{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}
ENTER AS PRIVATE-PAYING PATIENTS EXHAUST THEIR PERSONAL
SAVINGS, LOSE THEIR HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE DURING THEIR STAY
AND BECOME MEDICAID BENEFICIARIES. MEDICAID IS FOR MOST
RETIREES THE LAST REFUGE OF FINANCIAL SUPPORT. ON APRIL THE
10TH, THE FLORIDA MEDICAID BUREAU RESPONDED TO EVIDENCE OF
{18:15:35} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MEDICAID DUMPING IN TAMPA BY LEVYING A STEEP $260,000 FINE
AGAINST THE TAMPA NURSING HOME. THAT WAS STRONG AND APPROPRIATE
ACTION, BUT IT WAS ONLY A PARTIAL SOLUTION. MEDICAID FUNDING IS
A SHARED RESPONSIBILITY, SHARED BETWEEN THE STATES AND THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. AND WHILE THE MOST EGREGIOUS INCIDENT
OCCURRED IN FLORIDA, MEDICAID DUMPING IS NOT THE PROBLEM OF A
SINGLE STATE. WHILE NURSING HOMES WERE ONCE LOCALLY-RUN,
{18:16:06} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
FAMILY-OWNED, THEY ARE INCREASINGLY ADMINISTERED BY MULTISTATE,
MULTIFACILITY CORPORATIONS THAT HAVE THE POWER TO AFFECT SENIOR
AS CROSS THE UNITED STATES. -- SENIORS ACROSS THE UNITED
STATES. MR. PRESIDENT, LET ME ALSO POINT OUT THAT THE LARGE
MAJORITY OF NURSING HOMES IN AMERICA TREAT THEIR RESIDENTS
WELL. THEY ARE RESPONSIBLE COMMUNITY CITIZENS. OUR BILL IS
DESIGNED SOLE 8 TO PREVENT POTENTIAL FUTURE ABUSES BY THE BAD
APPLES. THIS BILL IS SIMPLE AND FAIR. IT WOULD PROHIBIT CURRENT
{18:16:41} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MEDICAID BENEFICIARIES OR THOSE WHO SPEND DOWN TO MEDICAID FROM
BEING EVICTED FROM THEIR HOMES. THAT IS A CRUCIAL POINT, MR.
PRESIDENT. ADELLA MONJOVI IS NOT JUST A BENEFICIARY. SHE IS A
MOTHER. SHE IS A GRANDMOTHER. AND TO ADELLA MONJOVI, THE
REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER OF TAMPA IS NOT AN
ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY. TO ADELLA MONJOVI, IT IS HOME. THIS
{18:17:15} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
IS THE PLACE WHERE SHE WANTS AND DESERVES, LIKE ALL SENIORS, TO
LIVE THE REST OF HER LIFE WITH THE SECURITY OF KNOWING THAT SHE
WILL NOT BE EVICTED. AND THROUGH THE PASSAGE OF THIS BILL, MR.
PRESIDENT, WE CAN PROVIDE THAT SECURITY TO ADELLA MONJOVI AND
TO ALL OF OUR NATION'S SENIORS. MR. PRESIDENT, I, THEREFORE,
SUBMIT AND ASK FOR ITS IMMEDIATE REFERRAL LEGISLATION
{18:17:50} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
INTRODUCED BY MYSELF, JOINED BY SENATORS CHAFEE, JOHNSON,
HARKIN AND GRASSLEY.
{18:17:58 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE CLERK -- THE BILL WILL BE RECEIVED
AND APPROPRIATELY REFERRED.
{18:18:01 NSP} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. GRAHAM: THANK YOU, MR. PRESIDENT. I ALSO ASK UNANIMOUS
CONSENT THAT THE ARTICLE TO WHICH I REFERRED FROM THE APRIL 7,
1998, "WALL STREET JOURNAL" BE INCLUDED IN THE RECORD
IMMEDIATELY AFTER MY REMARKS.
{18:18:16 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{18:18:19 NSP} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. GRAHAM: THANK YOU, MR. PRESIDENT. MR. PRESIDENT, I WOULD
NOW JUST RETURN TO A STATEMENT ON ANOTHER SUBJECT, THE SUBJECT
OF NORTH ATLANTIC TREATY ORGANIZATION EXPANSION. APPROXIMATELY
TEN DAYS AGO, THE SENATE VOTED TO RATIFY THE ACCESSION OF
POLAND, HUNGARY AND THE CZECH REPUBLIC INTO THE NORTH ATLANTIC
TREATY ALLIANCE. I JOINED 79 OF MY COLLEAGUES IN SUPPORTING
THIS HISTORIC MEASURE. THIS VOTE OCCURRED AT THE END OF A WEEK
{18:18:51} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
OF DEBATE IN THE SENATE ON THIS MATTER BUT IT SIGNALED THE
BEGINNING OF AN EQUALLY IMPORTANT PROCESS, THAT OF REDOUBLING
OUR DIPLOMATIC EFFORTS TO BUILD GREATER TRUST AND COOPERATION
WITH RUSSIA. MANY WHO ARGUED AGAINST EXPANDING THE ALLIANCE DID
SO ON THE ASSUMPTION THAT SUCH EXPANSION WOULD SOUR OUR
RELATIONS WITH RUSSIA AND REDUCE THE CHANCES FOR PROGRESS IN
ARMS CONTROL. I BELIEVE THAT THE CONSEQUENCES OF EXPANDING NATO
{18:19:24} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
ARE STILL UNDETERMINED AND THAT THOSE CONSEQUENCES WILL DEPEND
LARGELY ON HOW WE CONDUCT OUR RELATIONS WITH RUSSIA IN THE
COMING YEARS. RUSSIA CURRENTLY HAS 6,680 STRATEGIC NUCLEAR
WARHEADS, THOUSANDS OF TACTICAL WARHEADS WARHEADS, AND HUNDREDS
OF TONS OF FISSILE MATERIAL THAT COULD BE USED TO PRODUCE
ADDITIONAL NUCLEAR WARHEADS. ASSURING THAT THESE WEAPONS ARE
PROPERLY CONTROLLED AND THAT FURTHER REDUCTIONS IN STRATEGIC
{18:19:57} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WARHEADS ARE MADE IS ONE OF THE PRINCIPAL NATIONAL SECURITY
INTERESTS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. THAT IS WHY IT IS
CRITICAL THAT WE TAKE GREATER STEPS TO REACH OUT TO RUSSIA AND
TO DEMONSTRATE OUR DESIRE TO WORK WITH RUSSIANS IN A
COOPERATIVE FASHION. MR. PRESIDENT, IN 1996, I WAS A MEMBER OF
THE COMMISSION ON AMERICA'S NATIONAL INTERES THIS COMMISSION,
{18:20:30} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WHICH PUBLISHED ITS REPORT IN JULY OF 1996, INCLUDED MY
COLLEAGUES, SENATOR MCCAIN AND ROBERTS AND FORMER SENATOR NUNN
AS WELL AS OTHER FOREIGN POLICY EXPERTS. THE COMMISSION WAS
CHARGED WITH IDENTIFYING AMERICA'S NATIONAL INTERESTS IN THE
POST-COLD WAR ERA. THE COMMISSION SPECIFICALLY ADDRESSED THE
QUESTION OF EXPANDING NATO AND SAID -- QUOTE -- "NATO
ENLARGEMENT IS IN THE UNITED STATES INTEREST BUT IT WILL BE
ESSENTIAL TO MANAGE THE PROCESS IN WAYS THAT TAKE ACCOUNT OF
{18:21:06} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
RUSSIAN CONCERNS." WE HAVE ALREADY TAKEN SEVERAL IMPORTANT
STEPS, INCLUDING THE U.S.-RUSSIAN FOUNDING ACT, THE NUNN-LUGAR
PROGRAMS, AND THE PARTNERSHIP FOR PEACE. INDEED, U.S. AND
RUSSIAN FORCES HAVE SERVED SIDE BY SIDE IN BOSNIA. BUT, MR.
PRESIDENT, THERE IS MUCH MORE TO BEONE. WE MUST SEEK NEW WAYS
TO COOPERATE AND BUILD TRUST BETWEEN OUR TWO GREAT NATIONS.
WHAT IS NEEDED IS A SUSTAINED, CREATIVE PROGRAM TO OUTREACH, TO
{18:21:43} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
DEMONSTRATE THAT NATO EXPANSION IS NOT A HOSTILE ACT DESIGNED
TO BUILD A NEW IRON OCCUR DANE -- CURTAIN CLOSER TO RUSSIA'S
BORDERS. NOR WAS IT A SIGNAL THAT WE HAVE LOST INTEREST IN
HELPING RUSSIA WORK THROUGH ONE OF THE MOST SIGNIFICANT
SOCIETAL TRANSFORMATIONS IN HISTORY. ONE SUGGESTION FOR
CREATIVE OUT OUTREACH INVOLVES THE YEAR 2000 PROBLEM, WHICH IS
SOMETIMES REFERRED TO AS Y2K. WE HAVE UNDERTAKEN A MASSIVE
{18:22:20} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
EFFORT TO DEAL WITH THIS ISSUE OF THE RELIABILITY OF OUR
INFORMATION SYSTEMS AFTER THE YEAR 2000. THE DEFENSE DEPARTMENT
HAS ALONE IDENTIFIED 2,800 CRITICAL SYSTEMS THAT MUST BE CURED
BEFORE Y2K. THE RUSSIANS HAVE NOT YET DETERMINED IF THEY HAVE A
SIMILAR PROBLEM, NOT TO MENTION THEY HAVE NOT COMMENCED THE
PROCESS OF ATTEMPTING TO FIX IT. IT IS IN OUR INTEREST TO WORK
{18:22:54} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WITH RUSSIA TO HELP THEM IDENTIFY THE SCOPE OF THEIR Y2K
PROBLEM AND TO REMEDY IT. IT WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL IN THE
EXTREME TO OUR INTERESTS IF THE RUSSIANS AWOKE ON THE MORNING
OF JANUARY 1, 2000, WITH BLANK SCREENS ON THEIR EARLY-WARNING
RADARS AND COMMAND-AND-CONTROL SYSTEMS. WHAT COULD BE EVEN
WORSE IS THAT IF THEIR CRITICAL SYSTEMS CONTINUED TO OPERATE
BUT WITH FALSE AND CORRUPTED INFORMATION INFORMATION. IT IS IN
BOTH U.S. AND RUSSIAN INTERESTS FOR US TO HAVE THE HIGHEST
LEVEL OF CONFIDENCE IN OUR COMMAND-AND-CONTROL SYSTEMS AND TO
{18:23:30} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BUILD CONFIDENCE THROUGH TRANSPARENCY AND OTHER COOPERATIVE
MEASURES. ANOTHER AREA THAT PRESENTS OPPORTUNITIES FOR
SUSTAINED OUT OUTREACH TO RUSSIA IS IN INTERPARLIAMENTARY
COOPERATION COOPERATION. EACH MEMBER OF CONGRESS, REGARDLESS OF
THEIR FEELINGS ON NATO ENLARGEMENT, SHOULD MAKE AN EFFORT TO
REACH OUT TO OUR COUNTERPARTS IN RUSSIA TO FOSTER GREATER TRUST
AND COOPERATION. DURING THE COLD WAR, INTERMITTENT ATTENTION
WAS PAID TO INTERPARLIAMENTARY RELATIONS RELATIONS.
{18:24:07} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
UNFORTUNATELY, SINCE 1989, RUSSIANS BELIEVE THAT U.S. INTEREST
IN SUCH CONTACTS HAS DWINDLED. NOW SOME EFFORTS AT
INTERGOVERNMENTAL COOPERATION ARE UNDERWAY.
I WOULD CITE TWO OF THESE: THE ASPEN INSTITUTE HAS HELD YEARLY
MEETINGS SINCE 1994, MEETINGS THAT BRING TOGETHER U.S. AND
RUSSIAN PARLIAMENTARIANS. SPEAKER GINGRICH HAS ESTABLISHED AN
INITIATIVE UNDER THE DIRECTION OF CONGRESSMAN KURT WELDON, TO
REACH OUT TO THE RUSSIAN DUMA. BUT MORE SHOULD BE DONE. AND
{18:24:39} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
BECAUSE OF ITS RESPONSIBILITY TO PROVIDE ADVICE AND CONSENT ON
TREATIES, THE SENATE HAS A SPECIAL RESPONSIBILITY TO PLAY A
ROLE IN THIS EFFORT. WE CAN BE INSTRUMENTAL IN CREATING AN
ENVIRONMENT IN WHICH THE RUSSIAN DUMA WOULD SEEK TO COOPERATE
WITH THE UNITED STATES. IN FACT, THE COMMISSION ON AMERICA'S
NATIONAL INTEREST SPOKE OF -- QUOTE -- "DIRECT CONTACT,
ENGAGING RUSSIA IN WAYS THAT DEMONSTRATE THE BENEFITS OF
NONAGGRESSIVE BEHAVIOR." AS ONE OF THE PRINCIPAL WAYS THAT WE
{18:25:13} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
CAN PROMOTE A BENIGN RUSSIAN FOREIGN POLICY. THESE TYPES OF
CONTACTS WILL ALSO SERVE TO STRENGTHEN RUSSIAN DEMOCRACY. ALL
OF THESE ARE VERY MUCH IN THE UNITED STATES NATIONAL INTEREST.
WHILE I SUPPORTED NATO EXPANSION, I WAS CONCERNED THAT THE
SENATE ENTERED INTO THE DEBATE AFTER THE UNITED STATES HAD
ALREADY COMMITTED TO EXPANDING THE ALLIANCE. THE VOTE FOR NATO
EXPANSION IN THE SENATE WAS BIPARTISAN, BUT, IN MY JUDGMENT,
{18:25:48} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE SUPPORT WAS NOT VERY DEEP. MANY SENATORS, INCLUDING MYSELF
MYSELF, FELT THAT WE WERE TOO DEEPLY COMMITTED TO REJECT
EXPANSION. CALCULATING THE COSTS OF NONACTION AT THIS POINT
WOULD BE GREATER THAN THE RISK OF ACTION. PREVENTING A
REPETITION OF THIS AND IF AND WHEN THERE IS TO BE ADDITIONAL
EXPANSION OF THE NATO ALLIANCE IS CRITICAL. A SERIOUS DIALOGUE
MUST INVOLVE CONGRESS, THE WHITE HOUSE AND, MOST IMPORTANTLY,
THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. AND THAT DIALOGUE MUST TAKE PLACE BEFORE
{18:26:20} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
COMMITMENTS ARE MADE. AN EXAMPLE OF THIS WAS THE STRUCTURED
CONSULTATIONS THAT TOOK PLACE BETWEEN A CONGRESS WHICH WAS
SHIFTING IN TERMS OF ITS PARTISAN LEADERSHIP AND A DEMOCRATIC
PRESIDENT IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING THE END OF THE SECOND WORLD
WAR. IN FACT, SENATORS TOM CONLEY AND ARTHUR VAND ENBERG, WHO
WERE ALTERNATELY CHAIRMAN AND RANKING MEMBER OF THE SENATE
FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMITTEE, WERE PERSONALLY INVOLVED IN
{18:26:55} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
NEGOTIATING MANY OF THE POST-WAR TREATIES, SPENDING MUCH OF
1946, FOR INSTANCE, NOT IN THE SENATE CHAMBERS BUT OVERSEAS
INVOLVED IN THE DETAILED NEGOTIATION OF WHAT WAS TO BECOME THE
FRAMEWORK OF OUR COLD WAR STRATEGY. PRESIDENT TRUMAN USED THESE
CLOSE CONSULTATIONS TO BUILD A BIPARTISAN CONSENSUS THAT LED,
AMONG OTHER THINGS, TO THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE NORTH ATLANTIC
TREATY ORGANIZATION IN 1949 AND THE STRONG VOTE OF SUPPORT
{18:27:27} (MR. GRAHAM) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
WHICH THAT TREATY RECEIVED FROM THE UNITED STATES SENATE.
DIVIDED GOVERNMENT RAISES THE LEVEL OF PARTISANSHIP ON DOMESTIC
ISSUES. AS A NATION, WE CANNOT ACCEPT SIMILAR DESTABILIZATION
OF OUR INTERNATIONAL VALUES, GOALS AND RESPONSIBILITIES. IT
WILL BE ON OUR ABILITY TO MEET THOSE CHALLENGES THAT THE
ULTIMATE TEST OF THE WISDOM OF OUR VOTE TO EXPAND THE NORTH
ATLANTIC TREATY ORGANIZATION WILL BE PREDICATED. THANK YOU, MR.
PRESIDENT.
{18:27:57 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WHO SEEKS TIME?
{18:27:58 NSP} (A SENATOR) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
A SENATOR: MR. PRESIDENT?
{18:28:00 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: THE SENATOR FROM MINNESOTA.
{18:28:03 NSP} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. GRAMS: MR. PRESIDENT, I ASK UNANIMOUS CONSENT THAT I BE
ALLOWED TO SPEAK AS IF IN MORNING BUSINESS FOR UP TO FIVE
MINUTES.
{18:28:07 NSP} (THE PRESIDING OFFICER) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: WITHOUT OBJECTION.
{18:28:12 NSP} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MR. GRAMS: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MR. PRESIDENT, I WANTED TO RISE
TODAY TO RECOGNIZE AND ALSO TO HELP CELEBRATE THE 140TH
ANNIVERSARY OF MY HOME STATE OF MINNESOTA'S ADMISSION INTO THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. NOW, LET ME BEGIN, MR. PRESIDENT, BY
QUOTING JAMES HILL, THE FOUNDER OF GREAT NORTHERN RAILROAD AND
ONE OF MINNESOTA'S TRUE PIONEERS. IT IS SAID THAT MR. HILL
PROCLAIMED HIS REASONS FOR LIVING AND WORKING IN MINNESOTA BY
SAYING, "YOU CAN'T INTEREST ME IN ANY PROPOSITION IN ANY PLACE
WHERE IT DOESN'T SNOW." WELL, MINNESOTA HAS NEVER HAD A
SHORTAGE OF SNOW, WHICH, DEPENDING ON WHO YOU ASK AND JUST HOW
{18:28:42} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MANY MONTHS THE WINTER HAS LINGERED, IS CONSIDERED EITHER A
BLESSING OR A CURSE. BUT EVEN MR. HILL RECOGNIZED THAT SNOW IS
JUST ONE OF MINNESOTA'S MANY RICHES. EVER SINCE WORD BEGAN TO
SPREAD LAST CENTURY ABOUT A NORTHERN LAND OF PROMISE AND
PROSPERITY, A LAND WITH ABUNDANT NATURAL RESOURCES AND
INDESCRIBABLE BEAUTY, PEOPLE HAVE TRAVELED TO MINNESOTA TO
LIVE, TO WORK AND TO PROSPER. AND DURING ITS 140 YEARS OF
STATEHOOD, MINNESOTA HAS PRODUCED SOME OF THE COUNTRY'S BEST
AND BRIGHTEST, MAKING IT A WORLD LEADER IN AGRICULTURE,
{18:29:14} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
TECHNOLOGY, MEDICINE AND IN BUSINESS. ALONG THE WAY,
MINNESOTANS HAVE ENDURED COLD WINTERS, HOT SUMMERS, FLOODS,
TORNADOES AND ANY OTHER NATURAL DISASTER MOTHER NATURE HAS
THROWN HER WAY. AND AT NO TIME HAS THE RESOLVE 6 OUR PEOPLE
BEEN MORE TESTED THAN WITH THE NATURAL DISASTERS THAT HAVE
PLAGUED OUR STATE DURING THE LAST TWO YEARS. LAST SPRING, THE
PEOPLE OF NORTHWESTERN MINNESOTA WERE HIT WITH THE WORST
FLOODING IN OUR STATE'S HISTORY. EARLIER THIS SPRING, THE
RESIDENTS OF SOUTH CENTRAL MINNESOTA LIVED THROUGH ONE OF THE
LARGEST TORNADOES EVER TO HIT OUR STATE. YET IN BOTH CASES,
{18:29:48} (MR. GRAMS) { NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT }
MINNESOTANS WORKED TOGETHER TO REBUILD AND TO RECOVER. OUR --
AND MINNESOTA IS STRONGER FOR THOSE EFFORTS. YOU KNOW,
STRANGERS THAT LABELED THAT WILLINGNESS TO STEP FORWARD AND
HELP ONE ANOTHER AS "MINNESOTA NICE." WE THINK THAT IT'S JUST
THE WAY THINGS OUGHT TO BE.
{END: 1998/05/11 TIME: 18-30 , Mon. 105TH SENATE, SECOND SESSION}
{ NOT AN OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF THE SENATE PROCEEDINGS.}