Rep. Christopher H. Smith, Co-Chairman May 3, 2002 www.csce.gov
GEORGIAN GOVERNMENT COMPLICITY IN MOB VIOLENCE AGAINST MINORITY RELIGIOUS GROUPS
By H. Knox Thames
CSCE Counsel
Over the past two years, mob violence against minority religious groups has plagued the Republic of Georgia, a participating State in the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) since 1992. A country of five million people, Georgia has seen more than its share of sectarian violence, as individuals propagating religious chauvinism conduct a campaign of brutality against other religious communities. Adding to this, police units have reportedly participated in violence against minority religious groups, or have failed to respond to attacks in an adequate fashion. As a result, a number of minority religious communities remain at risk in Georgia today as depredations continue with impunity.
As a participating OSCE State, Georgia pledged to uphold freedom of thought, conscience and religion or belief to all individuals without distinction. As stated in the 1983 Madrid Concluding Document, participating States “agree to take the action necessary to ensure the freedom of the individual to profess and practice, alone or in community with others, religion or belief acting in accordance with the dictates of his own conscience.”
Since 1999, organized mob brutality against minority religious groups has gradually escalated, with the Jehovah’s Witnesses being a repeated target. As stated by the Department of State’s 2001 International Religious Freedom Report, local “police and security officials at times harassed nontraditional religious minority groups and were complicit or failed to respond to attacks by Orthodox extremists against Jehovah’s Witnesses and other nontraditional religious minorities.” Despite the inability of Georgian authorities to incarcerate the perpetrators, the 1995 Georgian Constitution does guarantee protection.
Despite constitutional protections, over the past two years, approximately 80 attacks against Jehovah’s Witnesses have taken place, mostly led by Vasili Mkalavishvili, a defrocked Georgian Orthodox priest, and Paata Bluashvili, the director of the Orthodox “Jvari” Union. While victims have filed more than 700 criminal complaints, the authorities have not responded, leaving the perpetrators free to repeat their attacks.
Reports give startling examples of individuals being dragged by their hair into a group, only to be pummeled with punches, kicks and clubs. Buses taking Jehovah’s Witnesses to various events have been stopped by police, and then attacked by Mkalavishvili’s and Bluashvili’s mob. In September 2001, Bluashvili led an attack during a Jehovah’s Witness religious service, with some of his militants brandishing firearms. In addition, Mkalavishvili, viewing himself as a pugilist defending Georgian Christianity, reportedly declared Jehovah’s Witnesses “should be shot, we must annihilate them.”
Soon thereafter, with the violence steadily increasing and the government declining to intervene, Jehovah’s Witnesses conducted their activities in private, and for four months no violence occurred. However, in April of this year, that calm was shattered when Mkalavishvili’s and Bluashvili’s mob attacked on two separate occasions private homes that were hosting meetings. Considering the brutality Mkalavishvili and Bluashvili have displayed, it is astonishing that to date no fatalities have occurred.
While the Jehovah’s Witnesses have borne the brunt of these attacks, other minority religious communities have also suffered under this vigilantism. Last year, during choir practice of a Pentecostal church, Mkalavishvili’s militants raided the building, seriously injuring twelve church members. A mob exceeding 100 hooligans targeted an Evangelical church two days before Christmas 2001, clubbing members and stealing property. In February of this year, Mkalavishvili’s mob tried to raze a warehouse owned by the Baptist Union, burning Bibles and religious materials. Mkalavishvili organized approximately 150 followers in three buses to accomplish this goal. In addition, Mkalavishvili has targeted the offices of government ombudswoman Nana Devdariani, the Tbilisi based NGO Liberty Institute, and the Rezonansi newspaper. The police have consistently refused to restrain the attackers, with only a few exceptions to note.
Unfortunately, the judicial system has proven equally inept. On January 25th, prosecutors commenced legal proceedings against Mkalavishvili and one of his lieutenants for two mob attacks, although the minor charges brought do not reflect the gravity of their crimes. Yet, since the first hearing, the commitment of Georgian officials to vigorously prosecute Mkalavishvili has been evanescent. The case has been postponed five times, most recently due to the prosecutor failing to appear. These delays can be attributed to Mkalavishvili’s mob, sometimes numbering in the hundreds, maintaining a menacing presence both outside and inside the Didube-Chugureti District Court. At several hearings, large numbers have crashed into the court while carrying wooden and iron crosses, as well as banners with offensive slogans. Obviously feeling immune from government action, Mkalavishvili has used the courtroom itself as a platform, reportedly threatening lawyers and victims through a megaphone. Evidence of these events is readily available as local television stations are usually tipped in advance, airing footage of the attacks and interviews of Mkalavishvili and Bluashvili on the nightly news.
Despite fervent appeals by victims and their lawyers, the police have refused to provide adequate courtroom security. Attorneys for the victims even petitioned the court for assistance, only for the judge to decide no more than 10 police officers would be permitted. Inexcusably, the judge put no limit on the number of Mkalavishvili’s followers granted access to the courtroom. In a stark contradiction, more than 200 police and a SWAT team were ordered to protect officials from the Ministry of Interior when Mkalavishvili was brought to trial under different charges.
In sum, the Georgian Government is proving ineffective in ameliorating the situation and protecting its citizens, regardless of their religious faith, from mob violence. Meanwhile, President Eduard Shevardnadze has held meetings with faith communities to demonstrate religious tolerance.
He has also issued a presidential decree calling for the Ministry of Interior to take action, but by allowing lawless bands of militants to attack peaceful gatherings, his illusory actions are speaking louder than his words. By allowing the strength of the police and judicial systems to become a farce, it will only further encourage contravention of Georgian laws. However, despite actions demonstrated to date, the Georgian Government can end the attacks and bring to justice the perpetrators of this brutality.
Related documents on the Helsinki Commission website (http://www.csce.gov):
The United States Helsinki Commission, an independent federal agency, by law monitors and encourages progress in implementing provisions of the Helsinki Accords. The Commission, created in 1976, is composed of nine Senators, nine Representatives and one official each from the Departments of State, Defense and Commerce.
Moscow Should Engage the OSCE in Resolving the Chechen Problem Press Release
Dec 22, 2003
Romania: Moving Toward NATO and the EU Article
Dec 19, 2003
Letter to The Honorable Colin L. Powell Dated 12/19/03 Article
Dec 10, 2003
Helsinki Commission Members Engage Government Leaders
at Annual Human Rights Review Article
Dec 3, 2003
Commission Hearing Looked Ahead
to Maastricht Ministerial Article
Nov 26, 2003
Helsinki Commission Reviews
OSCE Dutch Leadership Article
Nov 25, 2003
Further Assault Against Activists in Belarus Article
Nov 10, 2003
CANCELLED
Azerbaijan's Flawed Presidential Election
Focus of Helsinki Commission Hearing Press Release
Oct 28, 2003
Criminal Defamation and "Insult" Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech Developments in Armenia
Article
Oct 28, 2003
Democracy and Human Rights in Mediterranean
Focus of Commission Briefing Article
Oct 10, 2003
Helsinki Commission Chairman Holds
Teleconference on Azerbaijani Presidential Election Press Release
Oct 1, 2003
Helsinki Commission Briefing Features
Democracy and Human Rights in the Mediterranean Press Release
Sep 30, 2003
Helsinki Commission Briefing Highlights
Romania's Road to NATO and the EU Press Release
Sep 4, 2003
U.S. Policy Under Review
by Helsinki Commission
Press Release
Jul 30, 2003
Chairman Smith Welcomes Romania's Proposed
Improvements to Free Speech Protections Press Release
Jun 2, 2003
Human Rights in Chechnya
Focus of Helsinki Commission Briefing Article
May 8, 2003
Co-Chairman Smith Hails Incorporation of
Key Provisions of Belarus Democracy Act
into Foreign Relations Act Press Release
May 8, 2003
Violence Again Overrules Order in Georgian Court;
Helsinki Commission Members React Press Release
May 3, 2003
United States Helsinki Commission Recognizes
World Press Freedom Day Press Release
May 2, 2003
Helsinki Commission Decries Central Asia’s
Imprisoned Press Freedoms Press Release
May 2, 2003
Helsinki Commission Co-Chairman
Urges Romania, Other Countries to
Repeal Criminal Defamation & Insult Laws
Press Release
Apr 30, 2003
Murdered and Imprisoned Journalists
Remembered on World Press Freedom Day Press Release
Apr 3, 2003
Belarus Democracy Act of 2003
Moves Closer to Passage
Press Release
Mar 27, 2003
Helsinki Commission Leaders Introduce
“Belarus Democracy Act of 2003”
Press Release
Feb 13, 2003
Helsinki Commission Leaders Call for
“Accurate Assessment” of Chechnya Situation Press Release
Feb 10, 2003
Moscow Should Engage the OSCE in Resolving the Chechen Problem (Russian) Article
Jan 15, 2003
Hearing Surveys Human Rights
in Republic of Georgia Article
Dec 31, 2002
Democracy and Human Rights Trends in Eurasia and East Europe: A Decade of Membership in the Organization (Report Only) Article
Dec 13, 2002
Commission Staff Meet with Georgian Officials
while Religious Persecution Persists
Article
Nov 14, 2002
Co-Chairman Smith's Submitted Statement
to New Atlantic Initiative Conference on Belarus Press Release
Nov 8, 2002
Turkey’s Post-Election Future
Focus of Helsinki Commission Briefing Press Release
Oct 29, 2002
Co-Chairman Smith Suspicious of
Charge Against Journalist in Kazakhstan Press Release
Oct 18, 2002
Shevardnadze Urged to Act on Violence
Against Congregations Press Release
Oct 8, 2002
Helsinki Commission Briefing to Preview
Reports on Anti-Semitism, Nationalism,
Xenophobia and Intolerance in Today’s Russia Press Release
Oct 7, 2002
Belarus Religion Law
Prompts Reaction from
Helsinki Commission Co-Chairman Press Release
Sep 20, 2002
Helsinki Commission Releases
U.S. Statement on Freedom of Expression,
Free Media and Information at
OSCE Human Dimension Implementation Meeting
Press Release
Sep 19, 2002
Helsinki Commission Hearing Examines
Democracy, Human Rights & Security in Georgia Press Release
Sep 15, 2002
Statement by Helsinki Commission
Co-Chairman Rep. Christopher H. Smith
on the Second Anniversary of the
Disappearance of Georgiy Gongadze Press Release
Jun 20, 2002
Smith: Repeal Romanian
Criminal Defamation Laws
Press Release
Jun 20, 2002
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws Article
Jun 12, 2002
Human Rights in Greece Subject of
Commission Hearing Press Release
Jun 11, 2002
Helsinki Commission Co-Chairman
Praises Slovak Reforms,
Urges Passage of Anti-Discrimination Law Press Release
May 24, 2002
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech Developments in Romania
Article
May 17, 2002
Rise of Anti-Semitic Violence
Focus of Helsinki Commission Hearing
Press Release
May 16, 2002
Hearing Focuses on Russian-Chechen War Article
May 6, 2002
Russian-Chechen War Focus of Hearing
Press Release
May 3, 2002
Georgian Government
Complicity in Mob Violence
Against Minority Religious Groups
Article
Apr 19, 2002
Journalist’s Attempted Hand-Shake
Leads to Criminal Indictment
Press Release
Mar 22, 2002
Escalating Violence and
Rights Violations in Central Asia
Subject of Helsinki Commission Briefing Press Release
Mar 21, 2002
Commissioners Spearhead Passage
of Resolution on Ukraine Press Release
Mar 13, 2002
Karimov Receives Helsinki Commission Letter on Uzbekistan’s Human Rights Violations Press Release
Mar 12, 2002
Text of Letter from United States
Helsinki Commission Members
to President Karimov
Press Release
Mar 12, 2002
Karimov Urged to Confront
Uzbekistan’s Human Rights Record
Press Release
Mar 6, 2002
U.S. Policy in Central Asia
and Human Rights Concerns
Focus of Helsinki Commission Briefing
Press Release
Feb 20, 2002
Ukraine Parliamentary Elections
Focus of Helsinki Commission Briefing
Press Release
Jan 11, 2002
Jailed Pastor Released in Turkmenistan,
But Systematic Abuses Persist
Press Release
Jan 9, 2002
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech
Developments in the Czech Republic
Article
Dec 20, 2001
Commissioners Raise Religious Freedom
Concerns with Turkmenistan Ambassador
to the United States Press Release
Dec 14, 2001
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech Developments in Slovakia
Article
Sep 14, 2001
Missed Opportunity in Belarus Article
Jul 19, 2001
Senate Adopts Campbell Resolution on
Tenth Anniversary of Baltic
Freedom from Soviet Rule Press Release
Jun 5, 2001
Helsinki Commission Hearing Examines
Downward Spiral in Russia’s Human Rights Record Press Release
May 31, 2001
Status of Human Rights in Russia
Focus of Helsinki Commission Hearing Press Release
Apr 25, 2001
Human Rights, Democracy in Ukraine
Focus of Helsinki Commission Hearing Press Release
Mar 1, 2001
Helsinki Commission Chairman Urges
Ukraine to Confront Legacy of Corruption Press Release
Feb 7, 2001
Smith Decries Turkmen Torture
of Baptist Minister Atakov Press Release
Jan 12, 2001
Helsinki Commission Welcomes Efforts to
Locate U.S. Aid Worker Missing in Chechnya Press Release
Oct 6, 2000
Helsinki Commission Chairman’s
Statement on Gusinsky Release Press Release
Sep 12, 2000
Russia’s Human Rights Record
Subject of Helsinki Commission Briefing Press Release
Sep 1, 2000
Report: U.S. Statements at the 1999 OSCE Review Conference Article
Aug 30, 2000
Helsinki Commission Leaders: Attack on Glasnost
Foundation Another Step Towards “Thugocracy” Press Release
Aug 3, 2000
Helsinki Commission Chairman
Expresses Disappointment on Nikitin Delay Press Release
Jul 27, 2000
Milosevic Reign of Terror in Yugoslavia Hindering
Human Rights and Democracy, Witnesses Testify Press Release
Jul 20, 2000
Freedom of Religion Remains in Peril Press Release
Jul 20, 2000
Helsinki Commission Chairman Urges Clinton
to Raise Nikitin Persecution in
G-8 Summit with Putin Press Release
Jul 3, 2000
Bi-partisan Congressional Letter
to Russian President Vladimir Putin Press Release
Jul 3, 2000
Russian Government Denounced
for Babitsky Travel Restraints Press Release
Jun 29, 2000
Helsinki Commission Chairman
Decries Torture of Uzbek Writer Press Release
May 31, 2000
Helsinki Commission Chairman Condemns Russian
Confiscation of Amnesty International Documents Press Release
Mar 22, 2000
Helsinki Commission Documents
Deplorable State of Human Rights in Turkmenistan Press Release
Mar 14, 2000
Helsinki Commissioners Call on United Kingdom
to Promote Rule of Law through Independent Judicial Inquiries into Murders of Human Rights
Defenders in Northern Ireland Press Release
Jan 11, 2000
“Whither Human Rights in Russia?” Helsinki Commission Hearing Announced Press Release
Dec 4, 1999
Report on Macedonia's Presidential Election Article
Oct 20, 1999
Belarus' President Lukashenka Called on the Carpet by
Helsinki Commission for Human Rights Violations Press Release
Oct 18, 1999
“Uzbekistan is One of the Most Repressive
New Independent States,” says Helsinki Commission
Chairman Smith Press Release
Apr 19, 1999
Hearing Announced:
“Belarus—Back in the USSR?” Press Release
Apr 12, 1999
Commission releases Chairman’s statement on the assassination of Slavko Curuvija Press Release
Feb 19, 1999
Helsinki Commission Co-Chairman
Calls Upon Russian Officials to Prevent
Murder in St. Petersburg Press Release
Jan 21, 1999
Helsinki Commissioners
Reps. Smith and Hoyer Discuss Keys Issues with
Czech Deputy Foreign Minister Palous Press Release
Jan 21, 1999
Helsinki Commission Leaders:
Milosevic Responsible for “Barbaric” Kosovo Massacre Press Release
Mar 1, 1998
Report on Political Reform and Human Rights in Uzbekistan, Kyrgystan, and Kazakstan Article
Mar 1, 1997
Report on Government-Opposition Relations in Uzbekistan Article
Jan 1, 1994
Report: Human Rights and Democratization in Poland Article
Sep 1, 1993
Report: Human Rights and Democratization in Bulgaria Article
Sep 1, 1993
Report: Human Rights and Democratization in Slovakia Article
Oct 29, 1985
Hearings: Restrictions on Artistic Freedoms in the Soviet Union, October 29, 1985; and the Budapest Cultural Forum, December 11, 1985 Article
Jul 1, 1982
Human Rights in Czechoslovakia: The Documents of Charter '77, 1977-1982 (14MB) Article
CSCE :: User Groups
Jul 25, 2006
Uzbekistan: Are There Prospects for Change? Briefing
Jun 28, 2006
Belgium’s Chairmanship of the OSCE Hearing
Mar 9, 2006
Freedom Denied: Belarus on the Eve of the Election Hearing
Feb 8, 2006
Human Rights, Civil Society, and Democratic Governance in Russia : Current Situation and Prospects for the Future Hearing
Oct 12, 2005
The Meaning of Egypt's Elections and their Relevance to the Middle East Briefing
Mar 16, 2005
The Greek Orthodox Church in Turkey: A Victim of Systematic Expropriation Briefing
Sep 15, 2004
Hearing: Advancing U.S. Interests Through the OSCE Hearing
Jun 24, 2004
Hearing: Uzbekistan: Stifled Democracy, Human Rights in Decline Hearing
Feb 26, 2004
Hearing: The Bulgarian Leadership of the OSCE Hearing
Oct 3, 2003
Briefing: Democracy and Human Rights in the Mediterranean Partner States of the OSCE: Algeria, Egypt, Israel, Jordan, Morocco and Tunisia Briefing
Oct 1, 2003
Briefing: Romania: Moving Toward NATO and the EU Briefing
Sep 9, 2003
Hearing: U.S. Policy Toward the OSCE Hearing
Sep 3, 2003
Hearing: The Dutch Leadership of the OSCE Hearing
Oct 10, 2002
Hearing: U.S. Policy Toward the OSCE Hearing
Sep 24, 2002
Hearing: The Republic of Georgia: Democracy, Human Rights and Security Hearing
Jun 20, 2002
Hearing: Human Rights in Greece: A Snapshot of the Cradle of Democracy Hearing
May 22, 2002
Hearing: Escalating Anti-Semitic Violence in Europe Hearing
Mar 26, 2002
Briefing: If the Cyprus Talks Fail
Briefing
Mar 7, 2002
Briefing: U.S. Policy in Central Asia and Human Rights Concerns Briefing
Dec 12, 2001
Hearing: Human Rights and Democracy in Kyrgyzstan Hearing
Oct 31, 2001
Hearing: Romania's Chairmanship of the OSCE Hearing
Oct 11, 2001
Briefing: Religious Registration in the OSCE Region Briefing
Oct 3, 2001
Hearing: U.S. Policy Toward OSCE Hearing
Jun 5, 2001
Hearing: Troubling Trends: Human Rights in Russia Hearing
Jul 20, 2000
Briefing with Alexandr Nikitin Briefing
May 25, 2000
Hearing: Elections, Democratization, and Human Rights in Azerbaijan Hearing
May 23, 2000
Hearing: The Putin Path: Are Human Rights in Retreat? Hearing
Apr 4, 2000
Hearing: The Deterioration of Freedom of the Media in OSCE Countries Hearing
Mar 21, 2000
Hearing: The State of Democracy and Human Rights in Turkmenistan Hearing
Mar 9, 2000
Hearing: Belarus at the Crossroads Hearing
Oct 18, 1999
Hearing: Democratization and Human Rights in Uzbekistan Hearing
May 6, 1999
Hearing: The State of Human Rights and Democracy in Kazakstan Hearing
Apr 27, 1999
Hearing: Belarus--Back in the USSR? Hearing
Mar 24, 1999
Briefing: Deputy Shishlov: The Decline in Human Rights, Rule of Law, Religious Liberty, and Environmental Safety in Russia Today Briefing
Oct 8, 1998
Briefing: The Status of Human Rights in Russia Briefing
Sep 19, 1995
Hearing: Turkey-U.S. Relations: Potential and Perils Hearing
Jun 6, 1995
Briefing: Human Rights in Turkey Briefing
Dec 10, 1994
Briefing: Electoral Reforms in Russia Briefing
Jul 1, 1994
Briefing: Banned Turkish Parliamentarians Discuss State of Democracy in Turkey Briefing
Jun 3, 1994
Briefing: Doing Business in Russia and the NIS: Opportunities and Obstacles Briefing
May 16, 1994
Briefing: Human Rights Law Group Briefing on Human Rights in Turkey Briefing
May 1, 1994
Briefing: Criminalizing Parliamentary Speech in Turkey Briefing
Nov 3, 1993
Hearing: The Current State and Future Prospects of Democracy in Russia Hearing
Oct 27, 1993
Briefing: The Situation in Russia Briefing
May 17, 1993
Briefing: Situation of Kurds in Iran, Iraq and Turkey Briefing
Apr 5, 1993
Briefing: Human Rights in Turkey Briefing
Apr 5, 1993
Briefing: Human Rights In Turkey: Part 2 Briefing
Jul 31, 1991
Hearing: Geneva Meeting on National Minorities and Moscow Meeting on the Human Dimension Hearing
May 22, 1991
Hearing: Democratic Developments in Albania Hearing
May 7, 1991
Hearing: Baltic Leadership on the Status of Independence Movements Hearing
Feb 6, 1991
Hearing: The USSR in Crisis: State of the Union Hearing
Jan 17, 1991
Hearing: Soviet Crackdown in the Baltic States Hearing
Jul 18, 1990
Hearing: Copenhagen Meeting on the Human Dimension Hearing
May 3, 1990
Hearing: Meeting with Prime Minister Kazimiera Prunskiene of Lithuania (N/A) Hearing
Apr 3, 1990
Hearing: CSCE Process (N/A) Hearing
Nov 28, 1989
Hearing: The New and Improved Supreme Soviet and the Institutionalization of Human Rights Reform Hearing
Mar 16, 1989
Hearing: The Right to Receive and Impart Information - Prelude to the London Information Forum Hearing
Jun 25, 1985
Hearing: The Ottawa Human Rights Experts Meeting and the Future of the Helsinki Process Hearing
May 11, 1979
Hearing: Implementation of the Helsinki Accords Vol. X - Alexsandr Ginzburg on the Human Rights Situation in the U.S.S.R. Hearing
Apr 3, 1979
Hearing: Implementation of the Helsinki Accords Vol. VIII - U.S. Compliance: Human Rights Hearing
May 19, 1977
Hearing: Implementation of the Helsinki Accords Vol. III - Information Flow, and Cultural and Educational Exchanges Hearing
CSCE :: User Groups
Dec 7, 2006
Belarus Democracy Reauthorization Act of 2006 Statement
Jul 27, 2006
President Niyazov Intensifies Repression in Turkmenistan Statement
May 16, 2006
Thirtieth Anniversary of the Founding of the Moscow Helsinki Group Statement
Mar 14, 2006
Promoting Religious Freedom in the Russian Federation Statement
Dec 6, 2005
Riding Roughshod Over Rights in Belarus Statement
Nov 9, 2005
Religious Speech Limitations in Sweden Statement
Mar 15, 2005
Russian Support for the Syrian Regime Statement
Mar 4, 2005
Belarus--Outpost of Tyranny Statement
Nov 20, 2004
Democratization in Central Asia Statement
Nov 16, 2004
The Case of Mikhail Trepashkin Statement
Nov 16, 2004
Bring Paul Klebnikov’s Killers to Justice Statement
Oct 7, 2004
Supporting Democracy in Belarus Statement
May 5, 2004
Encouraging Democratic Elections in Ukraine Statement
May 5, 2004
Presidential Elections Critical to Ukrainian Democracy Statement
Feb 11, 2004
Belarusian Authorities Continue to Stifle Democracy Statement
Jan 20, 2004
Troubling Pre-Election Developments in Ukraine Statement
Oct 31, 2003
80th Anniversary of the Turkish Republic Statement
Jul 25, 2003
Continuous Religious Freedom Concerns in Armenia Statement
Jul 15, 2003
Floor Statement in Support of H.R. 1950, the Foreign Relations Authorization Act for Fiscal Years 2004 and 2005 - Rep. Smith Statement
Jun 24, 2003
Repression Spreading in Belarus Statement
May 19, 2003
The Continuing Plight of Roma in Greece Statement
May 7, 2003
Taking Stock in Romania Statement
Apr 30, 2003
The Troubled Media Environment in Ukraine Statement
Apr 11, 2003
Regime Targets Independent Media in Belarus Statement
Apr 9, 2003
President Shevardnadze’s Statement Welcomed, but Action also Needed Statement
Feb 13, 2003
Introduction of Belarus Democracy Act 2003 Statement
Nov 18, 2002
Prospects for Change in Turkey Statement
Nov 13, 2002
Situation in Belarus Continues to Deteriorate Statement
Oct 7, 2002
Russian Democracy Act of 2002 Statement
Jun 27, 2002
Introduction of Belarus Democracy Act Statement
Jun 21, 2002
Human Rights Concerns in Kazakhstan Statement
May 3, 2002
Murder of Ukrainian Heorhiy Gongadze Still Unsolved Statement
Mar 22, 2002
Kyrgyzstan's Release of Azimbek Beknazarov Statement
Mar 20, 2002
Re-Registration Campaign Denying Religious Freedom in Azerbaijan Statement
Feb 7, 2002
Introduction of S. Res. 205 on Parliamentary Elections in Ukraine Statement
Feb 6, 2002
Alarming Developments for Religious Freedom in Kazakhstan Statement
Dec 20, 2001
Human Rights in Central Asia Statement
Dec 18, 2001
Do Registration Requirements Thwart Religious Freedom? Statement
Dec 13, 2001
Ambassador Stephan H. Minikes Statement
Dec 7, 2001
Slovak Parliament Narrowly Defeats Repeal of Criminal Defamation Provisions
Statement
Jun 27, 2001
Twenty-Five Years of the Helsinki Commission Statement
May 17, 2001
Eightieth Anniversary of the Birthday of Dr. Andrei Sakharov Statement
May 17, 2001
Human Rights Problems in Kazakhstan Statement
May 10, 2001
Democracy Under Siege in Belarus Statement
Apr 26, 2001
Senate Concurrent Resolution 34 Statement
Apr 5, 2001
Atmosphere of Trust Missing in Belarus Statement
Nov 2, 2000
Turkey and Possible Military Equipment Sales Statement
Oct 6, 2000
Missing Journalist in Ukraine Statement
Sep 25, 2000
Serbia Democratization of 2000 Statement
Sep 25, 2000
Calling the President to Issue a Proclamation Recognizing 25th Anniversary of the Helsinki Final Act Statement
Jul 27, 2000
25th Anniversary of the Helsinki Final Act Statement
Jul 27, 2000
Free Speech and Media in the OSCE Region After 25 Years Statement
Jul 15, 2000
OSCE PA Delegation Trip Report Statement
Jun 9, 2000
Helsinki Final Act 25th Anniversary Resolution Statement
May 25, 2000
The Putin Path: Are Human Rights in Retreat? Statement
Jul 20, 1999
Developments in Belarus Statement
Mar 10, 1999
The Serbia and Montenegro Democracy Act of 1999 Statement
Mar 9, 1999
Politically Motivated Arrests in Belarus Statement
Feb 9, 1999
1999-A Critical Year for Belarus Statement
CSCE :: User Groups
Mar 11, 2008
Helsinki Commission Delegation Visits Prague and Bratislava Article
Nov 5, 2007
OSCE Chairman Addresses Helsinki Commission in Advance of Madrid Ministerial Article
Sep 18, 2006
Freedom of the Media Revisited at Vienna Meeting Article
Nov 23, 2005
The Meaning of Egypt's Elections and Their Relevance to the Middle East Article
Aug 12, 2005
Human Rights in Iran: Prospects and the Western Response Article
Jan 18, 2005
The Mediterranean Dimension Today: Seeds of Hope Article
Jul 16, 2004
Uzbekistan’s Human Rights Record Spurs State Department De-Certification Article
Jul 2, 2004
Commission Hearing Surveys Human Rights in Putin’s Russia Article
Jul 1, 2004
Activists Brief Commission on the War in Chechnya,
Civil Society and Military Reform in Russia Article
Jun 30, 2004
OSCE Meeting Examines Hate Crimes
and Racist, Xenophobic and
Anti-Semitic Internet Propaganda Article
Jun 30, 2004
Helsinki Commission Briefing Sheds Light on Russia’s Human Rights Situation Article
Apr 20, 2004
Helsinki Commissioners Active at Parliamentary Assembly Winter Meeting Article
Dec 22, 2003
Romania: Moving Toward NATO and the EU Article
Dec 19, 2003
Letter to The Honorable Colin L. Powell Dated 12/19/03 Article
Dec 10, 2003
Helsinki Commission Members Engage Government Leaders
at Annual Human Rights Review Article
Dec 3, 2003
Commission Hearing Looked Ahead
to Maastricht Ministerial Article
Nov 26, 2003
Helsinki Commission Reviews
OSCE Dutch Leadership Article
Nov 25, 2003
Further Assault Against Activists in Belarus Article
Oct 28, 2003
Criminal Defamation and "Insult" Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech Developments in Armenia
Article
Oct 28, 2003
Democracy and Human Rights in Mediterranean
Focus of Commission Briefing Article
Jun 2, 2003
Human Rights in Chechnya
Focus of Helsinki Commission Briefing Article
Feb 10, 2003
Moscow Should Engage the OSCE in Resolving the Chechen Problem (Russian) Article
Jan 15, 2003
Hearing Surveys Human Rights
in Republic of Georgia Article
Dec 31, 2002
Democracy and Human Rights Trends in Eurasia and East Europe: A Decade of Membership in the Organization (Report Only) Article
Dec 13, 2002
Commission Staff Meet with Georgian Officials
while Religious Persecution Persists
Article
Jun 20, 2002
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws Article
May 24, 2002
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech Developments in Romania
Article
May 16, 2002
Hearing Focuses on Russian-Chechen War Article
May 3, 2002
Georgian Government
Complicity in Mob Violence
Against Minority Religious Groups
Article
Jan 9, 2002
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech
Developments in the Czech Republic
Article
Dec 14, 2001
Criminal Defamation and “Insult” Laws:
A Summary of Free Speech Developments in Slovakia
Article
Sep 14, 2001
Missed Opportunity in Belarus Article
Sep 1, 2000
Report: U.S. Statements at the 1999 OSCE Review Conference Article
Dec 4, 1999
Report on Macedonia's Presidential Election Article
Mar 1, 1998
Report on Political Reform and Human Rights in Uzbekistan, Kyrgystan, and Kazakstan Article
Mar 1, 1997
Report on Government-Opposition Relations in Uzbekistan Article
Jan 1, 1994
Report: Human Rights and Democratization in Poland Article
Sep 1, 1993
Report: Human Rights and Democratization in Bulgaria Article
Sep 1, 1993
Report: Human Rights and Democratization in Slovakia Article
Oct 29, 1985
Hearings: Restrictions on Artistic Freedoms in the Soviet Union, October 29, 1985; and the Budapest Cultural Forum, December 11, 1985 Article
Jul 1, 1982
Human Rights in Czechoslovakia: The Documents of Charter '77, 1977-1982 (14MB) Article
234 Ford House Office Building | 3rd and D Streets SW | Washington, DC 20515
Tel: 202-225-1901 | Fax: 202-226-4199 | Email: info@csce.gov | Privacy Statement
The U.S. Delegation in a roundtable meeting in Pakistan