOING TO DENY THE LESSON THAT CAN COME OUT OF THIS TO
{18:29:58} (MR. KERRY) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BAGHDAD OR TO PYONGYANG, TRIPLY OR OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLD?
{END: 1999/05/03 TIME: 18-30 , Mon. 106TH SENATE, FIRST SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}