{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
DECADE, ONE GROUP OF PEOPLE REDUCING THE DEBT THAT MUCH. I'M
FINISHED, MR. PRESIDENT. I UNDERSTAND MY TIME HAS EXPIRED. I
THANK THE SENATE FOR PERMITTING ME TO DO THIS. I'LL COME TO THE
FLOOR AT A LATER TIME AND EXPRESS WHY I AM CONVINCED THAT THE
SURPLUSES ARE FOR REAL AND THAT AS A MATTER OF FACT THERE ARE
APT TO BE MORE RATHER THAN LESS OVER THE NEXT DECADE BECAUSE OF
WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE AMERICAN ECONOMY. I YIELD THE FLOOR.
{16:45:33 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM SOUTH CAROLINA IS
RECOGNIZED.
{16:45:37 NSP} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HOLLINGS: MR. PRESIDENT, I ASK CONSENT FOR AN ADDITIONAL
FIVE MINUTES ON MY ALLOTTED TIME.
{16:45:40 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{16:45:43 NSP} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HOLLINGS: I THANK THE DISTINGUISHED CHAIRMAN. THE REASON I
ASK FOR THE EXTRA TIME IS IN ADDRESSING THE SENATE WITH RESPECT
TO THE EDUCATIONAL SAVINGS ACT, I WAS GOING TO MAKE THE POINT,
OF COURSE, THAT WE WEREN'T SAVING AND WE HAD NO MONEY FOR THE
PARTICULAR ACT. AND THIS ACT ITSELF, OR PROPOSAL, WAS SOME $2
BILLION SHY. BUT THE DISTINGUISHED SENATOR FROM NEW MEXICO, THE
CHAIRMAN OF OUR BUDGET COMMITTEE, SAYS THE SENATOR FROM SOUTH
{16:46:15} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CAROLINA CALLS THE SURPLUS A DIFFERENT FROM WHAT HE CALLS A
SURPLUS AND WHAT HAVE YOU. LET ME GO RIGHT TO THE MINUTE HERE
ON 2/23, THE PUBLIC DEBT TO THE PENNY. MR. PRESIDENT, YOU CAN
GO TO YOUR INTERNET, AND UNDER THE LAW, THE DEPARTMENT OF
TREASURY LISTS TO THE PENNY AND BY THE MINUTE JUST EXACTLY WHAT
THE PUBLIC DEBT IS. IT ISN'T WHAT THE SENATOR FROM MEXICO CALLS
A DEBT OR SURPLUS. IT ISN'T WHAT THE SENATOR FROM SOUTH
{16:46:49} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CAROLINA CALLS A DEBT OR SURPLUS. IT'S WHAT WE ALL CALL A DEBT
UNDER THE PUBLIC LAW, AND THE PUBLIC DEBT TO THE MINUTE RIGHT
NOW -- I JUST GOT DID OFF THE INTERNET TWO MINUTES AGO. OUR
DEBT NOW IS $5,744,135,736,409.24. I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO
INCLUDE THIS IN THE RECORD AT THIS PARTICULAR POINT.
{16:47:20 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{16:47:28 NSP} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HOLLINGS: NOW, MR. PRESIDENT. WE FIND THAT WHILE IT'S UP TO
5.7, WE'VE GOT THE ARTICLE HERE FROM OCTOBER WHEN WE REPORTED
AT THE END OF THE FISCAL YEAR, SEPTEMBER 30, 1999, THAT FOR
THAT FISCAL YEAR YEAR, AND WE FIND THAT THE -- IT WAS DATED,
OH, OCTOBER 27, THE DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY SAID WE BEGAN THE
{16:47:59} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
YEAR WITH A DEBT OF $5,478,70400. AND WE ENDED THE FISCAL YEAR
1999, MR. PRESIDENT, NOT WITH A SURPLUS, BUT WITH A DEFICIT OF
$5,606,486,000,000. NOW IT'S NOT ANY MONKEYSHINES ON THIS
SENATOR'S PART. IT'S THE MONKEYSHINES ON THE MAJORITY OF THIS
BODY ALL RUNNING AROUND CALLING SURPLUS, SURPLUS, SURPLUS, WHEN
THERE ISN'T ANY SURPLUS. MR. PRESIDENT, LET'S GO DIRECTLY TO
{16:48:36} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
YESTERDAY'S RELEASE BY THE DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY, AND YOU'LL
FIND ON TABLE 6, PAGE 20, THAT THEY BEGAN THE YEAR WITH A DEBT
LIKE I'VE JUST REPORTED: $5,606,486,000,000. AND NOW AT THE
CLOSE OF THE MONTH -- THAT'S OF JANUARY -- AT THE CLOSE OF THAT
{16:49:10} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MONTH IT WAS $5,660,780,000,000. THE TREASURY DEPARTMENT HAS
ALREADY BORROWED THIS FISCAL YEAR, BEGINNING OCTOBER 1 LAST
YEAR, THE FISCAL YEAR 2000 IT'S ALREADY BORROWED $54 BILLION.
PLEASE LET'S TELL THE SECRETARY OF TREASURY THAT IF WE'VE GOT
SURPLUSES, QUIT BORROWING MONEY. WHAT'S HE BORROWING MONEY FOR?
IT'S TIME THIS CHARADE STOPS. LET'S PUT UP THE MAJOR CHART, AND
I'LL ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT THAT THE HOLLINGS BUDGET REALITIES
{16:49:42} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
-- I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO INCLUDE IN THE RECORD AT THIS
POINT THESE BUDGET REALITIES.
{16:49:50 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{16:49:52 NSP} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HOLLINGS: MR. PRESIDENT, WHEN THE DISTINGUISHED SENATOR,
THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BUDGET COMMITTEE, SAYS WE ENDED 1998 WITH
THE SO-CALLED BALANCED BUDGET ACT OF 1997, IT WAS SO
SUCCESSFUL, HE SAID WITH ALMOST $70 BILLION -- IT WAS 69.2 --
IN ORDER TO STICK THAT FIGURE HE HAD TO BORROW $178.2
BILLION FROM THE TRUST FUNDS: SOCIAL SECURITY, HIGHWAY,
{16:50:22} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
AIRPORT, MILITARY RETIREES, CIVIL SERVICE RETIREES AND
OTHERWISE. EVEN MEDICARE. AND THEN WHEN HE SAYS THAT LAST YEAR
WE ENDED UP WITH A SURPLUS OF $124 -- ALMOST $125 BILLION, YOU
HAD TO BORROW $251.8 BILLION FROM THE TRUST FUNDS. SO ACTUALLY
THE ACTUAL DEBT OR DEFICIT FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 1998 WAS $109
{16:50:56} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BILLION. AND FOR 1999 IT WAS $127.4 BILLION. THERE THEY ARE
RIGHT SO EVERYONE CAN SEE. NOW, YES, WE WERE REDUCING IN THAT
FOUR TO FIVE-YEAR PERIOD THE DECIT EACH YEAR UNTIL LAST YEAR.
FOR EXAMPLE, WE WENT FROM $109 UP TO 127.4. SO THAT WAS AN
INCREASE. MR. PRESIDENT, LET ME STATE VERY CLEARLY WHAT'S BEEN
{16:51:31} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
GOING ON, BECAUSE THEY USED TO TALK OF A UNIFIED BUDGET AND THE
UNIFIED DEFICIT. NOW THEY TALK OFF-BUDGET AND ON-BUDGET AND
PUBLIC DEBT, WHICH MISLEADS YOU BECAUSE THE OFFICIAL RECORD AND
LAW AND UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY -- NOT
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE WITH ESTIMATES AND GUESSES FOR THE
NEXT FIVE YEARS, NOT WHAT SENATOR HOLLINGS, NOT WHAT SENATOR
DOMENICI, BUT WHAT THE LAW IS AND THE ACTUAL ACCOUNTANTS. YOU
KNOW, ECONOMISTS CAN LIE, BUT ACCOUNTANTS CAN'T. THEY'VE GOT TO
{16:52:03} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
KEEP THE ACTUAL RECORD AND GIVE YOU THE TRUTH. SO LET ME GET
THOSE BORROWED TRUST FUNDS NOW AND SHOW JUST EXACTLY WHAT'S
GOING ON, BECAUSE THEY THOUGHT THAT THEY BORROWED -- THEY COULD
BORROW ENOUGH FROM THE OTHER TRUST FUNDS -- I'M SAYING OTHER
THAN SOCIAL SECURITY, AND AND THEREBY THEY COULD SAY, WELL,
WE'RE NOT GOING INTO SOCIAL SECURITY. OF COURSE THEY ARE. YOU
FIND OUT ALREADY THAT SOCIAL SECURITY, WE OWE AT THE END OF THE
{16:52:37} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FISCAL YEAR $855 BILLION TO SOCIAL SECURITY, $1554 PLUS 27 IS
181 TO MEDICARE. WE OWE MILITARY RETIREES 141 BILLION, CIVILIAN
RETIREMENT $492 BILLION. GO RIGHT ON DOWN. WE OWE
$1,869,000,000,000 TO THE TRUST FUNDS. YOU CAN TALK ABOUT THE
WONDERFUL RECORD AND ALL, BUT THIS IS WHAT THE SENATOR FROM
SOUTH CAROLINA IS LOOKING AT, BECAUSE THAT'S THE DEBT. WHEN THE
{16:53:10} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
YEAR 2013 COMES ALONG AND WE ALREADY OWE NOT JUST IN 2000 $1.9
TRILLION, BUT WE'LL OWE NEARLY $3 TRILLION OR $4 TRILLI TO
SOCIAL SECURITY, YOU'VE GOT TO GO OUT AND REDEEM THE BONDS.
THAT'S WHEN INFLATION GOES UP. THAT'S WHEN YOU START INTO THE
MARKET. OR OTHERWISE FOR MILITARY AND CIVILIAN RETIREMENT AND
WHAT HAVE YOU. NOW WHAT I'VE DONE IS GONE TO EACH ONE OF THE
TRUST FUNDS, AND WITH ME LIMITED TIME I WILL NOT INCLUDE ALL OF
THEM IN THE RECORD, BUT YOU TALK ABOUT HEREBY CREATED ON THE
{16:53:49} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BOOKS OF THE TREASURY OF THE UNITED STATES A TRUST FUND TO BE
KNOWN AS THE FEDERAL -- SURVIVORS AND SO FORTH AND SO ON. MR.
PRESIDENT, ON PAGE 2 OF THE ACT, SECTION (B) IT IS HEREBY
CREATED ON THE BOOKS OF THE TREASURY OF THE UNITED STATES A
TRUST FUND TO BE KNOWN AS THE FEDERAL DISABILITY INSURANCE
TRUST FUND. MR. PRESIDENT, WHEN WE DID THAT IN 1983 WE HAD A
GRADUATED PAYROLL TAX. THAT WAS 6.25 AND 6.25 BY THE COMPLWEER
{16:54:22} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FOR 12.5%. IT'S GONE UP, UP AND AWAY. YES, WITH HIGH
EMPLOYMENT, LOW UNEMPLOYMENT AND THE GOOD PROSPERITY THAT WE
HAVE HAD UNDER THE 1993 ACT -- NOT THE 1997 BALANCED BUDGET
THING THAT THEY'RE TRYING TO POLITICALLY GO TO THE PRESIDENTIAL
RACE AND TAKE CREDIT FOR. BUT UNDER THE 1993 ACT, MR.
PRESIDENT, WE HAVE REALLY TRIED OUR BEST TO RETAIN A STATUS
THERE OF TRUST WITHIN SOCIAL SECURITY, BECAUSE IN 1983 IF YOU
{16:54:54} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WOULD HAVE SAID WE'RE GOING TO VOTE THIS INCREASE TAXES FOR
FOOD STAMPS OR FOR KOSOVO OR FOR COURTHOUSES OR FOR DREDGING OR
FOR SHIPS AT THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE THAT THEY DON'T NEED AND
THOSE KIND OF THINGS, YOU COULDN'T HAVE GOTTEN A VOTE ON THE
FLOOR OF THE SENATE FOR THAT. WE PASSED IT IN TRUST TO BE USED,
BUT THEY HAVE BEEN SPENDING IT. AND THAT'S HOW THEY'RE SPENDING
IT. WE'VE GOT A WAY SO THEY WON'T SPEND IT, WHAT THEY CALL THE
LOCKBOX, AND THEY WON'T LET US VOTE ON IT ANY TIME, ANYWHERE
THAT THEY WANT TO VOTE ON A REAL LOCKBOX, CALL THIS SENATOR UP.
{16:55:32} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
I'VE HAD IT DRAWN UP BY THE ADMINISTRATOR OF SOCIAL SECURITY.
WE WORKED WITH HIM WHEN WE WERE ON THE BUDGET COMMITTEE
TOGETHER WITH THE SENATOR FROM NEW MEXICO, OUR PRESENT CHAIRMAN
OF THE BUDGET COMMITTEE, AND WE'LL HAVE A TRUE LOCKBOX WHERE
WE'LL STOP SPENDING SOCIAL SECURITY TRUST FUNDS. SO THERE IT
IS. I GOT ON AND IT WAS BLOCKED IN THE LONG -- A LONG TIME IN
THE BUDGET COMMITTEE IN 1990, BUT I FINALLY GOT IT OUT WITH ONE
{16:56:05} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DISSENTING VOTE, THE SENATOR FROM TEXAS, THAT WE PUT IT OFF
BUDGET AND QUIT USING SOCIAL SECURITY. THAT'S THE BEST WAY I
COULD DO IT. SECTION 1330 16R789 I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT --
SECTION 13 13301. I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO INCLUDE THIS PE.
{16:56:23 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{16:56:25 NSP} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HOLLINGS: IT'S AGAINST THE LAW ITSELF, BUT WE CONTINUE TO
VIOLATE THAT LAW. NOW EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT THE PRACTICE IN THE
GOVERNMENT IS UNDER THE PENSION ACT, THE 1994 PENSION REFORM
ACT THAT YOU CAN'T USE PENSION MONEY TO PAY OFF THE COMPANY
DEBT. WE KNOW DANNY MCLEAN, THE FAMOUS PITCHER OF THE DETROIT
TIGERS, HE DIDTHAT, WAS CHARGED WITH A FELONY, AND I THINK HE'S
PRESENTLY SERVING TIME. IF YOU CAN FIND OUT WHAT CELL HE'S IN,
{16:56:57} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TELL HIM NEXT TIME INSTEAD OF PAYING OFF THE COMPANY DEBT WITH
THE PENSION FUND TO RUN FOR THE UNITED STATES SENATE. INSTEAD
OF A JAIL TERM, YOU GET THE GOOD GOVERNMENT AWARD. YOU CAN COME
OUT HERE AND SAY, WELL, NOW THE PUBLIC DEBT IS DOWN, THE PUBLIC
DEBT IS DOWN. BUT IT'S LIKE TAKING YOUR VISA CARD AND YOUR
MASTER CARD PAYING OFF THE MASTER CARD WITH THE VISA CARD. YOU
STILL OWE THE SAME AMOUNT OF MONEY. THAT'S WHAT WE'VE BEEN
DOING. WE PLAY A SHABBY GAME UP HERE TALKING ABOUT SURPLUSES. I
HAD THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE COME OVER. HE DISAPPEARED THIS
{16:57:29} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MORNING. BUT YESTERDAY HE CAME TO MY OFFICE BEFORE HIS
APPEARANCE AND WANTED TO TALK ABOUT SURPLUS. AND I SAID, MR.
SECRETARY, WE DON'T HAVE ANY SURPLUS. I SAID, LOOK AT THE
PRESIDENT'S BUDGET. HERE IT IS RIGHT HERE ON PAGE 420. YOU CAN
SEE IT. MR. PRESIDENT, ON PAGE 420, AND I ASK 420, THIONE PAGE
BE DUPLICATED IN THE RECORD AT THIS PARTICULAR POINT.
{16:57:52 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{16:57:58 NSP} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. HOLLINGS: MR. PRESIDENT, NOT ANY SURPLUSES AS FAR AS THE
EYE CAN SEE, AS THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BUDGET COMMITTEE JUST SAID,
DEFICITS FAR AS THE EYE CAN SEE. TOTAL GROSS FEDERAL DEBT
STARTS OFF IN THE YEAR 2000, $5,606,000,000,000. NEXT YEAR IS
GOES UP $80 BILLION. IT ADDS UP $6.8 TRILLION. SO IT GOES UP
{16:58:29} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
$1.2 TRILLION OVER THIS PERIOD TO 2013 AS FAR AS THE EYE CAN
SEE. THE DEBT UP, UP, UP AND AWAY. NO, NO, NO SURPLUS. EVERY
YEAR SINCE PRESIDENT CLINTON'S BEEN IN OFFICE WE'VE SPENT MORE
IN THE CONGRESS THAN THE PRESIDENT'S BUDGET, THIS BUDGET I GOT
IN MY HAND. AND BOTH SIDES ARE NOW CALLING FOR A TAX CUT. THE
DEMOCRATIC SIDE IS TALKING ABOUT 350. THE REPUBLICAN SIDE IS
{16:59:01} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TALKING ABOUT 750 OR 900. I'LL NEVER FORGET, MR. PRESIDENT,
WHEN THE PRESIDENT WAS GOING TO GIVE HIS STATE OF THE UNION
ADDRESS, THE DISTINGUISHED MAJORITY LEADER, THE SENATOR FROM
MISSISSIPPI, HE SAID, GOOD GOSH, THAT'S GOING TO COST US $1
BILLION A MINUTE! WELL, THE DISTINGUISHED PRESIDENT TALKED FOR
AN HOUR AND A HALF. THAT'S $90 BILLION. GEORGE W. -- GEORGE W.
HAS GOT A $90 BILLION A YEAR, $900 BILLION OVER THE TEN YEARS
{16:59:34} (MR. HOLLINGS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TAX CUT. MR. PRESIDENT, WE'RE SPENDING THAT KIND OF MONEY RIGHT
NOW, 90 AND 90, $180 BILLION PLUS. WE'RE SPENDING $365 BILLION.
YOU KNOW I CAN GIVE YOU THE REPUBLICAN PROGRAM AND THE
DEMOCRATIC PROGRAM AND HAVE $185 BILLION TO PAY DOWN THE DEBT
WITH THE $365 BILLION WE PAY IN INTEREST COSTS ON THE NATIONAL
DEBT?
{END: 2000/02/24 TIME: 17-00 , Thu. 106TH SENATE, SECOND SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}